Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 11 Sep 2019

Singapore International Commercial Court

BXS v BXT

Feedback & support

[2019] SGHC(I) 14Case no. Originating Summons No 1 of 2019 (Summons No 1035 of 2019)5 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. (a) Who should bear the costs of SIC/OS 1/2019 (“OS 1”), HC/SUM 1035/2019 (“SUM 1035”), and HC/SUM 5770/2018 (“SUM 5770”)?

  3. (b) What should the amount of those costs be?

  4. (c) What interest should run on such costs?

  5. Discussion

  6. Who should bear the costs of the three applications?

  7. What should the quantum of costs be?

  8. “Appendix G” refers to Appendix G to the Supreme Court Practice Directions, and is entitled “Guidelines for Party-and-Party Costs Awards in the Supreme Court of Singapore”.

  9. [7] The Defendant submits that S$70,000 is reasonable for the following reasons:

  10. (a) The Plaintiff behaved in a “highly culpable” manner by raising unmeritorious arguments in OS 1 and SUM 1035, constantly attempting to “derail timelines and/or frustrate the Singapore proceedings,” and generally conducting itself in a manner that “generated unnecessary costs”.

  11. (b) The amount of S$70,000 is proportionate to the sum at stake, since the Final Award required the Plaintiff to pay the Defendant THB 91,153,182.62 (approximately S$4,010,740.04), together with costs of US$647,112.51 and interest.

  12. (c) A significant amount of work had to be done by the Defendant, including the filing of 3,278 pages of documents, the submission of 105 authorities, and seven court attendances (that is, pre-trial conferences, a case management conference, and the substantive hearing of OS 1 and SUM 1035).

  13. The foregoing factors are said to have led the Defendant to incur legal fees and disbursements in OS 1 amounting to S$116,733.84 in total. The legal fees comprise S$94,295.65 in fees for Rajah & Tann (“R&T”), and S$15,510.72 in fees for Allen & Overy (Asia) Pte Ltd (“A&O”). The disbursements consist of S$5,785.20 in e-litigation fees, and S$1,142.27 in miscellaneous expenses.

  14. [8] The Defendant acknowledges that, if Appendix G were applicable, it would be entitled to between S$19,000 and S$34,000 for the three applications and S$6,927.47 for disbursements in connection with OS 1. The lower bound of $$19,000 is calculated by adding the figures of S$1,000 for SUM 5770, S$6,000 for SUM 1035, and S$12,000 for OS 1. The upper bound of S$34,000 is calculated by adding the figures of S$2,000 for SUM 5770, S$20,000 for SUM 1035, and S$12,000 for OS 1. The Defendant says that, although the substantive hearing of OS 1 and SUM 1035 together only lasted for half a day, the two applications had been set down for a whole day.

  15. (a) OS 1 was transferred to the SICC on 8 March 2019. Accordingly, only the costs of SUM 5770 (which would be relatively minimal) should be subject to Appendix G.

  16. (b) It is true that a party is only allowed to claim for the costs of two solicitors under Appendix G and the Defendant is claiming for three solicitors. But the Plaintiff also made use of three solicitors.

  17. (c) The Defendant should be entitled to claim the costs of A&O as the latter had acted as the instructing solicitors for R&T in the Singapore court proceedings. This arrangement ensured proper coordination of the Defendant’s efforts in the litigation proceedings in Thailand and Singapore arising out of the Final Award.

  18. Reliance is placed on the same factors to justify the reasonableness of the S$70,000 claimed

  19. (b) for SUM 1035, the amount of S$7,000; and

  20. (c) for OS 1, the amount of S$8,000.

  21. Paragraph 3 of Appendix G stresses that:

  22. [16] Plainly, the S$70,000 claimed by the Defendant, being 175% more than the S$40,000 obtained through applying Appendix G, is too high and thus unreasonable. The question then is whether I should depart from Appendix G for the reasons given by the Defendant. In my opinion, it would not be appropriate to do so.

  23. [17] As far as solicitors are concerned, both parties made use of three solicitors. That indicates that both parties regarded the matter as important. This is hardly surprising. International arbitration awards are not susceptible to appeal. They may be set aside or refused recognition or enforcement on limited grounds. Consequently, where significant amounts are at stake, parties on both sides of an international commercial arbitration are likely to expend substantial resources in pursuing or resisting applications to set aside awards or have them recognised and enforced. However, the resultant greater use of resources has already been taken into account by applying the higher end of the ranges in Appendix G.

  24. [19] In so far as the Defendant also relies on the Plaintiff’s alleged culpable conduct, I agree with the Plaintiff that the matters raised largely concern different applications from the three being considered here. Any culpable conduct in connection with those separate applications will no doubt have been considered by the courts undertaking the taxation of those applications. For the purposes of the three applications under consideration here, I would accept that, before the substantive hearing of OS 1 and SUM 1035, the Plaintiff showed itself to be difficult and uncooperative. However, that attitude will also have already been factored in by taking the higher end of the range in Appendix G.

  25. What rate of interest should be payable on the Defendant’s costs?

  26. Conclusion