General Division of the High Court · Decided 3 August 2023
Crescendas Bionics Pte Ltd v Jurong Primewide Pte Ltd
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 209 · Case no. Suit No 477 of 2015 · 38 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background facts
- [2]
[2] Crescendas was a property developer while JPW was a general building contractor. On 30 June 2008, Crescendas and JPW signed a four-page Letter of Intent (“LOI”) dated 26 June 2008 under which Crescendas engaged JPW as the management contractor to build Biopolis 3, a seven-storey multi-tenanted business park development at Biopolis Drive/Biomedical Grove in One-North (the “Project”).
- [3]
[3] After the LOI was signed, the parties’ relationship deteriorated due to disagreements on each party’s obligations and the scope of each party’s responsibilities under the LOI. Ultimately, there were substantial delays in the completion of the Project, which was certified as completed on 12 January 2011. It was undisputed that the time taken for completion exceeded the time period of 18 months stipulated in the LOI for JPW to complete the construction of the Project.
- [4]
[4] Crescendas brought Suit No 477 of 2015 (“Suit 477”) against JPW and JPW also had counterclaims against Crescendas. The trial was bifurcated.
- [5]
[5] The first tranche of the trial dealt with the liabilities of the parties. The High Court made its findings on the liabilities of the parties in Crescendas Bionics Pte Ltd v Jurong Primewide Pte Ltd [2019] SGHC 4 (“Liability Judgment (HC)”). Upon the conclusion of the first tranche of the trial, the parties were dissatisfied with the High Court’s decision and lodged their respective appeals. At the appellate hearing, the Liability Judgment (HC) was largely affirmed by the Court of Appeal (the “CA”) in Jurong Primewide Pte Ltd v Crescendas Bionics Pte Ltd and another appeal [2019] SGCA 63 (“Liability Judgment (CA)”), save in relation to the arithmetic computation of the days of delay for which JPW was responsible and the time taken for the capping beams work (see Liability Judgment (CA) at [16]–[20]).
- [6]
[6] Briefly, the Liability Judgment (HC) and the Liability Judgment (CA) found that the completion of the Project was delayed by a total of 334 days. Of the 334 days, Crescendas was responsible for an aggregate of 173 days of delay caused by its acts of prevention (see Liability Judgment (HC) at [352]), while JPW was responsible for 161 days of delay (see Liability Judgment (CA) at [14]–[20]). On this basis, JPW was found to be liable to Crescendas for general damages for 161 days of delay.
- [7]
[7] The second tranche of the trial dealt with an assessment of the general damages due to Crescendas in respect of the 161 days of delay for which JPW was responsible. This is because of the finding made in the first tranche of the trial that the contractual provision on liquidated damages in the LOI was rendered inoperative as a result of the acts of prevention by Crescendas. The High Court made its findings on the general damages owed to Crescendas by JPW in Crescendas Bionics Pte Ltd v Jurong Primewide Pte Ltd [2021] SGHC 189 (the “Damages Judgment (HC)”). The parties again were dissatisfied with the High Court’s decision and they lodged their respective appeals. On 9 February 2023, the Appellate Division of the High Court (the “AD”) released its decision on the appeals in Crescendas Bionics Pte Ltd v Jurong Primewide Pte Ltd and other appeals [2023] SGHC(A) 9 (the “Damages Judgment (AD)”).
Outcome of the first tranche and the second tranche of the trial and the respective appeals
The first tranche of the trial and the appeal to the CA
- [10]
[10] The issues and the Court’s findings at the first tranche of the High Court trial are as follows:
(a) The first issue related to the provision of $12.3 million under the signed LOI for the preliminaries (“Preliminaries Sum”). Crescendas argued that the Preliminaries Sum under the LOI was tentative and that the parties had intended for the Preliminaries Sum to be finalised within four weeks of the commencement of the Project. JPW, on the other hand, submitted that the Preliminaries Sum was fixed at $12.3 million under the signed LOI. In the Liability Judgment (HC), the High Court found that the parties’ intention was for the Preliminaries Sum under the LOI to be fixed at $12.3 million (see Liability Judgment (HC) at [164]–[170]). The High Court, therefore, dismissed Crescendas’ claim on this issue. This finding was affirmed by the CA on appeal (see Liability Judgment (CA) at [10]).
(b) The second issue related to JPW’s counterclaim of $155,000, which was the amount JPW incurred to procure a performance bond from Oversea-Chinese Banking Corporation Limited (“OCBC Bond”). In the Liability Judgment (HC), the High Court found that Crescendas was not liable to pay JPW $155,000 for the procurement of the OCBC Bond (see Liability Judgment (HC) at [171]–[179]). The High Court, therefore, dismissed JPW’s counterclaim for the amount incurred to procure the OCBC Bond. JPW did not appeal on this issue.
(c) The third issue related to JPW’s counterclaim for its share of $2.5 million in the first $5 million of the shared savings. Crescendas claimed that JPW had agreed to forgo its share in the first $5 million of the shared savings. In the Liability Judgment (HC), the High Court found that there was no agreement between the parties that JPW would forego its 50% share in the first $5 million of the shared savings as Crescendas failed to comply with its conditions. The High Court, therefore, allowed JPW’s counterclaim of $2.5 million (see Liability Judgment (HC) at [217]). This was upheld by the CA on appeal (see Liability Judgment (CA) at [12]).
The second tranche of the trial and the appeal to the AD
- [11]
[11] In the second tranche of the trial, Crescendas sought an assessment of general damages in respect of the 161 days of delay for which JPW was responsible. In particular, Crescendas claimed general damages for the delayed completion in respect of three heads of losses, namely:
- [12]
[12] Crescendas engaged three expert witnesses to support its case: Mr Andre Toh Sern (“Mr Toh”), Dr Annie Woo Yen Lee (“Dr Woo”) and Mr Dennis Yeo Huang Kiat (“Mr Yeo”). JPW engaged one expert witness, Assoc Prof Yu Shi Ming (“Assoc Prof Yu”), to support its case. In view of the extreme positions taken by the parties on the quantum of Crescendas’ loss of net rental revenue (see [13] below), a court expert who was chosen and agreed upon by the parties, Adjunct Assoc Prof Tay Kah Poh (“Assoc Prof Tay”), was appointed to assist the Court.
- [13]
[13] In respect of the “loss of chance” to earn net rental revenue, the parties’ positions can be summarised as follows:
(a) Crescendas argued that the combined delay of 344 days resulted in the loss of five pre-commitment tenants which would have otherwise taken up lease agreements in the Project. In quantifying its net rental revenue loss, Crescendas submitted that the appropriate method of quantification was the multi-year model, ie, a computation of the difference between the projected net rental revenue Crescendas would have earned had there been no combined delay and the actual net rental revenue Crescendas had earned, over the span of multiple years including the combined delay of 344 days to stabilised occupancy. A discount rate of 8% was then applied to the difference to take into account the project risk. Crescendas contended that the multi-year model reflected the full loss it suffered. Using the multi-year model, Crescendas claimed net rental revenue loss of $10.2 million from JPW. Alternatively, if a single-year model was adopted, ie, where damages are awarded only in respect of the loss of net rental revenue for the period of delay in 2010, Crescendas claimed net rental revenue loss of $2.89 million to $2.91 million from JPW (see Damages Judgment (HC) at [29]–[34]).
(b) JPW raised various issues of causation and remoteness to deny Crescendas’ high recoverability of damages for net rental revenue loss. As to the quantum, JPW argued that, if the multi-year model was to be applied, a more appropriate quantification of the loss suffered by Crescendas was $362,183.83. Alternatively, under the single-year model, JPW argued that it was only liable for a sum of between $308,045.33 and $627,987.17 (see Damages Judgment (HC) at [41]–[45]).
- [14]
[14] In the Damages Judgment (HC), the High Court preferred the single-year model over the multi-year model. The High Court opined that the single-year model was fairer and would not have infringed the principle of remoteness of damages. Further, the single-year model computed the delay without any uncertainty and assumptions which were inherent in the multi-year model. Thus, the single-year model was the more appropriate method of quantifying Crescendas’ loss of net rental revenue (see Damages Judgment (HC) at [125]–[128]). Applying the single-year model, the High Court found JPW liable for a sum of $1,789,398.82 in respect of Crescendas’ loss of net rental revenue (see Damages Judgment (HC) at [317]). In the Damages Judgment (AD), the AD found that the multi-year model should have been used instead of the single-year model in assessing Crescendas’ loss of net rental revenue. Applying the multi-year model, JPW was found to be liable to Crescendas for a sum of $4,185,802.60 (see Damages Judgment (AD) at [196]–[197]).
Previous costs orders set aside by the AD following the Damages Judgment (AD)
The parties’ agreement on the issues of costs
The parties’ submissions on costs
Crescendas’ submission on costs for the first tranche and the second tranche of the trial
Crescendas’ submission on costs for the first tranche of the trial
- [21]
[21] Crescendas argues that it is the successful party for the first tranche of the trial. Crescendas states that it had established that JPW was liable for 161 days of delay as opposed to its original claim of 355 days of delay. Crescendas submits that the issue of delay was its main claim given that a significant part of the Liability Judgment (HC) and the parties’ written closing submissions were dedicated to dealing with the issue of delay. Crescendas also states that it had successfully defended against JPW’s counterclaim on the issue relating to the OCBC Bond. Crescendas acknowledges that JPW had succeeded on the issues relating to the Preliminaries Sum, the shared savings and liquidated damages for the delays. Nevertheless, Crescendas argues that it is the successful party on the basis that the practical and overall outcome of Suit 477 is that Crescendas is entitled to receive compensation from JPW which JPW would not have paid but for Suit 477.
(b) In relation to disbursements, Crescendas relies on its costs schedule for the first tranche of the trial which sets out its total disbursements for the period up to the written closing submissions as amounting to $455,355.53. Taking into account disbursements incurred for and after the oral closing submissions, Crescendas seeks the following costs orders:
Crescendas’ submission on costs for the second tranche of the trial
(b) In relation to disbursements, Crescendas relies on its costs schedule for the second tranche of the trial which sets out its disbursements. Crescendas seeks an average of 75% of all its disbursements. Crescendas’ submissions on the appropriate costs orders for the expert fees incurred by Crescendas and general disbursements are as follows:
JPW’s submission on costs for the first tranche and the second tranche of the trial
JPW’s submission on costs for the first tranche of the trial
- [25]
[25] JPW submits that it is the successful party for the first tranche of the trial. JPW states that it had succeeded on two highly contentious issues, namely the issues relating to the Preliminaries Sum and the shared savings. JPW submits that since it won on these issues, JPW was entitled to approximately $14.65 million. This comprises the Preliminaries Sum of $12.3 million and JPW’s $2.5 million share in the first $5 million of the shared savings, less $155,000 which was for the OCBC Bond which JPW failed in its counterclaim against Crescendas. Further, JPW argues that it succeeded in proving Crescendas’ acts of prevention which made the liquidated damages provision of the LOI inoperative and this led to the outcome that Crescendas was liable for 173 days out of the total combined delay of 334 days.
JPW’s submission on costs for the second tranche of the trial
(a) In relation to legal costs, JPW states that Crescendas should only be entitled to claim 40.6% of legal costs on the basis that Crescendas only succeeded in claiming 40.6% of the amount of $13.3 million it was seeking to claim against JPW for delay-related losses at the start of the second tranche of the trial. Further, JPW takes issue with the quantum of legal costs claimed by Crescendas for the second tranche of the trial. JPW, instead, suggests that Appendix G should be used as a guide on legal costs for the second tranche of the trial. JPW states that Appendix G suggests legal costs for pre-trial costs, 16 days of trial and post-trial costs in the range of $167,000 to $413,000. JPW states that the appropriate starting point for legal costs in this case is $350,000. Therefore, JPW argues that Crescendas should only be entitled to 40.6% of legal costs and thus, Crescendas should be entitled to only $142,100 (ie, 40.6% of $350,000).
(b) In relation to disbursements, JPW argues that Crescendas’ claim for disbursements of $1,171,185.06 is not a reasonable and proportionate figure. The details of JPW’s submission are as follows:
(i) In relation to general disbursements for Crescendas, JPW states that Crescendas should be entitled to no more than 40.6% of its general disbursements. JPW states that this would amount to $89,524.31.
(ii) In relation to the expert fees incurred by Crescendas, JPW states that there is a need for substantial moderation to accord with principles of proportionality and reasonableness. JPW’s submission on the various expert fees for Crescendas’ experts is as follows:
The parties’ submissions on costs for various interlocutory matters
The applicable law on costs
The general principles on costs
Generally costs follow the event
- [32]
[32] When deciding who is the successful party in the litigation, the court would have to ascertain the overall outcome of the litigation as well as which party in substance and reality won the litigation, looking at its outcome in a realistic and commercially sensible way: Comfort Management at [27]–[28], citing Straker v Tudor Rose (a firm) [2007] EWCA Civ 368 at [11]; HLB Kidsons (A Firm) v Lloyds Underwriters subscribing to Lloyds Policy No 621/PKID00101 & Others [2007] EWHC 2699 (Comm) at [10].
- [33]
[33] In Comfort Management, Coomaraswamy J stated that in commercial litigation where the dispute is ultimately about money, the successful party would typically be the party whom the court has found is entitled to receive money, see [29]–[35] as follows:
When would it be appropriate to depart from the general rule that costs follow the event?
My decision
Crescendas is the successful party and is entitled to costs for both the first tranche and the second tranche of the trial
Crescendas is the successful party for the first tranche of the trial
- [37]
[37] In determining the successful party for the first tranche of the trial, the parties have agreed that the issues-based approach is not the appropriate approach. The parties agree that the Court has to ascertain ultimately which party is entitled to receive money after taking into account the claims and counterclaims.
- [38]
[38] While the trial was bifurcated, this does not mean that the Court must ignore the outcome of the second tranche of the trial, which is an assessment of damages for the 161 days of delay caused by JPW. On the contrary, the Court must view the overall outcome of the litigation in determining which party in substance and in reality won the litigation (see [32] above). This would require an examination of which party is ultimately entitled to receive more money. The result of the overall litigation is that JPW must pay a substantial sum to Crescendas after taking into account JPW’s counterclaims. Crescendas could not have recovered this sum if it had not commenced legal action against JPW and succeeded in Suit 477. Therefore, Crescendas must be the successful party in this litigation for both the first tranche and the second tranche of the trial.
- [39]
[39] Crescendas only recovered a portion of its overall pleaded claims as Crescendas took extreme positions for its claims. JPW argues that Crescendas cannot be the successful party in the first tranche of the trial as Crescendas was liable for 173 days of delay. However, JPW was liable for 161 days of delay and this was the subject of the second tranche of the trial where damages were to be assessed for JPW’s 161 days of delay.
- [40]
[40] JPW had also won some important issues in the first tranche. JPW succeeded in its counterclaim in relation to its $2.5 million share in the first $5 million of the shared savings. JPW won on the issue of the Preliminaries Sum and managed to resist Crescendas’ claim on liquidated damages. JPW also succeeded in proving that Crescendas was liable for 173 days of delay as a result of its acts of prevention. However, these successes were outweighed by Crescendas’ victory in Suit 477 as the overall result of this litigation is that JPW must pay Crescendas a substantial sum.
JPW’s submission that it is the successful party for the first tranche of the trial is not convincing
- [41]
[41] JPW’s argument that it is the successful party for the first tranche of the trial appears to be based primarily on its successes on some of the issues. JPW submits that it “was found to be entitled to approximately $14.65m [at the end of the first tranche of the trial], comprising $12.3m of the [Preliminaries Sum] plus $2.5m for [its share in the first $5 million of the shared savings] that it had succeeded on, less $155,000 for the [OCBC Bond] which [Crescendas] had succeeded on”.
- [42]
[42] This submission, however, is incorrect. Although JPW had won on the issue of the Preliminaries Sum of $12.3 million, JPW cannot claim that it had won $12.3 million from Crescendas. The issue relating to the Preliminaries Sum (see [10(a)] above) was whether the Preliminaries Sum of $12.3 million was a fixed sum as JPW contended or a tentative figure subject to negotiation within four weeks of the commencement of the Project as Crescendas contended. JPW succeeded in proving that the Preliminaries Sum was a fixed sum of $12.3 million. The result of this was that JPW was not required to refund any portion of the Preliminaries Sum to Crescendas. But the result was not that Crescendas had to pay more for the Preliminaries Sum.
- [44]
[44] For the above reasons, the monetary win for JPW at the end of the first tranche of the trial was only in relation to JPW’s share of $2.5 million in the first $5 million of the shared savings. In contrast, Crescendas had succeeded in the following claims: (a) JPW was responsible for 161 days of delay, for which general damages was to be assessed in the second tranche of the trial; and (b) JPW was liable to refund a portion of the additional preliminaries Crescendas paid to JPW for 161 days of delay, which sum was fixed at $2.75 million following a settlement agreement by the parties before the hearing of the second tranche.
The quantum of costs to be awarded to Crescendas for the first tranche of the trial
(a) Crescendas failed in its claim that the Preliminaries Sum was not a fixed sum.
(b) Crescendas succeeded in refuting JPW’s counterclaim of $155,000 which was the amount JPW incurred to procure the OCBC Bond.
(c) Crescendas failed in relation to JPW’s counterclaim for JPW’s share of $2.5 million in the first $5 million of the shared savings.
(d) Crescendas succeeded in proving that JPW caused substantial delays to the completion of the Project. However, Crescendas claimed in its pleadings that JPW was liable for 355 days of delay but JPW was ultimately only found to be liable for 161 days of delay. The Court also found Crescendas liable for 173 days of delay by its acts of prevention.
(e) As a result of the delay by JPW, Crescendas succeeded in its claim for a refund of the portion of the additional preliminaries it paid to JPW which the parties agreed at $2.75 million.
- [48]
[48] The High Court also noticed that Crescendas had taken extreme positions which were unnecessary in Suit 477. These had lengthened and increased the complexity of the proceedings.
- [49]
[49] In particular, Crescendas alleged that the delays were all due to JPW. However, the High Court found that Crescendas had committed acts of prevention that caused the Project’s completion to be delayed. In the Liability Judgment (HC) (at [378]–[384]), the High Court found that Crescendas had embarked on an insidious campaign to slow down the completion of the Project as it was a period of global financial crisis in 2008 which moderated construction prices. There were also serious uncertainty and challenges to seek tenants to occupy the Project at that time. To delay the progress of the work, Crescendas engaged in conduct which was highly interventionist and unconducive to the progress of the works towards the completion of the Project. Despite the delay caused by Crescendas, it took an unreasonable position at the first tranche of the trial and blamed JPW solely for all 355 days of delay. This unnecessarily added to the length and the complexity of the proceedings.
(a) The parties agree that the quantum of legal costs for the first tranche is $700,000. However, the parties’ costs schedules have not included legal costs for the parties’ oral closing submissions which took 2.5 days. Crescendas has referred to the costs guidelines in Appendix G which provides a maximum daily tariff for construction cases of $18,000. This maximum daily tariff should be used to compute the legal costs for the 2.5 days of oral closing submissions, given the complexity of Suit 477. On this basis, Crescendas’ total legal costs for the first tranche of the trial is $745,000, ie, $700,000 plus $45,000. Accordingly, JPW is to pay Crescendas 30% of Crescendas’ legal costs, ie, $223,500.
(b) In relation to the general disbursements, Crescendas’ costs schedule for the first tranche of the trial sets out its general disbursements for the period up to the written closing submissions as amounting to $220,183.75. Taking into account the general disbursements incurred for and after the oral closing submissions, Crescendas states that its total general disbursements amount to $224,828.22. Accordingly, JPW is to pay Crescendas 40% of Crescendas’ general disbursements, ie, $89,931.29.
(c) In relation to Mr Connor’s expert fee, Crescendas states that it incurred the sum of $239,816.25. Accordingly, JPW is to pay Crescendas 40% of Mr Connor’s expert fee of $239,816.25, ie, $95,926.50.
The quantum of costs to be awarded to Crescendas for the second tranche of the trial
The quantum of legal costs which Crescendas is entitled to for the second tranche of the trial
- [57]
[57] Based on a holistic overview, Crescendas has won a substantial sum of $8,125,952.92 (see the breakdown below) at the end of the second tranche of the trial, less the sum of $2.5 million owed by Crescendas to JPW for JPW’s share of the first $5 million of the shared savings. The breakdown of the award is as follows:
(a) JPW was found to be liable for a sum of $4,185,802.60 in relation to Crescendas’ loss of net rental revenue.
(b) JPW was found to be liable for a sum of $1,061,285.86 in respect of Crescendas’ holding costs.
(c) JPW was found to be liable for a sum of $128,864.46 in respect of the site staff costs.
(d) JPW was found to be liable to refund a portion of the additional preliminaries paid by Crescendas to JPW for 161 days of delay. Following the settlement, JPW agreed to pay a sum of $2.75 million to Crescendas.
(e) JPW succeeded in its counterclaim against Crescendas for the sum of $2.5 million which was JPW’s share in the first $5 million of the shared savings.
- [58]
[58] Further, Crescendas had also succeeded in showing, and the AD had agreed, that the multi-year methodology was the correct method for computing the loss of rental arising from the 161 days of delay caused by JPW.
(b) JPW disagrees with Crescendas’ legal costs as set out in Crescendas’ costs schedule. Instead, JPW suggests using the costs guidelines in Appendix G to arrive at an approximation of the appropriate legal costs for the second tranche of the trial. Appendix G provides the following:
JPW states that an application of Appendix G would lead to costs in the range of $167,000 to $413,000 for pre-trial costs, 16 days of trial and post-trial costs. JPW states that the appropriate starting point for legal costs in this case is $350,000. Based on JPW’s costs schedule for the second tranche of the trial, I note that JPW’s legal costs amounted to $350,000.
(c) There is clearly a significant difference in the quantum of legal costs of the parties as set out in their respective costs schedules. The costs guidelines in Appendix G should be used to arrive at an approximation of legal costs which would ordinarily have been incurred for the second tranche of the trial. The second tranche of the trial was clearly complex and lengthy. I agree that the complexity of the second tranche of the trial warrants using the highest end of the ranges set out in Appendix G. This would lead to the total legal costs of $413,000, comprising the following:
Crescendas’ entitlement to disbursements for the second tranche of the trial
(1) General disbursements
- [62]
[62] I shall now consider the amount of the expert fees that JPW has to pay for the Court’s expert and Crescendas’ experts.
(2) Assoc Prof Tay’s expert fee
- [63]
[63] Assoc Prof Tay was the Court’s expert appointed with the consent of the parties who agreed to bear his fee which amounted to $57,600. This was the lowest of all the expert fees and it was borne by Crescendas and JPW in equal proportion in the first instance.
(3) Dr Woo’s and Mr Yeo’s joint expert fee
- [66]
[66] JPW argues that the joint expert fee of Dr Woo and Mr Yeo is unreasonable and excessive. The joint expert fee amounts to $256,242.26.
- [67]
[67] JPW argues that this fee is twice that of JPW’s expert, Assoc Prof Yu, which was $119,600. However, this ignores the fact that the joint expert fee of $256,242.26 is a combined fee issued for the work done by two experts – Dr Woo and Mr Yeo. In contrast, the expert fee of JPW’s expert was for the work done by a single expert. Therefore, JPW’s comparison of the two fees is erroneous and inaccurate.
- [68]
[68] In the same vein, JPW’s submission that the joint expert fee of Dr Woo and Mr Yeo is four times that of the fee of the Court’s expert, Assoc Prof Tay, which was $57,600, is similarly incorrect.
- [69]
[69] Crescendas is seeking a reimbursement of 95% of the joint expert fee of Dr Woo and Mr Yeo while JPW submits that JPW should only be liable for 50% of the joint expert fee of $256,242.26.
(4) Mr Toh’s expert fee
- [72]
[72] I note JPW’s argument that Mr Toh’s expert fee is five times that of JPW’s expert, Assoc Prof Yu. It is undisputed that Mr Toh’s expert fee is significantly higher than the expert fees of the other experts who assisted in the trial. The issue, however, is whether Mr Toh’s expert fee is reasonable and proportionate.
- [73]
[73] In my view, I agree with JPW’s submission that much of Mr Toh’s evidence relating to quantification of Crescendas’ loss of net rental revenue was based on a calculation of the difference between projected earnings (ie, the delay scenario) and actual earnings of Crescendas (ie, no delay scenario). This aspect of Mr Toh’s evidence was also commented on by the other experts of Crescendas at the trial. Hence, it is questionable whether it was really necessary for Crescendas to engage Mr Toh as his fee was astronomically higher than the other experts. It is excessive for Crescendas to have engaged three experts to quantify the delay for the second tranche of the trial.
(5) Summary of the costs orders relating to disbursements for the second tranche of the trial
Costs orders for various interlocutory applications
Conclusion
- [79]
[79] In summary, Crescendas is the successful party for both the first tranche and the second tranche of the trial. These are my findings:
(a) The Court must view the overall outcome of the litigation in determining which party in substance and in reality won the litigation. It is clear that the result of the overall litigation is that JPW must pay a substantial sum to Crescendas. Crescendas could not have recovered this sum if it had not commenced Suit 477 against JPW. Crescendas has succeeded to recover a substantial sum from JPW. I am mindful that Crescendas only recovered a fraction out of its overall pleaded claim. This is largely due to the fact that Crescendas took extreme positions on some of the important issues. I am also aware that JPW succeeded on a number of issues in the first tranche of the trial. However, this is outweighed by the fact that the overall result of this litigation is that JPW must pay Crescendas a substantial sum.
(b) JPW’s position that it is the successful party for the first tranche of the trial is premised on its claim that it had won the Preliminaries Sum of $12.3 million following the first tranche of the trial. This is, however, inaccurate. The issue relating to the Preliminaries Sum was whether the Preliminaries Sum of $12.3 million was a fixed sum. Crescendas contended that the Preliminaries Sum of $12.3 million was a tentative figure subject to negotiation. JPW’s success on this issue was the High Court’s finding, which was affirmed by the Court of Appeal, that the Preliminaries Sum was a fixed sum of $12.3 million. The result of this issue is that JPW does not have to refund any portion of the Preliminaries Sum to Crescendas.
(c) While Crescendas is the successful party for both the first tranche and the second tranche of the trial, this does not mean that JPW’s successes in relation to its counterclaim and in defending against the various claims of Crescendas are to be given no weight. Rather, JPW’s successes on these issues allow the Court to exercise its discretion to moderate Crescendas’ claims for legal costs and disbursements.
(a) The parties agree that the quantum of legal costs for the first tranche of the trial is $700,000. For the oral closing submissions which took 2.5 days and applying the maximum daily tariff of $18,000 in the costs guidelines in Appendix G, legal costs for the 2.5 days is $45,000. Hence, Crescendas’ total legal costs for the first tranche of the trial is $745,000. JPW is to pay 30% of this amount to Crescendas, ie, $223,500.
(b) In relation to general disbursements which amounts to $224,828.22, JPW is to pay 40% of Crescendas’ general disbursements to Crescendas, ie, $89,931.29.
(c) In relation to Mr Connor’s expert fee of $239,816.25, JPW is to pay 40% of Mr Connor’s expert fee to Crescendas, ie, $95,926.50.
- [81]
[81] For the first tranche of the trial, JPW is to pay Crescendas an aggregate of $409,357.79 (ie, $223,500 plus $89,931.29 plus $95,926.50).
(a) JPW is to pay 80% of Crescendas’ legal costs for the second tranche of the trial. I reject JPW’s submission that it should be held liable for only 40.6% of Crescendas’ legal costs.
(d) The expert fee of Assoc Prof Tay is $57,600. Assoc Prof Tay was appointed with the consent of the parties as the Court’s expert to assist in the second tranche of the trial as the parties had taken extreme positions. Crescendas and JPW will bear the expert fee of Assoc Prof Tay in equal proportion.
- [83]
[83] For the second tranche of the trial, JPW is to pay Crescendas an aggregate of $889,193.92 (ie, $330,400 plus $179,810.40 plus $179,369.58 plus $199,613.94).
- [85]
[85] For the interlocutory matters, JPW is to pay an aggregate of $15,951.17 to Crescendas.