Court of Appeal · Decided 24 April 2020
Goel Adesh Kumar v Resorts World at Sentosa Pte Ltd
Feedback & support[2020] SGCA 40 · Case no. Originating Summons No 12 of 2020 · 2 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [2]
[2] In HC/S 484/2013 (“the Suit”), the applicant brought a claim against the respondent, Resorts World at Sentosa Pte Ltd, for false imprisonment, assault and battery. Alleged participants in these torts included auxiliary police officers employed by SATS Security Services Pte Ltd (“SATS”). As such, the respondent joined SATS as a third party. In [2015] SGHC 289 (“the Liability Judgment”), the High Court Judge (“the Judge”) found in favour of the applicant, and awarded him damages in the sum of $45,915.74. The Judge, however, rejected the majority of the sums the applicant claimed, which were for loss of earnings and aggravated and exemplary damages. It should be stated that the applicant’s aggregate claim was for the sum of $484,196.16. The Judge found the respondent liable for 80% of the award of damages, and SATS liable for 20%. However, since the applicant did not bring any claim against SATS, he could only recover against the respondent for its 80% share of the award, which amounted to $36,732.59. The applicant’s appeal in CA/CA 215/2015 to increase the award of damages was dismissed by this court.
(a) The respondent shall pay the applicant’s costs incurred in the Suit on a standard basis on the Magistrate’s Court scale up to 2 July 2014.
(b) The applicant shall pay the respondent’s costs incurred in the Suit on an indemnity basis on the High Court scale from 2 July 2014.
(a) It was undisputed that the applicant had rejected the First Offer, and that the offer was not withdrawn before the end of the Suit on liability (at [18]).
(b) The judgment sum of $45,915.74 would not be more favourable than the First Offer of $62,000, even taken together with the costs incurred by the applicant up to the date of the First Offer (at [19]).
(i) These costs should be calculated on the Magistrate’s Court scale by virtue of s 39(1)(b) of the State Courts Act (Cap 321, 2007 Rev Ed), since the award in the applicant’s favour was below the Magistrate’s Court limit, and there were no additional grounds for commencing the Suit in the High Court (at [19(a)]).
(ii) The relevant costs would be unlikely to exceed $16,084.26 (being the difference between $62,000 and $45,915.74), since the scale of costs for completed Magistrates’ Court cases leading to an award of $40,000 to $60,000 was between $5,000 and $18,000, and as of 2 July 2014, the Suit was far from being close to completion (at [19(b)]).
(c) There was no reason to depart from the general rule in O 22A r 9(3) since the First Offer was reasonable, serious and genuine (at [20]–[25]).
To date, there has been no application to review this decision.
- [11]
[11] Arising from the applicant’s and the respondent’s submissions on the foregoing points, the correct comparison for the purposes of O 22A r 9(3)(b) should instead have been as follows: