The text
NEW MEMBER SWORN Mr William Allmond Codrington Goode, Chief Secretary, took and subscribed the Oath of Allegiance.
MESSAGES FROM THE OFFICER ADMINISTERING THE GOVERNMENT - (O.A.G's Assent to Bills passed) I have received two messages from the Officer Administering the Government in connection with Bills which have been passed by the Assembly. The first is dated 10th April, 1956: "Sir, I have the honour to inform you that in accordance with the provisions of Section 62 (2) of the Singapore Colony Order in Council, 1955, I have this day assented to the Bills intituled: -
An Ordinance to amend the Registration of Births and Deaths Ordinance, 1937 (No. 34 of 1937). (ii) An Ordinance to establish a licensing authority for omnibus services. I have the honour to be, Sir, Your obedient servant, W. A. C. GOODE, Officer Administering the Government." The second message is dated 16th May, 1956: "Sir, With reference to your S/LA 6/55 Pt. II (28) of 27th March, 1956, I have the honour to inform you that, having received instructions from Her Majesty through the Secretary of State authorising me so to do, I have this day assented to the Bill, passed by the Legislative Assembly at its meeting on the 7th March, 1956 intituled: - "An Ordinance to make provision for the winding up of the War Damage Fund". I have the honour to be, Sir, Your obedient servant, W. A. C. GOODE, Officer Administering the Government."
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - RICE PRICES asked the Minister for Commerce and Industry whether he is aware that the average retail selling price of rice has been higher in the current year than was the case in 1955; and whether he will state the reasons.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - RICE PRICES Sir, the hon. Member appears to have been misinformed. Reliable figures are available in my Ministry as from 1st April, 1955, and according to these figures, the average retail selling price of rice per katty this year was cheaper by one cent than it was for the last 9 months of 1955. The second part of the question, therefore, does not arise.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - RICE PRICES Mr Speaker, Sir, is the Minister aware that the rise in prices appears on page 54 of Malayan Statistics, No. 4 of 1956, prepared by his own Ministry?
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - RICE PRICES Sir, in drafting my reply, I have not consulted the statistics. Did I hear the Member say 1954?
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - RICE PRICES No. 4 of 1956.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - RICE PRICES The figures that I quote from are reliable and are compiled in my own Ministry.
HOUSING UNITS asked the Minister for Local Government, Lands and Housing whether he is aware that the Singapore Improvement Trust has planned the completion (a) of less housing units in 1956 than were completed in 1955 and (b) of a lower percentage of housing units carrying rentals of not more than $30 p.m.; and whether this represents the Government's policy in the matter.
HOUSING UNITS Mr Speaker, Sir, last year the Trust built a total of 2,795 housing units. This year the Trust expects to complete a total of 2,272 units, although the original estimate for the completion was 3,158 units. The reasons for this drop are: (1) The delay in the clearance of squatters from Queenstown during the last 24 months. (2) Delay in squatter clearance as well as main drainage and sewerage difficulties at another building site at Macpherson Road. (3) Difficulty in the recruitment of technical staff, particularly architects and engineers, which has prevented adequate advanced planning. The clearance of squatters in Queenstown is now making satisfactory headway, and the technical staffing position has improved. To the second part of the question (b), the Trust in its building programme this year has planned a lower percentage of semi-permanent houses carrying rentals of less than $30 per month. Government's policy is to make cheap and economical housing available to as many of the lower income group as possible. There are two types of cheap housing being built by the Singapore Improvement Trust at present, namely: (1) Low-cost housing built to the minimum standards required and to be let at monthly rentals not exceeding $50 for two-bedroom units, and $55 per month for three-bedroom units. These houses, with an expected life of between 80 and 100 years, may be classed as permanent buildings. (2) Low-rental housing built not quite up to the minimum standards required and to be let at monthly rentals ranging between $20 and $30. These houses have a shorter term of life - about 40 years - and are classed as semi-permanent buildings. The latter type of housing, that is to say, low-rental housing, which is the subject of the Member's second part of the question, is not suitable for erection on valuable sites in urban areas as it is uneconomical in land, building and maintenance costs, and accordingly has been recommended for erection in suburban and rural areas. The Singapore Improvement Trust is, in fact, proceeding with a scheme this year for the construction of 200 low-rental houses at Bukit Panjang as part of a pilot rural development project. The greater part of the Trust's construction activity this year has been planned for urban areas where the building of low-cost housing of the permanent type has been recommended, and this explains why fewer low-rental houses are being built this year.
MALAYANISATION - (Public Service) - (Statement by the Chief Minister) If it please you, Sir, as you are aware, I shall be tendering my resignation as Chief Minister at the end of this sitting, and in accordance with constitutional procedure all my appointed Ministers will be resigning with me. It is, however, Sir, the view of your appointed Ministers that it is possible and desirable, both politically and administratively, to proceed with Malayanisation irrespective of the recent constitutional setback and the impending change of government. I have to inform you that we have requested that an approach be made to the Secretary of State and to the Staff Associations concerned with a view to the earliest possible implementation of the following recommendations: (1) Appointment of a Malayan Director of Personnel; (2) Appointment of a Malayan Permanent Secretary - designate to the Treasury; (3) Appointment of a Public Service Commission with executive powers and a directive to take into consideration the recommendations of the Malayanisation Commission's Majority Report when it considers appointments and promotions; and (4) A scheme for full abolition terms. Your appointed Ministers, Sir, are of the view that the abolition terms should provide for full compensation to all expatriate officers, payable not later than the end of four years after the Public Service Commission with executive powers takes office; such compensation to be paid if officers retire earlier with the consent of the Government. On the other hand, if officers wish to retire within this four-year period, they are free out the consent of the Government dur to do so but will then only be entitled to half the abolition terms. The approach of your appointed Ministers, Sir, is based on the principle that, where there is compulsory termination of a career, full abolition terms should be given; but where there is merely interference of the career without depriving the officer of his livelihood, then he should await the end of the four years or earlier agreed termination before receiving full compensation, but if he insists on retiring earlier, half the abolition terms would be generous compensation for the disturbance and departure from some of the existing service principles affecting expatriates. The reason, Sir, for the provision of half and not full abolition terms on voluntary retirement is intended to ensure that Malayanisation is carried out in a planned and efficient manner. Your appointed Ministers, I must add, Sir, do not accept the principle of a standstill for promotions of expatriates as recommended by the Majority Report but seek in place thereof promotion to grades and not to posts, so that expatriate officers' remuneration and ultimate abolition quantum are not prejudicially affected, though this would mean a considerable additional burden on the country's finances.
MALAYANISATION - (Public Service) - (Statement by the Chief Minister) Mr Speaker, Sir, although this may be a matter out of the competence of the present Chief Minister, does he not agree that this is a subject which should be debated on a White Paper rather than on a statement by the Chief Minister?
MALAYANISATION - (Public Service) - (Statement by the Chief Minister) Sir, I am informing the Assembly of the approach of the appointed Ministers to this problem. When a decision is finally arrived at in conjunction with the Secretary of State, who holds the whip hand, then the matter will be presented to this Assembly for its own confirmation or otherwise of the decision.
RUBBER EXPORTS TO CHINA - (Statement by the Minister for Commerce and Industry) Sir, hon. Members will no doubt have read with pleasure the announcement I made on Monday that exports of rubber in reasonable quantities may now be permitted to China. The embargo on such exports has been a source of great dissatisfaction to the trade. Therefore, in accordance with the declared policy of this Government to do everything within its power to encourage and expand trade, strong representations were made to the Secretary of State for the Colonies for the removal of the ban. I am sure that the favourable reaction of Her Majesty's Government to our representations and those of the Federation Government in permitting such exports now will be received with gratification by hon. Members and by the trade. Certain doubts have been expressed, Sir, in the last two days as to the precise meaning of the term "reasonable quantities". This is a matter on which my Ministry would have to use their judgment, and where they are in doubt, they will use their judgment in consultation with the Colonial Office. The number of applications, total quantity applied for, and the actual demand from China would be some of the factors that we shall take into consideration. Individual applications for, say, up to 2,000 tons will be dealt with straightaway in my Ministry, each application being judged on its merits. Applications for larger quantities would be referred to the Colonial Office. I may add, Sir, that there is no need for the trade to take an unduly pessimistic viewpoint that our discretion will be exercised harshly. One other matter, Sir. Hon. Members will recollect a statement made by my friend and colleague the Hon. the Chief Minister a few months back that, while in Delhi in December last, together with him, I took up the matter of according preferential treatment, for duty purposes, to some commodities exported from Singapore to India which, until now, were not enjoying such treatment. In accordance with the declared policy of this Government to assist trade and to develop friendly relations with our neighbours, I again took the opportunity to make personal representations on this subject to the Hon. the Minister for Commerce of the Government of India when I was in Bangalore attending the E.C.A.F.E. conference last January. As a result of these representations, hon. Members will be pleased to learn that the Government of India have been kind enough to see our viewpoint, and the difficulties of our merchants on this score have been satisfactorily solved.
CITY COUNCIL ELECTIONS (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) (AMENDMENT) BILL Mr Speaker, Sir, I lay upon the Table a Certificate of Urgency signed by His Excellency the Governor in respect of the City Council Elections (Temporary Provisions) (Amendment) Bill, 1956, and desire to proceed with the Bill throughout all its stages today. Certificate of Urgency handed in.
CITY COUNCIL ELECTIONS (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) (AMENDMENT) BILL The Certificate is in order. Are typed copies of the Bill available for hon. Members?
CITY COUNCIL ELECTIONS (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) (AMENDMENT) BILL Yes. Typed copies of the Bill handed in to the Clerk and distributed to hon. Members.
CITY COUNCIL ELECTIONS (TEMPORARY PROVISIONS) (AMENDMENT) BILL Will the Minister please proceed?
First Reading Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move the First Reading of the Bill intituled "An Ordinance to amend the City Council Elections (Temporary Provisions) Ordinance, 1955 (No. 21 of 1955)". Bill read the First time.
Second Reading Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time." Members are aware that the tenure of office of City Councillors, both elected and nominated, who were due to retire on the 1st of December, 1955, has been extended to the 1st of July, 1956. As it will not be possible for the new local government legislation, based on the recommendation of the Committee on Local Government, to be in force by 1st July, 1956, it will be necessary to further extend the tenure of office of the City Councillors, elected as well as nominated, beyond 1st July, 1956. The purpose of this short and straightforward Bill is to enable the present City Council to continue in existence till December 1956. Sir, I beg to move.
Second Reading I second it.
Second Reading Question put, and agreed to. Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Committee Mr Speaker, Sir, I move, That the Assembly do resolve itself into Committee on the Bill.
Committee I second it.
Committee Question put, and agreed to. Bill considered in Committee.
Committee Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Committee Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be reported to the Assembly."
Committee Question put, and agreed to. Bill reported, without Amendment.
Third Reading Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read the Third time."
Third Reading I second it.
Third Reading Question put, and agreed to. Bill accordingly read the Third time.
HOTELS (AMENDMENT) BILL Order for Second Reading read.
HOTELS (AMENDMENT) BILL Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move. "That the Bill be now read a Second time." This, Sir, is another short and simple Bill. Its main object is to cure a defect in the Hotels Ordinance, 1954. That defect is that under section 1 of the Ordinance the whole of the Ordinance has to be brought into force at one time on one day. The Ordinance and the regulations made under it will provide for the registration of hotels and hotelkeepers and will lay down certain standards to be complied with by hotels, and it is clearly right that the regulations requiring acts to be done should be brought into force a reasonable period before failure to carry out those acts becomes an offence. The purpose of clause 2 of this Bill is to enable some sections to be brought into force earlier than others, thus making it possible to give time for hotelkeepers to comply with the Ordinance and the regulations made thereunder before they become liable to penalties. The opportunity has also been taken to transfer the power of making appointments to the Hotels Licensing Board from the Governor to the Governor in Council. Sir, I beg to move.
HOTELS (AMENDMENT) BILL Question put, and agreed to. Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Committee stage, what day?
Committee Now, Sir. Sir, I move, That the Assembly do resolve itself into Committee on the Bill.
Committee I second it.
Committee Question put, and agreed to. Bill considered in Committee.
Committee Clauses 1 to 4 inclusive ordered to stand part of the Bill. The Schedule ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Committee Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be reported to the Assembly."
Committee Question put, and agreed to. Bill reported, without Amendment.
Third Reading, what day?
Third Reading Now, Sir. Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read the Third time."
Third Reading I second it.
Third Reading Question put, and agreed to. Bill accordingly read the Third time.
PORTS (AMENDMENT) BILL Order for Second Reading read.
PORTS (AMENDMENT) BILL Mr Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be now read a Second time." The Chairman of the Singapore Harbour Board, under subsection (1) of section 23 of the Ports Ordinance, is vested with certain powers of appointments, promotions, disciplinary control and the grant of leave without the previous approval of the Board in respect of officers whose monthly basic salary does not exceed $435. Recently, in agreement with the Staff Association, the Harbour Board has revised the salary structure of its staff and this revision has affected the powers of the Chairman, as a number of officers, who were prior to this revision drawing salaries of below $435, are now drawing a basic monthly salary of above this figure - up to $465. It is desirable, therefore, that the status quo of the Chairman should be restored in this respect, and to achieve this, the Ports Ordinance requires an amendment by substituting the figure $465 for the figure $435 appearing in section 23 (1). Sir, I beg to move.
PORTS (AMENDMENT) BILL Question put, and agreed to. Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Committee stage, what day?
Committee Now, Sir. Sir, I move, That the Assembly do resolve itself into Committee on the Bill.
Committee I second it.
Committee Question put, and agreed to. Bill considered in Committee.
Committee Clauses 1 and 2 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Committee Sir, I move, "That the Bill be reported to the Assembly."
Committee Question put, and agreed to. Bill reported, without Amendment.
Third Reading, what day?
Third Reading Now, Sir. Sir, I move, "That the Bill be now read the Third time."
Third Reading I second it.
Third Reading Question put, and agreed to. Bill accordingly read the Third time.
LEGAL AID AND ADVICE BILL Order for Second Reading read.