General Division of the High Court · Decided 6 November 2025
The lawyers' fee estimate was not a promise, but the hours billed were not explained
Selvam LLC v AMLA Pte Ltd and another appeal
Feedback & support[2025] SGHC 220 · Case no. Registrar’s Appeal from the State Courts No 8 of 2025 · 26 paragraphs
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
The lawyers' fee estimate was not a promise, but the hours billed were not explained
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [33], [65]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [2]
[2] The appellant in HC/RAS 8/2025 (“RAS 8”) and the respondent in HC/RAS 9/2025 (“RAS 9”) is Selvam LLC (“Selvam”). Its ex-client, the respondent in RAS 8 and the appellant in RAS 9, is AMLA Pte Ltd (“AMLA”).
Facts
Background to the dispute
- [3]
[3] AMLA accused one Ms Vu Thi Mui (“Ms Vu”) of, essentially, conducting a social media smear campaign targeting its business. Consequently, AMLA sued Ms Vu for defamation and malicious falsehood in DC/OC 116/2022 (“OC 116”). Ms Vu, in turn, counterclaimed for defamation.
- [4]
[4] AMLA hired Selvam to act for it in OC 116, as well as a number of related matters:
Procedural history
Decision below
- [8]
[8] The DJ’s full grounds of decision are set out in Selvam LLC v AMLA Pte Ltd [2025] SGDC 124 (“GD”).
The parties’ cases
- [14]
[14] AMLA also alleges that the DJ made the following misapprehensions of facts and law:
(a) The DJ erred in assessing Selvam’s Section 1 costs using a revised starting point of $229,950 instead of the $174,000 it had claimed before the DR.
(b) The DJ erred in failing to apply the doctrine of estoppel based on certain representations Selvam had made as to costs.
(c) In her assessment of costs, the DJ had completely failed to apply the principles of proportionality and had not conducted her assessment based on the actual work done.
(d) The DJ erred in excluding the costs for SCT 12485 from the scope of the Letter of Engagement (“LOE”).
(e) As regards the Section 2 costs, the DJ erred in applying O 21 r 13 of the Rules of Court 2021 (“ROC”) when the operative rule was that in s 128 of the Legal Profession Act 1966 (2020 Rev Ed) (“LPA”), and failed to consider AMLA’s settlement offers and certain misconduct by Selvam.
(f) As regards the Section 3 costs, the DJ erred in allowing disbursements resulting from the SOC amendment, and transcript fees which had not been included in the costs schedule provided to the trial judge in OC 116.
AMLA also argues that Selvam’s appeal in RAS 8 should be dismissed for abuse of process.
Selvam’s appeal is not an abuse of process
- [15]
[15] AMLA argues that Selvam’s appeal in RAS 8 should be dismissed for three reasons:
(a) Selvam had on 21 April 2025 unilaterally extracted the Certificate of Taxation Order without AMLA’s consent or knowledge, thereby contravening O 17 rr 3(5) and 3(6) of the ROC and para 76(6)(b) of the State Courts Practice Directions 2021. This “misled the Court and resulted in the rejection of [AMLA]’s Further Arguments”, resulting in procedural unfairness. Had AMLA’s further arguments been accepted, there would be no need for the current appeal.
(b) Following the extraction of the Certificate of Taxation, Selvam demonstrated its unequivocal acceptance of the DJ’s decision by refunding the taxed-off portion of legal fees. Hence, it should be estopped from appealing against the DJ’s decision.
(c) Finally, in its oral submissions, AMLA noted that Selvam had filed its written submissions two hours late. As such, it should be deemed to have withdrawn its appeal.
- [16]
[16] The DJ had rejected AMLA’s request on the basis that she did not require further arguments. As such, there is no apparent link between Selvam’s alleged extraction of the Certificate of Taxation Order and the DJ’s rejection of AMLA’s application. AMLA has also failed to provide any explanation of such. Further, Selvam had not “unilaterally extracted the Certificate of Taxation Order” in contravention of O 17 rr 3(5) and 3(6) of the ROC and para 76(6)(b) of the State Courts Practice Directions on 21 April 2025. Rather, on 21 April 2025, Selvam had filed a draft of the order in accordance with O 17 r 3(5). AMLA was then required to respond with any objections to the draft pursuant to O 17 r 3(6), and it did, in fact, do so. As of the date of this judgment, Selvam has yet to extract the order.
- [17]
[17] Moving then to AMLA’s argument on estoppel, it is trite that an appeal does not operate as a stay of execution. Parties are expected to comply with a court’s decision even if they intend to appeal against it. The fact that Selvam abided by the DJ’s decision by refunding the taxed-off portion of the legal fees thus does not estop it from appealing against said decision.
- [18]
[18] Finally, AMLA argues that as Selvam had filed their written submissions at 8.12pm despite the court’s directions for parties to file their written submissions by 30 May 2025, 6pm, it should be taken to have withdrawn its appeal. This argument was already raised to and rejected by the Assistant Registrar (“AR”) at the case conference for this matter. I agree with the AR’s decision – I do not see how Selvam filing its written submissions two hours late is prejudicial to AMLA.
Amendment to SOC
The amendment to the SOC was done on AMLA’s instructions
- [20]
[20] AMLA argues that the DJ erred in finding that Selvam had amended the SOC on AMLA’s instructions for two reasons:
(a) The DJ erred in accepting Selvam’s unsubstantiated, speculative statement that it would have either updated AMLA’s representatives orally or sent the e-mail to Ms Vu regarding the proposed amendments to the SOC in their presence.
(b) The DJ erred in holding that the amendment to the SOC was necessitated by AMLA’s supplementary AEIC. The amendment to the SOC was made prior to the supplementary AEIC. As such, Selvam’s reliance on the supplementary AEIC as justification was an ex post facto rationalisation.
- [21]
[21] I will first address the latter argument. At no point in the GD did the DJ find that the amendment to the SOC was necessitated by AMLA’s supplementary AEIC. Rather, the DJ explicitly found that there was no basis for “relating the supplementary chat records [adduced in AMLA’s supplementary AEIC] to the SOC amendments” (GD at [12]).
- [22]
[22] Assuming that AMLA is referring to the DJ’s finding (GD at [12]) that “the application to amend the SOC to seek exemplary damages instead of aggravated damages … was supported by an affidavit by [Li Benjin (“Mr Li”)] affirmed on 29 May 2023”, the DJ was referring to Mr Li’s supporting affidavit affirmed on 29 May 2023, and not his supplementary AEIC affirmed on the same date. In this supporting affidavit, AMLA’s Mr Li notes that “[t]he proposed amendment to [AMLA]’s Statement of Claim dated 29 May 2022 involves a minor correction to the reliefs sought … [AMLA] will be seeking exemplary damages instead of aggravated damages”. This supporting affidavit is hence clear evidence of AMLA’s knowledge of and agreement to the amendment.
- [23]
[23] AMLA also argues that its representative’s signature on the amended SOC was procured improperly and / or through misrepresentation. On 19 June 2023, Selvam sent AMLA an e-mail stating that it made an “inadvertent mistake” by attaching the wrong version of the amended SOC to the summons. On 30 June 2023, Selvam sent another email to AMLA requesting for its signature on the updated amended SOC. AMLA suggests that Selvam had procured its representative’s signature through this means, ie, by “conceal[ing] the deliberate amendment of the SOC by attributing it to a minor clerical error”.
- [24]
[24] However, this cannot be the case. As noted above (at [22]), AMLA’s representative had already signed an affidavit in support of the application to amend the SOC one month prior on 29 May 2023. Therefore, AMLA cannot now claim that it only signed the amended SOC on a misapprehension arising from an e-mail sent on 19 June 2023. Further, it was not the case that Selvam had concealed an amendment to the SOC by attributing it to a minor clerical error. The intended amendment to the SOC was to replace “aggravated damages” with “exemplary damages” (above at [22]). However, Selvam had inadvertently attached a wrong version of the amended SOC, which included a number of other changes, to its summons. The e-mail Selvam sent to AMLA on 19 June 2023 was to inform them of this error, not to mislead. The amended SOC that was eventually filed on 30 June 2023 also contained only the intended changes stated in Mr Li’s supporting affidavit.
Amendments to SOC did not delay trial
- [25]
[25] In any case, the DJ was correct to find that there was no evidence that the amendment to the SOC delayed the trial. The notes of evidence of 2 May 2023 clearly show that the trial on 2 May 2023 was vacated “given there [was a] medical memo that [said] that Ms Vu [was] medically unfit to attend Court”. AMLA’s argument that “the trial would have been disrupted regardless of [Ms Vu’s] medical memo” as Selvam had intended to apply to amend the SOC on the first day of trial is purely speculative. Further, by the same token, it could also be said that even if the SOC had not been amended, the vacation of the trial dates and subsequent case conferences would have been necessary due to Ms Vu’s medical memo and the filing of supplementary AEICs.
Admission of supplementary chat records unrelated to the SOC amendment
- [26]
[26] While AMLA alleges that Selvam had “deliberately orchestrated the use of supplementary evidence to conceal a restart of the case”, it has not shown any basis for linking the filing of supplementary AEIC to the SOC amendment. Further, whilst AMLA repeatedly emphasises Selvam’s alleged acknowledgement that the supplementary AEIC was “substantially similar” to the original AEICs as evidence that they were unnecessary, this does not appear to be entirely accurate.
- [27]
[27] Selvam had sent AMLA a draft of the supplementary AEIC and the affidavit in support of the application by way of an e-mail dated 29 May 2023. In this e-mail, Selvam “highlight[ed] that these affidavits [were] substantially similar to the affidavits [AMLA] had commissioned before the trial, save that [Selvam had] included the WeChat conversation between Annie and [Mr Li] on 29 March”.
- [28]
[28] A review of the e-mails provided by AMLA itself reveals that AMLA had provided supplementary chat records to Selvam on 21 April 2023. Subsequently, after the trial was postponed, AMLA provided Selvam with another chat record (namely, the one dated 29 March 2022), thereby causing Selvam to amend the supplementary AEIC to include it. This is the full context of Selvam’s statement at [27] above. Selvam was simply stating that the new draft supplementary AEIC was similar to the previous drafts.
- [29]
[29] AMLA also appears to argue that the filing of the supplementary AEIC was done without authorisation, as it had “requested to dispense with the supplementary records to avoid further delay to the trial” by way of an e-mail on 22 May 2023 at 12:43pm. However, it has not produced any evidence of this request. The e-mail that it cites as support is simply an e-mail from Selvam informing it that trial dates could not be taken before the resolution of its filing application.
No estoppel
- [33]
[33] The DJ was also correct in finding that Selvam’s fee estimate did not amount to a promise that their fees would fall within the estimated range of $50,000 – $70,000, as Selvam had explicitly qualified that its estimate was subject to the complexity of the matter.
Starting point of $229,950
The DJ’s exercise of discretion
(a) failed to have sufficient regard to O 21 rr 23(2)(a), 23(2)(b) and O 21 r 22(3) of the ROC; and
(b) erred in her application of the principle of proportionality.
Order 21 rr 23(2)(a), 23(2)(b) and O 21 r 22(3) of the ROC
Proportionality
Section 1 costs
(a) AMLA was only awarded $27,000 in damages and $15,000 in party-and-party costs, yet the solicitor-and-client costs were assessed at over $96,000 (ie, approximately 360% of the awarded damages and 640% of the recoverable party-and-party costs). Such an outcome was thus “manifestly excessive and unjustified”.
(b) The DJ had erred in relying on Selvam’s “self-serving and inflated timesheet” and not considering the nature of the actual work undertaken.
(a) The DJ taxed the costs of SCT 12485 down from $10,920 to $6,000 “[g]iven that this was a matter in respect of which legal representation was not allowed in hearings”.
(b) The DJ taxed the costs of SCTDJ 8026 down from $20,160 to $9,000, noting that AMLA’s written submissions and bundle of authorities were 16 and 22 pages respectively, and Selvam had assisted AMLA in the proceedings below.
(c) The DJ taxed the costs of PHC 10157 taxed down from $13,475 to $6,000 bearing in mind that “the application filed by [Ms Vu] on 15 May 2023 was ultimately withdrawn at the hearing on 1 June 2023”.
(d) The DJ taxed the costs of OC 116 down from $185,395 to $75,000. The DJ noted that based on Selvam’s timesheet and assuming a standard work schedule of eight hours per day in a five-day week, the lawyers would have worked exclusively on OC 116 for 10 weeks. This was excessive given that the matter was not complex and there were only three days of trial.
It is evident from these explanations that the DJ had based her assessment of costs on the actual work performed by Selvam. Moreover, in her evaluation of the costs claimed for OC 116, the DJ explicitly found that the hours recorded in Selvam’s timesheet were unreasonable considering the complexity of the matter (GD at [23]). It is thus unclear on what basis AMLA alleges that the DJ relied on Selvam’s timesheet or that she failed to assess costs based on the actual work performed.
SCT 12485
(a) SCT 12485 was “vital” as it directly impacted AMLA’s claim in defamation against Ms Vu. Accordingly, there was “extensive support” given to AMLA to ensure that it prevailed in SCT 12485. Selvam reviewed the papers submitted by Ms Vu and drafted three witness statements for AMLA with an aggregate of 64 pages. It also helped AMLA with its submissions. Hence, the 2.5 hours expended by DS and 14.9 hours expended by CK were reasonable and proportionate.
(b) The negotiations lasted from 29 June 2022 to 14 September 2022, a period of 77 days. Considering that it is not disputed that work was carried out and CK was the sole solicitor whose billable hours were charged to AMLA, the 11.3 hours billed were reasonable and proportionate.
SCTDJ 8026/2022
- [53]
[53] Selvam had three lawyers work on SCTDJ 8026 – one director and two junior associates. Selvam argues that the hours billed by all three lawyers are not unreasonable, as the PTC for the hearing was 1.5 hours, while the hearing itself was 4.5 hours. As such, the lead counsel had expended only 5.1 hours in the lead-up to and preparation for the hearing. The two junior associates had, together, spent a total of 38.4 hours. Selvam proposed to deduct 20.4 hours from the latter “in the interest of saving judicial time”. Excluding the 1.5 hours at the PTC and 4.5 hours at the hearing, this would amount to a total of 12 hours spent on preparation by the two associates, which was reasonable and appropriate.
- [54]
[54] I do not agree. The issues in SCTDJ 8026 were simple, being:
Moreover, as the DJ correctly noted, Selvam had assisted AMLA in the proceedings below (GD at [20]).
PHC 10157/2022
- [58]
[58] I do not agree with either party.
DC/OC 116/2022
- [65]
[65] The fact remains that Selvam has failed to explain why it has billed hours that were equivalent to, as noted by the DJ, a lawyer working exclusively on this matter for 10 weeks for a relatively simple defamation claim, for which trial only lasted three days, and where the falsity of Ms Vu’s statements had already been determined in SCT 12485. On appeal, Selvam has highlighted the fact that Ms Vu appointed legal counsel at a relatively late point in the proceedings. This is insufficient explanation. The appointment of legal counsel did not significantly change the complexity of the matter.
GST
Section 2 costs
(a) The DJ erred in accepting Selvam’s “unfounded claim that [AMLA] consented to bear Section 2 costs”.
(b) The DJ had applied O 21 r 13(1) of the ROC, which applies only to party-and-party costs. The operative rule is instead that in s 128(1)(a) of the LPA, ie, if the bill, when assessed, is less by a sixth part than the bill delivered, then the solicitor must pay the costs.
(c) Even if the operative rule is that in O 21 r 13 of the ROC, the DJ erred in treating AMLA’s cost computation in the Notice of Dispute as a formal settlement proposal. In so doing, the DJ failed to consider the “multiple genuine settlement proposals” made by AMLA which, if accepted, would have exceeded the amount eventually assessed by the DR.
(d) The DJ also erred in concluding that AMLA’s allegations of certain misconduct by Selvam were unfounded.
Allegations of misconduct
- [72]
[72] I do not find that the DJ erred in disregarding the alleged breach of O 11 rr 12(1) and 12(2) of the ROC. The appropriate recourse for a such a breach would be to apply to court for a production order pursuant to O 11 r 12(3). No such order has been granted.
Application of O 21 r 13 of the ROC
- [76]
[76] The DJ did not err in her application of O 21 r 13 of the ROC.
Section 3 costs
Conclusion