Court of Appeal · Decided 25 November 2022
Senda International Capital Ltd v Kiri Industries Ltd
Feedback & support[2022] SGCA(I) 10 · Case no. Civil Appeal No 14 of 2022
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background
- [2]
[2] The DyStar group was a major player in the international dye industry and was based in Germany. It experienced financial difficulties in 2009 and insolvency administrators were appointed. Kiri wanted to acquire the DyStar group’s business but could not raise the funds to do so on its own. Kiri accordingly turned to Zhejiang Longsheng Group Co Ltd (“Longsheng”) and invited it to enter into a joint venture for this purpose. The relevant agreements were executed by Kiri and Longsheng in 2010 and DyStar Global Holdings (Singapore) Pte Ltd (“DyStar”) was incorporated as the vehicle that would be used to acquire the DyStar group’s business. Kiri was the majority shareholder in DyStar while Longsheng (through its wholly-owned subsidiary Well Prospering Ltd (“WPL”)) held one share in DyStar and a €22m zero-coupon bond issued by DyStar, which could be converted at any time into ordinary shares at S$10 per share.
- [3]
[3] In July 2012, the convertible bond was transferred from WPL to Senda, which was another wholly-owned subsidiary of Longsheng. Then, in December 2012, which was also around the time DyStar turned profitable, Senda converted all of the debt under the convertible bond into equity. As a consequence of these developments, Senda became the majority shareholder of DyStar while Kiri became a minority shareholder. Respectively, they held 62.43% and 37.57% of the issued capital.
- [4]
[4] The relationship between Kiri and Senda as joint venture partners deteriorated following the emergence of Senda as a majority shareholder in DyStar. On 26 June 2015, Kiri commenced a suit in the High Court against Senda alleging minority oppression. On 11 May 2017, the suit was transferred to the SICC.
Procedural history leading to the Costs Judgment
The Court invites the parties to file costs submissions
The first round of costs submissions
The Court’s direction after the first round of costs submissions
- [18]
[18] On 28 July 2021, the Court issued the following direction, seeking that the parties address it by way of further written submissions also limited to ten pages on the following:
The second round of costs submissions
(a) Both Pre-Transfer Costs and Post-Transfer Costs for SIC 4 should be assessed “with primary reference to Appendix G”. Senda submitted that the nature of the work done in the pre-transfer period did not justify a departure from the costs scales set out in Appendix G, and for the work done in the post-transfer period, Kiri had not shown how the nature of such work was so different from other similar proceedings in the High Court at or around that time that would warrant such a significant uplift from Appendix G. Relying on Appendix G, Senda argued that Kiri should only be entitled to S$204,000 for the Liability Tranche (with that sum apportioned equally as Pre-Transfer Costs and Post-Transfer Costs), and S$156,000 (representing 52% of S$300,000) for the Valuation Tranche.
(b) Further, Kiri’s claimed costs for SIC 4 should be rejected, for two reasons.
(i) First, these were said to be “wholly disproportionate” to the previous costs awards made by the High Court in minority oppression proceedings, and thus they were “plainly unreasonable and excessive”.
(ii) Second, although Kiri’s Costs Schedule does set out a breakdown of time spent by Kiri’s legal team, “there [was] no detailed breakdown or narration of what the time was precisely spent on” and it was therefore “difficult for Senda to assess whether the costs incurred [were] indeed justified and reasonable”. Senda argued that it would suffer prejudice if Kiri’s costs were “fixed instead of taxed”, because Kiri has not been required to provide “the kinds of necessary details that are ordinarily expected to be provided in a taxation”. Senda also pointed to five aspects of Kiri’s Costs Schedule (the details of which we need not go into) and sought to show that these claims were “excessive and wholly disproportionate”. Senda also emphasised that these objections were “merely illustrative” and that it would require a “more detailed breakdown and narration of the costs claimed by Kiri” to assess whether they were indeed justified and reasonable.
(c) As to the sum of S$3,336,800.42 claimed for payments made to Accuracy, this was said to be “exorbitant”. There had been no means for Senda to assess and determine whether the amount claimed by Kiri was reasonable because, save for the invoices generally documenting the payments made to Accuracy, no breakdown of the fees incurred had been provided.
Decision below
The parties’ arguments on appeal
Issues in the appeal
(a) First, what is the proper interpretation of “reasonable costs” under O 110 r 46?
(b) Second, what is the manner in which such “reasonable costs” are to be assessed?
(c) Third, in the light of our views on the first and second issues, whether the Court erred (i) in its assessment of Post-Transfer Costs, and (ii) in allowing Kiri to recover part of the Expert Fees as disbursements?
What is the proper interpretation of “reasonable costs” under O 110 r 46?
The Court’s reasoning
Our difficulties with the Court’s reasoning
Our analysis of “reasonable costs”
The indemnity principle
Costs awarded under O 59
Costs awarded under O 110 r 46
Costs under O 110 r 46 and solicitor-and-client costs under O 59
How are “reasonable costs” under O 110 r 46 assessed?
The process for the assessment of costs in the SICC
Senda’s argument about the Liability Tranche Costs Order
The process for the assessment of costs in the SICC
What is the level of information that the court must be furnished with and who bears the burden of proof?
- [74]
[74] We add that this is also the level of information that is contemplated in Form 24 of the SICC PD 2021, as well as Form 24 the SICC Practice Directions (effective 1 August 2022) that is presently in force.
The use of previous costs awards of the SICC in the assessment of “reasonable costs” under O 110 r 46 and some other considerations
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.