Court of Appeal · Decided 14 January 2022
ST Group Co Ltd and others v Sanum Investments L td
Feedback & support[2022] SGCA 2 · Case no. Civil Appeal No 113 of 2018 (Summons No 44 of 2021) · 36 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Facts
The parties
- [2]
[2] The respondent in CA 113 and SUM 44, Sanum Investments Limited (“Sanum”), is a company incorporated in Macau, and was the claimant in arbitration proceedings brought under the rules of the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (“the SIAC Arbitration”). The respondents to the SIAC Arbitration were the three Lao Appellants and ST Vegas Enterprise Ltd (“STV Enterprise”). Where necessary, we refer to all four respondents in the SIAC Arbitration as the “Lao Parties”. ST Group owned various business industries in Laos, while ST Vegas and STV Enterprise were affiliated with ST Group. Mr Sithat was the president of both ST Group and STV Enterprise.
The substantive dispute and SIAC Arbitration
- [3]
[3] The substantive dispute between the parties concerns arrangements relating to a slot machine club in Laos. In a bid to obtain relief against the Lao Parties for what it claimed were breaches of contract, Sanum commenced the SIAC Arbitration on 23 September 2015. For present purposes, it is sufficient to note here that a three-member tribunal was appointed, and that the tribunal determined that the seat of arbitration was Singapore. On 22 August 2016, Sanum obtained the SIAC Award against the Lao Parties.
Procedural history
Enforcement proceedings
- [6]
[6] On 23 November 2016, Sanum obtained HC/JUD 792/2016 (“the Judgment”) against the Lao Parties for the relief stated in the SIAC Award for, inter alia, US$200m as damages for breach of contract and interest at the rate of 6% per annum compounded annually from 12 April 2012.
- [7]
[7] On the basis of the Judgment, the following garnishee applications were made, with the respective final garnishee orders granted as follows:
- [8]
[8] We refer to these three final garnishee orders, viz, HC/ORC 477/2017, HC/ORC 4233/2017 and HC/ORC 4443/2017, as the “FGOs”, and the sums garnished under the FGOs as the “Garnished Sums”. The Judgment, the FGOs and the Garnished Sums are the subject of the application in SUM 44. While there were other garnishee applications, they did not result in final garnishee orders and they do not concern us here. Other enforcement applications were also brought, resulting, inter alia, in a writ of seizure and sale, HC/WSS 77/2016 (“WSS 77/2016”) in respect of ST Group’s shares in S3T Pte Ltd, which were seized by the Sheriff on 27 December 2016.
Applications to set aside
- [12]
[12] The relief sought in SUM 4933/2017 was as follows:
- [13]
[13] In SUM 4933/2017, the Judge held that Macau was the correct seat of arbitration and that the appointment of a three-member tribunal was incorrect, but that the Lao Parties had not shown prejudice arising from these procedural irregularities (see Sanum Investments Ltd v ST Group Co, Ltd and others [2020] 3 SLR 225 at [106], [110] and [114]). STV Enterprise, however, was not a party to the relevant agreement and so was not properly a party to the SIAC Arbitration nor bound by the Award (at [107(c)]). Hence, the Judge dismissed the application in relation to the Lao Appellants but allowed the application in relation to STV Enterprise.
The appeals
- [14]
[14] CA 113 was the Lao Appellants’ appeal against the Judge’s dismissal of SUM 4933/2017 in relation to them, while CA/CA 114/2018 (“CA 114”) was Sanum’s cross-appeal against the Judge’s decision in relation to STV Enterprise. As noted above, we issued our judgment in these appeals on 18 November 2019. We dismissed CA 114, finding that the Judge was correct to find that STV Enterprise was not a party to the relevant agreement. Nothing turns on CA 114 in the present application.
- [16]
[16] In CA 113, we found that the wrong choice of seat in Singapore as opposed to Macau was a sufficient basis on which to conclude that the SIAC Award could not be enforced, without there being need for proof of prejudice, and allowed the appeal. At [109] of ST Group (CA), our conclusion was stated as follows:
SUM 44 concerns, in essence, what else should be done as a consequence of this conclusion in CA 113.
Post-appeal developments
(1) Drafting of the court order
- [18]
[18] After CA 113 was allowed on 18 November 2019, the Lao Appellants’ counsel, Haridass Ho & Partners (“Haridass”), wrote to Sanum’s counsel, WongPartnership LLP (“WongPartnership”) on 27 November 2019 seeking a return of the Garnished Sums together with interest thereon. WongPartnership replied that its Primary Position was that the application in SUM 4933/2017 was out of time and the question of whether an extension of time should be granted was pending, and the request was therefore premature. On 6 January 2020, WongPartnership offered not to pursue the Primary Position if, inter alia, the Garnished Sums were placed in escrow instead. The Lao Appellants did not agree.
(2) Remaining applications in OS 890/2016
- [22]
[22] On 21 February 2020, the Lao Parties filed HC/SUM 846/2020 (“SUM 846/2020”) for leave to withdraw the three outstanding applications referred to at [9] above. The Lao Parties also brought HC/SUM 2318/2020 (“SUM 2318/2020”) on 5 June 2020 to apply for the Sheriff’s release of the shares that were seized under WSS 77/2016 (see [8] above). These applications were fixed to be heard by the Judge on 30 July 2020.
- [24]
[24] Subsequently, on 13 August 2020, Haridass wrote to WongPartnership seeking the return of the Garnished Sums. On 20 August 2020, WongPartnership responded that they were taking their client’s instructions and would endeavour to respond by 1 September 2020. On 1 September 2020, however, WongPartnership indicated that they were still taking their client’s instructions.
(3) Application to the High Court for the return of the Garnished Sums
- [25]
[25] In the absence of a response, Mr Sithat applied to the High Court on 4 September 2020 for the return of the Garnished Sums in HC/SUM 3785/2020 (“SUM 3785/2020”). SUM 3785/2020 sought return of the Garnished Sums with interest of 5.33% per annum from the date of the respective FGOs until payment to Mr Sithat.
- [27]
[27] The application was heard on 9 and 12 November 2020 by the Judge. On 12 November 2020, the Judge held that under O 92 rr 4 and 5 of the ROC, she did not have the power to make the consequential orders sought in SUM 3785/2020, and dismissed the application.
(4) Arbitration proceedings in Macau
- [28]
[28] Alongside these developments in Singapore, on 11 December 2019, Sanum had filed a mediation request with the Macau office of the ICC International Centre of Alternative Dispute Resolution. The request to mediate was refused by the Lao Appellants. On 29 January 2020, Sanum commenced a Macau-seated arbitration with the ICC International Court of Arbitration (“the ICC Arbitration”). On 9 November 2020, in those proceedings, Sanum filed an application to the tribunal (“the ICC Tribunal”) for interim measures, to enable it to retain the Garnished Sums pending the resolution of the ICC Arbitration. This was withdrawn without prejudice in the light of the dismissal of SUM 3785/2020 (see [27] above). However, when the Lao Appellants renewed their request before this court for the Garnished Sums to be returned in November 2020 by way of correspondence (see [30] below), Sanum renewed its application to the ICC Tribunal for interim measures on 30 November 2020 (“the Interim Measures Application”).
- [29]
[29] On 25 January 2021, the Interim Measures Application was heard by the ICC Tribunal. On 26 March 2021, the ICC Tribunal granted the following interim measures (“the Interim Measures”):
The application in SUM 44
- [30]
[30] On 23 November 2020, ie, 11 days after the Judge decided not to grant the orders sought, Mr Sithat made his request for consequential orders to this court by way of correspondence. On 1 December 2020, Sanum stated its objections to such a request in a letter to this court. On 25 March 2021, we issued various directions in relation to Mr Sithat’s request, indicating that a formal application should be filed, and providing timelines for the application, together with a list of issues to be addressed.
- [31]
[31] On 9 April 2021, SUM 44 was filed, consisting of three substantive prayers that: (a) the Judgment be set aside; (b) the FGOs be set aside; and (c) the Garnished Sums be returned together with interest thereon at 5.33% per annum from the date of the respective FGOs until payment to Mr Sithat.
- [32]
[32] After receiving the parties’ first round of written submissions, we directed parties to file a further round of written submissions to address specific queries that we had, specifically in relation to the relevance of the ICC Tribunal’s Interim Orders. Our decision takes into account both the first and second rounds of submissions.
The Lao Appellants’ position
- [34]
[34] As for the issue of interest, the Lao Appellants argue that interest of 5.33% per annum from the date of the respective FGOs should apply, citing cases to the effect that where moneys are returned, interest should also be paid on those moneys. Mr Sithat, they argue, has been deprived of the use of the moneys since 2017. Further, Sanum’s claim that it had not earned substantial interest is irrelevant. The interest should run from the dates of the respective FGOs and not from the judgment of this court in CA 113, and the interest rate should be the default of 5.33% per annum.
Sanum’s position
- [37]
[37] In the alternative, if the Garnished Sums are to be returned, interest should only run from a date much later than the dates of garnishment and should not be at the rate of 5.33% per annum. Further, if the consequential orders are made, they should be stayed pending the determination of the ICC Arbitration.
Issues to be determined
- [38]
[38] It is now common ground between the parties that the effect of our decision in CA 113 was that the SIAC Award could not be enforced and that the underlying debt arising from the SIAC Award was extinguished. It is also common ground that the Judgment and the FGOs no longer have a legal basis, in that they are based on an extinguished debt. Consistent with these positions, the parties are also agreed that this court had the power to set aside the Judgment and the FGOs upon its judgment in CA 113, and continues to have this power which can now be exercised in SUM 44. The parties are, however, in disagreement as to the following issues:
(a) Should this court exercise its power to set aside the Judgment and the FGOs?
(d) If so, what (if any) interest should be payable on the Garnished Sums?
(e) If the consequential orders are granted, should they be stayed?
Should the Judgment and FGOs be set aside?
- [39]
[39] The parties’ disagreement turns on whether this court should exercise its inherent powers to set aside the Judgment and the FGOs. Both parties rely on this court’s judgment in Harmonious Coretrades Pte Ltd v United Integrated Services Pte Ltd [2020] 1 SLR 206 (“Harmonious Coretrades”) and apply that decision to reach different conclusions. As the scope of what this court decided in Harmonious Coretrades is significant here, we first set out the facts and decision in that case.
- [43]
[43] Following from that, certain illustrations were provided for cases where the inherent power could be justifiably invoked. The first of these situations is particularly apt for the present case (at [40]):
(b) Secondly, there was no injustice occasioned by CTPL’s insolvency. This court held that the critical point was that the show cause hearing had gone on without an objection from UIS. Indeed, no objection could have been raised given the debt created by AD1. The mere fact that CTPL was insolvent and UIS would not be able to claim fully against CTPL did not, therefore, give rise to injustice (at [61]).
- [46]
[46] In our judgment, we should exercise our powers to set aside the Judgment and the FGOs.
- [48]
[48] Secondly, in any event, even if some balancing exercise needs to be undertaken, we consider that the factors raised by Sanum are not so persuasive as to merit a different conclusion. In the first place, we consider that Sanum’s complaint of delay is overblown.
(a) While it is not clear exactly why the Lao Appellants had failed to seek all the relief sought in SUM 4933/2017 when they appeared before us in CA 113, due weight must be given to the fact that because of Sanum’s reservation of its Primary Position (see [18] above), the result of CA 113 would still have been subject to whatever position that Sanum would then take on the issue of whether the application to set aside was filed out of time. Indeed, as we have recounted above, the history of the matter after our decision in CA 113 shows that a significant part of the alleged delay arose from Sanum’s retention of its Primary Position, before it ultimately agreed not to pursue it in July 2020 (see [23] above). We pause to observe that there is an unsatisfactory aspect about the way in which both parties have conducted this matter. In reserving its Primary Position, Sanum and its counsel allowed the matter to proceed all the way to this court, with the Lao Appellants and their counsel similarly in agreement, without specifically bringing this fact to our attention. Our decision in CA 113 may have been rendered entirely hypothetical since Sanum could still object that the application to set aside was out of time. However, as Sanum eventually decided not to pursue its Primary Position, we need not comment further except to highlight this court’s recent decision in Tan Ng Kuang Nicky (the duly appointed joint and several liquidator of Sembawang Engineers and Constructors Pte Ltd (in compulsory liquidation)) and others v Metax Eco Solutions Pte Ltd [2021] 1 SLR 1135.
The power to order the return of the Garnished Sums
In Crédit Agricole at [10], this court’s decision was as follows:
- [55]
[55] As the Lao Appellants correctly submit, this position is consistent with English and Australian authorities. In England, the House of Lords stated in Nykredit Mortgage Bank plc v Edward Erdman Group Ltd [1997] 1 WLR 1627 (“Nykredit”) at 1637 as follows:
- [56]
[56] Similarly, the High Court of Australia in Commonwealth v McCormack (1984) 55 ALR 185 (“McCormack”) stated at 186–187:
Should the court order that the Garnished Sums be returned?
- [64]
[64] In coming to this conclusion, the New South Wales Court of Appeal cited various English authorities to that effect, namely R v Jones (1722) 1 Str 474 (93 ER 643) and R v Wilson (1836) 3 Ad and E 830 (111 ER 629). In its view, the absence of original jurisdiction on an application for consequential orders was not a reason against granting those consequential orders, but was in fact why those other arguments could not even be entertained.
Interest on the Garnished Sums
- [70]
[70] We turn then to the question of what interest, if any, should be paid on the Garnished Sums to be returned. The Lao Appellants seek interest at the rate of 5.33% per annum from the date of the FGOs until payment of the Garnished Sums to Mr Sithat. Sanum argues instead that interest should only run from a date much later than the dates on which the sums were garnished, and, in any event, the rate of interest should only be the interest actually earned or reasonably estimated to be earned.
- [72]
[72] The basis for interest to be paid on such sums that are returned appears to be part of the court’s inherent powers to make the necessary orders to give effect to the underlying policy of unravelling the effect of court orders that have been found to be incorrect or which have been set aside, ie, what this court has referred to as part of its “equitable jurisdiction” (see Citiwall Safety Glass Pte Ltd v Mansource Interior Pte Ltd [2015] 5 SLR 482 (“Citiwall”) at [34]; see also Nykredit at 1637B). In that regard, we do not consider that the authorities set out an absolute rule, but only a general one that in most instances, justice will require that the money paid out be returned with interest. We note that in Rodger (at 476), the ultimate appeal was to “what the justice of such a case demands” and in Meerkin v Rossett Pty Ltd [1999] 2 VR 31 at [11] (cited in Singapore Airlines at [22]), the reference is again to what “does justice as between the appellant and the respondent to an appeal” (see also Citiwall at [34]).
- [73]
[73] We note that in both Singapore Airlines and Crédit Agricole, the judgments were reversed on appeal, and the substantive disputes between the parties appear to have been completely settled by the decisions of this court. There were no more pending proceedings and the matters were essentially concluded by the time this court considered the question of the award of interest on the sums paid out under the judgments that had been reversed on appeal. By contrast, in the present case, the dispute between the parties is still pending resolution. Our decision in CA 113 was a decision that the SIAC Award could not be enforced because the arbitration was wrongly seated under the relevant arbitration agreement. It followed that Sanum was entitled to attempt to obtain another award that was not irregular in a properly-seated arbitration (subject to any bars, procedural or substantive, that the Lao Appellants may seek to raise, on which we make no comment).
- [74]
[74] Sanum has done so by commencing the ICC Arbitration in Macau. The matter is pending resolution before the ICC Tribunal. The parties have agreed on an escrow arrangement reflected in the Interim Measures made by the ICC Tribunal. While it is true that as part of the restitution of what it had received, Sanum should prima facie have to return the sums with interest, the broader point is that the question of who is ultimately successful in the substantive dispute is of greater significance to the issue of who should pay interest on the sums found to be due in the arbitration, which will necessarily overlap with who should pay interest on the Garnished Sums, if at all, and the amounts paid into escrow. In the cases cited above, no such question arose because the appeals also resolved the substantive disputes between the parties.
Should our orders be stayed pending the determination of the ICC Arbitration?
- [77]
[77] The final point raised by Sanum was that even if we were to grant the orders sought by the Lao Appellants, the orders should be stayed pending the determination of the ICC Arbitration. We see no merit to this contention. First, the ICC Tribunal has already determined that the Interim Measures should be put in place pending its own determination. Secondly, the reasons put forward by Sanum justifying a stay are essentially the same as its allegations of prejudice which have already been dismissed above.
- [78]
[78] However, to ensure that our orders are executed in a manner consistent with the ICC Tribunal’s Interim Measures, we will make an allowance for time for the parties to bring our decision to the ICC Tribunal’s attention for directions to be sought. This is a matter of practicality, especially given the Lao Appellants’ undertaking to us that they will abide by the terms of the Interim Measures. This is reflected in our orders below.
Conclusion
- [79]
[79] Our orders are therefore as follows:
(a) The Judgment (ie, HC/JUD 792/2016) is set aside.
(b) The FGOs dated 18 January, 5 July and 13 July 2017 respectively are set aside.
(c) Sanum shall return the Garnished Sums, ie, the sum of US$2,353,921.47 and S$216,272.30. We leave it to the parties to make the necessary arrangements and/or seek the necessary directions from the ICC Tribunal as to how this is to be effected in the light of the Interim Measures.
(f) There shall be liberty to apply.