General Division of the High Court · Decided 18 November 2026
Chia Chai Hong v Lim Hsien Chau and another
Feedback & support[2026] SGHC 236 · Case no. Originating Claim No 639 of 2024
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Philip Jeyaretnam J:
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The claimant, Chia Chai Hong (“Mdm Chia”), is an 83-year-old homemaker who used to own a property at 22 Li Hwan Drive, Singapore 557056 (“Property”) in her sole name. Over three years, she took several loans from the first defendant, Lim Hsien Chau (“Mr Lim”) and granted him successive options to purchase (“Options”) in respect of the Property. Mdm Chia described Mr Lim at trial as having been “even closer to [her] than [her] own children” because he “showed more concern and care towards [her]”.
- [2]
[2] Mdm Chia could not repay the money she borrowed from Mr Lim. Eventually, Mr Lim’s wife, the second defendant, Tan Chieh Hui, Tracy (Chen Jiahui Tracy) (“Mrs Lim”), exercised the fourth and final option as Mr Lim’s nominee in 2019. I will refer to Mr Lim and Mrs Lim collectively as the “Defendants”. After some years during which Mdm Chia and her family remained in the Property without paying rent, Mrs Lim sold it to a third party (whom I will refer to as the “Onward Buyer”) in 2023 for a significantly higher price than she had paid. It was only after this subsequent sale that Mdm Chia and her family moved out of the Property.
- [3]
[3] Mdm Chia commenced the present suit against the Defendants in 2024. She claims that she had only granted the options as a result of their misrepresentations, undue influence or unconscionable conduct. She also seeks remedies in unjust enrichment, and for breach of trust and breach of fiduciary duties by the Defendants.
- [4]
[4] Both Mdm Chia and Mr Lim resiled from the contents of documents that they admitted signing (in Mdm Chia’s case) or put forward (in Mr Lim’s case). The question then is what really happened between them. In Mdm Chia’s telling, the options granted were security for loans, with the amounts said to be disbursed to her inflated either arbitrarily or perhaps to include interest on the outstanding loans. Mr Lim by contrast asserted that he had paid the option fees as stated in the options. He claimed that his intention had always been to purchase the Property, although he accepted that they had verbally agreed that if Mdm Chia repaid the loans before the end of the (long) option periods, the respective options were not supposed to be exercised.
- [5]
[5] I first set out the background to this matter at [6]–[32] and the parties’ cases at [33]–[41], before setting out my findings of fact at [44]–[96], and finally explaining my decision on the claims and counterclaims at [97]–[161].
Facts
Background to the dispute
- [6]
[6] Mdm Chia was formerly a payroll clerk at a construction company, and she also assisted her husband’s trading company with payroll matters. She has been a homemaker since sometime in or around 1978. The Property was originally in her sole name, and her husband had paid for the Property entirely. At the material time, Mdm Chia resided at the Property with her husband and their two adult children.
- [7]
[7] Around the time that he first met Mdm Chia in 2016, Mr Lim owned four nightclubs, invested in cryptocurrency, and invested in properties either with his wife or other people (although Mrs Lim claimed that she did not know of any investment properties that she and her husband held together).
- [8]
[8] In 2015, Mdm Chia’s husband’s health deteriorated, affecting his ability to work and resulting in a fall in household income. Neither of Mdm Chia’s children was able to provide financial assistance at the time, leaving Mdm Chia solely responsible for mortgage repayments and family expenses.
The February 2016 Loan
- [9]
[9] According to Mdm Chia, she asked her son, Koh Wei How (Xu Weihao) (“Mr Koh”), to find someone to lend her money. In February 2016, she was introduced to Mr Lim by a friend of her son. She took a loan of $50,000 from Mr Lim and according to her, this loan had “nothing to do with [her] son”. On the other hand, Mr Koh testified that because he was looking to take out a loan, he was introduced to Mr Lim by a mutual acquaintance in 2016. Although Mr Koh eventually did not obtain a loan from Mr Lim, he claimed to have introduced Mr Lim to his mother when she asked him if he knew anyone who could provide a loan. Mr Koh knew that his mother, Mdm Chia, borrowed monies from Mr Lim, although he did not know the exact amount borrowed.
- [10]
[10] Both of these accounts differed from that given by Mr Lim, which was that Mr Koh was introduced to him by a friend. Mr Lim then lent $50,000 to Mr Koh in February 2016. However, Mr Koh later told Mr Lim that it was in fact Mdm Chia who had borrowed the money and so she would be making the repayments. Further, while Mr Lim claimed that he had extended a loan of $50,000 with interest of $10,000, to be payable in instalments over 24 weeks, Mdm Chia asserted that she was not informed of any specific interest rate. It was Mdm Chia’s position that she had only taken a $50,000 loan from Mr Lim, and no interest rate or deadline for repayment had been set. I will refer to the loan extended by Mr Lim to Mdm Chia in February 2016 as the “February 2016 Loan”. Parties agree that Mdm Chia has repaid $29,800 out of this loan. As such, Mr Lim’s case is that $30,200 remains outstanding (ie, the sum of $50,000 and interest of $10,000, less $29,800).
The Alleged July 2016 Payment and the First Option
- [11]
[11] Mdm Chia’s evidence was that at her request, on or about 19 July 2016, she received a further loan from Mr Lim. This was in the sum of $61,000. Again, she claimed that she was not informed of any specific interest rate applicable to this loan. I will refer to this as the “Alleged July 2016 Payment”. This time, however, Mr Lim allegedly asked her to provide an option in respect of the Property as collateral for the loan, and being in need of money, Mdm Chia agreed even though she did not intend to sell the Property. I will refer to this option dated 19 July 2016, and which was to expire on 31 July 2017, as the “First Option”.
- [12]
[12] The sale price of the Property was stated as $2,000,000 in the First Option. Mdm Chia did not agree that this was the true or fair value. She testified that she believed the Property was instead worth $3,000,000. Although the First Option was stated to be granted “[i]n consideration of the sum of [$240,000] … received by [Mdm Chia] from [Mr Lim] this day by way of option money”, Mdm Chia claimed that she did not receive the $240,000 option money. She said that Mr Lim had assured her that “this [was] part of the company procedure” and “a mere formality”. Mr Lim also allegedly told her that the First Option would be torn up if she repaid the loan.
- [13]
[13] Mr Lim’s position is that in July 2016, he rejected Mdm Chia’s request for a loan of $60,000. She then offered to allow him to purchase the Property for $2,400,000. He testified that he did not purchase the Property immediately because he held a matrimonial home in joint names with Mrs Lim in 2016, and did not wish to incur the additional buyer’s stamp duty (“ABSD”) which would have to be paid if the Property was purchased then. Mr Lim only bought over Mrs Lim’s share of their matrimonial home in 2019 (see [20] below). Although Mdm Chia eventually agreed to a lower purchase price of $2,000,000, she purportedly insisted that the downpayment remain at $240,000 (ie, 10% of the original proposed purchase price).
- [14]
[14] Mr Lim instructed Alan Shankar & Lim LLC (“AS&L”) to prepare an option (ie, the First Option). The First Option was signed at the offices of AS&L, with Mr Koh witnessing the signing. Mr Lim claimed that he passed $240,000 in cash to Mdm Chia at this meeting without letting Mr Koh know, and so there were no witnesses to this cash transfer. On the same day (ie, 19 July 2016), Mr Lim signed an acknowledgement note, confirming that he undertook not to exercise the First Option if the option money of $240,000 was returned on or before 30 July 2017. After the signing of the First Option, Mr Lim instructed AS&L to lodge a caveat over the Property.
The August 2016 Payment
- [15]
[15] According to Mdm Chia, upon her request, Mr Lim provided a further loan of $30,000 on 22 August 2016. Mr Lim, however, claims that he paid $60,000 to Mdm Chia not as a loan, but as part payment of the purchase price of the Property. Although she had signed an acknowledgement before a Commissioner for Oaths which provided that she had received $60,000 from Mr Lim as “further payment towards the sale price of [the] Property”, Mdm Chia argues that she had only received $30,000, and Mr Lim had told her that the acknowledgement was just a formality. I will refer to this as the “August 2016 Payment”, the quantum of which is disputed.
The Second to Fourth Options
- [16]
[16] Shortly before the First Option was due to expire, Mdm Chia and Mr Lim signed a new option dated 17 July 2017, which was to expire on 1 July 2018. I will refer to this as the “Second Option”. The Second Option was signed at an office of a Commissioner for Oaths. The option money stated on the Second Option was $400,000, and it is Mr Lim’s case that he paid $100,000 in cash to Mdm Chia outside the Commissioner’s office on the day of signing. Taken together with the sums of $240,000 and $60,000 that he had purportedly paid her previously (see [14] and [15] above), the cumulative option money allegedly paid to Mdm Chia was $400,000. Mdm Chia, however, said that she did not receive any money when signing the Second Option. She only “blindly” signed it as she “totally rel[ied]” on Mr Lim and his representation that the signing of this document was a formality and part of his company’s procedure. As noted at [12] and [15] above, she also claims that she did not receive the sums of $240,000 and $60,000 from Mr Lim previously.
- [17]
[17] A similar process was adopted for the signing of the next option, which I will refer to as the “Third Option”. Mr Lim’s evidence was that he needed the Third Option because he was still the owner of another residential property and so was not willing to exercise the Second Option. The Third Option was not prepared by AS&L, but by a real estate firm, C&H Group. Before the expiry of the Second Option, Mdm Chia and Mr Lim signed the Third Option dated 19 June 2018, which was stated to expire on 1 July 2019. The option money for the Third Option was stated to be $500,000, and again, Mr Lim claims that he paid Mdm Chia $100,000 in cash on the day of signing this Option. This sum, together with the $400,000 allegedly paid to Mdm Chia previously (see [16] above), constituted the option money. Similar to her position on the Second Option, Mdm Chia testified that she “blindly” signed the Third Option and did not receive any option monies.
- [18]
[18] The final option – which I will refer to as the “Fourth Option” – was signed on 18 February 2019, and was due to expire on 31 December 2019. This time, the option money was not amended, and was reflected as $500,000. It is noteworthy that on the same day, Mdm Chia signed a letter (“February 2019 Acknowledgement”) acknowledging her receipt of $500,000 paid on 18 February 2019 from Mr Lim, this “being the payment deposit towards the sale price of [the] Property”. Mr Lim accepts that despite the wording of the acknowledgement, he did not pay her any money on that day. Indeed, the parties agree that no monies were given by Mr Lim to Mdm Chia on the day on which the Fourth Option was signed.
- [19]
[19] However, according to Mr Lim, he had paid Mdm Chia a total of $500,000 prior to this date (see [17] above). The Fourth Option was said to be required because Mdm Chia requested for an extension of time to repay the outstanding balance due under the February 2016 Loan and the option money of $500,000. On the other hand, Mdm Chia states that she agreed to sign the Fourth Option and the February 2019 Acknowledgement despite not having received any option monies because Mr Lim allegedly assured her that the documents were a matter of formality and the Fourth Option “would not be used against [her]”.
- [20]
[20] I pause to explain why the parties had signed multiple options. In my view, this was both because the options were entered into as security for the loans extended by Mr Lim to Mdm Chia and because he was not ready to exercise the first three options prior to their lapsing. On his own account, he was not ready to exercise the First or Second Option while he was still a joint owner of a separate property with Mrs Lim. I also find that this was the case in relation to the Third Option. As an owner of another property, he would have incurred the ABSD if he purchased the Property (see [13] above). On the other hand, as the loans that he extended to Mdm Chia remained largely unpaid, Mr Lim was unwilling to let each option expire, because that would have meant losing his security for the loans that the Property represented. A fresh option thus had to be signed close to the expiry date of the previous option. Mdm Chia does not appear to have been aware of these underlying considerations. As explained above, her consistent evidence (in her affidavit and at trial) was that she was unclear why she needed to sign the options and she merely relied on Mr Lim’s reassurances that it was his company’s usual procedure to do so. While one obvious solution to her financial woes would have been to sell the Property on the open market, that avenue was not realistically open to her, given her fear of causing her ailing husband (who lived with her in the Property) further stress. I also find that Mr Lim knew full well of Mdm Chia’s fear and, as I explain later, took advantage of this fear. Mdm Chia’s genuine and heartfelt concern not to involve her husband in this matter was apparent at trial. The parties thus signed multiple options over several years. Mr Lim was only ready to exercise the option over the Property (albeit by his wife as nominee) on or after 15 August 2019, when he bought over his wife’s half-share of their matrimonial home. That was followed shortly afterwards by Mrs Lim exercising the Fourth Option, to which I now turn.
Exercising the Fourth Option
- [21]
[21] According to Mrs Lim, it was only on 20 September 2019 that Mr Lim informed her about the Fourth Option, and she then paid $500,000 to Mr Lim (that being the equivalent of the option monies that Mr Lim had allegedly paid to Mdm Chia). On 19 November 2019, Mrs Lim – as Mr Lim’s nominee – exercised the Fourth Option. The Fourth Option provided for the Option to be exercised by the signing of the part of the Option marked “Acceptance Copy” and the payment of a balance deposit (equivalent to 26% of the sale price of $2,000,000 less the option monies of $500,000, ie, $20,000). It is undisputed that the balance deposit of $20,000 was paid to Mdm Chia’s solicitors on the day that the Option was exercised. The sale was completed on 30 December 2019.
- [22]
[22] On 27 December 2019, Mdm Chia received $50,000 from Mr Lim. Mdm Chia’s own account of this payment was unclear: she vacillated between describing it as payment towards the purchase price of the Property, and referring to it as a loan. In her Statement of Claim (Amendment No. 1) dated 7 August 2025 (“SOC”), this payment is described as being made towards the purchase price. Mr Lim’s evidence was that Mdm Chia had requested a loan urgently, and he had agreed to lend her $50,000 as she promised to repay this loan after receiving the sale proceeds of the Property. I will refer to this as the “December 2019 Payment”, which I discuss further at [66]–[68] below.
- [23]
[23] Following completion of the sale of the Property, Mdm Chia collected two cashier’s orders totalling $547,001.66 from her solicitors. This sum was the balance of the sale price and reimbursement of her share of property tax after the completion date, less the option monies of $500,000, the amount of $950,000 set aside for repayment of redemption monies to Mdm Chia’s mortgagee, and legal fees of $3,000.
The Tenancy Agreement and the three Statements of Account
- [24]
[24] After the Property was sold to Mrs Lim in end-2019, Mdm Chia faced difficulties in finding an alternative place of residence given the restrictions imposed during the Covid-19 pandemic. She thus sought two six-month-long extensions of time to vacate the Property. Even though the Fourth Option had been exercised by Mrs Lim, Mdm Chia only liaised with Mr Lim. Mrs Lim agreed to Mdm Chia’s request for the two extensions via Mr Lim. In February 2021, Mr Lim informed Mdm Chia that Mrs Lim required her to pay rent and enter into a tenancy agreement. Mdm Chia claims that Mr Lim verbally promised that she could reside in the Property without paying rent, until the Property was sold in about three years; Mr Lim’s case is that no such representation was made. Although Mdm Chia and Mrs Lim signed a tenancy agreement dated 23 February 2021 (“Tenancy Agreement”), both of them agree that all discussions regarding the tenancy only involved Mdm Chia and Mr Lim. The Tenancy Agreement provided for an 11-month-long tenancy of the Property from 1 February 2021 to 31 December 2021 (with the option to extend the tenancy for a further year thereafter), with monthly rent fixed at $4,000. No rental was collected and Mdm Chia resided in the Property rent-free from 2020 to April 2023.
- [25]
[25] During this time, Mr Lim produced what were described as statements of account, the first of which was dated 1 January 2022. He later produced another two, both dated 1 February 2023. I will refer to these as the “First”, “Second” and “Third Statement of Account” respectively; each statement superseded the previous one.
- [26]
[26] For ease of reference, I set out the figures in the three Statements of Account in the table below. Under the First, Second and Third Statements, Mr Lim offered to pay Mdm Chia $54,000, $190,000 and $284,500 respectively.
Description
First Statement of Account
Second Statement of Account
Third Statement of Account
Amount due from Mdm Chia: (A)
Principal
$158,000
$158,000
$158,000
Interest
$60,000
$60,000
$60,000
Exercise fee
$20,000
$20,000
$20,000
Legal fee (buyer)
$6,000
$6,000
$6,000
Stamp duty (3%)
$85,000
$85,000
$85,000
Rental
$96,000
$144,000
$144,000
Legal fee (seller)
$6,000
$6,000
$6,000
Stamp duty (4%)
$120,000
NA (struck out in 2nd Statement of Account)
NA (struck out in 3rd Statement of Account)
Cash
$50,000
$50,000
$50,000
Agent fee
$30,000
$66,000
NA (struck out in 3rd Statement of Account)
Late payment
$15,000
$15,000
$15,000
Advance
NA (no such item in 1st Statement of Account)
NA (no such item in 2nd Statement of Account)
$100,000
Amount due to Mdm Chia: (B)
Cash over value
$200,000
$200,000
$200,000
Downpayment
$500,000
$500,000
$500,000
Cash over sale
NA (no such item in 1st Statement of Account)
$100,000
$100,000
Additional cash over sale
NA (no such item in 1st Statement of Account)
NA (no such item in 2nd Statement of Account)
$100,000
Investment
NA (no such item in 1st Statement of Account)
NA (no such item in 2nd Statement of Account)
$28,500
Balance (amount due to Mdm Chia = (B) – (A))
$54,000
$190,000
$284,500
- [27]
[27] According to Mr Lim, these statements were produced because Mdm Chia allegedly insisted that she should be provided with a statement, and also that she should be paid more for the sale of the Property, failing which she would not vacate the Property. He claims that he had to keep increasing his offer in order to persuade her to vacate. It became urgent that she vacate once Mrs Lim sold the Property in early 2023 with vacant possession to the Onward Buyer for $3,800,000, with the completion date set on 24 April 2023. Mr Lim felt “pressured” to offer Mdm Chia more money to persuade her to move out; he thus issued the Second, and shortly afterwards, the Third Statements of Account.
- [28]
[28] Mr Lim resiles from all three statements that he prepared. His evidence is that he added “inaccurate” and “arbitrary” figures to arrive at the final figures in the statements. That was simply what he was prepared to pay Mdm Chia at the relevant time to “resolve all issues” and have her vacate the Property. Focusing on the Third Statement of Account, I find that the figures indeed appear to be inflated and padded up in a rather misleading manner: for instance, it is unclear why: (a) the legal fee of $6,000 is taken to be owed by Mdm Chia; (b) a late payment fee of $15,000 is included; and (c) Mdm Chia (as the seller) is said to owe stamp duty (3%) of $85,000. Meanwhile, Mdm Chia contends that the First Statement of Account contains “unjustified” or “false” claims of expenses incurred by her, while the Second Statement of Account is inaccurate as it was premised on a property value of $2,200,000 (when Mr Lim had allegedly previously agreed to use $2,500,000 as the property value). Mdm Chia also disagrees with the sums in the Third Statement of Account, for instance because certain expenses were wrongly attributed to her, and an advance payment of $100,000 was stated to have been made to her when she had not received this (at least at the time that she received this statement).
- [29]
[29] I note that there was some inconsistency in Mr Lim’s evidence: in his affidavit, he states that he agreed to pay Mdm Chia $100,000 as an advance, and this sum was part of the total amount of $256,000 that he was willing to pay her. However, the Third Statement of Account provides for a balance sum of $356,000 (which includes the advance of $100,000). I stood down the trial briefly to allow Mr Lim’s counsel to take instructions from his client on this matter. Counsel subsequently clarified that Mr Lim’s final position was in line with the Third Statement of Account; ie, he had offered a total of $356,000 to Mdm Chia in early 2023.
- [30]
[30] Pursuant to the Third Statement of Account, Mr Lim made two transfers of $50,000 each to Mdm Chia on or around 4 and 23 April 2023 (thus amounting to the total advance of $100,000). However, Mr Lim claims that Mdm Chia later informed him that she did not agree with the Third Statement of Account, notwithstanding her receipt of the advance of $100,000. He takes the view that since Mdm Chia reneged on her agreement to abide by the Third Statement of Account, he was not obliged to honour the offer (to pay her the remaining $256,000), and so he blocked her calls thereafter.
- [31]
[31] Mdm Chia accepts that she received $100,000 from Mr Lim, made in two payments of $50,000 each on or around 4 and 24 April 2023 (there being a minor difference in the parties’ accounts of when the second payment was made). According to her, Mr Lim assured her that he would “settle the final account with [her]” after he received the sale proceeds from the sale of the Property. However, she submits that after the completion of the sale of the Property on 24 April 2023, Mr Lim became uncontactable and she received no further payment. Mdm Chia lodged a police report on 19 July 2023, claiming that Mr Lim owed her outstanding sums in relation to the sale of the Property.
- [32]
[32] As a final observation, I add that Mrs Lim claimed to have expended all of the sale proceeds from the Property on two hotels that she opened in early 2023.
The parties’ cases
- [33]
[33] Mdm Chia alleges that the Second, Third and Fourth Options are invalid for lack of consideration, and/or were granted while she was under the undue influence of Mr Lim. In any event, all four options were procured by Mr Lim’s alleged misrepresentation and/or unconscionable conduct. Mdm Chia also claims that the option monies of $500,000 were not paid to her, the Property was sold at a gross undervalue (in reliance on representations made by Mr Lim), and the Defendants were unjustly enriched by the resale of the Property to the Onward Buyer.
- [34]
[34] In addition, Mdm Chia submits that Mr Lim “cultivated a relationship of trust and confidence” with her, and “exploited [her] vulnerability and financial difficulties”. Mr Lim breached the fiduciary duties that he owed Mdm Chia by failing to make full and frank disclosure of material facts (eg, the true market value of the Property) and placed his own interests above that of Mdm Chia. Further, as Mr Lim’s nominee, Mrs Lim knew or ought reasonably to have known of the circumstances surrounding the sale of the Property. In so far as Mr Lim breached his fiduciary duties, she was liable for “knowing receipt and participation”.
- [35]
[35] Mdm Chia also contends that the First, Second and Third Statements of Account are all instantiations of fraudulent misrepresentation and/or unconscionable conduct by Mr Lim, and that the three statements should be declared null and void.
- [36]
[36] Finally, Mdm Chia claims that the Defendants’ conduct in relation to the sale of the Property gives rise to a constructive trust and/or a resulting trust over the Property and/or the proceeds of sale, in her favour.
- [37]
[37] To sum up, Mdm Chia seeks the following broad relief:
(a) A declaration that the sale and purchase agreement dated 19 November 2019 between Mdm Chia and Mrs Lim be set aside.
(b) Further or in the alternative, $2,038,800 from the Defendants, this being the resale price of the Property ($3,800,000), less the payment of the purchase price made by Mrs Lim to Mdm Chia of $1,500,000, the balance of the loans she owes to Mr Lim, the December 2019 Payment (see [22] above) and the $100,000 payment in April 2023 (see [30]–[31] above).
(c) Further or in the alternative, a declaration that the Defendants hold the proceeds of sale and/or profits from the Property on constructive and/or resulting trust for Mdm Chia, and that Mdm Chia be entitled to an accounting and tracing of the same.
(d) An order that Mr Lim be held liable for breach of fiduciary duty and ordered to make restitution or account for profits.
- [38]
[38] Mr Lim rejects Mdm Chia’s characterisation of events and instead argues that she had “complete knowledge of all her contractual obligations”. According to him, the Options are valid and the amounts stated therein or in the acknowledgements are genuine. The purchase price of $2,000,000 for the sale of the Property by Mdm Chia to Mrs Lim was agreed between parties and therefore not grossly undervalued. Any profit made from the resale of the Property in 2023 was by Mrs Lim (not Mr Lim), and in any case it is unfair for Mdm Chia to seek to increase the valuation of the Property when she had agreed to the original price of $2,000,000 as stated in all four options. Mr Lim also denies having been unjustly enriched or having breached fiduciary duties owed to Mdm Chia; it is also denied that any constructive or resulting trust arises over the Property.
- [39]
[39] In his counterclaim, Mr Lim seeks $180,200 from Mdm Chia, this being the sum of: (a) the outstanding amount owed under the February 2016 Loan (ie, $30,200) (see [10] above); (b) the December 2019 Payment which Mr Lim described as a loan (see [22] above); and (c) the advance payment of $100,000 (see [30] above).
- [40]
[40] Mrs Lim submits that she has no knowledge of the events involving Mdm Chia and Mr Lim prior to Mr Lim informing her about, and nominating her to exercise, the Fourth Option. She denies that the Fourth Option is invalid for lack of consideration, and asserts that it was voluntarily granted by Mdm Chia. Mrs Lim claims to be a bona fide purchaser for value, who did not know and had no reasonable grounds to have known that Mdm Chia had not received any option monies, or that the Property was grossly undervalued when it was sold at $2,000,000. This is because Mrs Lim dealt with Mdm Chia at an arm’s length, commercial basis, and Mrs Lim also made an independent decision to exercise the Fourth Option, without acting in concert with Mr Lim. She therefore cannot be liable for unjust enrichment, and in any case she claims that she can rely on the defence of change of position as she has spent the proceeds from the sale of the Property on her hotel business (see [32] above). There is no basis to impute any alleged unconscionable conduct on Mr Lim’s part to her, and she did not know of any alleged undue influence or misrepresentation by Mr Lim. Mrs Lim also denies that any constructive or resulting trust arose over the Property.
- [41]
[41] In her counterclaim, Mrs Lim seeks $107,440 from Mdm Chia, this being the sum of the rent owed for the period from 1 February 2021 to 31 December 2022 at a monthly rent of $4,000 (ie, $92,000), and for the period from 1 January 2023 to 23 April 2023 at a monthly rent of $4,100 (ie, $15,440).
Issues to be determined
- [42]
[42] The present case gives rise to the following factual disputes:
- [43]
[43] The resolution of these factual issues is necessary before the following legal issues can be addressed:
Factual issues in dispute
Whether Mdm Chia received payment of the option monies of $500,000
- [44]
[44] The option monies of $500,000 comprise four individual payments allegedly made to Mdm Chia; namely, $240,000 paid in cash on 19 July 2016 (see [14] above), $60,000 paid on 22 August 2016 (see [15] above), $100,000 paid on 17 July 2017 (see [16] above), and $100,000 paid on 19 June 2018 (see [17] above).
- [45]
[45] First, I do not accept that Mdm Chia was paid $240,000 in cash at the office of AS&L on the day that she signed the First Option. I find that she never received this money in cash or otherwise. I make this finding for the following reasons:
(a) Payment of such a large sum of money in cash is unusual. Mr Lim explained that his nightclub businesses generated very large quantities of cash such that he was usually in possession of several hundred thousands of dollars. However, even if this was cash generated by his businesses, his use of such a large sum of money belonging to those businesses would likely have required some form of accounting entry in relation to the books of such businesses. No such entry was adduced in evidence.
(b) Mr Lim’s evidence on the handover of the money was inconsistent and unconvincing. When questioned about how he handed $240,000 in cash to Mdm Chia, he first testified that the stack of money in $1,000, $100 and $50 bills could fit into a backpack, before clarifying that he had placed the money in an envelope, and then explaining that some of the money was actually placed in a plastic bag, with the rest in an envelope. It was only when the claimant’s counsel asked if he handed such a large sum to Mdm Chia without even taking a photograph that Mr Lim belatedly suggested that he had taken a photograph of the cash, but that he needed time to find this photograph which had not been disclosed or included in his affidavit.
(c) Mr Lim’s evidence of what Mdm Chia did after receiving the money from him was also implausible. He testified that Mdm Chia placed the plastic bag and envelope of cash in her handbag, and after being questioned about whether she counted the money, clarified that she had indeed counted the stacks of cash. However, he also said that Mdm Chia “didn’t really count much”. His affidavit did not contain these, or any other specific, details concerning the alleged handover.
- [46]
[46] Second, I do not accept that Mr Lim paid Mdm Chia $100,000 in cash on 17 July 2017 and $100,000 in cash on 19 June 2018 and find that he did not make these payments in cash or at all. Mr Lim simply asserts that these sums were paid when the Second and Third Options were signed, without offering any evidence in support of his having done so. I find that he has not discharged the burden of proving that these payments were made.
- [47]
[47] Third, the fact that there was the August 2016 Payment is common ground, but parties disagree on: (a) whether this was a loan or part payment of the purchase price; and (b) how much Mr Lim paid Mdm Chia. As noted at [15] above, Mdm Chia signed an acknowledgement of receipt of $60,000 as payment towards the price of the Property. While she stated in her affidavit that she borrowed $30,000 cash from Mr Lim, and she reiterated this at trial, she had also testified that she took $60,000 from Mr Lim to pay off a creditor (ABM Creditz) that had filed a caveat over the Property.
- [48]
[48] Notwithstanding this slight inconsistency, I find that the August 2016 Payment was a loan for $30,000. This is because the caveat lodged by ABM Creditz named Mr Koh as the borrower, and he testified that he had borrowed $30,000 from ABM Creditz (of which he retained several thousand dollars, with the rest given to Mdm Chia). If – as Mr Lim himself accepts – the purpose of this loan was to pay off the debt owed to ABM Creditz, it would be more likely for Mdm Chia to have borrowed $30,000 (not $60,000) to repay a loan of the same amount to ABM Creditz. I am also satisfied that this payment of $30,000 to Mdm Chia was likely a loan (and not part payment of the purchase price) because this payment is not reflected in the completion account dated 30 December 2019 provided to Mdm Chia. There is no evidence that this sum of $30,000 was taken into account when calculating the amount due to Mdm Chia following the sale of the Property to Mrs Lim. As such, the August 2016 Payment does not constitute part payment of the option monies to Mdm Chia.
- [49]
[49] In sum, I find that Mr Lim has failed to prove that Mdm Chia was paid the option monies of $500,000, and hold that she did not receive these monies.
- [50]
[50] My conclusion is fortified by the fact that all three Statements of Account contain an entry for a “downpayment” of $500,000 owed to Mdm Chia (see [26] above). Parties disagree on what this figure represents. Mr Lim’s explanation was that he included the figure of $500,000 as a “downpayment” to appease Mdm Chia, who had insisted that the Property was worth $2,500,000 when it was only sold by her to Mrs Lim for $2,000,000. Mdm Chia appears to have reached this conclusion because Mr Lim had told her that the valuation of the Property adopted by the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore was $2,500,000. This explanation of the “downpayment” suggests that the figure of $500,000 was specifically calculated and deliberately included by Mr Lim. Yet this runs counter to his own pleaded case that the Statements of Account contain “arbitrary” figures that were merely included to add up to the final figure which Mr Lim was willing to pay (see [28] above). Instead, a more likely reason for the use of the word “downpayment” in respect of the figure of $500,000 is that, as Mdm Chia contended, it reflects the option monies which Mr Lim owed to her because she had not received them from him in the first place. I accordingly make this finding in Mdm Chia’s favour.
- [51]
[51] I make three further observations on parties’ submissions regarding the option monies.
- [52]
[52] First, although Mdm Chia signed the February 2019 Acknowledgement (see [18] above) to acknowledge receipt of $500,000 “on [18] February 2019 from [Mr Lim]”, Mr Lim accepted that he did not pay any monies to Mdm Chia on that day. Instead, he had “already paid a total of [$500,000] progressively from 2016”. I find the February 2019 Acknowledgement to be of little assistance in determining whether the option monies had in fact been paid to Mdm Chia, since it reflects yet another document which the parties agree is inaccurate, albeit for different reasons. Mdm Chia disputes receipt of the monies entirely, while Mr Lim argues that the monies were paid, just not on 18 February 2019 alone. In the circumstances, the document neither sheds light on when the option monies were paid (if at all), nor can it be held against Mdm Chia as proof of her receipt of the option monies. I should add that the fact that the signing of the February 2019 Acknowledgement was witnessed by a commissioner for oaths – whose role includes administering oaths for various purposes (see s 68(2) of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1969 (2020 Rev Ed)) – does not necessarily mean that Mdm Chia had in fact received $500,000 from Mr Lim. There was no suggestion that the commissioner for oaths witnessed any handing over of cash.
- [53]
[53] Second, counsel for Mr Lim pointed to the fact that Mdm Chia had not objected to the completion account included in a letter from her own solicitors (K H Ching LLC) dated 23 December 2019. The completion account was drawn up on the basis that the option monies of $500,000 had been received by Mdm Chia. Mdm Chia’s response was that she was not consulted on any of the figures prior to the finalisation of the completion account, and after she received that letter, she did not think about informing her lawyers that she had not received the option monies. Reading the letter and completion account in the context of the overall relationship between Mdm Chia and Mr Lim, I accept Mdm Chia’s explanation. Mdm Chia’s testimony was also that she had “suffer[ed] a lot while handling this matter”. Considering that Mdm Chia had to bear the hefty burden of trying to pay off the loans extended by Mr Lim alongside her trepidation about telling her husband about the sale of the home, I accept that Mdm Chia was likely focused on Mr Lim’s assurances that he would top up the monies payable to her once he sold the Property on to a third party (see [84]–[89] below), and that that she could continue to stay at the Property (see [90]–[96] below).
- [54]
[54] Third, although Mrs Lim stated that she did not know if Mdm Chia received the option monies, she claims to have paid an equivalent sum of $500,000 to Mr Lim, so that she could be nominated to exercise the Fourth Option. She claimed to have done so by depositing a cashier’s order for $436,575.05 in the Defendants’ joint account, and then making two transfers of $50,000 and $49,000 from her personal bank account to the Defendants’ joint account. However, I find that this account of events is not borne out by the evidence, and thus neither buttresses Mr Lim’s claim that he had paid Mdm Chia the option monies nor demonstrates that the dealing between the Defendants was at arm’s length.
- [55]
[55] Beginning with the cashier’s order for $436,575.05, Mrs Lim testified that she could not remember who had obtained this cashier’s order (which was stated to be payable to her, not Mr Lim). She also claimed that she deposited a cashier’s order instead of simply making a transfer from her personal bank account to the Defendants’ joint bank account to “prove a point” and “tick [Mr Lim] off”, although she failed to provide further explanation of what this meant. When asked why she paid such a specific sum to Mr Lim (instead of $500,000), she suggested that she might have received that amount “from somewhere” but she “forgot where”.
- [56]
[56] Indeed, there is evidence that Mrs Lim probably received the cashier’s order from someone else on a different occasion. This is because the cashier’s order is dated 18 September 2019, and it is Mrs Lim’s own pleaded case that it was only on or around 20 September 2019 that Mr Lim informed her about the existence of the Fourth Option. I find that the more likely sequence of events is that on an unrelated occasion, Mrs Lim received the cashier’s order for the specific sum of $436,575.05 payable to her. She then repurposed this document to support her case that she had paid Mr Lim the option fee of $500,000, to create a mirage of independence and arm’s length dealing between the Defendants. I add that although counsel for Mr Lim stated in closing submissions that he was instructed that the cashier’s order made out in Mrs Lim’s favour (and which was paid into the Defendants’ joint account) had been provided by Mr Lim, this assertion, even if true, did not assist Mrs Lim’s case that she had paid Mr Lim $500,000.
- [57]
[57] As for the two transfers of $50,000 and $49,000 that Mrs Lim says she made from her personal bank account to the Defendants’ joint account, these were carried out on 24 October 2019, one month after the cashier’s order was deposited into the Defendants’ joint account on 24 September 2019. The sums of $436,575.05, $49,000 and $50,000 add up to $535,575.05. Mrs Lim’s pleaded case is that the amount in excess of $500,000 was “for other monies for [Mr Lim]”, In the absence of any evidence regarding what these “other monies” were, I find that this was likely an afterthought conjured by Mrs Lim in an attempt to demonstrate that she had paid Mr Lim for the option monies that he claimed had been paid to Mdm Chia. I do not accept that Mrs Lim had paid Mr Lim for the option monies of $500,000.
- [58]
[58] To sum up, I find that Mdm Chia was not paid the option monies of $500,000 (or any part thereof). This sum thus remains outstanding to Mdm Chia.
The loans provided by Mr Lim to Mdm Chia
- [59]
[59] The parties disagree on the number of loans that Mdm Chia took from Mr Lim. This evidently has a bearing on the amount that Mdm Chia owes to Mr Lim, which should be taken into account when calculating the net amount owed to or by Mdm Chia.
- [60]
[60] On Mr Lim’s case, he had only granted two loans: the first was the February 2016 Loan (comprising a principal sum of $50,000 and interest of $10,000) (see [10] above) which he had given to Mr Koh but which Mdm Chia later took responsibility for repaying; the second was the December 2019 Payment of $50,000 (see [22] above). These loans amount to a total of $110,000.
- [61]
[61] According to Mdm Chia, she obtained three loans from Mr Lim: the February 2016 Loan of $50,000, the Alleged July 2016 Payment of $61,000 (see [11] above), and the August 2016 Payment of $30,000 (see [15] above). These loans – which Mdm Chia accepts should be repaid – amount to a total of $141,000.
- [62]
[62] For ease of reference, I summarise the parties’ cases and my decision below:
Parties’ positions on nature of payment
Parties’ positions on quantum of payment
My decision
February 2016 Loan
Undisputed: both agree that this is a loan given to Mdm Chia.
Both agree that a principal loan of $50,000 was given to Mdm Chia. Mr Lim claims that interest of $10,000 is due too, and Mdm Chia disputes this.
This is a loan of $50,000 given to Mdm Chia. No interest is due.
Alleged July 2016 Payment
Mdm Chia claims that this is a loan given to her. Mr Lim denies having made such payment.
Mdm Chia claims that a loan of $61,000 was given to her.
This is a loan of $61,000 given to Mdm Chia.
August 2016 Payment
Mdm Chia claims that this is a loan. Mr Lim claims that this is a part payment of the purchase price (which forms part of the option monies paid to her).
Mdm Chia claims that a loan of $30,000 was given to her. Mr Lim claims that he paid her $60,000.
This is a loan of $30,000 given to Mdm Chia.
December 2019 Payment
Mdm Chia’s pleaded case is that this is part payment of the purchase price. Mr Lim claims that it is a loan.
Undisputed: both agree that payment of $50,000 was made to Mdm Chia.
This is a loan of $50,000 given to Mdm Chia.
- [63]
[63] I now explain my decision on the nature and the quantum of each of the four payments above. I deal first with the February 2016 Loan and the December 2019 Payment, as both are the subject of Mr Lim’s counterclaims. I will then turn to the Alleged July 2016 Payment and the August 2016 Payment which, despite not having been counterclaimed as debts owed by Mr Lim, are relevant since Mdm Chia herself admits that she owes those monies to Mr Lim.
- [64]
[64] First, beginning with the February 2016 Loan, Mdm Chia and Mr Lim agree on the principal sum of $50,000, but disagree on whether interest of $10,000 is payable by Mdm Chia. While Mr Lim’s counsel argued in closing submissions that Mdm Chia had accepted the need to pay interest on this loan, I do not find that to be borne out by the available evidence. Notwithstanding counsel’s selection of various responses given by Mdm Chia which appear to suggest an acceptance of the need to pay interest, Mdm Chia had – in her affidavit and at trial – consistently denied having been informed of any interest due on the February 2016 Loan. In addition, I find that Mr Lim’s claim that he had communicated the interest of $10,000 to Mdm Chia is unsubstantiated; he merely asserts that he had entered into a verbal agreement for this. Under s 105 of the Evidence Act 1893 (2020 Rev Ed), Mr Lim bears the burden of proving the fact that he asserts (ie, that he had previously communicated the interest owed to Mdm Chia).
- [65]
[65] In this regard, a relevant consideration is the fact that on Mr Lim’s case, he extended a $50,000 loan to Mdm Chia in 2019 (ie, the December 2019 Payment) (see [22] above), yet there is no indication that interest was to be charged on this loan. Indeed, in his counterclaim, Mr Lim includes no interest – apart from interest from the date of the originating claim to the date of payment of the judgment sum – for this loan of $50,000. I flag that whether this sum truly took the nature of a loan is discussed at [66]–[68] below. However, for present purposes, the absence of interest for the December 2019 Payment suggests – at least – that Mr Lim did not adopt a consistent practice in charging interest for the loans that he extended to Mdm Chia. This also casts doubt on whether Mr Lim had communicated the interest of $10,000 for the February 2016 Loan to Mdm Chia. Given the absence of evidence of interest having been charged on the February 2016 Loan, I find that under that loan, Mdm Chia owed $50,000 (with no additional interest element), and she has since repaid $29,800 (see [10] above). She therefore owes $20,200 under the February 2016 Loan.
- [66]
[66] Second, as noted at [22] above, parties disagree on whether the December 2019 Payment is a loan or payment towards the purchase price of the Property. In arguing that the payment of $50,000 took the form of a loan, Mr Lim points to two exchanges of messages between him and Mdm Chia. In the first exchange, Mdm Chia asked Mr Lim to call her on 6 December 2019. On 10 December 2019, she mentioned that she “need[ed] about $50k before 15th [that] month and [Mr Lim] had promise[d]”. In the second exchange, Mdm Chia texted on 26 December 2019 that she would wait for Mr Lim at a taxi stand. According to Mr Lim, that was the day on which he passed her $50,000 in cash at a taxi stand. I accept that these messages support Mr Lim’s explanation that Mdm Chia had told him that she urgently required a further loan in December 2019.
- [67]
[67] Conversely, Mdm Chia was unable to point to any evidence in support of her claim that “[o]n or about 27 December 2019, [Mr Lim] extended a sum of $50,000 towards the purchase price of the Property”. There was also no reason why Mr Lim would abruptly provide this sum several days before the completion of the sale of the Property, when Mdm Chia would then be entitled to the sum of $547,001.66 (see [23] above).
- [68]
[68] Further, as counsel for Mr Lim pointed out at trial, the completion account dated 30 December 2019 which Mdm Chia’s lawyers provided to her did not take into account any payment by Mr Lim to the purchase price of $50,000. I therefore find that the December 2019 Payment was not a payment to the purchase price and was instead a loan from Mr Lim to Mdm Chia.
- [69]
[69] Having addressed both loans that form the subject of part of Mr Lim’s counterclaim (see [60] above), I now address the remaining two payments.
- [70]
[70] I have already set out at [48] above my reasons for finding that the August 2016 Payment is a $30,000 loan extended by Mr Lim to Mdm Chia. That was relevant to my earlier finding that Mr Lim had not paid Mdm Chia $60,000 in August 2016, which he claimed was part of the total option monies that he had paid her.
- [71]
[71] Finally, regarding the Alleged July 2016 Payment, although Mr Lim claims that he had rejected Mdm Chia’s request for a loan of $60,000 in July 2016, Mdm Chia claims that Mr Lim provided her with a $61,000 loan by cheque on 19 July 2016 (see [11] above). The reason for the $1,000 discrepancy in their accounts is unclear. In any case, the point is that Mdm Chia admits that she ought to repay this sum. Mr Lim’s position is that he had not given her any such loan, and had instead agreed with Mdm Chia to pay her option monies of $240,000 if an option to purchase was given to him (thus leading to the issuance of the First Option).
- [72]
[72] I have already explained my finding that Mr Lim did not in fact pay her the option monies of $240,000 (see [45] above). That militates in favour of Mdm Lim’s version of events. Further, Mdm Chia’s bank statement shows that on 19 July 2016, she deposited $30,000 into her bank account. This supports her claim that she had taken a loan from Mr Lim in July 2016; it is unclear where else she could have obtained that sum. Counsel for Mr Lim pointed out at trial that this evidence of $30,000 payment differs from Mdm Lim’s claim that a loan of $61,000 was given, and further that her bank statement for July 2016 contained no evidence of a cheque deposit of $61,000. Given that Mdm Chia was responsible for mortgage repayments and family expenses (see [8] above), I accept that she may have only deposited part of the $61,000 loan in her bank account. While Mdm Chia testified that the loan was given by way of cheque, the bank account statement shows a cash deposit of $30,000. I find this to be a minor discrepancy regarding the mode of payment that can be attributed to the vagaries of memory in relation to an event that occurred some ten odd years ago. As such, I accept Mdm Chia’s position that she obtained a loan of $61,000 from Mr Lim, and she now owes him that sum, there being no evidence of repayments made by Mdm Chia.
- [73]
[73] In short, apart from the two loans for which Mr Lim counterclaimed, Mdm Chia’s pleaded case – which I accept – is that she is willing to give credit for two other loans (totalling $91,000) that he gave her in July and August 2016. All sums that Mdm Chia owes Mr Lim should be set off against any amount that he owes her (see [157] and [162] below).
Whether the Property was sold by Mdm Chia to Mrs Lim at a gross undervalue
- [74]
[74] The parties appointed different expert witnesses to provide independent opinions on the valuation of the Property. Mdm Chia relied on the valuation (of $2,950,000) produced by Asian Appraisal Company Ltd (“Asian Appraisal”) to argue that the sale of the Property to Mrs Lim for $2,000,000 was undervalued.
Valuation Date
Valuation by Asian Appraisal
Valuation by Premas
- [19]
[19] July 2016
$2,430,000
$2,070,000
- [19]
[19] November 2019
$2,950,000
$2,300,000
- [76]
[76] I make two preliminary observations, the first of which is that the relevant valuation to consider must be that as of 19 November 2019 (ie, the date on which Mrs Lim exercised the Fourth Option) (see [21] above). This valuation can then be meaningfully compared with the purchase price of $2,000,000 that was reflected in the Fourth Option and in the subsequent sale of the Property to Mrs Lim. I thus reject Mr Lim’s submission to adopt the 2016 valuation.
- [77]
[77] Second, Asian Appraisal and Premas adopted the same valuation methodology, namely the comparison method. Under this method, the valuers analysed sales of comparable properties, and took into account differences in location, the conditions of the properties and the date of the transactions (among other factors). Even so, the valuers arrived at different valuations.
- [78]
[78] In my view, the valuation of $2,950,000 by Asian Appraisal as at 19 November 2019 should be adopted because the comparables analysed by Asian Appraisal are more relevant to the Property than those used by Premas.
- [79]
[79] The most important point is that Asian Appraisal’s comparable transactions related to properties that were closer to the Property (specifically, within 300 metres) and thus shared the same locality as the Property. On the other hand, Premas’s comparable properties were 1.3km, 1.7km and 3km away from the Property. According to Asian Appraisal’s valuer, Tay Shiow Jiuan (“Ms Tay”), Premas’s comparables were thus in a different locality from the Property. Ms Tay testified that the most important factor for the purpose of valuation is geographical location. Premas’s valuer, Kwang Heng Lee (“Ms Kwang”) accepted that Asian Appraisal’s comparables are closer to the Property, but said that she chose other comparables based on the dates of transactions.
- [80]
[80] I note that Asian Appraisal’s comparable transactions were dated 13 June 2018, 18 October 2019 and 24 November 2020. One comparable transaction thus dated more than a year before, and another comparable transaction dated more than a year after, the valuation date of 19 November 2019. On the other hand, Premas’s comparable transactions were dated 21 June 2019, 6 August 2019 and 2 September 2019 (ie, less than six months from the valuation date of 19 November 2019). However, Ms Kwang conceded that she had no evidence that the market would have moved by 2020 (the date of one of Asian Appraisal’s comparable transactions). As such, I find that there is no evidence that the date of the transactions affected the prices of the properties to such an extent that that factor should outweigh the much greater proximity of the comparables.
- [81]
[81] For completeness, I also note that the Premas valuer conducted a site inspection of the Property on 28 November 2019, and was thus able to measure the floor area and the condition of the Property. This can be contrasted with the approach adopted by Asian Appraisal, the valuer of which did not conduct a site visit and so based the calculation of the floor area of the Property on a satellite view of the Property using the Singapore Land Authority’s OneMap software. Further, Asian Appraisal’s understanding of the condition of the Property was based on information provided by their client (ie, Mdm Chia). Ms Tay acknowledged at trial that the fact that Premas had independently measured the floor area, and also had inspected the Property in person, could render Premas’s valuation more accurate.
- [82]
[82] Even so, several of the valuers’ assumptions were similar, such as the fact that the Property has not been renovated since the 1970s. Also, Asian Appraisal described the Property as being in a “fair and liveable state of repair and maintenance”, and similarly, Premas referred to the Property being in an “[a]verage state of repairs and maintenance”. The valuers’ assessment of the condition of the Property thus did not appear to be worlds apart. Further, although Asian Appraisal did not have the actual floor area of the Property, both valuers used the same land area in their valuations, and this too is a relevant factor in valuation. In any event, given the importance of the location of the comparables as noted above, I am satisfied that Asian Appraisal’s valuation is preferable given its reliance on geographically closer comparable transactions.
- [83]
[83] In sum, I find that the market value of the Property was $2,950,000 as at 19 November 2019. This valuation is significantly above the actual sale price of $2,000,000, which preliminarily suggests that the sale of the Property by Mdm Chia to Mrs Lim was undervalued. The next questions are: (a) whether Mr Lim had made a representation to Mdm Chia that they would share any future profits when the Property was sold to a third party; and (b) whether Mdm Chia had relied on this representation. The answers to these questions are relevant to, among other things, my decision on the issue of misrepresentation below.
Whether Mr Lim had represented to Mdm Chia that they would share profits from the sale of the Property
- [84]
[84] According to Mdm Chia, Mr Lim had represented to her that they would share the profits made from any eventual sale of the Property. Indeed, it was Mdm Chia’s evidence that Mr Lim had already made this representation even prior to the signing of the First Option. For the reasons set out below, I agree that Mr Lim had indeed made such a representation to Mdm Chia before the latter signed the Fourth Option.
- [85]
[85] First, Mr Lim’s evidence was that by early 2019, Mdm Chia was making insufficient loan repayments and appeared to be unlikely to be able to repay the February 2016 Loan. He also testified that he felt that there was “no way we can keep extending this [option]”, so by signing the Fourth Option, he had given her a “deadline” to repay the loan. Yet Mdm Chia’s consistent evidence, in her affidavit and at trial, was that she was not willing to sell the Property, much less at the purchase price of $2,000,000. This is bolstered by Mdm Chia’s evidence (which no party disputes) that her husband did not know about her sale of the Property to Mrs Lim until January 2023 when the Property was sold by Mrs Lim to the Onward Buyer. Mdm Chia had not informed her husband about the sale any earlier because of his “fragile health condition” and out of fear of causing him “severe distress”. This shows that at the time of the signing of the Fourth Option, Mdm Chia was understandably reluctant to do so, which in turn supports the inference that she would not have done so without an additional inducement from Mr Lim.
- [86]
[86] Second, the three Statements of Account support Mdm Chia’s case that this oral representation was made. This is because they included amounts payable to Mdm Chia that were consistent with a profit-sharing arrangement between Mdm Chia and Mr Lim. As noted at [26] above, all three Statements included a “cash over value” of $200,000. Further, the Second and Third Statements included a “cash over sale” of $100,000, and the Third Statement included an “additional cash over sale” of $100,000. Mdm Chia interpreted the cash over sale and additional cash over sale as representing the amounts that Mr Lim intended to pay her from the profit made by Mrs Lim when she sold the Property to a third party.
- [87]
[87] Mr Lim testified that the cash over value amount was added to “sweeten the deal” for Mdm Chia, by which he meant that that figure was added to convince Mdm Chia to agree to the statement and the figures therein. He later added the cash over sale amount to “increase the valuation” but he also mentioned that since “the sale was completing”, he “might as well put cash over sale”. By this, he meant that since the sale of the Property by Mrs Lim to the Onward Buyer had been completed, he labelled the additional sum as “cash over sale”. Mr Lim claimed that this was not a profit-sharing mechanism and was merely an attempt to provide compensation to Mdm Chia to convince her to vacate the Property. I reject this attempt to recast these additional amounts as top-ups offered by him without obligation so as to persuade Mdm Chia to vacate the Property. If they were merely arbitrary inducements, there was no need or logic to justify them by reference to the Property’s true market value or to the sale price to the Onward Buyer.
- [88]
[88] I am satisfied that prior to the signing of the Fourth Option, Mr Lim had represented to Mdm Chia that they would share the profits (if any) from a subsequent sale of the Property by Mrs Lim to a third party.
- [89]
[89] I note that parties did not specify the proportions in which Mdm Chia and Mr Lim were to share the profits from the sale of the Property. While counsel for Mr Lim observed in closing submissions that Mdm Chia had not pleaded any specific percentage of profit-sharing, it is well-established that only “material facts supporting each element of a legal claim” [emphasis in original] must be pleaded, and the “particular legal result flowing from the material facts that the claimant wishes to pursue need not always be pleaded” (How Weng Fan v Sengkang Town Council [2023] 2 SLR 235 at [19]). The underlying rationale is to ensure that the opposing party has fair notice of the substance of the case (V Nithia (co-administratrix of the estate of Ponnusamy Sivapakiam, deceased) v Buthmanaban s/o Vaithilingam [2015] 5 SLR 1422 at [43]). In my view, the specific proportion of profit-sharing is not a material fact supporting an element of a legal claim that had to be pleaded in this case. I find that in the absence of evidence to the contrary, the plain and ordinary meaning of the statement that the profits are to be “shared” between parties is that the profits should be apportioned equally between all parties to the profit-sharing arrangement (ie, Mdm Chia and Mr Lim).
Whether Mr Lim had represented to Mdm Chia that she need not pay rent when residing in the Property from 2021 onwards
- [90]
[90] As highlighted at [24] above, parties disagree on whether Mr Lim had made a representation to Mdm Chia that she could reside in the Property rent-free from February 2021 until the Property was sold.
- [91]
[91] In my view, Mdm Chia has established on a balance of probabilities that such a representation had been made by Mr Lim prior to the signing of the Tenancy Agreement. I explain.
- [92]
[92] First, it is undisputed that Mdm Chia paid no rental from February 2021 to April 2023, during which time she resided in the Property. According to Mdm Chia, Mr Lim did not collect any rent from her, although he submits that he had tried to do so, but his efforts were in vain. Mr Lim provided no supporting evidence for his claim that he had followed up on rental arrears with Mdm Chia. This supports Mdm Chia’s account of events, namely that Mr Lim had assured her that she could reside in the Property rent-free, and she relied on this in signing the Tenancy Agreement but continued to stay in the Property rent-free. The fact that the Defendants did not even collect the security deposit of $4,000 from Mdm Chia supports her case that Mr Lim had assured her that the Tenancy Agreement was “only a formality”.
- [93]
[93] Indeed, there is some inconsistency in Mrs Lim’s explanation of why she did not commence legal proceedings against Mdm Chia for the unpaid rent. In her affidavit, she says that she did not do so because Mr Lim had assured her that Mdm Chia would pay her eventually. However, in her Defence and Counterclaim, Mrs Lim claims that she did not want to pursue her claim for rent and “pressuri[s]e” Mdm Chia in the midst of the Covid-19 pandemic.
- [94]
[94] Second, as noted at [24] above, the Tenancy Agreement was to lapse on 31 December 2021 unless it was extended for a further year thereafter. No steps were taken to extend the Tenancy Agreement. Although Mrs Lim claims to have assumed that Mdm Chia had renewed the Tenancy Agreement “for another year since she was still staying in the Property”, this is a baseless assumption given that Mdm Chia had not paid any rent pursuant to the Tenancy Agreement in the preceding year. Indeed, in the very next sentence in her Defence and Counterclaim at para 48(e), Mrs Lim admits to having “overlooked the issue of signing the [Tenancy Agreement] as she was overloaded with work since the re-opening of the borders after [the Covid-19 pandemic]”.
- [95]
[95] In my view, Mrs Lim’s conduct vis-à-vis the Tenancy Agreement supports the finding that the agreement was treated as a mere formality by all parties, given Mr Lim’s representation to Mdm Chia allowing her to reside in the Property without paying rent. It is also for this reason that I place no weight on Mrs Lim’s assertion at trial that she had not evicted Mdm Chia from the Property for failing to pay rent because “[p]eople [were] hurting” during the Covid-19 pandemic. Mrs Lim did not demur from collecting rent from Mdm Chia out of sympathy; the evidence shows that Mrs Lim simply neglected to do so.
- [96]
[96] In sum, I find that prior to the signing of the Tenancy Agreement between Mdm Chia and Mrs Lim, Mr Lim did make a representation to Mdm Chia that she would be allowed to reside in the Property rent-free until the Property was sold.
My decision on the legal issues
- [97]
[97] I first turn to address the legal consequences of my findings of fact, with reference to the parties’ pleaded cases.
The non-payment of $500,000 to Mdm Chia
- [98]
[98] I begin with the consequences of my finding (see [44]–[58] above) that the option monies of $500,000 were in fact not paid to Mdm Chia.
- [99]
[99] Mdm Chia’s pleaded case is that “no fresh consideration was furnished for the grant of the [Fourth Option]” and so that Option was “invalid for lack of consideration”. Mdm Chia seeks a declaration that the sale and purchase agreement between her and Mrs Lim be set aside on grounds of, among others, unconscionable conduct, which includes the failure to pay the option monies of $500,000. Yet Mdm Chia also acknowledges that since the Property was sold by Mrs Lim to the Onward Buyer, the Defendants should pay her “damages for her loss and damage jointly and/or severally, to be assessed”. In addition, Mdm Chia seeks interest from the date of her originating claim to the date on which full payment of the judgment sum is made.
- [100]
[100] According to Mr Lim, however, the consideration for the Fourth Option was clearly stated on the face of the Option, which provided that it was issued in consideration of the sum of $500,000. Mrs Lim only generally avers that the Fourth Option was a “perfectly valid instrument” that gave rise to a binding sale and purchase agreement when she exercised the Option as Mr Lim’s nominee.
- [101]
[101] I begin by noting that it is undisputed that valuable consideration was provided for the contract for the sale and purchase of the Property, since even on Mdm Chia’s own case, she had received $1,500,000 from Mrs Lim and $50,000 from Mr Lim as payment towards the purchase price (although, for the avoidance of doubt, I find that this latter payment was in fact a loan from Mr Lim to Mdm Chia: see [66]–[68] above). The sale and purchase agreement for the Property that was entered into between Mdm Chia and Mrs Lim has been executed. The Property was transferred to Mrs Lim and then to the Onward Buyer. The non-payment of the option monies of $500,000 renders – at its highest – the agreement between Mdm Chia and Mr Lim (to sell him the Property for $2,000,000 once the option was exercised) a consideration-free promise. That, however, simply has no bearing on the sale and purchase agreement that Mdm Chia and Mrs Lim entered into and executed.
- [102]
[102] The parties agree that under the sale and purchase agreement, the purchase price of $2,000,000 includes $500,000 (in the form of option monies which Mr Lim alleges was paid to Mdm Chia, and which Mdm Chia denies). Since I have found that the option monies were in fact not paid (see [58] above), that means that the full purchase price of $2,000,000 was not paid in return for the sale of the Property. That amounts to a breach of the sale and purchase agreement for the Property.
- [103]
[103] The appropriate remedy is for Mr Lim to pay Mdm Chia damages in the sum of $500,000. Mdm Chia also seeks – and is entitled to – interest from the date of her originating claim to the date of full payment of the judgment sum. Mdm Chia did not justify her claim (see [99] above) that Mrs Lim should be held jointly and severally liable for the payment of the option monies when the Fourth Option was entered into between Mdm Chia and Mr Lim. Indeed, Mr Lim’s counsel had accepted at trial that if the option monies of $500,000 were found to not have been paid to Mdm Chia, then only Mr Lim would be liable for any legal consequences of such non-payment.
Fraudulent misrepresentation
- [104]
[104] I now turn to Mdm Chia’s fraudulent misrepresentation claim.
Applicable legal principles
- [105]
[105] The five cumulative elements of fraudulent misrepresentation are well-established: (a) there must be a representation of fact by words or conduct; (b) the representation must be made with the intention that it should be acted on by the claimant; (c) the claimant had acted on the false statement; (d) the claimant suffered damage by so doing; and (e) the representation must be made with the knowledge that it is false or in the absence of any genuine belief that it is true: Panatron Pte Ltd v Lee Cheow Lee [2001] 2 SLR(R) 435 (“Panatron”) at [14]; see also Lo Yew Seng v Astrawati Aluwi [2026] 1 SLR 1101 (“Lo Yew Seng (AD)”) at [28]; Chan Pik Sun v Wan Hoe Keet (alias Wen Haojie) [2024] 1 SLR 893 (“Chan Pik Sun”) at [66]. It is implicit in the first element that the representation must have been false: Ernest Ferdinand Perez De La Sala v Compañia De Navegación Palomar, SA [2018] 1 SLR 894 (“Ernest Ferdinand”) at [170]. I will consider elements (a), (e) and (b) – which pertain to the nature of the representations or the accompanying mental state of the representor – before turning to elements (c) and (d).
Element (a): Whether Mr Lim made representation(s) of fact to Mdm Chia, and if so, what representation(s) were made
- [106]
[106] The first element constitutes the following sub-issues: what representations were made by Mr Lim to Mdm Chia (if any), whether these amounted to representations of fact, and whether the representations were false.
- [107]
[107] Beginning with the first sub-issue, Mdm Chia pleads that Mr Lim had made the following representations vis-à-vis the Fourth Option and/or the sale of the Property:
(a) a representation that it was a “mere formality” to have to sign the Fourth Option, and that such signing was “routine” and would have “no real consequences”;
(b) a representation that the Property was worth $2,500,000 but that the purchase price should be set at $2,000,000 to help Mdm Chia save on stamp duty; and
(c) a representation that Mr Lim and Mdm Chia would share any profits from a sale of the Property.
- [108]
[108] I focus on these representations even though Mdm Chia had included in her pleadings various representations related to the First to Third Options, and other representations unrelated to the sale of the Property. Given my conclusion on the fraudulent misrepresentation claim (as explained below), it is unnecessary to address the other alleged representations.
- [109]
[109] Mr Lim denies making any of the representations set out at [107] above.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.