General Division of the High Court · Decided 28 February 2023
Lakshmi Anil Salgaocar (suing as the administratrix of the estate of Anil Vassudeva Salgaocar) and another v Darsan Jitendra Jhaveri and others (Kwan Ka Yu Terence, third party)
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 47 · Case no. Suit No 821 of 2015
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] This judgment is the final act in a long-running dispute that has spawned multiple satellite proceedings and seen the intervening passing of the original plaintiff. HC/S 821/2015 (“Suit 821”) centres on an oral agreement that was allegedly made in December 2003 (“the December 2003 Agreement”) between Mr Anil Vassudeva Salgaocar (“Mr Salgaocar”) and the first defendant, Mr Darsan Jitendra Jhaveri (“Mr Darsan”) pursuant to which a trust (“the 2003 Trust”) was created with Mr Darsan as trustee. The gist of the December 2003 Agreement was that Mr Darsan would, as trustee: (a) be Mr Salgaocar’s nominee shareholder and director in various special purpose vehicles (“SPVs”) to be funded by Mr Salgaocar, and (b) act in accordance with Mr Salgaocar’s instructions. Following the December 2003 Agreement, six SPVs were initially incorporated in the British Virgin Islands (“the BVI”) and funded by Mr Salgaocar (see [14] below). These six BVI SPVs were used to trade in iron ore – purchasing iron ore from entities owned or controlled by Mr Salgaocar and on-selling it to buyers in China. The profits made by these SPVs as a result were some US$690m between 2004 and 2012, and a significant portion of those profits was used to incorporate other SPVs and purchase assets and make investments through them. As pleaded, the equity in all the SPVs, the profits, and the assets and investments purchased using them constitute the trust assets. However, the plaintiffs’ have clarified in their Opening Statement and Closing Submissions that they are not making a claim to the assets of the SPVs.
- [2]
[2] The plaintiffs’ overarching case is that Mr Salgaocar and Mr Darsan entered into the December 2003 Agreement in the manner described above and that Mr Darsan breached his duties as trustee of the 2003 Trust by, inter alia, misappropriating the trust assets for the benefit of his family and himself. The first plaintiff thus seeks, inter alia, a declaration that Mr Darsan holds the assets subject to the 2003 Trust on trust for Mr Salgaocar’s estate (subject to the clarification stated above). The first plaintiff also seeks reliefs against the second to fourteenth defendants that are consequential on the declaration that is sought against Mr Darsan being granted. The second plaintiff seeks reliefs against Mr Darsan and the second defendant that are independent of the reliefs sought by the first plaintiff.
- [3]
[3] The defendants contend that there is no December 2003 Agreement and therefore the 2003 Trust does not exist. In any event, the December 2003 Agreement, and thus the 2003 Trust, are unenforceable on the basis that the December 2003 Agreement was illegal under Indian law. Instead, the defendants claim that Mr Salgaocar and Mr Darsan had embarked on a shipping venture (defined at [40] below as “the Shipping Venture”), the management and operations of which Mr Salgaocar would be responsible for. According to the defendants, Mr Salgaocar would underwrite any losses that Mr Darsan suffered in the Shipping Venture and Mr Darsan would share any profits that were made with Mr Salgaocar. Mr Darsan claims that pursuant to this venture, the parties agreed to keep a “running account” (“the Running Account”) between them, which Mr Salgaocar and his estate have failed to settle or equalize. Thus, Mr Darsan seeks an account and inquiry in relation to the Running Account as part of his counterclaim against the first plaintiff. Mr Darsan also claims an indemnity against or contribution from a third-party, Mr Kwan Ka Yu Terence (“Mr Kwan”), in the event that he is found liable to the first plaintiff in respect of the misappropriation claim in relation to one of the SPVs incorporated in the BVI, Eltina Ltd (“Eltina”). I shall refer to Mr Darsan’s claim against Mr Kwan as “the Third-Party Action”.
- [4]
[4] Having considered the submissions of the parties and the evidence before me, I find that Mr Salgaocar and Mr Darsan did enter into the December 2003 Agreement pursuant to which the 2003 Trust arose. I also find that the December 2003 Agreement is not illegal under Indian law and therefore the 2003 Trust may be enforced. I further find that Mr Darsan breached the 2003 Trust and dismiss his counterclaim against the first plaintiff. Finally, I find that the plaintiffs have no claim against Mr Darsan for the sums that are subject of indemnity and contribution sought by Mr Darsan against Mr Kwan in the Third-Party Action. Accordingly, I dismiss the Third-Party Action. I now set out my reasons.
Facts
The parties
- [5]
[5] I begin by introducing the parties to Suit 821.
The plaintiffs
- [6]
[6] The first plaintiff, Mdm Lakshmi Anil Salgaocar (“Mdm Lakshmi”), is the widow of Mr Salgaocar. Suit 821 was commenced by Mr Salgaocar in August 2015. Unfortunately, Mr Salgaocar passed away suddenly intestate on 1 January 2016, which resulted in Mdm Lakshmi taking over the conduct of Suit 821 in her capacity as the sole administratrix of his estate. While he was alive, Mr Salgaocar was a businessman who engaged in a wide range of business interests. Within India, Mr Salgaocar and his family had owned iron ore mines, in Goa since 1955 and in Karnataka since 1972. The iron ore produced by these mines was sold and/or exported principally through Salgaocar Mining Industries Pvt Ltd (“SMI”), a company incorporated in India. Five of the BVI SPVs (see [14] below) bought iron ore exclusively from SMI while the sixth purchased iron ore from one of Mr Salgaocar’s companies in Swaziland.
- [7]
[7] The second plaintiff is Winter Meadow Capital Inc (“Winter Meadow”). Winter Meadow is a company also incorporated in the BVI. Mdm Lakshmi is the sole shareholder in her capacity as sole administratrix of Mr Salgaocar’s estate.
The defendants
- [9]
[9] The second and third defendants are Mr Darsan’s wife, Mdm Jhaveri Jashma Darsan, and daughter, Ms Pooja Darsan Jhaveri, respectively. The plaintiffs discontinued Suit 821 against the second defendant on 4 March 2019 and have not effected service of process on the third defendant.
- [10]
[10] The fourth to fourteenth defendants are SPVs incorporated in Singapore, of which Mr Darsan is a director and, either directly or indirectly, the sole shareholder. The 11 companies are as follows (see Annex 2 and Annex 3 below for the organisational structure of the 11 companies before and after restructuring by Mr Darsan):
The Third-Party to Suit 821 – Mr Kwan
- [11]
[11] As alluded to at [3] above, in the Third-Party Action, Mr Darsan claims an indemnity against or contribution from Mr Kwan in the event that Mr Darsan is found liable to the first plaintiff in respect of the misappropriation claim relating to Eltina. Mr Kwan was hired by Mr Salgaocar to work in relation to the BVI SPVs (defined at [14] below). Specifically, Mr Kwan was involved in the sale of iron ore from India and Swaziland to buyers in China, through the BVI SPVs. Mr Kwan was the plaintiffs’ witness in Suit 821.
Companies that comprise the assets of the 2003 Trust
- [12]
[12] The SPVs incorporated in the BVI and a number of the SPVs incorporated in Singapore are relevant to Suit 821. The plaintiffs claim that they are part of the assets of the 2003 Trust. By the plaintiffs’ account, these companies were set up by Mr Salgaocar and he was the sole beneficial owner of all the shares issued by the SPVs as well as the monies, investments and other assets that were held by the SPVs. However, as noted above, the plaintiffs have clarified that they are not making any claims in Suit 821 against the assets of the SPVs.
- [13]
[13] The SPVs incorporated in the BVI are the six SPVs referred to at [1] above. I shall refer to them collectively as “the BVI SPVs”. The SPVs incorporated in Singapore, 21 in total, include the fourth to fourteenth defendants, and are collectively referred to as “the Singapore SPVs”.
- [14]
[14] The BVI SPVs are as follows:
(a) Ling Tao Trading Ltd (“Ling Tao”) (now struck off);
(b) Sino Ling Tao Resources Ltd (“Sino Ling Tao (BVI)”) (now struck off);
(c) GBA Minmetals Trading Ltd (“GBA Minmetals”) (now struck off);
(d) Cheermark Global Ltd (“Cheermark”) (now struck off);
(e) Joyking Global Ltd (“Joyking”) (now struck off); and
(f) Eltina.
- [15]
[15] Apart from the fourth to fourteenth defendants listed at [10] above, the other Singapore SPVs are:
Background to the dispute
- [16]
[16] I now set out the brief background to the dispute.
- [17]
[17] Mr Darsan was introduced to Mr Salgaocar in the late 1980s. Thereafter, Mr Darsan frequently met Mr Salgaocar and/or his family members socially and for business and became a close friend of Mr Salgaocar and his family. Mr Darsan likened his relationship with Mr Salgaocar to that between a “father and son”. This was not seriously challenged by the plaintiffs.
- [19]
[19] The two-legged contracts proved to be hugely profitable for the BVI SPVs. Between 2005 and 2012, the Singapore SPVs were incorporated, and they acquired vessels, shipping assets and real estate using the trading profits made by the BVI SPVs. However, the plaintiffs claim that from 2011 to 2014, Mr Darsan had without Mr Salgaocar’s knowledge or approval, inter alia, arranged for the BVI SPVs to pay US$270,372,938 to himself or entities controlled by or connected to him. The plaintiffs also claim that Mr Darsan caused the transfer of various apartments in Newton Imperial, a residential project in Singapore, from the developer, Great Newton Properties, to himself and the second defendant, as well as third parties and 22 BVI companies owned by Million Dragon Wealth Ltd (“Million Dragon”). Million Dragon is a BVI company whose sole shareholder and director was the third defendant at the time of transfer of the apartments in question. When Mr Salgaocar found out about the events described above, his relationship with Mr Darsan started to fray and deteriorate.
- [20]
[20] On 14 May 2014, Holman Fenwick Willan Hong Kong (“HFW”), acting on Mr Salgaocar’s instructions, issued a letter of demand to Mr Darsan (“the HFW Letter”) for a return of the trust assets that were alleged to have been misappropriated. What transpired subsequently are events and correspondences in respect of which Mr Darsan has claimed “without prejudice” privilege, a matter which is further discussed below at [131]–[144].
- [21]
[21] Eventually, in or around December 2014, Mr Ajaib Haridass (“Mr Haridass”), a lawyer retained by Mr Salgaocar in relation to the recovery of the trust assets, approached representatives from Deloitte & Touche LLP (“Deloitte”) to undertake an assessment of the assets that could be part of a settlement. In the subsequent months, Mr Haridass corresponded with Deloitte. Meetings involving Mr Haridass, Mr Darsan’s representative Mr Rajiv Bhoj (“Mr Bhoj”), one of Mr Salgaocar’s accountants Mr Nitin Sud (“Mr Sud”), and two directors from Deloitte took place in Mr Haridass’ office. Eventually Deloitte was not engaged.
- [22]
[22] Mr Salgaocar commenced Suit 821 in August 2015 after, according to the plaintiffs, Mr Darsan failed to comply with some of Mr Salgaocar’s demands in relation to the trust assets. Mr Darsan filed the defence on 6 October 2015 before applying by Summons No 6205 of 2015 (“SUM 6205”) on 28 December 2015 to strike out the Statement of Claim (“the SOC”) and for Suit 821 to be dismissed. This was on the basis that if the matters in the SOC were accepted as true, Mr Salgaocar’s export arrangements to China through the BVI SPVs breached Indian law including the Customs Act 1962 (India) (“the Customs Act”) and the Foreign Exchange Management Act 1999 (India) (“the FEMA”), as he was said to have not made a true declaration of the full export value of the iron ore sold in China, amongst others.
- [23]
[23] Subsequently, following Mr Salgaocar’s passing in 2016, there was a lengthy impasse in the proceedings. This was because a dispute arose in the Family Justice Courts between Mdm Lakshmi and Ms Chandana Anil Salgaocar (“Ms Chandana”), Mr Salgaocar and Mdm Lakshmi’s daughter, over the appointment of the administratrix of Mr Salgaocar’s estate. As matters neared resolution, on 15 May 2017, Mdm Lakshmi’s solicitors notified the court, copying Mr Darsan’s solicitors, that a settlement of the issue on appointment was expected with the result that a single administratrix would administer the estate’s affairs including the conduct of Suit 821.Several satellite litigation followed.
- [24]
[24] The next day, on 16 May 2017, Mr Darsan commenced proceedings against Mr Salgaocar’s estate and Million Dragon in the BVI (“BVI 83”). In BVI 83, Mr Darsan alleged that he was the beneficial owner of the sole share in Million Dragon, which had been transferred to Mr Salgaocar in July 2014. The transfer was allegedly made in return for Mr Salgaocar agreeing to transfer to Mr Darsan monies that were paid for the purchase of units in Newton Imperial by Million Dragon. As Mr Salgaocar failed to transfer the monies, Mr Darsan asserted that he was the beneficial owner of the share. About three weeks later, on 7 June 2017, Mdm Lakshmi filed Originating Summons No 627 of 2017 (“OS 627”) in the High Court for an anti-suit injunction to restrain Mr Darsan from proceeding in BVI 83. The application was not granted by the High Court in April 2018 but later allowed by the Court of Appeal in July 2019. Mdm Lakshmi obtained the grant of letters of administration (dated 8 August 2017) of Mr Salgaocar’s estate on 25 September 2017.
- [26]
[26] On 15 November 2017, Mr Darsan applied in Originating Summons No 1293 of 2017 (“OS 1293”) for a declaration that Suit 821 had been automatically discontinued pursuant to O 21 r 2(6) of the Rules of Court (Cap 322, R 5, 2014 Rev Ed) (“Rules of Court”) on the basis that no party to the action had taken a step as reflected in the court records for over a year. This was resisted by Mdm Lakshmi, who applied in Summons 5581 of 2017 in OS 1293 for a declaration that Suit 821 was not deemed discontinued, alternatively that Suit 821 be reinstated. On 22 February 2018, the High Court determined that Suit 821 had not been automatically discontinued. Separately, Mr Darsan was granted leave to withdraw SUM 6205 (the striking out application) on 25 May 2018.
The parties’ cases
The plaintiffs’ case
- [27]
[27] As stated above, the plaintiffs’ claim centres on the December 2003 Agreement, which is the source of the 2003 Trust. The defendants dispute that there was such an agreement. Establishing the December 2003 Agreement is therefore critical for the plaintiffs. The crucial elements of the December 2003 Agreement are as follows:
- [28]
[28] The plaintiffs claim that Mr Darsan had committed the following breaches of the 2003 Trust and/or fiduciary duties owed to Mr Salgaocar:
- [29]
[29] Further, the plaintiffs allege that despite Mr Salgaocar’s repeated demands since August 2012, Mr Darsan failed to (a) transfer ownership of the trust assets, and (b) relinquish control over the same.
- [30]
[30] As result of the Caveat Proceedings, the plaintiffs do not make a claim to assets of the SPVs, including assets acquired and investments from the profits of the iron ore trade. Instead, the plaintiffs’ claim is limited to the shares in the BVI SPVs and Singapore SPVs subject to the 2003 Trust. However, as some of these companies are now defunct, the 2003 Trust presently relates to shares in 10 companies – Eltina, Singapore Star Holdings, Great Newton Properties, Singapore Star Investments, Singapore Star Shipping, Singapore Star Properties, Sino Ling Tao (SG), Millers Capital, Sino Noble and Nova Raffles.
- [31]
[31] As regards illegality, the plaintiffs submit that the use of the BVI SPVs to sell iron ore to buyers in China pursuant to the December 2003 Agreement was not illegal. Even if it was, the plaintiffs contend that (a) neither the principle in Foster v Driscoll [1929] 1 KB 470 (“Foster”) nor the principle in Ralli Bros v Compania Naviera Sota y Aznar [1920] 2 KB 287 (“Ralli Bros”) apply, and (b) enforcement of the December 2003 Agreement and the 2003 Trust would not violate international comity.
- [32]
[32] Finally, as regards the allegations in the Third-Party Action, the plaintiffs assert that Eltina is one of the BVI SPVs and therefore subject to the 2003 Trust. In the SOC, the plaintiffs claim that Mr Darsan had wrongfully arranged for payments of, inter alia, US$6.8m from Eltina’s bank account to his bank accounts or a bank account in the name of Star Gold Ltd (“Star Gold”), a company beneficially owned by Mr Darsan. The sum of US$6.8m forms the basis of the claim in the Third-Party Action. However, this claim was not developed during the trial or in the plaintiffs’ written submissions. Instead, the plaintiffs have not challenged Mr Kwan’s position that the transfers amounting to US$6.8m were authorised by Mr Salgaocar. The plaintiffs’ only submission in relation to the Third-Party Action is that even if there is any basis for Mr Darsan’s claim against Mr Kwan for the US$6.8m, the proper plaintiff ought to be Eltina and not Mr Darsan. As such, the plaintiffs invite the court to infer that the Third-Party Action was brought by Mr Darsan to intimidate Mr Kwan from testifying for the plaintiffs in Suit 821.
The defendants’ case
- [33]
[33] As stated above, Mr Darsan disputes the existence of the December 2003 Agreement, and asserts that there is no evidence of Mr Salgaocar’s intention to create the 2003 Trust. He argues that it was he, not Mr Salgaocar, who had funded the BVI SPVs, and procured and paid for the incorporation of, inter alia, Trustworth Shipping, Regent Shipping, Cheermark and Joyking.
- [35]
[35] Mr Darsan explains the circumstances leading to his involvement in the iron ore trading as follows:
- [37]
[37] Sometime in early 2005, Mr Darsan met Mr Salgaocar in Hong Kong to discuss the logistics of Sino Ling Tao (BVI)’s iron ore trading business. Mr Salgaocar then advised Mr Darsan to set up a charter or fixture agent company to complement its iron ore trading business. Accordingly, Trustworth Shipping was incorporated in Singapore on or about 2 March 2005, as the freight and logistics arm of Sino Ling Tao (BVI)’s iron ore trading business. Mr Darsan held 99% of the issued shares in Trustworth Shipping, with the remaining shares held by a Singapore national as his nominee.
- [38]
[38] In April 2005, Mr Darsan had a “falling out” with Mr Salgaocar over the iron ore trading business. This was after several occasions in March 2005 when Mr Salgaocar allegedly threatened Mr Darsan with raising prices for the iron ore that SMI sold. Mr Salgaocar took the view that Sino Ling Tao (BVI)’s profit margins should be reduced. Mr Darsan “perceived that Mr Salgaocar was over-stepping his role and abusing his position” and feared that the pressures of doing business together was affecting their relationship. He therefore decided to end his iron ore trading relationship with Mr Salgaocar and SMI. Mr Darsan and Mr Salgaocar agreed over a phone call that the latter would buy over the former’s shares in Sino Ling Tao (BVI) for US$32.6m. Mr Darsan asserts that this was the equivalent of the company’s accumulated profits at that time. Pursuant to this agreement, Mr Darsan transferred his shares in Sino Ling Tao (BVI) to Mr Salgaocar on or about 19 April 2005.
- [39]
[39] However, according to Mr Darsan, Mr Salgaocar subsequently said that he could only pay the US$32.6m in instalments rather than in a lump sum. A few weeks after 19 April 2015, Mr Salgaocar proposed, and Mr Darsan agreed, that Mr Darsan would continue to buy iron ore from SMI for sale to Chinese buyers. In or around October 2005, they agreed, inter alia, that Mr Darsan would incorporate a new SPV for iron ore trading and have his own team in Hong Kong to oversee its operations. Mr Salgaocar would provide advice where required and not interfere with Mr Darsan’s iron ore trading business. Thus, on or about 15 November 2005, Mr Darsan procured the incorporation of GBA Minmetals, of which he was sole shareholder and sole director. Between January to May 2006, Mr Salgaocar also paid Mr Darsan the US$32.6m that was due for the shares in Sino Ling Tao (BVI) in four instalments.
- [40]
[40] In or around February 2006, Mr Salgaocar and Mr Darsan entered into an oral agreement to expand Trustworth Shipping’s operations into a fully-fledged shipping venture (“the Shipping Venture”). This would “complement Mr Darsan’s iron ore trading business”. As part of the Shipping Venture:
- [41]
[41] Mr Darsan and Mr Salgaocar agreed that the Running Account would be kept between themselves. At the end of the Shipping Venture, they would take stock of their respective contributions to and withdrawals from the venture, and the profits made and the losses suffered (the losses would be underwritten by Mr Salgaocar under the Shipping Underwriting Agreement). Any sums due to Mr Darsan under the Shipping Underwriting Agreement would be added to the Running Account. While the Running Account was initially intended to apply to the Shipping Venture, it was over time extended to include other expenses that were not strictly connected to it.
- [42]
[42] Further to the Shipping Venture, in April 2006, Mr Salgaocar incorporated Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Sino Noble Holdings (now Singapore Star Holdings). At Mr Salgaocar’s request, in August 2006, Mr Darsan took over Mr Salgaocar’s shares in Sino Ling Tao (BVI) (which had previously been transferred by Mr Darsan to Mr Salgaocar (see [38] above)) as Mr Salgaocar claimed that he needed to divest his shareholdings in various SPVs that he had used for iron ore trading.
- [43]
[43] The Running Account forms the primary basis of Mr Darsan’s counterclaim against the plaintiffs. Mr Darsan argues that the Shipping Venture ended at the latest when Mr Salgaocar passed away. However, Mr Salgaocar and/or his estate have failed to settle or equalize the Running Account.
- [44]
[44] Mr Darsan denies committing the breaches of trust and/or fiduciary duties alleged by the plaintiffs in [28] above. He also denies that Mr Salgaocar had demanded that he transfer the trust assets and that he had refused to do so.
- [45]
[45] In any event, Mr Darsan submits that even if the December 2003 Agreement was entered into, it breached Indian law, including the Customs Act and the FEMA, and therefore with the 2003 Trust was unenforceable.
- [46]
[46] In respect of the Third-Party Action, Mr Darsan claims that Mr Kwan had transferred US$6.8m to Mr Kwan’s own bank account and is therefore liable for the amount as an unlawful recipient. Thus, to the extent that the first plaintiff is able to establish liability against Mr Darsan in respect of Eltina, he seeks an indemnity or contribution from Mr Kwan as regards the US$6.8m.
Issues to be determined
- [47]
[47] In view of the parties’ respective cases above, the following issues arise for determination:
Issue 1: The existence of the December 2003 Agreement and the 2003 Trust
- [48]
[48] The first issue that arises for consideration is whether Mr Salgaocar and Mr Darsan entered into the December 2003 Agreement, consequently giving rise to the 2003 Trust. In summary, I find that the December 2003 Agreement must have existed for the following three reasons:
Mr Salgaocar’s management of the BVI and Singapore SPVs
General observations
- [49]
[49] I begin by considering the management and operations of the BVI SPVs and Singapore SPVs. I make some general observations. The evidence quite clearly points to Mr Salgaocar’s close level of involvement with and oversight over these SPVs. Such control is consistent with the plaintiffs’ case that Mr Salgaocar owned and operated these SPVs. I conclude accordingly.
- [50]
[50] Documentary evidence and the evidence of (a) Mr Kwan, (b) Mr Cheong Hock Wee (“Mr Cheong”), the general manager of Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping from 2007 to 2010, and (c) Ms Tan Ai Kheng (“Ms Tan”), a real estate agent, support the plaintiffs’ position that all significant decisions concerning the trading of iron ore by the BVI SPVs were by Mr Salgaocar or at least were made with his approval. Moreover, all significant decisions on how the profits from the iron ore trading activities of the BVI SPVs should be invested by the Singapore SPVs were made by Mr Salgaocar.
- [51]
[51] In relation to the BVI SPVs, all significant decisions involving trading matters were made by Mr Salgaocar or required his approval. This included (a) the terms of sale of the iron ore to the Chinese market, (b) identification of the Chinese purchasers to whom the iron ore would be sold on a CFR basis, (c) the vessels nominated for each shipment of iron ore, and (d) the freight and charter hire rates for the vessels used to carry the iron ore. In contrast, notwithstanding his assertion that the BVI SPVs were his, Mr Darsan had little or no involvement in any of these matters. In fact, he was not substantially involved in the day-to-day trading operations, with his role limited to signing the relevant documents as required by Mr Salgaocar, either pursuant to instructions from Mr Salgaocar directly or conveyed through Mr Kwan and Ms Yuk Fang Chiang Mirrica (“Ms Chiang”), another employee of Mr Salgaocar.
- [52]
[52] The same may be said of the Singapore SPVs. Further, it is pertinent that Mr Darsan was appointed director and bank signatory for 17 of the 21 Singapore SPVs on and from 8 October 2011 on Mr Salgaocar’s instructions only after one of Mr Salgaocar’s nominees passed away in or around May 2011. Before this, Mr Darsan was only a director in Trustworth Shipping and majority shareholder and director in Singapore Star Holdings. In other words, until October 2011, Mr Darsan had no involvement in most of the 17 Singapore SPVs, and only then because Mr Salgaocar brought him into the picture. In fact, Mr Salgaocar continued to exercise sole control over the significant aspects of the operations, asset purchases and investment activities of the Singapore SPVs even after Mr Darsan’s appointment as director and bank signatory.
The BVI SPVs
- [53]
[53] I turn now to my findings on Mr Salgaocar’s management of the BVI SPVs. Mr Kwan’s evidence was key in understanding Mr Salgaocar’s role in the management of the BVI SPVs and I found his evidence to be generally credible.
- [54]
[54] Mr Kwan testified that Mr Salgaocar wanted to hire him and Mr Darsan made the approach on Mr Salgaocar’s behalf. Mr Kwan started working for Mr Salgaocar in June 2011. Mr Kwan was initially employed by a company called Horizon Villa Limited. He was later employed by Great Hero Services Limited (“Great Hero”), which was incorporated by Mr Darsan in Hong Kong on 31 August 2005. According to Mr Kwan, Mr Salgaocar informed him that Great Hero was incorporated by Mr Darsan on his instructions. Mr Salgaocar explained that Great Hero would employ staff who would help him manage the sale of iron ore to buyers in China.
- [55]
[55] According to Mr Kwan, the iron ore sales took place as described at [18] above namely, that one of the BVI SPVs would enter into a contract with a company in India to purchase iron ore on a FOB basis save for Eltina, which bought iron ore from one of Mr Salgaocar’s companies in Swaziland on a CFR basis (see [18] above). The relevant BVI SPV would then arrange a vessel through Trustworth Shipping or Regent Shipping (collectively, “the Chartering Companies”) to load the iron ore from a port in India or Mozambique for shipment to a port in China. While the vessel was on its way to China, the BVI SPV would enter into a contract with a buyer in China for the sale of that shipment on a CFR basis. He testified that this arrangement was in place from the time he started working with Mr Salgaocar until he stopped in or around March 2014.
- [56]
[56] There are three key points from Mr Kwan’s testimony.
- [57]
[57] First, Mr Kwan treated Mr Salgaocar as the owner-operator of the BVI SPVs. Mr Kwan took instructions directly from Mr Salgaocar, not Mr Darsan, and “had to seek [Mr Salgaocar’s] approval on all matters” in relation to the sale of iron ore. Mr Darsan was content to allow this and did not raise any objections. Mr Kwan also stated that in many of their conversations, Mr Salgaocar had informed him that the BVI SPVs and the Chartering Companies belonged to Mr Salgaocar. Mr Kwan stated that while documents for remitting funds would have to go through Mr Darsan as he was appointed the bank signatory for these companies, Mr Darsan “never gave [Mr Kwan] any instructions in relation to and was not involved in the trade of iron ore”. In this regard, Mr Darsan conceded during cross-examination that the instructions to Mr Kwan to prepare the documents to effect the transfers came from Mr Salgaocar.
- [58]
[58] Second, Mr Salgaocar controlled both legs of the two-legged contracts. As to the first leg, Mr Kwan testified that as the appointed representative of the BVI SPVs and the Chartering Companies, he would sign the contracts between the BVI SPVs and the vendors of iron ore in India and Swaziland, who were SMI and other companies owned by Mr Salgaocar. However, he was not involved in settling the terms of these contracts. Mr Salgaocar would give instructions to Mr Kwan through Ms Lorena D’Cunha (“Ms D’Cunha”) to have these contracts signed. Ms D'Cunha was Mr Salgaocar’s secretary in India. As to the second leg, Mr Kwan was clear that Mr Darsan never instructed him on the execution of the CFR contracts between the BVI SPVs and the buyers in China. He testified that it was Mr Salgaocar who gave him the relevant instructions. Mr Kwan added that Mr Salgaocar “knew and personally dealt with” many of the buyers in China until 2014 and regularly held meetings with them at his office in Goa. These contracts were initially negotiated by Mr Salgaocar, who would instruct Mr Kwan to relay the key terms of the proposed CFR contracts to those buyers, including the amount, the quality and the selling price of the iron ore. Mr Kwan deposed that Mr Salgaocar provided the contacts of these buyers when he first started work as he did not have the knowledge or experience to trade in iron ore. However, as Mr Kwan gained experience, Mr Salgaocar eventually allowed him to conduct negotiations on the key terms of the CFR contracts with the Chinese buyers, although he had to seek Mr Salgaocar’s approval before agreeing to any of the terms. As an example of Mr Salgaocar’s instructions to him, Mr Kwan produced an email from Mr Salgaocar directing him to negotiate with “each of our regular Buyers contract for sale of 3/4 capesize shipments or quantity 400/500,000 tons depending on the size of the cape vessel”. Mr Darsan was not at all involved in any of these matters.
- [60]
[60] While Mr Kwan copied Mr Darsan on the emails attaching the daily reports, Mr Kwan clarified that he had done so at Mr Darsan’s request and because he did not see any reason to refuse. Nonetheless, when asked about these daily reports during cross-examination, Mr Darsan conceded that on his case, Mr Salgaocar would have had “no business” in receiving such details as the account balance of the BVI SPVs. It is telling that Mr Darsan was unable to produce “old emails” showing any instructions from him to Mr Kwan that he be given daily reports in the same manner as given to Mr Salgaocar. In fact, Mr Darsan only received the daily reports on copy when they were sent to Mr Salgaocar. That the emails were sent to Mr Salgaocar as the primary recipient strongly suggests that the daily reports were meant for his consumption, and not Mr Darsan’s.
- [61]
[61] There is a further point to be made. It is significant that the FOB contracts entered into by the BVI SPVs were only with SMI and other companies owned by Mr Salgaocar (as mentioned at [58] above). In other words, the BVI SPVs were totally reliant on Mr Salgaocar’s companies for their iron ore. Mr Darsan would have had no reason to restrict himself to only purchasing from Mr Salgaocar’s companies if he had truly been running his own iron ore trading business.
- [62]
[62] For these reasons, I am of the view that Mr Salgaocar’s management of the BVI SPVs shows that he treated these entities as his own. This state of affairs is in keeping with the terms of the December 2003 Agreement and supports the conclusion that it was entered into.
The Singapore SPVs
(1) Trustworth Shipping
- [64]
[64] During cross-examination, Mr Darsan conceded that Trustworth Shipping was under the management of Mr Salgaocar. Mr Darsan tried to explain that Mr Salgaocar’s management of Trustworth Shipping was pursuant to an agreement between them (discussed below at [104]). As deposed by Mr Darsan in his affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) dated 12 March 2020, Mr Salgaocar had promised to “help [him] with the logistical management of [Mr Darsan’s] chartering agency” and “took charge of managing [its] operations” in accordance with what they discussed. This evidence, however, is inconsistent with an affidavit filed by Mr Darsan in OS 727 on 14 October 2015 (“OS 727 Affidavit”), in which he stated that he “always had majority ownership of Trustworth Shipping and it was under [his] management” up till 2014 when parties agreed that Mr Darsan would transfer certain assets to Mr Salgaocar. When asked about this discrepancy, Mr Darsan stated that he had previously so claimed as “[Mr Kwan] was involved in this and [Mr Kwan] was my man”. Apart from this explanation not being cogent as it is not evident how Mr Kwan being his man was consistent with Trustworth Shipping being managed by Mr Salgaocar (as opposed to by Mr Darsan), it flies in the face of Mr Kwan’s evidence as set out at [63] above. I therefore do not accept Mr Darsan’s explanation as credible. The evidence suggests that it was Mr Salgaocar who owned and managed Trustworth Shipping.
(2) Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping
- [65]
[65] I find that Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping were also managed by Mr Salgaocar. In this regard, Mr Cheong’s evidence, which is important, was not seriously challenged or contradicted by Mr Darsan. I make several observations.
- [66]
[66] First, Mr Cheong’s evidence was that he regarded Mr Salgaocar as the owner and operator of Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping. Mr Cheong deposed that after getting to know him while Mr Cheong was the general manager of another shipbuilding company, Mr Salgaocar hired him. He stated that at a meeting with Mr Salgaocar, Mr Salgaocar explained that he owned iron ore mines in India which he sold and shipped to buyers in China, and that he wanted someone with sufficient experience to maintain and expand the shipment and transhipment fleet that was used, as well as expand the operations to include the shipping of coal from Indonesia to India. According to Mr Cheong, Mr Salgaocar “did not mention…Mr Darsan…or suggest that he (Mr Salgaocar) was at that meeting as anyone’s representative or on someone else’s behalf”; rather “it was clear” from the manner and substance of what Mr Salgaocar had said that he “was talking about his own businesses”. Mr Cheong’s testimony is that he agreed to be hired on the condition that he would only take instructions from Mr Salgaocar. Though Mr Cheong was employed by Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping, Mr Salgaocar informed him that they were wholly owned subsidiaries of Sino Noble Holdings, which was incorporated by Mr Salgaocar. Mr Cheong deposed that he and the staff of both companies referred to Mr Salgaocar as “MD”, short for “Managing Director”.
- [67]
[67] It is clear from Mr Cheong’s account that Mr Salgaocar was intimately involved in running the two companies and was regarded as their owner. Mr Cheong and the staff “took [their] instructions directly” from Mr Salgaocar and “sought [his] approval” on any decisions by the companies, including all payments for their purchases and day-to-day operations. Similar to Mr Kwan in the case of the BVI SPVs, the staff of Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping were also expected to send Mr Salgaocar detailed daily reports. These reports consisted of a Word document that set out (a) matters affecting the companies and any matters requiring Mr Salgaocar’s approval, and (b) scanned copies of a ledger recording the bank balances of the Singapore-incorporated companies which the staff would refer to collectively as “the Singapore office”.
- [68]
[68] Second, Mr Salgaocar exercised direct control over the operations of Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping. Contemporaneous documentary evidence shows that Mr Salgaocar had signed shipbuilding and related contracts in his capacity as the President of Singapore Star Holdings (which fully owned Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping). Mr Salgaocar also monitored the prices of vessels and was intimately involved in acquiring them. For example, Mr Salgaocar sent Mr Cheong an email on 25 March 2009 enclosing a newspaper article on a potential decrease in iron ore prices which Mr Salgaocar told Mr Cheong would “bring shipping freight down” and which accordingly afforded an “opportunity to wait for [a] bottom price purchase” of new vessels.
- [70]
[70] On the other hand, it is significant that Mr Darsan has adduced no evidence of being involved in the operations of Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping. Mr Darsan’s explanation that Mr Salgaocar was to manage the Shipping Venture (at [40] above) is not credible. There was no reason for Mr Salgaocar to closely manage these companies unless he regarded them as his own.
- [71]
[71] The findings above on the ownership of Trustworth Shipping, Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping point to the conclusion that the Shipping Venture and consequently the Shipping Underwriting Agreement and the Running Account did not exist. I expand on this point below at [116]–[122].
(3) The Singapore Properties
- [72]
[72] Finally, it is clear that Mr Salgaocar was also closely involved in acquiring and managing numerous properties in Singapore that were registered in the names of various Singapore SPVs (“the Singapore Properties”). The Singapore Properties consists of units in (a) Residences@Evelyn; (b) Waterford Residence; (c) WCEGA Tower; (d) Newton Imperial and (e) The Sail @ Marina Bay. I make two points.
- [73]
[73] First, Ms Tan’s testimony is that it was Mr Salgaocar who made the decisions on the purchase of the Singapore Properties. Ms Tan’s testimony is critical, as she, is the real estate agent who assisted Mr Salgaocar in acquiring these properties and thereafter helped to manage them for him. I consider Mr Salgaocar’s purchase of the Singapore Properties in seriatim.
- [74]
[74] In relation to the units purchased at Residences@Evelyn, Ms Tan deposed that she met Mr Salgaocar at the show flat at Evelyn Road on or about 18 January 2007. According to her, Mr Salgaocar decided to purchase four units in the development that day. Subsequently, Mr Salgaocar directed Ms Tan to speak with his accountant, Mr Ramanujam (“Mr Ramanujam”), to prepare the booking forms for those units. The four units were registered in the names of Millers Capital, Cargills Investments, Sino Noble and Albana Investments respectively.
- [75]
[75] In relation to the units at the Waterford Residence, Ms Tan’s testimony is that Mr Salgaocar decided to purchase 24 units in the development sometime in January 2007, after he had reviewed brochures which she had handed to him. Ms Tan was again told to speak with Mr Ramanujam to prepare the booking forms. Newton Noble then purchased 17 units and Capital Glory purchased seven units in the development.
- [76]
[76] WCEGA Tower was a commercial development. Mr Cheong deposed that he had suggested to Mr Salgaocar to purchase an office unit there, as Sino Ling Tao (SG) and Singapore Star Shipping’s office premises were too small. Mr Salgaocar thus requested Mr Cheong to contact Ms Tan to discuss the purchase of a number of units in WCEGA Tower. Ms Tan confirmed that she met Mr Salgaocar in or around June 2008 for that purpose. During their meeting, Mr Salgaocar explained that the purchase was to expand the available office space for his employees. After a short discussion, Mr Salgaocar decided to purchase 60 office units in the development. These units were purchased by Sino Noble for S$24m following negotiations between Ms Tan (which were conducted on Mr Salgaocar’s behalf) and the developer of WCEGA Tower.
- [78]
[78] Ms Tan deposed that she attended at least three to four of the many meetings and site visits between Mr Salgaocar and the architects and contractors for the project. These meetings were organised by Mr Salgaocar. Mr Salgaocar would comment on aspects of individual apartments that were under construction, such as the marble for the apartment floor and the size of the four-bedroom units, which he regarded as too cramped (proposing instead that they be converted into three-bedroom en suite units). Mr Salgaocar’s detailed observations suggest his intimate involvement in the project. Finally, when Newton Imperial obtained its Temporary Occupation Permit in or around 2011, it was Mr Salgaocar who asked Ms Tan to market the development, save for six units which he wished to keep for his family. These are the same units which Mr Darsan allegedly misappropriated to himself and the second defendant (see [28(c)(i)] above).
- [79]
[79] In relation to The Sail @ Marina Bay, Ms Tan deposed that in 2007, Mr Salgaocar informed her that he owned seven units on the 36th floor. Mr Salgaocar instructed Ms Tan to take over the keys, and handed her a letter from the developer which stated that the units were held by Sino Diamond Investments Pte Ltd, Mi Amorey Investments and Agapimo Investments. These were companies owned by Mr Salgaocar. Mr Salgaocar gave Ms Tan $50,000 in cash to refurbish the units and instructed her to lease and sell those units (as the case may be), which she did.
- [80]
[80] Ms Tan’s interactions with Mr Salgaocar in relation to the purchase and management of the Singapore Properties is consistent with the plaintiffs’ case that Mr Salgaocar treated the properties as his own.
- [81]
[81] Ms Tan’s evidence as set out above was not challenged during cross-examination by Mr Darsan. In fact, Mr Darsan accepted that Ms Tan had no reason to lie and conceded during cross-examination that the manner in which Mr Salgaocar behaved in relation to properties such as the Newton Imperial development was consistent with ownership.
- [83]
[83] For these reasons, I find that Mr Salgaocar’s control and management of the Singapore SPVs is consistent with the plaintiffs’ position that he was the owner-operator of Trustworth Shipping, Sino Ling Tao (SG), Singapore Star Shipping and the Singapore Properties (and the SPVs in whose names the Singapore Properties were registered). This state of affairs is in keeping with the terms of the December 2003 Agreement and points to its existence.
The implausibility of the defence and counterclaim
- [84]
[84] I turn now to consider Mr Darsan’s defence and counterclaim in relation to the BVI SPVs and the Singapore SPVs. In summary, I find his defence and counterclaim implausible. The analysis and conclusion above that the BVI SPVs and the Singapore SPVs were Mr Salgaocar’s speak in turn to the unsustainability of the defence and counterclaim. If the BVI SPVs and Singapore SPVs were Mr Salgaocar’s, they could not have belonged to Mr Darsan. This points to the existence of the December 2003 Agreement and 2003 Trust, and the non-existence of the Shipping Venture, the Shipping Underwriting Agreement and the Running Account. The analysis which follows must be seen through this lens.
- [85]
[85] Mr Darsan claims that with the exception of Ling Tao (which Mr Salgaocar had already been using at the time that Mr Darsan allegedly became involved in the iron ore trading business, in late 2004), the rest of the BVI SPVs belonged to him. However, there are multiple difficulties with Mr Darsan’s evidence as to how he became involved with the BVI SPVs. I do not find his evidence credible. I make several points.
- [86]
[86] First, Mr Darsan’s qualification as regards Ling Tao itself raises questions. I note that the position that Ling Tao was in fact established by Mr Salgaocar was only taken by Mr Darsan in the first round of amendments that he had made to the defence on 30 October 2015. In contrast, in the first iteration of his defence, Mr Darsan had taken the position that all the SPVs which Mr Salgaocar asserted that he had set up in the SOC (ie, those listed at [10] and [14]–[15] above, including Ling Tao, were established by Mr Darsan). Similarly, in Mr Darsan’s OS 727 Affidavit filed on 14 October 2015, he had taken the position that all the SPVs that had been mentioned by Salgaocar, including Ling Tao, were “in fact established by [himself]” and “funded by monies which [he] had raised”. When queried about the inconsistency on the ownership of Ling Tao, Mr Darsan responded that it was an “oversight” for him to have included Ling Tao as he “did not go through minutely the details of the companies” and was “referring to all my trading companies”. This is not a convincing explanation and does raise doubts on how he came to be involved in the iron ore trading business. However, I do not rest my conclusion on this alone and I go further.
- [87]
[87] Second, Mr Darsan’s version of events is not credible. As mentioned in [35(d)]–[35(f)] above, Mr Darsan deposed that Mr Salgaocar had approached him in late 2004, asking Mr Darsan to buy iron ore from him to sell to the Chinese market, as he was facing payment issues with Chinese buyers. According to Mr Darsan, it would be a “win-win” as SMI would sell iron ore to him or his designated business entity at prices higher than what he would have received from the Japanese buyers, though Mr Darsan would “effectively be assuming the risk of non-payment or delayed payment by the Chinese buyers”. Mr Darsan deposed that Mr Salgaocar had confidence this would work given Mr Darsan’s familiarity with Chinese buyers, albeit in a different industry. That Mr Darsan had business contacts in China and was located in Hong Kong would enable him to oversee the enforcement of payments more effectively. Sino Ling Tao (BVI) was thus set up in or around November 2004. At that time, Mr Salgaocar had been selling to the Chinese market through three companies – Ling Tao, GBA Products and Sino Source.
- [89]
[89] On his first explanation, I observe the contracts with Sino Source do not appear to be long-term contracts, nor does Mr Darsan have evidence of such long-term commitments on Mr Salgaocar’s part. That aside, Sino Source was Mr Salgaocar’s company and it would have been easy for Mr Salgaocar to unwind any long-term commitments if they did exist.
- [90]
[90] The second explanation holds even less water. SMI did not bear payment or credit risk of the Chinese buyers. Under SMI’s contracts with Sino Source, SMI would obtain payment against certain documents provided “through negotiating and opening Bank after reimbursement of sale proceeds”.
- [91]
[91] The contracts between SMI and the intermediaries (Ling Tao, Sino Source and GBA Metals) provided that full payment would be made to SMI for the FOB value of the shipment after receipt by the intermediaries of the invoice and other supporting documents. In turn, the contracts between Ling Tao, Sino Source and GBA Products and the Chinese buyers provided for payments under letters of credit arrangements upon the relevant documents being presented. It therefore appeared to be the case that the payments were structured such that SMI would receive them upon the relevant documents being presented to the issuing or negotiating bank. There was no credit risk to speak of.
- [92]
[92] When this was pointed out to Mr Darsan during cross-examination, he claimed that the risk was of Sino Source or GBA Products defaulting on its payment obligation to SMI, if the Chinese buyers were unable to pay the former. This was of course contrary to the point above that there was no credit risk given the letter of credit arrangement. Mr Darsan also claimed that there were issues concerning payment from Sino Source without producing any evidence to back this up. However, this is a non-starter as if Sino Source did not have a credit risk because of the letter of credit arrangement, then SMI would not have any difficulties in collecting money from Chinese buyers. In truth, Mr Darsan was not able to offer any credible explanation.
- [93]
[93] Third, the fact that in the defence, Mr Darsan had referred to Ling Tao, GBA Products and Sino Source as “SPVs” that “[Mr] Salgaocar was selling iron ore to China through” suggests that they were in fact Mr Salgaocar’s all along. When asked about this inconsistency, Mr Darsan responded that this was another “oversight” and he did not know why he had so referred to them. Mr Darsan further explained that only Ling Tao should have been referred as an SPV, on the understanding that an SPV was a company owned by Mr Salgaocar that was incorporated to perform particular acts. Mr Darsan’s explanation is difficult to accept as these are specific acknowledgements by Mr Darsan of Mr Salgaocar’s ownership.
- [94]
[94] Fourth, Mr Darsan’s claim that Mr Salgaocar assured him that (a) there would be the “necessary advisory and logistical support”, (b) he could “pull out after a short trial period” of about six months if he felt that things were not working out, and (c) he would be indemnified for any losses sustained during the trial period, is remarkable. In other words, this was a risk-free venture for Mr Darsan completely supported by and underwritten by Mr Salgaocar. Mr Darsan stated that the indemnity was relevant to his decision to join the iron ore trading business. However, it is unclear why Mr Salgaocar would even offer to underwrite Mr Darsan’s losses. The very purpose of the arrangement, according to Mr Darsan, was for Mr Salgaocar to avoid assuming the credit risks that he was allegedly facing by leveraging Mr Darsan’s relationships in the Chinese market. There is a further point. Any loss that Mr Darsan would incur would be as a result of the BVI SPVs having to pay for the iron ore purchased. But the vendors of the iron ore were companies owned by Mr Salgaocar. There would be no need for an indemnity from Mr Salgaocar. It is absurd to believe that in effect, Mr Salgaocar was indemnifying Mr Darsan for a liability that was owed to one of his companies. Indeed, the importance of the indemnity to Mr Darsan is not apparent given the “father-son” relationship that Mr Darsan claims he had with Mr Salgaocar.
- [95]
[95] Fifth, Mr Darsan has not offered a compelling reason why Mr Salgaocar would require his involvement in the iron ore trading business. As testified by Mr Kwan (see [58] above), the contacts of all the Chinese buyers were Mr Salgaocar’s. It was Mr Salgaocar who negotiated the CFR contracts with these buyers. There is also no evidence that prior to 2004, Mr Darsan had any iron ore trading experience let alone in relation to the Chinese markets. Mr Darsan accepts this. At the material time, Mr Darsan’s business was solely in gemstones and polymers, which is evidently not related to iron ore trading and certainly did not extend to the Chinese market (at least there is no evidence that it did). In other words, Mr Darsan did not have any relevant relationships in the iron ore business generally, let alone in the Chinese market. During cross-examination, Mr Darsan conceded that he did not know the identity of a single Chinese buyer at that time and only knew, “not in minute details”, what the general reasons were for the Chinese buyers to delay or withhold payments. If so, it is inconceivable how he would have been able to assist Mr Salgaocar with payment issues concerning the Chinese buyers. It is pertinent that Mr Darsan did not call for a list of outstanding account receivables from Chinese buyers prior to accepting Mr Salgaocar’s offer. In other words, by his account, Mr Darsan went into the venture blind. He was prepared to enter the iron ore business without specifically knowing which buyers were the issue and what their reasons were for defaulting. Mr Darsan would have the court believe that he accepted Mr Salgaocar’s offer with complete opacity as to the situation he would be facing. The contrived nature of the explanation for his involvement was apparent during cross-examination:
- [96]
[96] Further, Mr Darsan could not explain why, if it was indeed the case that Mr Salgaocar was facing payment problems from Chinese buyers, he would use a very similar name for his own company namely, Sino Ling Tao (BVI). Mr Salgaocar also sold through Ling Tao. During cross-examination, he stated that he had forgotten the meaning of “Sino Ling Tao”, but recalled that “it was a good auspicious name, Chinese trade, something”. On the other hand, Mr Cheong deposed that he was told by Mr Salgaocar that he (Mr Salgaocar) had chosen the name “Sino Ling Tao” in relation to the twelfth defendant, Sino Ling Tao (SG), as it combined the words “Sino”, another name for “Chinese”, and “Ling Tao” which is Mandarin for “leader”. Similarly, Mr Darsan could not explain why he would have later chosen the name “GBA Minmetals” if that had already been used by GBA Products, an unrelated company according to him, save to say that it “was a good word for the Greater Bay area”.
- [97]
[97] This suggests that it was Mr Salgaocar who incorporated Sino Ling Tao (BVI) and GBA Minmetals. This is reinforced by a point concerning the appointment of staff that Mr Darsan purportedly started Sino Ling Tao (BVI) with. Mr Darsan testified that Ms Chiang had assisted in the running of Sino Ling Tao (BVI) from its incorporation in or around November 2004, as “[s]he was looking into the affairs of Mr Salgaocar’s Ling Tao Trading”. Yet, he had deposed that he employed her, Mr Kwan and a clerical assistant Ms Esther Tam (“Ms Tam”) in October 2005, as part of his “own team in Hong Kong to oversee and manage the operations of [his] iron ore trading business”. Mr Darsan was unable to explain away the inconsistency. His inability to keep a consistent narrative suggests that it was Mr Salgaocar, not Mr Darsan, who had set up the companies and hired Mr Kwan and Ms Chiang. That was in fact Mr Kwan’s evidence.
- [98]
[98] Sixth, on a related note, Mr Darsan’s account of how he eventually managed to make the iron ore business work where Mr Salgaocar had failed is unconvincing. He claimed that once he got involved in the business and understood the type of buyers available, he had a “very defined strategy” to only sell to owners of steel mills, as opposed to traders in China or Hong Kong. This was because they would be interested in consistent and regular supply and would have lower chances of default or disputes. He stated that “maybe one or two” had been part of the group of buyers Mr Salgaocar had originally been selling to, but could not remember whom. According to Mr Darsan, he had come up with this strategy all on his own.
- [99]
[99] Mr Darsan’s account is difficult to accept. As a person with vast experience and relationships, including the iron ore trade in the Chinese market, it is inconceivable that Mr Salgaocar could not have known that these steel mill owners were potential buyers. It is equally inconceivable that Mr Salgaocar, with his experience and contacts, would not have been able to formulate the same strategy devised by a novice (Mr Darsan) in the business, if that indeed offered the solution. In fact, Mr Darsan had deposed that Mr Salgaocar had shared with him in December 2003 or January 2004 that “Chinese steel mills were looking to purchase iron ore from India, and the demand from Chinese steel mills for iron ore was growing”. It therefore could not have been a strategy that Mr Darsan formulated. Further, even if Mr Darsan had indeed identified this strategy, it is simply not believable that Mr Salgaocar would have been content to allow Mr Darsan to continue making such profit for himself from this group of buyers. After all, the iron ore was from mines owned by his companies and the contacts in the Chinese markets were his. If the solution to Mr Salgaocar’s payment issues was simply a matter of strategy, there would be no need for Mr Salgaocar to trade through Mr Darsan – Mr Salgaocar could have easily circumvented Mr Darsan and earned the profits himself. After all, the profits were significant. According to Mr Darsan, accumulated profits of Sino Ling Tao (BVI) over a period of about five months alone was US$32.6m (see [38] above).
- [100]
[100] Seventh, Mr Darsan’s account of the “falling out” leading to the incorporation of GBA Minmetals was also difficult to believe. As noted at [38] above, Mr Darsan claimed that Mr Salgaocar had in or around March 2005 started to ask to share in some of the profits made by Sino Ling Tao (BVI), and threatened to raise prices for the iron ore sold by SMI. This is odd considering that as conceded by Mr Darsan, Mr Salgaocar had all the relationships with the Chinese buyers and knew how to run the business. Had Mr Salgaocar been truly dissatisfied about the profits purportedly being made by Mr Darsan, he would simply have conducted the business on his own, bypassing Mr Darsan, as noted at [99] above. At the same time, it is not clear why it would truly have been a threat to Mr Darsan for SMI to increase its prices for the iron ore sold to Sino Ling Tao (BVI). If so, it would surely have been open to Mr Darsan to decide not to purchase from Mr Salgaocar, especially in light of strong demand for iron ore from China. Apart from having been in the business of iron ore trading for five months, Mr Darsan had also, on his own account, set up a chartering company (as discussed at [104]) below. He therefore could have walked away and dealt with another supplier of iron ore. Mr Salgaocar would surely have known this (if this was the case). This suggests that there were in fact no such threats by Mr Salgaocar.
- [101]
[101] In the same vein, Mr Darsan’s explanation for the sum of US$32.6m that Mr Salgaocar came to owe him for the alleged purchase of shares in Sino Ling Tao (BVI) is also contrived. This sum is alleged in the SOC as transferred on Mr Salgaocar’s directions from Sino Ling Tao (BVI) to GBA Minmetals as initial working capital for GBA Minmetals. The transfers were in four instalments between 16 January 2006 and 3 May 2006. On the other hand, Mr Darsan asserts that this sum was payment for shares in Sino Ling Tao (BVI) purchased by Mr Salgaocar from Mr Darsan. This requires explanation as the transfers were made from Sino Ling Tao (BVI) to GBA Minmetals and not from Mr Salgaocar to Mr Darsan (as purchaser and vendor). Mr Darsan’s explanation is not credible. In his AEIC dated 12 March 2020, Mr Darsan asserts that as part of their agreement for the purchase of the shares, Mr Salgaocar asked Mr Darsan to make his son, Mr Arjun Salgaocar (“Mr Arjun”), and his son-in-law, Mr Gautam Radia (“Mr Gautam”), shareholders of Sino Ling Tao (BVI), with the result that the shareholders would be Mr Salgaocar, Mr Arjun and Mr Gautam. It is not apparent why this would be necessary as Mr Salgaocar could have himself transferred shares to Mr Arjun and Mr Gautam following his purchase of shares from Mr Darsan. Mr Salgaocar would have complete control of Sino Ling Tao (BVI) as Mr Darsan would also step down from his post as a director. In attempting to explain during cross-examination, Mr Darsan took an illogical position. He claimed that since Mr Arjun and Mr Gautam would become shareholders of Sino Ling Tao (BVI), they would also be liable to him for the sum of US$32.6m:
The absence of logic in the explanation is only explicable if one accepts, which I do, that Mr Darsan was being untruthful.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.