General Division of the High Court · Decided 3 March 2023
Mah Kiat Seng v Attorney-General and others
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 52 · Case no. Suit No 256 of 2020 · 7 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Incidence of costs
(a) success for Mah on two claims, namely against Rosli for unlawful apprehension and against the SPF in respect of the search conducted on him and his bag; and
(b) success for Tan on the claim of assault and for the SPF on the balance claims.
- [3]
[3] Mah contends that I should consider the “thesis” of his case, which he submits was wrongful arrest, and as he succeeded on that he should be considered the successful party even though he failed on other claims.
Quantum of costs
Costs payable to Mah
- [10]
[10] This brings me to the question of how to assess the amount that would reasonably compensate Mah for the time expended by him. In my view, there are two parts to this. The first is to determine the time expended by him and the second is to fix an amount (for example an hourly rate) that compensates him for that time.
- [11]
[11] In the oral hearing, Mah suggested that he had expended about 1,000 hours in total on these proceedings. There were six days of trial, and he had to prepare for cross-examination as well as for his own evidence. He had to file closing submissions after the trial. He had to view video recordings. He referred to the amount of legal research he had done, and the results of that effort were certainly visible in the proceedings.
- [12]
[12] The AG did not offer any estimate of the time that Mah might have expended. They argued that he had failed to substantiate the number suggested by him.
- [14]
[14] However, from this total of 460 hours it must be determined how much is referable to the claims on which Mah succeeded. Taking a broad brush approach, I am satisfied that the issue of unlawful apprehension was by far the one involving most work, especially in terms of legal research but also in terms of factual analysis. Accordingly, I would take a proportion of 70%, resulting in a net figure of 322 hours.
Costs payable by Mah
- [22]
[22] In my view, it is more helpful to look at the complexity of the case as a whole and then consider the proportion of the case taken up by the claims on which Tan and the SPF succeeded.
- [25]
[25] Mah is to have 70% of his reasonable disbursements incurred while the AG is to have 30%. If these disbursements cannot be agreed within 14 days hereof, then any disputed items can be resolved by the Registrar.
Conclusion