Court of Appeal · Decided 7 June 2024
Crédit Agricole Corporate & Investment Bank, Singapore Branch v PPT Energy Trading Co Ltd and another appeal
Feedback & support[2024] SGCA(I) 3 · Case no. Civil Appeal from the Singapore International Commercial Court No 2 of 2022 · 23 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] CA/CAS 2/2022 and CA/CAS 3/2022 (the “Appeals”) arose out of two cases heard by the Singapore International Commercial Court (“SICC”), SIC/S 1/2021 (“SIC 1”) and SIC/S 2/2021 (“SIC 2”). Crédit Agricole Corporate & Investment Bank, Singapore Branch (“CACIB”) was the plaintiff in SIC 1 and the defendant in SIC 2. PPT Energy Trading Co Ltd (“PPT”) was the defendant in SIC 1 and the plaintiff in SIC 2. The Judge in the SICC (the “Judge”) dismissed CACIB’s claim in SIC 1 and allowed PPT’s claim in SIC 2. Dissatisfied, CACIB filed the Appeals.
The court proceedings
- [4]
[4] On 28 May 2020, CACIB commenced HC/S 451/2020 (“Suit 451”) in the General Division of the High Court (“GDHC”) against PPT seeking, essentially, a permanent injunction to restrain payment under or pursuant to CACIB’s letter of credit dated 3 April 2020 in favour of PPT (the “Credit”). Concurrently, CACIB filed and obtained, ex parte, an interim injunction to the same effect.
- [6]
[6] Following a series of hearings in regard to the interim injunction, the parties came to an agreement on 9 November 2020 that the interim injunction to restrain payment under the Credit was to be discharged and CACIB was to pay the LC Sum into a bank account held by PPT in the Bank of China Limited (“BOC”). The arrangement was for BOC to issue a banker’s guarantee to CACIB as a form of security (the “BOC Guarantee”) for the repayment of the LC Sum in the event that CACIB succeeded in its claim against PPT. CACIB paid US$23,662,732.50 into the designated BOC bank account on 18 November 2020.
- [7]
[7] In the meantime, there was a dispute as to whether CACIB or ING was entitled to the proceeds of Zenrock’s sale of the oil to TOTSA. This was a sum of US$16,517,443.06 (the “Receivables”). Interpleader proceedings were started by CACIB to resolve this question. Pending resolution of the interpleader, TOTSA remitted the Receivables to CACIB’s solicitors to hold as escrow agent. On 23 November 2020, a settlement agreement was entered into between CACIB, ING and the escrow agent (the “Settlement Agreement”). Under the settlement, CACIB received US$6,197,532.75 from the Receivables.
- [8]
[8] On 19 November 2020, CACIB filed its Defence and Counterclaim (Amendment No. 1) to Suit 555, adding an alternative counterclaim for the sum of US$23,662,732.50 under the letter of indemnity issued by PPT to CACIB dated 9 April 2020 (the “LOI”).
(a) PPT was entitled to payment of US$23,662,732.50, representing the sum due under the Credit, on 5 June 2020 from CACIB and was entitled to interest at the rate of 5.33% per annum and pro rata on the said sum of US$23,662,732.50 from 5 June 2020 to 18 November 2020 (the “Interest”);
(b) CACIB was to pay PPT the Interest forthwith;
(c) CACIB was to pay PPT the Recoverable Costs, as defined in para 14 of the court’s Minute Sheet dated 30 March 2022 and in the amounts set out below, forthwith;
- [12]
[12] The Appeals were heard on 19 and 20 October 2022. By the Liability Judgment, we allowed the Appeals in part, finding that (a) in respect of the Credit dispute, CACIB was not entitled to rely on Zenrock’s fraud to set aside and avoid liability to pay the LC Sum to PPT; but (b) in respect of the LOI dispute, PPT had breached the warranty of marketable title given in the LOI, such that CACIB was entitled to damages. Crucially, we found that what CACIB was entitled to claim under the LOI was loss which it would have avoided if it had unquestionable security over the Receivables payable by TOTSA to Zenrock to which it was entitled under the LOI, and which it would have had in the absence of fraud, in return for making payment under the Credit.
The parties’ cases
CACIB’s submissions
- [15]
[15] CACIB submits that it is entitled to interest as follows:
PPT’s submissions
- [17]
[17] As regards interest, PPT contends that it is entitled to interest on the sum “locked up” by BOC (US$23,662,732.50) in exchange for the BOC Guarantee given to CACIB, from 18 November 2020 to the date when the BOC Guarantee is discharged, at the default rate of 5.33% per annum. PPT further claims interest on the loan that it had to take (“PPT Loan”) due to CACIB’s failure to pay the LC Sum, in the sum of US$23,487,896.05 for the period from 14 May 2020 to 30 November 2022, amounting to US$382,985.08.
PPT’s case is that while CACIB generally succeeded on the LOI dispute, PPT succeeded on sub-issue 4 of the LOI Dispute, and CACIB succeeded on sub-issue 3 only because in the Appeals CACIB presented an alternative claim at the hearing itself. CACIB initially argued that under sub-issue 3, it should be put in the same position “as if it had been provided the original bills”, but changed its position on appeal where it asserted that it should be put in the same position as it would have been in, either if “the warranties had been true” or if the original bills had been presented.
- [25]
[25] On the basis of the foregoing, we have to determine:
(a) the principal amounts and periods for which interest is payable to either party, if any, and the rate applicable thereto; and
(b) the costs to be awarded for the Appeals and the trial below.
The quantum of damages that CACIB is entitled to claim under the LOI
- [26]
[26] Firstly, we explain and reiterate our decision on the quantum of damages. In our decision on liability, we gave judgment in favour of CACIB in the sum of US$10,319,470.81, subject only to the matter raised at [74] of the Liability Judgment:
The sum of US$10,319,470.81 was derived by taking the net difference between the price payable by TOTSA to Zenrock and caught by the interpleader proceedings, namely US$16,517,532.06, and the recovery of US$6,197,532.75 obtained by CACIB in the settlement of those proceedings. It is this latter amount of CACIB’s alleged recovery that we observed was subject to “a degree of uncertainty raised by PPT”, which had to be resolved to determine whether the judgment sum of US$10,319,470.81 in favour of CACIB was accurate and, if not, what the quantum of damages should be.
- [27]
[27] It is clear now that the quantum of damages that CACIB is entitled to be paid under the LOI is the sum of US$10,319,910.31 as stated in [9] of the Interrogatories Judgment. The slight variation in the figure from that given in [74] of the Liability Judgment arises from minor discrepancies in the numbers derived from the oral submissions at the hearing of the Appeals. As elaborated upon in [9] of the Interrogatories Judgment, this was attributable to a clerical error in the Liability Judgment, which was remedied by recourse to O 16 r 3(5) of the Singapore International Commercial Court Rules 2021.
- [28]
[28] The affidavit filed by CACIB on 10 November 2023 to address the element of uncertainty in respect of CACIB’s recoveries in its settlement with ING and the escrow agent (the “Affidavit”) provided documentary support for the position which counsel informed us of at the hearing of the Appeals. We admitted the Affidavit, and set out our reasons for doing so, at [15] of the Interrogatories Judgment. The Affidavit appended documents proving that (a) the Receivables payable by TOTSA to Zenrock was US$16,517,443.06 and this amount was transferred to Mayer Brown as escrow agent on 17 June 2020; and (b) by way of the Settlement Agreement, the balance of the Receivables in the sum of US$6,197,532.75 was to be distributed, and was in fact distributed, to CACIB. The appended documents included the Settlement Agreement, the release notice of the monies by the escrow agent, and the SWIFT message reflecting the distribution to CACIB. Any degree of uncertainty raised by PPT as to the amount of CACIB’s recovery in the settlement was resolved by the Affidavit.
The interest payable
Interest payable to PPT
- [29]
[29] In the Liability Judgment, we rejected CACIB’s appeal in relation to the Credit dispute and found that CACIB was liable to pay PPT the LC Sum of US$23,662,732.50. The due date for payment under the Credit was 5 June 2020, but CACIB paid the LC Sum into the designated BOC bank account only on 18 November 2020. In the interim, on 17 June 2020, after exchanges between ING and CACIB, TOTSA transferred the Receivables to Mayer Brown as escrow agent. As such, notwithstanding that CACIB only became entitled to the Receivables on 18 November 2020 when the LC Sum was paid to PPT, PPT had already become liable in damages to CACIB for the sum of US$16,517,443.06 as of 17 June 2020.
- [30]
[30] Accordingly, PPT is entitled to interest at the rate of 5.33% per annum and pro rata on:
(a) The principal amount of US$23,662,732.50 from 5 June 2020 (being the date the LC Sum was due) to 17 June 2020 (being the date that PPT became liable in damages to CACIB for the sum of US$16,517,443.06), amounting to US$41,464.89; and
(b) The principal amount of US$7,145,289.44 (ie, US$23,662,732.50 less US$16,517,443.06) from 17 June 2020 to 18 November 2020 (being the date the LC Sum was paid), amounting to US$160,684.84.
- [31]
[31] We do not accept PPT’s submissions that (a) PPT should be granted post-judgment interest until the BOC Guarantee is discharged; or (b) PPT should be paid interest on the PPT Loan (see [17] above). We affirm and reiterate the views of the Judge that once CACIB made payment under the Credit on 18 November 2020, there was “no outstanding debt post 18 November 2020” and the arrangement between BOC and PPT as to how the LC Sum was to be managed was “a matter for negotiation between PPT and BOC”. It suffices to say that having paid out the LC Sum on 18 November 2020, CACIB thereafter no longer owed any liability to PPT as regards the LC Sum on which interest could accrue and attach. With respect to the PPT Loan, there is no basis for PPT’s claim for interest as that was an arrangement which had nothing to do with CACIB.
Interest payable to CACIB
- [32]
[32] CACIB is entitled to interest at the rate of 5.33% per annum and pro rata on:
(a) The principal amount of US$16,517,443.06 from 18 November 2020 (being the date the LC Sum was paid and thus the date when CACIB was entitled to the Receivables) to 9 December 2020 (being the date US$6,197,532.75 was paid to CACIB pursuant to the Settlement Agreement), amounting to US$50,651.98; and
(b) The principal amount of US$10,319,910.31 from 9 December 2020 (being the date US$6,197,532.75 was paid to CACIB pursuant to the Settlement Agreement) to the date that such sum is paid to CACIB.
The costs of the trial below and the Appeals
To whom should costs be awarded?
- [37]
[37] Similarly, O 110 r 46(1)–(2) of the ROC 2014 provides:
- [38]
[38] In determining the identity of the successful party, the court must look at the outcome of the litigation overall, in a realistic and commercially sensible way, asking which party in substance and reality won the litigation: Comfort Management at [28]; BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd and another v PT Bayan Resources TBK and another [2022] SGHC(I) 17 (“BCBC”) at [30]. In commercial litigation, where the dispute is ultimately about money, the event is typically in favour of the party whom the court has found is entitled to receive money: Comfort Management at [29]; BCBC at [30].
Effect of contractual indemnity clause under the LOI
- [41]
[41] The LOI contains an indemnity clause, which states:
CACIB also pleaded:
Costs of the trial below
Pre-transfer costs
- [47]
[47] To recapitulate, CACIB has claimed the following:
Post-transfer costs
- [50]
[50] CACIB claims the following:
Costs of the Appeals
Overall discount
- [59]
[59] This generous discount also takes into account the fact that CACIB only succeeded in its LOI damages claim by virtue of CACIB’s late amendment to its case during the hearing of the Appeals. At the hearing of the Appeals, ACIB argued that it should be put in the same position as it would have been in if either “the warranties had been true” or the original bills had been presented. CACIB’s initial argument was that it should be put in the same position “as if it had been provided the original bills”, which would have caused CACIB to lose the argument on the damages to be awarded in the LOI dispute.
Conclusion
- [61]
[61] For the reasons above, we make the following orders:
(a) PPT is entitled to interest at the rate of 5.33% per annum and pro rata on:
(i) The principal amount of US$23,662,732.50 from 5 June 2020 to 17 June 2020, amounting to US$41,464.89; and
(ii) The principal amount of US$7,145,289.44 from 17 June 2020 to 18 November 2020, amounting to US$160,684.84.
(b) CACIB is entitled to a refund of all costs, fees and interest paid to PPT subsequent to the Judge’s decision of 30 March 2022, in the sum of US$1,983,971.30.
(c) CACIB is entitled to interest at the rate of 5.33% per annum and pro rata on:
(i) The principal amount of US$16,517,443.06 from 18 November 2020 to 9 December 2020, amounting to US$50,651.98;
(ii) The principal amount of US$10,319,910.31 from 9 December 2020 to the date that such sum is paid to CACIB; and
(iii) The principal amount of US$1,983,971.30 from 14 April 2022 to the date that such sum is repaid.
(d) CACIB is entitled to costs and disbursements in the sum of S$269,873.18, US$256,560.90 and £129,224.17.