Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 1 Nov 2022

General Division of the High Court

Wang Xiaopu v Goh Seng Heng and another

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHC 272Case no. Suit No 686 of 20155 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Facts

  3. The main action

  4. [4] The plaintiff, Wang Xiaopu (“Mdm Wang”) is a director and shareholder of Guangdong Marubi Biotechnology Co. Ltd., a company incorporated under the laws of the People’s Republic of China.

  5. [5] The defendants are both medical doctors. The first defendant, Goh Seng Heng (“Dr Goh”), is the father of the second defendant, Goh Ming Li Michelle (“Dr Michelle Goh”). Dr Goh was declared a bankrupt on 19 March 2020.

  6. Committal proceedings against Mr Goh

  7. Parties’ cases

  8. Issues

  9. [13] The key issues to be determined were:

  10. (a) whether Dr Michelle Goh should be made liable for the costs of SUM 5041; and

  11. (b) whether costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis, and the quantum of these costs.

  12. Issue 1: Whether costs should be ordered against Dr Michelle Goh

  13. The law on ordering costs against non-parties

  14. (a) There must be a close connection between the non-party and the proceedings. This is a fact-dependent exercise and there are many ways to demonstrate a close connection. It is sufficient that the non-party either funds or controls legal proceedings with the intention of ultimately deriving a benefit from them: (at [30]–[34]).

  15. Whether it was just in the circumstances of the case to order costs against Dr Michelle Goh

  16. Whether the allegations of dissipation of assets to Dr Goh’s family justified an order of costs against Dr Michelle Goh

  17. [19] With all due respect to counsel, notwithstanding any dissipation of assets (which, for the avoidance of doubt, I make no finding on), I did not see how Dr Michelle Goh would stand to benefit from committal proceedings, the nature of which is to impose punitive consequences upon a party (ie, Dr Goh) for his non-compliance with court orders. Moreover, the familial connection between Dr Michelle Goh and Dr Goh did not automatically connect Dr Michelle Goh to committal proceedings against Dr Goh. I was unpersuaded that any dissipation of Dr Goh’s assets and his familial relationship to Dr Michelle Goh evinced a “close connection” between Dr Michelle Goh and the committal proceedings.

  18. Whether Dr Michelle Goh’s undertaking to act as Dr Goh’s litigation sponsor justified an order of costs against her

  19. Issue 2: Costs ordered against Dr Goh

  20. Whether costs should be ordered on an indemnity basis

  21. Quantum of costs

  22. [36] Counsel for Mdm Wang submitted that the proceedings had become protracted due to Dr Goh’s conduct. Counsel for Dr Goh in turn submitted that the delays in the contempt proceedings could not be placed solely on Dr Goh’s shoulders, as two rounds of amendments were required for the contempt statement and four out of the nine pre-trial conferences conducted were because Mdm Wang had sought more time, eg, to respond to the affidavits, etc.

  23. Conclusion