Court of Appeal · Decided 9 July 2020
Goh Seng Heng v Wang Xiaopu
Feedback & support[2020] SGCA 66 · Case no. Civil Appeal No 225 of 2019 (Summons Nos 62 and 65 of 2020) · 12 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Factual background
- [5]
[5] By way of correspondence, we directed that both SUM 62 and SUM 65 be heard first as they concerned the capacity of the appellant to maintain his appeal in CA 225. On 17 June 2020, the Official Assignee granted the sanction under s 131(1)(a) of the Bankruptcy Act (Cap 20, 2009 Rev Ed) to the appellant upon certain conditions, including the requirement for the appellant from time to time to increase the amount of the security deposit which had been placed with the Official Assignee by a third party, depending on the progress of the action.
Our decision
- [7]
[7] Our decision here is confined to the matters in SUM 62 and SUM 65. The appeal on the merits has been scheduled to be heard in the third week of August 2020.
- [9]
[9] The primary case of the respondent in SUM 62 is that the appellant has been dissipating his assets worth millions of dollars to enrich his family and to put the assets beyond the reach of his creditors. She submits that the appellant, whom she describes as “a seasoned litigant in the Singapore courts”, has abused the process of the court in an astounding manner that is rarely seen and should not be allowed to continue with his appeal in CA 225 without the conditions sought in SUM 62.
- [10]
[10] It is undisputed that between 2013 and 2015, the appellant received a total of some $60m from the respondent and two other groups of investors (RSP Investments and Liberty Sky) as payment for AMP shares. The appellant had a successful medical practice for many years, earning more than $1m each year. For 2014 and 2015, his annual income from his medical and aesthetic practice in AMP was about $3.5m. Such a level of income is also borne out by the Statement of Affairs in his bankruptcy where the appellant declared his net monthly salary for July 2014 at $250,000 per month. There is a clinic known as Dr Goh Seng Heng & Partners in the Paragon shopping complex. After taking urgent instructions in the course of this hearing, Mr Jonathan Muk (“Mr Muk”) informed the Court that the clinic is being run by the appellant’s elder daughter and that the appellant is working as a consultant in the company which owns the clinic, earning a “small salary” of $2,000 per month.
- [11]
[11] Shortly after receiving the funds from the respondent and Liberty Sky, the appellant purchased two apartments in Sentosa Island at $4.88m and $5.8m, one each for his second daughter and his elder son (“the two apartments”). He also bought a ground floor unit in Leedon Heights through his family company.
- [12]
[12] The appellant also had some $18.44m in an OCBC bank account held by his elder son for the family. Sometime in 2016, while the appellant was involved in another High Court action and was served with a Mareva injunction, an agreement was reached to put up the two apartments together with the appellant’s matrimonial home at 36 Cove Way, a bungalow in Sentosa Island, as security for up to $20m in exchange for the discharge of the injunction. The appellant’s elder daughter affirmed in an affidavit in 2017 that the family wanted to help the appellant discharge the injunction by offering security. In exchange for the elder son agreeing to offer his apartment as security, the family decided that all the money in the OCBC bank account would be “gifted to (name of the son), as the eldest son of the family”. It was asserted that the money was for the said son to deal with as he pleased and that no part of it belonged to the appellant.
- [14]
[14] The appellant has offered no good reason in his affidavits why he divested his interest in the bungalow to his wife in April 2019. Upon questioning by the Court, Mr Muk explained that the appellant had some matrimonial problems with his wife. He also explained that the wife is still living in the bungalow with her mother and that the appellant would visit his wife and his mother-in-law every now and then. He is still married and there is no evidence of any matrimonial proceedings.
- [15]
[15] On 5 March 2020, one day before the appellant filed his bankruptcy application, he changed his registered residential address from 36 Cove Way to the Flynn Park apartment. A search at the Land Titles Registry revealed that the Flynn Park apartment is not owned by the appellant or his family members. The evidence from a process server shows that the appellant was not living at the Flynn Park apartment in June 2020 but was at the bungalow with his wife in the late evening. We see no good reason why the appellant needed to move (purportedly) to the Flynn Park apartment and why he had to change his address.
- [17]
[17] In any case, while the appellant’s family was willing to help him discharge the injunction taken out against him (see [12] above) by pledging their properties as security for up to $20m, it is hard to believe that they would not assist him to pay his declared debts of $676,350 such that he had to apply to make himself a bankrupt. They have their own homes, are gainfully employed and not all are married. Further, the elder son received some $18.44m purportedly as a family gift for his part in offering his $5.8m Sentosa apartment as part of that security and the Sentosa apartment was also a gift from the appellant anyway. It seems to us that the purported gift of $18.44m to the elder son for agreeing to pledge a property worth $5.8m or so which was paid for by the appellant was entirely disproportionate to say the least.
- [19]
[19] On the available evidence, we agree with the respondent that there was abuse of process of the Court by the appellant and we accept that the respondent would be prejudiced by the appellant’s conduct as detailed above. The appellant’s conduct casts his integrity into serious doubt. It is clear to us that the appellant was blatantly divesting and dissipating his assets to the value of tens of millions of dollars while ignoring his judgment debts. The unnecessary change of registered residential address and the highly suspicious manner in which he made himself bankrupt without even consulting or informing his lawyers on record show that he was preparing to stymie the respondent in recovering her money in the event that his appeal in CA 225 fails.
- [21]
[21] In relation to SUM 65:
(1) By consent, the time required for the filing of the appellant’s appeal papers as stipulated in the Rules of Court is extended to today;
(2) The said appeal papers filed on 23 March 2020 are deemed filed and served today;
(3) The appellant is to pay the respondent costs fixed at $2,000 (inclusive of disbursements) forthwith.
- [22]
[22] In relation to SUM 62:
(1) The appellant is to provide further security for costs fixed at $20,000 for CA 225;
(5) The costs of this application are to be costs in the appeal.