Skip to content
Official report

Hansard

Hansard, 1998-02-27

Feedback & support

The text

(1)

PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT Under the provisions of clause 2(d) of Article 46 of the Constitution of the Republic of Singapore, the following Members have been granted permission to be or to remain absent from sittings of Parliament (or any Committee of Parliament to which they have been appointed) for the periods stated: NameFromTo 19981998 Mr R Sinnakaruppan 26 Feb26 Feb Mr Davinder Singh 27 Feb27 Feb Mr K Shanmugam 27 Feb27 Feb Mr Tan Soo Khoon2 Mar5 Mar Mr Inderjit Singh17 Mar24 Mar Encik Othman Bin Haron Eusofe6 Mar8 Mar TAN SOO KHOON Speaker Parliament of Singapore

(2)

ASSENTS TO BILLS PASSED The following Bills were assented to by the President of the Republic of Singapore on the dates stated: 23 February 1998 Economic Expansion Incentives (Relief From Income Tax) (Amendment) Bill 1998. 24 February 1998 (i) Road Traffic (Amendment) Bill 1998; (ii) Copyright (Amendment) Bill 1998; (iii) Medicines (Amendment) Bill 1998; (iv) Undesirable Publications (Amendment) Bill 1998; and (v) Holidays Bill 1998. TAN SOO KHOON Speaker Parliament of Singapore

(3)

ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - SINGAPORE DOLLAR asked the Prime Minister, in the light of the Indonesian Government's decision to go ahead with the currency board, what steps would the Singapore Government take to see that the Singapore dollar does not suffer as a result of the fall in the Indonesian rupiah.

(4)

DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCIES OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES - (Effect on Singapore's competitiveness) asked the Deputy Prime Minister how the relative depreciation of the currencies of Singapore's neighbouring countries will affect our competitiveness.

(5)

DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCIES OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES - (Effect on Singapore's competitiveness) Prime Minister): Mr Speaker, Sir, with your permission, I will answer Question Nos. 1 and 2 together.

(6)

DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCIES OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES - (Effect on Singapore's competitiveness) Yes.

(7)

DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCIES OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES - (Effect on Singapore's competitiveness) The depreciation of the regional currencies relative to the Singapore dollar will have some impact on our export competitiveness. But we should take a broader perspective. First, the Singapore dollar has depreciated against the US dollar and most European currencies since July last year. On an overall trade-weighted basis, the Singapore dollar has been stable. Second, we are not direct competitors with the ASEAN economies in most product categories. An internal MAS study shows that, for both goods and services, our major competitors in the region are the NIEs, and within ASEAN, Malaysia. The Singapore dollar has not appreciated against the Hong Kong or Taiwanese currencies. Third, what matters to our export competitiveness is the real exchange rate, namely, the nominal rate, which is then adjusted for cost or inflation differentials between us and our trading partners. The sharp depreciation of the regional currencies will eventually raise domestic prices in these economies and erode the initial gains in competitiveness. Fears that a fall in the Indonesian rupiah will drag the Singapore dollar down are at this stage hypothetical. The Indonesian government has not yet decided to set up a currency board system. The Singapore dollar should not be unduly affected by movements in the Indonesian rupiah. Indonesia's exports do not compete with Singapore's exports. The weight of the rupiah in our basket is small. Furthermore, our exchange rate policy is not mechanically driven by the trade weights. MAS exercises judgment in managing the exchange rate, and takes into account exceptional market factors. MAS will maintain confidence in the Singapore dollar, by intervening in the foreign exchange market where necessary.

(8)

DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCIES OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES - (Effect on Singapore's competitiveness) Sir, may I ask the Deputy Prime Minister, with the lowering of the currency rates in our neighbouring countries, like in Indonesia and Malaysia, and therefore they have become more competitive and enjoy low manufacturing cost, would the promotion of the Growth Triangle concept be more useful?

(9)

DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCIES OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES - (Effect on Singapore's competitiveness) Mr Speaker, Sir, yes, indeed, the Growth Triangle concept is useful and the lower cost in the neighbouring provinces of Malaysia, Indonesia, Johor and Riau, should enable our businesses and companies which have operations there also to benefit from this lower cost. But, as I explained earlier, it is the real exchange rate which determines our competitiveness, not the nominal one. Let me explain the difference. If we trade with Indonesia and the rupiah goes down from 2,500 rupiah to 10,000 rupiah, other things being equal, Indonesian costs have gone down four times and therefore they are four times more competitive than us. But other things do not remain equal. When the rupiah goes down, imports cost more, people are unable to pay, they agitate for higher wages, and wages go up, inflation goes up. And if, for the sake of argument, the rupiah has gone down four times but prices have gone up four times in Indonesia, then although there has been a nominal depreciation of their currency, there is no real effect on our competitiveness or their competitiveness. It will not completely work out like that. It takes some time, and at the end of it, I think our neighbouring countries will end up somewhat more competitive than we are, but not to the extent as shown just by looking at the exchange rates now.

(10)

DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCIES OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES - (Effect on Singapore's competitiveness) Sir, does the Deputy Prime Minister think that, in light of the fact that probably there will be a real exchange rate devaluation among the regional countries, actually competitiveness will be a bigger issue for us now and particularly in the medium term after these Asian economies recover than before, let us say, July of last year?

(11)

DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCIES OF NEIGHBOURING COUNTRIES - (Effect on Singapore's competitiveness) I think it will vary from industry to industry. Overall, yes, it will be offset somewhat because we have become more competitive compared to, say, developed countries, and the developed countries were, to some extent, competing against us for investments and exports. But against the neighbouring countries, they will end up somewhat more competitive than us, particularly our more labour-intensive industries. The older plants which have been here for some time - mass production, very low margins - will be under pressure and adjustments will have to be made. At the upper end, the effect on us is not so much on the cost as on the state of the markets, and some of those have been affected too, particularly where they export to the region or where the region has a big influence on world prices. For example, with petrochemicals, when the region boomed it was a big consumer and now that the region is down, prices are down. Some of our projects are going to see investors reconsidering them, and maybe deferring them for some time. But it is part of being in an economic slowdown.

(12)

RETRENCHED WORKERS - (Particulars) asked the Minister for Labour (a) how many workers were retrenched in 1997; (b) on average, how long these retrenched workers took to find new employment; (c) whether older workers take a longer time than younger workers in securing new employment; and (d) how his Ministry will help retrenched workers, especially those who are unskilled and not-so-young, to find employment.

(13)

RATE OF UNEMPLOYMENT asked the Minister for Labour what is the current rate of unemployment and whether this rate is rising rapidly and, if so, how the Government plans to address this problem.

(14)

RATE OF UNEMPLOYMENT Mr Speaker, with your permission, may I take both Question Nos. 3 and 4 together?

(15)

RATE OF UNEMPLOYMENT Yes.

(16)

RATE OF UNEMPLOYMENT Sir, in 1997, 9,784 workers were retrenched. This was 11% lower than the 10,956 laid off in 1996. However, the number of workers retrenched has increased since the onset of the regional economic crisis. In the fourth quarter of 1997, 4,278 workers were retrenched, compared to 5,506 during the first three quarters of the year. Total employment in Singapore increased by 122,800 in 1997 compared with 102,600 in 1996. The economy continued to enjoy full employment as reflected in the low unemployment rate of 1.8% for the whole of 1997. However, the last quarter of 1997 saw higher unemployment rate of 2% reflecting the increased retrenchments during that quarter. Fortunately, for most of 1997, we experienced strong employment growth and a tight labour market. Many retrenched workers found alternative employment quickly. Based on CPF's records, 79% of the local workers retrenched during the first three quarters of 1997 were re-employed by December 1997. The re-employment rate for older workers aged 50 and above was lower at 66%. Among the workers who were re-employed, the average time taken to secure new jobs was 1.8 months after being retrenched. There was no significant difference in the average time for workers in the various age groups. As a result of the on-going regional economic crisis and a less than vigorous rebound in certain sectors of the electronics industry, we saw more retrenchments since the beginning of this year. As the economy is likely to grow at a slower pace this year, we are also expecting more retrenchments for the rest of the year. My Ministry has therefore decided to set up a Tripartite Panel comprising representatives from EDB, NTUC, SNEF, PSB and the Ministry itself to assist retrenched workers seeking re-employment. Retrenched workers who are older or lacking in skills will have to make special efforts to acquire useful skills or upgrade their skills to improve their employability. The Tripartite Panel will also look into ways of assisting such workers.

(17)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) asked the Minister for Labour whether the Government will consider amending the Employment Act to require employers to pay compensation to employees who are terminated by the companies that they had served for ten years or more.

(18)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Eusofe) (for the Minister for Labour): Sir, an employee's service may be terminated for a variety of reasons such as poor work performance, ill health or redundancy. Under any of these circumstances, the employer is required to give notice of termination or salary in lieu of notice. Notice of termination is usually provided in the employment contract. In the absence of such a provision, the period of notice will be in accordance with the Employment Act. Where an employee's service is terminated on ground of poor work performance, he will not be given compensation. In the case of an employee whose service is terminated on ground of ill health, his employer would usually grant an ex-gratia payment to assist him financially. For termination on ground of redundancy, an employee who is covered by the Employment Act is eligible to claim for retrenchment benefit if he has a minimum of 3 years' service. The Employment Act does not stipulate the quantum of retrenchment benefits payable. We have taken this approach to enable companies and the affected employees to have greater flexibility in determining the appropriate amount, taking into account the financial position of the company. Thus, the quantum of retrenchment benefit payable for a non-unionised employee is subject to negotiation with his employer. Where a non-unionised employee is dissatisfied with his compensation, he can always appeal to my Ministry for assistance. My Ministry's Labour Relations Department will, through conciliation, help the employee to pursue claim for retrenchment payment. In the case of a unionised employee, the amount of retrenchment benefit is determined through collective bargaining between the union and the company. The prevailing retrenchment benefit payable to affected workers in the non-unionised sector varies from a few days' salary for each year of service to one month's salary for each year of service. In the case of the unionised sector, the norm of retrenchment benefit payable is two weeks to one month's salary for each year of service, unless the financial position of the company warrants a lower quantum. In practice, the quantum of retrenchment benefit stipulated in collective agreements is higher compared to the quantum paid to those who are not unionised. This in itself is an incentive for workers to join trade unions. It should also be pointed out that employees with less than 3 years' service, while not eligible to claim for retrenchment benefit, are in practice also paid some form of ex-gratia payment. As the law already enables a retrenched employee with 3 years' service to claim retrenchment benefit and affected workers are paid such benefit based on the financial position of the company or in accordance with the collective agreements, the suggestion by the Member for Hougang that employers pay retrenchment benefit to employees with at least 10 years' service, is not in the interest of workers.

(19)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Sir, is the Minister of State aware that there are employees whose services are terminated by the employer giving just one month's notice or in lieu of notice, paying one month's salary without any further compensation? I think such cases have been referred to the Ministry before.

(20)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Sir, as I have stated, if he is a non-unionised employee and he is not satisfied with the retrenchment payment, he can appeal and seek assistance from the Labour Relations Department of my Ministry. In the case of unionised employees, it is based on the negotiations between the union and the company. As I have mentioned earlier, in most cases, the practice for unionised employees is that they can at least have two weeks to one month's salary for each year of service as compensation. But this depends on the financial position of the company. I am not sure which particular case the Member is referring to. In the case where a company has no money, there cannot be any retrenchment payment. So it depends on the financial position of the company and the circumstances of the retrenchment exercise.

(21)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Generally, do employers need to specify the reason for termination in their letter of termination or they just say, "Under the contract, I terminate your employment."?

(22)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Sir, in the case of retrenchment, the employer will mention to his employee that because of very poor business conditions or some other reasons there has to be a retrenchment. In the case of a unionised company, the union will be informed of any retrenchment that is necessary because of these reasons.

(23)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) A clarification, Sir. I am referring to termination, not necessarily retrenchment. The employer may just terminate an employee's services by giving him one month's notice, or in lieu of notice, paying one month's salary without specifying any reason. Is there anything under the Employment Act which could compel an employer to specify the reasons for termination?

(24)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Under the law, the employer has to give a notice of termination. But whether or not he gives the reasons for termination depends on the circumstances of the case. If it is poor conduct or poor performance, then the employer may want to give that reason. But it depends on the circumstances of the case.

(25)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) In the case of an employer not stating any reason at all, would the employee concerned be able to claim any compensation?

(26)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Sir, there is a termination clause. The employee can also terminate his services and he does not need to give a reason. If he finds another job, he just says, "Okay, I want to leave the company." Since there is a termination clause and the employer wants to terminate the services of his employee, he can also exercise it on the same basis. So it is not necessary for him to give a reason if he does not want to, because it is on a reciprocal basis. The employee can also give notice of termination. If he finds a better job, he does not need to give a reason to the employer. Likewise, it is up to the employer. In the case of retrenchment, and that was the Question filed, obviously in the case of a unionised company, the union would be informed and it will then negotiate on the type of retrenchment benefit or payment that should be paid, and this is based on the financial position of the company.

(27)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Does the Minister of State appreciate that the present laws in Singapore and the practices followed by his Ministry leave the worker entirely on the charity of the employer as to how much compensation he is to be paid? The Minister of State says that it will not protect the workers to legislate for payment of compensation for workers who have been employed for 10 years or more. Why will it not? May I ask the Minister of State when will this Government bring in an Unfair Termination Act so that an employee who feels that his services have been terminated unfairly may have it referred and reviewed by a board, quite outside the Ministry, who will then decide what compensation is to be paid to the employee?

(28)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Sir, I have already explained that under the current law there is adequate protection for all employees, and if an employee needs any help he can come to the Ministry. Under the law, if a worker has worked for more than three years, he can claim for retrenchment benefit. He does not have to work for 10 years. That was made very clear. If there is any problem relating to the amount of compensation paid, he can appeal to the Ministry of Labour, but the amount of compensation payable is dependent on the financial position of the company. If the company is doing well and retrenches its workers for reasons other than being insolvent, then the Ministry will have to look at the amount of compensation that should be paid. The norm is from two weeks to one month's salary for each year of service for companies which are able to pay. So there is adequate protection under the law and I do not think we need to make any changes at this stage.

(29)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) May I say to the Minister of State that I was not asking about retrenchment, but about workers whose services are terminated and the law, as I know it, does not require the employer to give any reasons. If he does not like the man's face, he can terminate his services by giving him a month's notice. So what is the protection? Why do we not have an Unfair Termination Board?

(30)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Sir, first, I have mentioned earlier that it applies to both employer and employee. The employee can also send in his letter of termination and he need not give any reasons.

(31)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) That is not an answer.

(32)

EMPLOYMENT ACT - (Compensation to long-service employees whose services are - terminated) Second, if the employee feels that his services have been unfairly terminated, he can appeal to the Ministry which will look into the reasons for termination. He can appeal to the Minister who will ask for an inquiry to be conducted. Both parties will be invited to the Ministry. The Ministry will study the reasons. If it is unfair, the Ministry will ask the employer to take whatever action that is needed. The law provides for this and I do not see why the Member is raising this matter.

(33)

CRASH OF SILKAIR MI185 - (Status of investigation) asked the Minister for Communications what is the status of investigation on the crash of SilkAir MI185; whether there is any evidence or suspicion of foul play; and whether families of the victims are fairly compensated.

(34)

CRASH OF SILKAIR MI185 - (Status of investigation) Sir, investigations on the crash by a team of Indonesian, Singaporean and American experts are in progress, both in the United States and Indonesia. The task is made more difficult by the lack of useful data from the two black boxes, despite extensive efforts by investigators from the United States National Transportation and Safety Bureau (NTSB) and other expert agencies. The investigation team is headed by Indonesia and includes representatives from Singapore, the US and Australia. It will meet in Jakarta soon to review the status of the investigation and to work out a plan for the subsequent investigation task. These tasks include laboratory examination of wreckage pieces, reconstruction of parts of the aircraft, flight simulations using computers of flight simulators, study of the human performance aspects, review of flight and maintenance documents and further analysis of data from the cockpit voice recorder and flight data recorder. We hope that this phase of the investigation will provide us some clues to the cause of this tragic incident. On the question of foul play, so far, the team has not uncovered any evidence and there is no suspicion of foul play. On the matter of compensation, I am informed by SilkAir that their lawyer is currently liaising with the legal next-of-kin of the deceased. Compensation will be paid in accordance with the contract of carriage under international aviation regulations.

(35)

CRASH OF SILKAIR MI185 - (Status of investigation) Sir, I would like to ask the Minister whether he would consider calling a press conference of the experts who can perhaps brief the public and the press on some of these issues.

(36)

CRASH OF SILKAIR MI185 - (Status of investigation) Sir, as I said in my reply just now, the experts will be reconvening in Jakarta some time next week. After they have formulated the next phase of their investigation, I will request them to hold a press briefing to explain the status of the investigation so far, from the experts' point of view, and also to brief the public on what it intends to do in the next phase.

(37)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES asked the Minister for Finance, in light of the fundamental dilemma of public accountability versus entrepreneurial risk-taking which Government-Linked Companies (GLCs) face, as well as the Government's long-term intention of full divestment of those companies with commercial activities, whether the Government will consider accelerating the full divestment of some GLCs or some of the businesses of GLCs by schemes such as Management Buy-Outs.

(38)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES Sir, in principle, the Government is prepared to divest fully its stakes in the GLCs other than those of strategic interest to our defence or our economy. Other than these strategic investments, the rest can be privatised in due course. However, apart from the obvious considerations of market conditions, the pricing and the capacity of the market to absorb the divestments, there are a number of other considerations in deciding whether we can accelerate the process of divestment. In particular, the Government has put in much effort and resources to develop the GLCs, and we would want to divest them in such a way that the issue of management succession is properly addressed and that there will be either a single shareholder or a group of shareholders with a significant stake to provide management direction and to grow the company. This is important as Government would want the GLC to remain in relatively good hands. Government has also to be fair to the other minority shareholders of the GLC and be mindful that its divestments do not have too adverse an impact on the future of the company. This requirement will, however, slow down the divestment process. Management Buy-Outs (MBOs) are not ruled out as a divestment method for GLCs where the Government has a direct stake. MBO is possible if there is interest as well as a willingness to take the business risk on the part of the companies' management and agreement on reasonable terms of sale. However, the size of the GLCs often makes them beyond the financial resources of managements. Nevertheless, besides MBOs, other approaches of divestment had been, and will be, considered when the terms of sale are reasonable. Government will continue to pursue its privatisation and divestment programme in an orderly manner as and when the opportunity presents itself.

(39)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES Sir, in terms of the Government divestment programme, does the Government also intend to divest management, and not merely corporatisation? In other words, is it the Government's intention to have a full divestment, including that of management?

(40)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES I do not quite understand the Member. By divesting management, does she mean that Government has no longer any responsibility? You are talking about the difference between corporatization -

(41)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES Corporatisation and full divestment in terms of management.

(42)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES Yes, we have, in most cases, gone the route of full divestment without residual management control. I will give you a few examples of companies which we have fully divested and only retained a minimal control. In the case of Singapore Press Holdings, it has been fully divested, except that Government holds a golden share because it is a sensitive area. National Iron and Steel Mill has been totally divested. It is in the hands of the public and it has its own management. The others are UIC, Phillips Petroleum of Singapore and so forth. So there are many areas where we have totally divested.

(43)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES Sir, I may be wrong, but it would seem to me that the shares of many of these GLCs belong to holding companies that are in turn actually owned by the Government.

(44)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES There are some. Can you name some specific companies that you are concerned about?

(45)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES As far as I know, I think Temasek Holdings actually holds a substantial number of shares in many of the companies that you have mentioned. To that extent, Temasek Holdings actually would have a substantial say in terms of the management direction of the company.

(46)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES For those where it retains significant shareholdings, yes. But for those in which it does not hold substantial shareholdings, it would not.

(47)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES The Minister has mentioned that the Government has still got some residual control of SPH. Can I know what sort of control?

(48)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES No single person or company can hold more than 3% of SPH shares. And Government holds one golden share to ensure that no third party can take over the company because of the sensitivity of its operations. That is all that is controlled. So financially, as far as the commercial operations are concerned, Government has no control over it.

(49)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES What does the Minister mean by "golden share"?

(50)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES One nominal share, but that share has overriding powers over the management of the company. In other words, it can determine the Chairman and the Board.

(51)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES Does it also include the control of editorial policies?

(52)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES No.

(53)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES In so far as there are holding companies, which are fully owned by the Government, would also the full divestment policy of the Government also mean the relinquishment of control of some of these holding companies, so that for the GLCs, for which these holding companies have substantial shares, that these become truly private companies where the Government has no say in terms of management and control?

(54)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES What holding companies is the Member referring to? Temasek is a main holding company. In Temasek's case, it is quite clear. The Government, through Temasek, manages and controls those companies in which it owns substantial shares. What other holding companies is the Member referring to?

(55)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES This is where I think there is actually not very much knowledge regarding Temasek Holdings and the companies that Temasek Holdings owns. But as far as I know, Temasek Holdings actually does have substantial shares in quite a number of GLCs, the extent of which I really do not know. So because of Temasek Holdings' share, many of these companies actually are seen as Government-linked. I think my question really is: is it possible to cut off the link from the Government so that these companies are no longer Government-linked companies but become truly private companies?

(56)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES I suppose that will take place if Government shareholdings fall significantly below 10% where it becomes a minority shareholder and therefore should no longer have any direct say on its management. So that would be a general criterion that applies not only to Government companies but to companies in general.

(57)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES In light of public accountability, would the Government make the accounts of the holding companies public and transparent, for example, Temasek Holdings?

(58)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES Temasek does publish its accounts. But whether you have full access, it is a different matter. I think we will consider if it is necessary. At the moment, we would like to preserve our present arrangements.

(59)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES Why does the Minister say that we want to preserve the status quo by not divulging more information on Temasek Holdings' shareholding position?

(60)

DIVESTMENT OF GOVERNMENT-LINKED COMPANIES I think the number of companies in which Temasek Holdings has is, in fact, published in a book. There is a published book on Government-owned companies in which all the Government-owned companies and their subsidiaries are published. And each of these companies has its own balance sheet and therefore published. So you can quite easily aggregate the totals. I can make this book available to whichever Member is interested. The published book of Government holding companies, in which all the companies belonging to Temasek Holdings are, in fact, set out, with the Board of Directors, and so forth, and each of these companies in turn, particularly if they are public companies, would have annual reports.

(61)

(Rationale) asked the Minister for National Development what is the rationale for allowing developers time extensions to complete the sales and purchases of state land and whether he will provide a detailed list of developers and particulars of sites that were granted such extensions from 1993 up to the current year. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for National Development (Mr Koo Tsai Kee) (for the Minister for National Development): Mr Speaker, Sir, first, I would like to thank the Member for asking this question to allow the Ministry to clarify some points. The successful tenderer of a Government land sale site is required to pay 25% of the land premium within 28 days from the date of award. The balance 75% is to be paid within 90 days from the date of award, or any further period as may be extended by the Government subject to late interest charges. These terms are quite clearly spelt out in the tender conditions. Provisions for time extensions are made in the tender conditions as the successful tenderer may sometimes require a longer time-frame to arrange financing for the full payment of the land premium. Since 1993, a total of 33 cases have been granted extension of time for land premium. The breakdown is as follows: 2 cases in 1993; 3 in 1994 [these were boom times, I remember]; 16 in 1995; 2 in 1996; 2 in 1997 and recently 1998, 8 cases. These eight cases in 1998 were fully reported in the press recently. The tenderers were Centrepoint Properties Private Limited, Orchard Terminal Private Limited, Allgreen Properties Limited and the joint venture between Allgreen Properties Limited and Hoe Seng Company (Private) Limited. These tenderers have already made the initial 25% payment and have requested for an extension to pay the remaining 75%, subject to late interest charges.

(62)

(Reduction) asked the Minister for Labour, in view of the fact that workers depend on their Central Provident Fund to service housing loans and build up savings for Medisave and their old age and there is already a flexible wage system, whether he will give an assurance that CPF cuts will be allowed only as the last resort.

This is the start of the text. The rest is on the official site. Open the official text