General Division of the High Court · Decided 10 February 2026
Two related claims heard together but not consolidated were costed as separate cases
Tjiang Giok Moy and another v Ang Jimmy Tjun Min and another matter
Feedback & support[2026] SGHC 33 · Case no. Originating Claim No 56 of 2022 · 16 paragraphs
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
Two related claims heard together but not consolidated were costed as separate cases
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [13], [28]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [2]
[2] In OC 56, Mdm Tjiang Giok Moy (“Mrs Ang”) and Ms Eileen Ang (“Eileen”) claimed against Mr Ang Jimmy Tjun Min (“Jimmy”) for unauthorised withdrawals made by Jimmy from their Citibank Account. The three of them are also shareholders of Banner (China) Investment Company Limited (“Banner”). In HC/OC 192/2022 (“OC 192”), Banner claimed against Jimmy for the return of an advance made to him by Banner.
Parties’ position for OC 56 and OC 192
One set of costs or two
- [10]
[10] In Hyflux Ltd (in compulsory liquidation) and others v Lum Ooi Lin and another suit [2024] SGHC 84 at [19] (“Hyflux”), the High Court cited Boswell J in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice decision of Paterson v Stewart Title Guaranty Company [2020] ONSC 4609 (“Paterson”). While Boswell J was interpreting the Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure, his description of the essential features of consolidation and a joint hearing was considered broadly applicable here. Boswell J in Paterson in turn quoted Quinn J from Wood v Farr Ford Ltd [2008] OJ No 4092, who held at [24]-[26]:
- [11]
[11] In How Weng Fan v Sengkang Town Council [2023] SGCA 21 (“How Weng Fan”), the Court of Appeal observed at [51] that in that case, the two suits there were not consolidated but merely heard together. AHTC’s pleadings in Suit 668 defined the matters to be decided by the court in Suit 668 and its pleaded case should not be conflated with or confused with PRPTC’s in Suit 716.
- [13]
[13] In this case, the claimants in OC 56 and OC 192 pursued different claims based on distinct pleaded cases. The parties continued to maintain two sets of pleadings throughout the proceedings. Consequently, following the Court of Appeal’s decision in How Weng Fan, OC 56 and OC 192 were not consolidated.
Party-and-party costs
- [16]
[16] Under Appendix G of the Supreme Court Practice Directions 2021 (“Appendix G”), the range for matters involving “Equity and Trusts” is: (a) for pre-trial work: $25,000 to $90,000; (b) trial work: $6,000 to $16,000 per day of trial and (c) post-trial work: up to $35,000.
- [19]
[19] The claimants in OC 56 and OC 192 relied on the following to support their proposed figure:
(a) First, they submitted that while OC 56 and OC 192 may not have raised novel or esoteric legal issues, they were factually complex. Jimmy made allegations concerning matters going back to 1992 (i.e. 33 years ago). The documents disclosed came up to approximately 2,200 pages.
(b) Second, Jimmy’s conduct of the litigation was unreasonable and improper. They relied on the fact that the court found him to be an evasive and inconsistent witness. They submitted that Jimmy’s conduct unnecessarily protracted the proceedings and caused the incurring of significant unnecessary time and costs. Pursuant to this submission, claimants sought uplifts in costs for various stages of proceedings, relying on O 21 r2(2) of the ROC 2021, which states that in fixing costs, court must have regard to all relevant circumstances, including the conduct of parties.
(c) Third, there is no overlap between OC 56 and OC 192. Parties dealt with the claims and issues in OC 56 and OC 192 in discrete sections in the AEICs and their written submissions.
(a) The claimants sought identical costs for overlapping stages in each of the Suits in their costs schedule: (i) Production of Documents: $5,000 each (same list of documents for both); (ii) AEICs: $25,000 each (same AEICs for both); (iii) Set down: $28,000 each (same documents, bundles, opening statements and attendance at consolidated case conferences for both); (iv) Trial: $75,000 each (both Suits heard together); (v) Post-Trial: $25,000 each (same set of closing submissions and reply submissions for both).
(b) The overlap justifies a discount of 50% each for OC 56 and OC 192 for work done after the consent orders made in SUM 2728. There should be separate costs for work done before the orders in SUM 2728.
(c) Matters going to inconsistencies in testimony at trial go towards the findings of credibility of a witness and strength of evidence. They do not warrant opprobrium through an uplifted costs order.
- [21]
[21] I had the following observations.
- [25]
[25] In this case, the claimants used the same list of documents, the same set of AEICs, the same opening statement and the same set of closing and reply submissions for both OC 56 and OC 192, albeit to address discrete issues. Both suits were also effectively heard together during the same trial, rather than one after another as they concerned a similar fact pattern and background.
- [26]
[26] While the claimants in OC 56 and OC 192 raised several issues in discrete fashion in their AEICs and written submissions, there were nevertheless overlaps. The family history and Mrs Ang’s conversations with Jimmy about the property were pertinent to both actions. Indeed, a central evidential question that ran through both actions was whether Mrs Ang had agreed to gift a particular property to Jimmy. The withdrawal from Mrs Ang and Eileen’s Citibank account in OC 56 and Banner’s advance to Jimmy in OC 192 were both used by Jimmy to purchase this property. Hence, although the claimants pursued distinct pleaded cases, the degree of overlap was not insignificant.
- [28]
[28] Taking into consideration the above, I awarded $104,500 to the claimants in OC 56 and $99,500 to the claimants in OC 192.
- [29]
[29] For OC 56, I awarded the following, which counsels confirmed in terms of the accuracy of the relevant figures and calculations:
(a) Pre-trial costs of $52,000 [Being ((10,000/66,000) x $66,000) and 75% of ((56,000/66,000) x $66,000) rounded down];
(b) Trial costs of $33,750 [Being 50% of 5 days of trial at $13,500 per day].
(c) Post-trial costs of $18,750 [Being 75% of $25,000].
- [30]
[30] For OC 192, I awarded the following, which counsels confirmed in terms of the accuracy of the relevant figures and calculations:
(a) Pre-trial costs of $47,000 [Being ((5,000/61,000) x $61,000) and 75% of ((56,000/61,000) x $61,000)]
(b) Trial costs of $33,750 [Being 50% of 5 days of trial at $13,500 per day].
(c) Post-trial costs of $18,750 [Being 75% of $25,000].
Costs for interlocutory applications
- [33]
[33] I awarded to the claimants $1,500 each for SUM 2727 and for SUM 2728, taking into account that similar reliefs were sought, and the same affidavit and submission was used. This includes the work done to apply for permission for the consolidation applications. I awarded to Banner $1,000 for SUM 3088.
(a) Mrs Ang and Eileen a total of $19,000 for eight requests filed by the parties for permission to file the interlocutory applications referred to in the table in Annex A: (i) two requests by Mrs Ang and Eileen for permission to apply for Further and Better Particulars (“FBP”) and consolidation, both of which were allowed; (ii) one request by Jimmy to apply for FBP, which was allowed; (iii) one request by Jimmy to amend his pleadings, which he withdrew; and (iv) four requests by Jimmy to apply for production of documents, all of which were rejected; and
(b) Banner $2,000, for a request for permission to file an application to consolidate OC 56 and OC 192, which was allowed.
- [35]
[35] The claimants submitted that these requests were not merely “administrative” but involved the adjudication of substantive rights. In deciding whether to allow a request for permission, the court exercises a judicial function in deciding whether the requesting party can take out an application other than in a Single Application Pending Trial (“SAPT”). The requesting party must satisfy the Court that the intended application is necessary at the stage of the proceedings.
Disbursements
- [41]
[41] Taking into consideration the above, I awarded disbursements to the claimants in the amount sought, of $50,486.30 in OC 56 and $23,592.40 in OC 192.
Conclusion
- [42]
[42] In conclusion, I awarded to the claimants in OC 56 and OC 192 the following:
(a) OC 56: Party-and-party costs of $104,500, disbursements of $50,486.30, $1,500 for SUM 2727 and $5,000 for the requests for applications that were rejected or not proceeded with;
(b) OC 192: Party-and-party costs of $99,500, disbursements of $23,592.40, $1,500 for SUM 2728, and $1,000 for SUM 3088.