Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 5 February 2020
[2020] SGHC(I) 02
Feedback & support[2020] SGHC(I) 02 · Case no. Suit No 2 of 2019
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] This is an action about a dispute over the ownership of a luxury villa, Villa 29, at the Andara Resort in Phuket, Thailand.
- [2]
[2] At the outset, it is necessary to be clear that the word “ownership” is used as a shorthand. Under Thai property law, foreign nationals cannot own land. The most that they can be granted is a 30-year lease over land which can be extended for a further period of 30 years. They can however own a building which is erected on land provided the necessary construction permit is issued in respect of the building. Three documents are thus required to give a foreign national the right to occupy property such as the villa in question: the land lease, the house registration and the construction permit. Assignment of the three documents is a cumbersome process which can be simplified by issuing all three documents in the name of an offshore company. Providing the only assets of that company are the three documents of title (and any other documents relating to the property in question), transfer of “ownership” of the property can be effected much more simply by transferring the shares in the offshore company to the new owners.
- [3]
[3] Some care therefore needs to be taken when the question of ownership of Villa 29 arises since, as a matter of law, it is ownership of the shares in the offshore company that is being referred to but, colloquially, it is often the case that reference is made to ownership of the villa. In particular, two of the issues that arise in this case, the proper law of the alleged oral agreement and enforcement of such an agreement under Singapore law, raise questions as to whether the corporate veil of an offshore company should be lifted so as to give effect to the fact that the corporate entity is a proxy for what is in substance the ownership of an interest in land.
The background to the dispute
- [4]
[4] The Andara Resort (also referred to as “the Resort”) is the culmination of a project founded by a Mr Allan Zeman which consists not only of villas such as Villa 29 but also of hotel suites, a leisure complex and other facilities so that the whole constitutes a leisure resort. Owners of the villas can either retain them for personal use or can use them for investment purposes by appointing the Resort as a letting agent. Equally the Resort provides facilities for assisting the buying and selling of villas and employs a sales manager for this purpose. Overall responsibility for running the estate lies in the hands of the General Manager of the Resort who, from 2011, has been Mr Daniel Meury. Mr Meury reports to Khun Natthakanya, the Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) of the Paradise group of companies which is responsible for the Andara Resort. Khun Natthakanya is referred to by the nickname Khun Apple. Although her name appears as a recipient of a number of the e-mails in this case, she played no real part in the relevant events.
- [5]
[5] Villa 29 was being built in 2007 when Mr and Mrs Nargolwala, the 1st and 2nd Defendants, decided to buy it. They did this using a company incorporated in the British Virgins Island (“BVI”), Querencia Ltd (“Querencia”), the 5th Defendant, which was thus named in the three documents. Additionally, it was registered as the owner of 26 shares in Andara Properties Investment Company (another BVI company) which in turn owned 49% of the shares in Andamandara Co Ltd (a Thai company) which owns the Andara Resort land.
- [6]
[6] The Andara Resort and the Nargolwalas agreed to use the Resort’s lawyer, Mr Anurag Ramanat (“Mr Anurag”), jointly for this purpose. The Nargolwalas occupied Villa 29 when it was completed in 2008. They did so until around November 2014 when they moved into a second villa they had purchased, Villa 8 on a further development by Andara, known as Andara Signature. Thereafter Villa 29 was put up for sale and was made available for rental.
- [7]
[7] On occasions Villa 29 was rented by Mr Solomon Lew, the Plaintiff. In September 2017, Mr Lew decided that he wished to buy Villa 29 and contends that on 11 October 2017 a binding oral contract of sale was reached between him and Mr Meury, acting as the authorised agent of the Nargolwalas. The Nargolwalas dispute both that Mr Meury was acting as their agent and that, even if he was, any such binding agreement was reached.
- [8]
[8] In late October 2017, Mr Christian Larpin, the 4th Defendant, approached a Mr Martin Phillips, a real estate agent in Phuket, as he was looking to buy one or more villas as an investment. In particular, Mr Larpin was interested in viewing Villa 11 at the Andara Resort for which Mr Phillips was the appointed agent. Although not the appointed agent for Villa 29, Mr Phillips was informed by his brother, Mr Lyndon Phillips, then on his last few days as the General Sales Manager at the Andara Resort, that Villa 29 was also available for sale.
- [9]
[9] I shall consider the history of the negotiations over Villa 29 between Mr Larpin and the Nargolwalas in more detail below but it is sufficient for present purposes to say that the negotiations were successful and that the appropriate Share Purchase Agreement (“SPA”) for the transfer of the shares in Querencia to Quo Vadis Investments Ltd (“Quo Vadis”) was executed on 14 November 2017. Quo Vadis, the 3rd Defendant, is a Hong Kong company controlled by Mr Larpin of which Mrs Dao Te Lagger is a director. Completion took place on 16 November 2017 and in consequence Mr and Mrs Nargolwala resigned as directors of Querencia on that day.
- [10]
[10] Mr Lew asserts that in entering the SPA and in completing the deal, the Nargolwalas acted in breach of the alleged oral agreement of 11 October 2017 and consequently acted in breach of their fiduciary duties to Mr Lew and in breach of trust in transferring the shares to Quo Vadis. He further contends that Mr Larpin (and hence Quo Vadis) had knowledge of the alleged oral agreement such that they were liable for inducing the breach and that Querencia acted dishonestly in assisting the Nargolwalas in their breach of fiduciary duty and breach of trust. All of this is denied by the Defendants.
- [11]
[11] Finally, the Plaintiff and the 1st and 2nd Defendants disagree as to what is the proper law of the alleged oral agreement: Singapore law or Thai law. Initially these was also a measure of disagreement as to what was the proper law of the alleged agency agreement between the Nargolwalas and Mr Meury but it is now common ground that all questions relating to agency fall to be answered by applying whichever law is held to be the proper law of the alleged oral contract.
The issues
- [12]
[12] The following issues thus arise for decision:
(a) Proper law:
(i) Is the question of whether or not a binding oral agreement was reached on 11 October 2017 to be decided under Singapore or Thai law?
(ii) It is now accepted by all parties that the question of whether Mr Meury was authorised to act as an agent for the Nargolwalas is to be decided under the same law?
(iii) Equally it is accepted that any question relating to ostensible authority is to be decided under the same law?
(b) The agency:
(i) Was Mr Meury authorised to act as an agent for the Nargolwalas and, if so, what was the extent of that agency?
(A) Under Singapore law?
(B) Under Thai law?
(ii) Was his ostensible authority different from his actual authority (if any)?
(iii) If so, what is the effect of this:
(A) Under Singapore law?
(B) Under Thai law?
(c) The alleged oral contract:
(i) What agreement, if any, was reached on 11 October 2017? In particular, if any agreement was reached, was it a binding oral contract of sale or was it an agreement subject to contract or what was it?
(A) Under Singapore law?
(B) Under Thai law?
(ii) What is the effect of the 14 days’ settlement term?
(A) Under Singapore law?
(B) Under Thai law?
(iii) If there was no binding oral agreement because of lack of an agency relationship, did the Nargolwalas nonetheless ratify the same by their conduct so as to make it enforceable?
(iv) If there was no binding oral agreement because of lack of an agency relationship, are the Nargolwalas nonetheless estopped from denying the existence of the agency relationship?
(v) If a binding oral contract was reached on 11 October 2017, is it enforceable:
(A) Under Singapore law?
(B) Under Thai law?
(d) The position of the 3rd and 4th Defendants:
(i) What was the actual knowledge of Mr Larpin with regard to the alleged oral contract at any given time?
(ii) Did Mr Larpin intend to induce the 1st and 2nd Defendants to act in breach of the alleged oral agreement?
(iii) Should he have made further enquiries at any given time?
(iv) Did Mr Larpin act in bad faith at any given time?
(v) Was Quo Vadis a bona fide purchaser for value without notice?
(e) The position of the 5th Defendant:
(i) Did Querencia assist the Nargolwalas in any breach of fiduciary duty or breach of trust by entering Quo Vadis’ name into its register of members?
(ii) Did the Nargolwalas’ knowledge constitute the knowledge of Querencia at the time when Quo Vadis’ name was entered into the register?
(iii) At the time Quo Vadis’ name was entered into the register, did Querencia have actual knowledge that the alleged oral agreement had been concluded between Mr Lew and the Nargolwalas and that the Nargolwalas were bound by the terms thereof?
(iv) Did Querencia act dishonestly in entering Quo Vadis’ name into the register?
The factual witnesses
- [13]
[13] Of the people mentioned above, Mr Zeman, Mr Anurag, Khun Apple and Mr Lyndon Phillips did not give evidence. The remainder did.
- [14]
[14] Mr Lew, the Plaintiff, is an Australian citizen who has built up a successful business empire in the fields of retail, property, equities, finance, foreign exchange and total investments. He is not legally trained. He has a forceful personality and plainly over his business career has been involved, and it would appear, successfully involved, in many business negotiations. His personality is such that he will drive a hard bargain and will not hesitate to use as a tactic supplying his opposite number with misinformation which is intended to be accepted as true and which, if true, would enhance his negotiating position. Equally he will not disclose information which is true if disclosure would harm his negotiating position. He referred to such tactics as “deal talk” and plainly saw it as part of the rough and tumble of his business life. The commercial market place in which Mr Lew operates is not a place for the mealy mouthed or faint hearted and I do not consider that the fact that a person is prepared to engage in “deal talk” in business means that he will do the same when giving evidence on oath in the witness box. When giving evidence, Mr Lew was composed, clear, precise and firm in his beliefs. I have concluded that those beliefs were beliefs which he truly held when giving evidence although, as will appear later in this judgment, some of those beliefs are inconsistent with contemporaneous documents upon which I have thought fit to place greater weight.
- [15]
[15] Mrs Roza Lew is a communicator by profession and conducted herself in the witness box as one might expect of such a person and gave her evidence in a straightforward and fair way. She acknowledged that she was neither a lawyer nor a business person and that she left all business dealings to her husband.
- [16]
[16] Mrs Te Lagger is Swiss. She is the Managing Director of Mr Larpin’s group of companies in Hong Kong. In particular, she is and was in 2017 a director of Quo Vadis. Additionally, as a result of the SPA she became a director of Querencia. She gave evidence on behalf of both. She is plainly a well-respected colleague of Mr Larpin whom he entrusts with many of the administrative responsibilities of his businesses. It was she who dealt directly with the Nargolwalas, particularly with Mr Nargolwala, in seeking to iron out some of the issues in the legal documents relating to the sale and purchase of Querencia. English was not her native tongue but she spoke it well. I found her to be a precise, reliable and helpful witness who had a clear recollection of events.
- [17]
[17] Mr Meury is also Swiss. His native tongue is Swiss German but his English is good. He graduated from the Swiss Hotel Management School in Lucerne in 1988 and has been in the hotel industry since then. He has worked in Thailand since 1990. This included working at the Chedi Hotel from 2002 until 2008 where he first met Mr Lew. He became the General Manager at the Andara Resort in 2011. He has plainly been a success there and has befriended many of the villa owners and the other guests. In particular, he became well acquainted with both the Nargolwalas and Mr Lew and regularly visited both when they were in residence. As a hotel manager it is his job to keep guests happy and it is apparent from the facts of this case that one of the ways this is done is by ensuring, whenever possible, that the guests are told what they want to hear and, likewise, that they are not told what they do not want to hear. This does however have the consequence that such guests may not get a full and complete picture of the actual state of affairs. Whilst such an approach may serve him well as a hotel manager it has led to a number of crossed wires in this case when Mr Meury acted as a go-between (to use a neutral term) between the Nargolwalas and Mr Lew over the possible sale of Villa 29. Mr Meury was called as a witness by the 3rd and 4th Defendants, not by the Nargolwalas or Mr Lew and was therefore cross-examined by counsel for Mr Lew and for the Nargolwalas. His recollection of events, particularly where there were no contemporaneous documents to refresh his memory, was poor. Further, he was clearly uncomfortable at times in the witness box since the dispute over the events of October 2017 in which he had played a major part had resulted in two families, both of which had become personal friends of his, being involved in litigation.
- [18]
[18] Mr Martin Phillips is a British citizen resident in Thailand where he is a real estate agent based in Phuket. He established his agency, Phillips Property, in 2005. He was the agent who acted on the sale of Villa 29 to Mr Larpin. He gave his evidence well although his recollection of precise details was somewhat hazy which is perhaps not surprising as the sale to Mr Larpin was no doubt one amongst a number that he was involved in at the time.
- [19]
[19] Mr Nargolwala is now a Singapore citizen having been brought up in India where he obtained a degree from Delhi University in 1969. He qualified as an accountant in London and has since had a successful career in banking, ending up as the CEO of Credit Suisse for the Asia-Pacific region from 2008 to 2010. Since that date he has held a number of non-executive directorships in public companies. When giving evidence he was polite, measured, coherent and cogent. He had a good grasp of detail and a relatively clear recollection of the events. His wife accurately said that he was a meticulous man. He remained patient during a long and, on occasions, somewhat repetitive cross-examination by counsel for Mr Lew and by counsel for Mr Larpin. All in all, he was an exemplary and impressive witness.
- [20]
[20] Mrs Nargolwala was also brought up in India and likewise obtained a degree from Delhi University. She is now a Singaporean citizen. She was quiet but firm when giving evidence but clearly found the experience stressful. She was less patient than her husband and was also less precise in her use of language. She was upset and angered by an e-mail from Mr Lew to Mr Zeman which was offensive both to her gender and her ethnic origin. Her evidence on the important issues was, in the main, reliable, but her recollection of what precisely she said at an important telephone call with Mr Meury on 11 October 2017 was not perfect.
- [21]
[21] Mr Larpin is a Swiss national who is now a Hong Kong resident. His mother was Italian and his father Swiss. He is fluent in Italian and French and speaks reasonably good English. He also has been a successful business man. It is, I think, not unfair to say that he exhibited many of the stereotypical characteristics of an Italian. He was loquacious in the extreme and spoke with his hands as well as with words. He was excitable and found difficulty in answering some questions directly. His recollection of some of the events was not always clear but the gist of his evidence was. I am satisfied that in his own way he was doing his best to assist the court.
The facts
- [22]
[22] Before addressing the issues, I shall make findings of fact relating to the events surrounding both the alleged oral contract and the purchase by Mr Larpin. Where the facts are in dispute, I make my findings on the basis of the balance of probabilities.
The events surrounding the alleged oral contract
- [23]
[23] When the Nargolwalas purchased Villa 8 on the Andara Signature estate, they put Villa 29 up for rental through the Andara Resort but also entered a one-year exclusive agency sales agreement with the Resort. Mr Lyndon Phillips was acting on behalf of the Resort. The one-year period expired on 16 February 2016 and was not renewed but the property remained on the Resort’s website and periodically the Nargolwalas were informed about interest from potential buyers but by September 2017 Villa 29 had not been sold.
- [24]
[24] In April 2017 Mr Lew rented Villa 29 and whilst staying there proposed to the lady who is now his wife and thus it had a special place in their affections. He considered making an offer for Villa 29 at that time but did not. They returned in September 2017 when Mr Lew began to take steps with a view to purchasing it. From discussions with Mr Meury, he learned that a BVI company owned Villa 29 and following a dinner with Mr Meury on 6 September 2017, he sent an e-mail to Mr Meury offering US$5m for Villa 29 on a “walk in walk out” basis, the offer being open for seven days. Mr Meury replied on the same day saying that he would try and do his best and get back to Mr Lew as soon as possible.
- [25]
[25] A number of text messages passed between Mr Meury and Mr Lew over the next few days in which Mr Meury gave the impression that the Nargolwalas were considering the offer and Mr Lew then texted Mr Meury to say that he had:
I shall return to consider the reference to chocolates to Switzerland later.
- [26]
[26] Mr Meury indicated that the owners would expect an offer that was slightly higher than their investment which was said to be close to US$5m but no further offer was forthcoming. On 16 September 2017 Mr Lew texted to say that since he was no longer under an obligation to the owners of Villa 29 he was going to send his property manager to Phuket to review villa opportunities and meet with a local agent. This was, as Mr Lew accepted, untrue “deal talk”, calculated to put pressure on Mr Meury to try to persuade the owners to come back and accept his offer. For his part, Mr Meury indicated that he was “hoping [that] the seller would come back with an offer of [US$5.2m or US$5.25m] … but sadly he did not”.
- [27]
[27] This is “hotel manager talk” since when Mr Lew’s offer was first made, Mr Meury spoke to Mr Zeman and it was agreed between them that they should not communicate the amount of the offer to the Nargolwalas because they knew that it would not be acceptable. Mr Meury merely informed the Nargolwalas that there was interest in Villa 29. It is to be noted that in the course of his evidence Mr Meury repeatedly emphasised that he was not used to property negotiations. The Nargolwalas therefore had no knowledge of the terms of Mr Lew’s offer and it thus lapsed.
- [28]
[28] On 28 September 2017 Mr Lew texted Mr Meury to book Villa 29 for four nights from Sunday, 8 November 2017, on the basis that his property manager had sourced a few opportunities which again was “deal talk”. On Friday, 6 October 2017, Mr Meury sent an e-mail to Mr Nargolwala telling him that:
and asked if he could speak with Mr Nargolwala either later that day or the following day.
- [29]
[29] This was somewhat strange language since Mr Meury accepted in cross-examination that he was not intending to get an offer from the Nargolwalas. Whilst Mr Nargolwala accepts that Mr Meury might have told him when he, Mr Nargolwala, was in Phuket a few weeks before that someone was interested in buying Villa 29 and cannot rule out that an Australian was involved, he contends that it is not surprising that he should have no recollection of it as it was not of any consequence to him. He regarded the e-mail as being of something of no substance but agreed to Mr Meury’s request that they speak on the telephone which they did on that afternoon.
- [30]
[30] Neither party can now recall who placed the phone call. Mr Nargolwala’s evidence-in-chief was to the effect that Mr Meury had asked him whether he would be keen to put forward an offer to sell Villa 29 for US$5m to which he replied that it was too low. In cross-examination he was asked if he had been told that there had been an offer from the Australian to purchase Villa 29 for US$5m and said that he did not recall any amount being mentioned. He was however adamant that he had not been informed of this at any earlier date.
- [31]
[31] Mr Nargolwala’s evidence was as follows:
- [32]
[32] Mrs Nargolwala’s evidence was that she had been present during the telephone conversation and that Mr Meury had mentioned that there was an Australian individual who might be interested in purchasing Villa 29 and that his budget was US$5m. In addition, he had asked whether the Nargolwalas would put forward an offer to sell at that price but her husband had said that the price was too low.
- [33]
[33] Mr Meury had little recollection about the details of this conversation but I am unable to accept his assertion that the Nargolwalas indicated that a price of US$6m would be acceptable to them.
- [34]
[34] I accept the substance of the Nargolwalas’ evidence. Whilst neither has a full recollection of the details of the conversation and there is no contemporaneous note relating to it, I am satisfied that the e-mail of 6 October 2017 was incorrect in suggesting that the Nargolwalas had previously put forward any offer in relation to the possible sale of Villa 29. Equally I accept that whilst they had been informed that there was a possible Australian buyer with a budget of US$5m, they were not told that he had made an offer and that they indicated that they were not interested in selling at that price.
- [35]
[35] On Monday, 9 October 2017, Mr Meury had a meeting with Mr Lew which resulted in an e-mail from Mr Meury to the Nargolwalas in which he reiterated that Mr Lew’s offer was at US$5m and passed on Mr Lew’s “deal talk” about his interest in other villas, including the statement that Mr Lew had put in an offer for another villa the day before. Mr Meury suggested that Mr Lew would possibly accept an asking price of US$5.5m. He invited the Nargolwalas to call him and indicated that he was having dinner with Mr Lew and his fiancée that evening.
- [36]
[36] In fact, Mr Meury called and spoke to Mrs Nargolwala and repeated the substance of his e-mail. Mrs Nargolwala said that she was prepared to discuss the figure with her husband but would only do so if there was a clear indication of what price was being offered for Villa 29. She gave evidence, which I accept, that at no point did she tell Mr Meury that he could put forward an offer on the Nargolwalas’ behalf of US$5.5m. Mr Meury has no recollection of the conversation.
- [37]
[37] Mr Lew and his then fiancée entertained Mr Meury for dinner on Monday, 9 October 2017, and there may then have been a further meeting between them on the following day. There are no documents recording anything that was discussed between them about the possible purchase of Villa 29 but Mr Meury accepted in cross-examination that at some time during those conversations he told Mr Lew that the Nargolwalas were offering US$5.5m for the sale.
- [38]
[38] This resulted in a “deal talk” text message from Mr Lew to Mr Meury late in the evening of 10 October 2017, Phuket time (recorded as 12.59am on 11 October 2017 in Melbourne):
- [39]
[39] The following morning, 11 October 2017, Mr Lew sent a text message to Mr Meury which contained further “deal talk” but the substance was that he was:
This serves to confirm that Mr Meury must have told Mr Lew that the Nargolwalas’ asking price was US$5.5m although this was not what the Nargolwalas had said and was something that they did not want him to do.
- [40]
[40] Mr Meury then sent an e-mail to the Nargolwalas. This e-mail and two other e-mails sent on 11 and 12 October 2017 are central to the matters in dispute.
- [42]
[42] Second, it must be appreciated that e-mails are not written on oath. Seldom will it be fair on the writer to submit any given e-mail to the sort of detailed verbal analysis that might be appropriate when considering the interpretation of a statute or contract. At times during the cross-examination, counsel were minded to ask the witness to do this and I did not find it a helpful exercise.
- [43]
[43] The first e-mail is timed at 8.49am Phuket time on 11 October 2017, which would be 9.49pm on 10 October 2017 New York time. It is from Mr Meury to both Mr and Mrs Nargolwala. Since it is important, I shall set it out in full.
- [44]
[44] Stripped of the verbiage, this was clearly an offer made on behalf of Mr Lew of US$5.25m “in your accounts” on a “walk in, walk out basis”, with “a settlement within 14 days”. Some emphasis was placed on the statement that there was a need for an answer “today” as suggesting that the Nargolwalas would appreciate that, if they did not accept the offer on the 11th the offer would lapse. Mrs Nargolwala, who did receive the e-mail on the morning of the 11th, when she was preparing to take an afternoon flight to Delhi to be with her mother who was seriously ill, did not however see the e-mail in this light. She said:
Mr Nargolwala gave evidence that he did not open the e-mail that evening in New York, it being his custom to retire early after long flights.
- [45]
[45] It was suggested in cross-examination that Mrs Nargolwala should have been upset by the reference to “split the difference” as that would indicate that Mr Meury had indeed put forward an offer price from the Nargolwalas contrary to their instructions. However, any detailed consideration of the wording of the e-mail by her was overtaken by a follow up phone call from Mr Meury. Mrs Nargolwala’s evidence-in-chief on this phone call was as follows:
- [46]
[46] In cross-examination she amplified upon that evidence and it is unclear as to what she merely thought at the time were matters that needed clarifying and which of those matters she articulated to Mr Meury.
- [47]
[47] In the passage of cross-examination at T6/113/2-20 she gave reasons why she thought she would have articulated the matters to Mr Meury but in subsequent passages it is apparent that she had no clear recollection of precisely what she did say and what she did not say. This aspect of cross-examination concluded as follows:
- [48]
[48] Mr Meury’s evidence-in-chief was brief. He stated:
- [49]
[49] He was cross-examined on this by both counsel for Mr Lew and for the Nargolwalas. His evidence to Mr Lew’s counsel was as follows:
- [50]
[50] His cross-examination by counsel for the Nargolwalas was extensive and it is apparent that his recollection of the details of the call is even more hazy than that of Mrs Nargolwala. The important evidence to my mind is his answer to a question based on the last lines of para 18 of Mrs Nargolwala’s affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) which reads:
- [51]
[51] On the basis of this, it is not possible to reach any definitive conclusion as to precisely what Mrs Nargolwala said to Mr Meury on that phone call. More specifically it is not possible to identify which of the matters which were concerning her she actually raised with Mr Meury. On the balance of probabilities however I am satisfied that the last sentence of para 18 of Mrs Nargolwala’s AEIC “I told Meury that I needed an "offer letter in writing” with "details" so that … Kai and I could discuss the proposal” does constitute the substance of the conversation and that Mr Meury would have been left in no doubt that any agreement on price was subject to knowing exactly what the offer meant and that Mrs Nargolwala required Mr Lew to clarify his position.
- [52]
[52] Following that telephone call, Mrs Nargolwala sent the second e-mail to her husband in New York (timed at 2.46pm Singapore time) just before she left for the airport to travel to Delhi. He therefore would have received it at 2.46am on 11 October 2017 in New York and he did not open it until the following morning. It reads:
- [53]
[53] Taken at face value, this records the fact that the buyer has agreed to the sale. It does not say that she had agreed to the sale. When cross-examined on the wording she had used, it was suggested that the wording was emphatic and Mrs Nargolwala responded as follows:
- [54]
[54] I accept this evidence which is consistent with her evidence that she had asked Mr Meury for more details both relating to the contact details of the buyer and the proposed next steps. I shall consider the reference to Singapore lawyers and Mr Anurag further at [77]–[79] and [100] below.
- [55]
[55] When Mr Nargolwala opened those two e-mails that morning in New York he also received the third e-mail, this one sent by Mr Meury, at 3.57pm Thai time (4.57am in New York). It reads:
- [56]
[56] This e-mail was sent after Mr Meury’s telephone conversation with Mrs Nargolwala. It is very much a repeat of the first e-mail although it does give Mr Lew’s name and indicates that some documents will be passed on to Mr Lew. Again there is a reference to Mr Anurag. The important part is the first sentence. This does no more to confirm the fact, contained in the first e-mail that Mr Lew has agreed on the offer for US$5.25m. It does not record Mr Meury’s belief that Mrs Nargolwala had agreed (in principle) to this figure. Further it does not contain any contact details for Mr Lew nor does it outline the proposed future steps other than the provision of some documents to Mr Lew. The Nargolwalas did not regard this e-mail as being the “offer letter in writing” which Mrs Nargolwala had requested and this is understandable.
- [57]
[57] On her arrival in Delhi Mr and Mrs Nargolwala spoke on the phone. Mrs Nargolwala is unsure whether she had read the third e-mail at this time but Mr Nargolwala had. Two passages in his evidence read as follows:
- [58]
[58] For her part Mrs Nargolwala said this:
- [59]
[59] I make no apology for going into such detail in relation to the three e-mails at 1AB/19, 20 and 21 (see [43], [52] and [55] above). They are fundamental to the question of whether a binding oral contract was reached later that day but also serve to explain why thereafter the parties were at cross-purposes as to what was to happen next. These are my findings in relation to the events that occurred on 11 October 2017 concerning the three e-mails.
- [60]
[60] First, whilst it is unclear how much of Mrs Nargolwala’s thinking set out in para 18 of her first AEIC was specifically communicated to Mr Meury I am satisfied that she did communicate that she had some concerns which needed to be resolved (even if they were not fully specified) and that she did tell “Meury that [she] needed an “offer letter in writing” with “details” so that [Mr Nargolwala] and [she] could discuss the proposal” [original emphasis omitted].
- [61]
[61] Secondly, I am also satisfied that Mr Meury understood that this was so although he may have been under a misapprehension as to the details required.
- [62]
[62] Third, so far as concerns the acceptability of the price to the Nargolwalas, I accept that Mrs Nargolwala did not expressly tell Mr Meury that the price of US$5.25m was acceptable. A conclusion that she did would be inconsistent with the subsequent discussion between Mr and Mrs Nargolwala on the telephone which contains reasoning for wishing to consider the details of the offer before accepting the price which are cogent and persuasive. I therefore doubt that Mr Meury’s recollection that Mrs Nargolwala actually said that they were agreeable in principle is correct but she must have said something during the conversation which led Mr Meury to believe that this was the case. He could not in good faith have acted as he did subsequently if he had not formed the belief that the sum was, or, possibly, would be acceptable to the Nargolwalas once the details (which he saw as being minor) were sorted out by the lawyers. I do not consider that Mr Meury ever acted in bad faith.
- [63]
[63] Finally, as indicated above, I accept that Mr and Mrs Nargolwala did not regard Mr Meury’s e-mail as being the offer letter in writing they were expecting in response to Mrs Nargolwala’s request.
- [64]
[64] Having sent the third e-mail, Mr Meury went to see Mr Lew and his fiancée at Villa 29. Mr Meury states in para 15 of his first AEIC that he informed Mr Lew that “the Nargolwalas were in principle agreeable to this latest offer, but wanted it in writing to consider further”.
- [65]
[65] Mr and Mrs Lew both dispute this. In para 22 of his first AEIC Mr Lew said:
- [66]
[66] Mrs Lew’s evidence was to like effect.
- [67]
[67] All three were cross-examined on their evidence-in-chief. In cross-examination by counsel for Mr Lew, Mr Meury contradicted his evidence-in-chief when he said:
- [68]
[68] In cross-examination by counsel for the Nargolwalas, his recollection was that he had spoken to Mr Lew before sending the third e-mail because he told him that the Nargolwalas wanted confirmation in writing of the deal and that he wanted to check with the Lews before writing the third e-mail. He went on to say:
- [69]
[69] In cross-examination Mr Lew stated that he never instructed Mr Meury to send the third e-mail and that it was not sent on his behalf. He went on to deny both that Mr Meury used the words “in principle agreed” or that he asked him to put it in writing:
- [70]
[70] Mrs Lew said that she never heard the words “in principle agreed” come out of Mr Meury’s mouth. There was, she said, no doubt in her mind that the Lews had purchased Villa 29.
- [71]
[71] Having heard all the witnesses, I have come to the conclusion that this was an occasion where Mr Meury acted as a hotel manager and not as a real estate agent. At the time, he felt in his own mind that the Nargolwalas had agreed in principle or at the least would agree to the deal once their concerns were met. He felt no need to speak to Mr Lew before sending the third e-mail and he trusted that the information that he gave the Nargolwalas in that e-mail would assist in moving matters forward. He realised that lawyers would have to be involved and that he would then cease to play a part and that thereafter the Nargolwalas’ concerns would be dealt with by the lawyers.
- [72]
[72] When dealing with the Lews, he told them what they wanted to hear and thus told them that the Nargolwalas had agreed to Mr Lew’s proposal, again assuming that the lawyers would sort things out in due course. He repeatedly emphasised in evidence that he was not a property agent and I doubt he appreciated at the time that there was any difference between an agreement in principle and a binding agreement. Subsequently he has become aware and has sought to convince himself that he did tell the Lews that the Nargolwalas had only agreed in principle but on this aspect of the case I prefer the evidence of the Lews that he did not. I shall have to consider below what the legal effect was in all the circumstances of Mr Meury’s statement that the Nargolwalas had agreed to Mr Lew’s offer.
- [73]
[73] By the end of 11 October 2017 therefore, Mr Lew believed that the next step would be that contract documents would be supplied to his lawyers by the Nargolwalas’ lawyers, but of course, the pre-requisite to this was that he had to instruct appropriate lawyers and inform the vendors of this so that the lawyers could be put in touch. On the other hand, the Nargolwalas were waiting for the offer letter in writing from Mr Lew’s lawyers. I shall therefore consider the subsequent events first by reference to the Nargolwalas and then the Lews.
Events subsequent to 11 October 2017 – the Nargolwalas
- [74]
[74] Mr Nargolwala responded to Mr Meury in relation to the third e-mail:
- [75]
[75] Mr Meury responded:
- [76]
[76] Three matters flow from these e-mails. First, Mr Nargolwala was anticipating steps being taken by Mr Lew during the course of the next few days to progress matters.
- [77]
[77] Second Mr Meury’s understanding was that the Nargolwalas wanted the matter to be handled by Singapore lawyers and that the role of Mr Anurag was to assist in any queries. This explains the brief reference to him in the second e-mail set out in [52] above.
- [78]
[78] The reason for this is that Mr Anurag had at all times acted on behalf of the Andara Resort. He had acted jointly for the Resort and the Nargolwalas on the purchase of Villa 29 and may have done the same in relation to Villa 8. He had also assisted the Nargolwalas in obtaining some necessary documents from the Thai authorities. He thus had intimate knowledge of the way in which dealings with properties at the Resort were conducted and was therefore the appropriate person for any lawyer responsible for a transfer of ownership of a property to discuss any queries with.
- [79]
[79] It was suggested that in fact the Nargolwalas had appointed Mr Anurag to act on their behalf on the possible sale to Mr Lew. This was not so. Mr Lew and his in-house lawyer apparently did and I shall consider this at [100] below.
- [80]
[80] Third, Mr Meury did indeed pass some documents in relation to Villa 29 to Mr Lew. Some of these documents were documents held by the Resort but others were obtained by the Property Estate Manager, Khun Koy, from Villa 8. The Nargolwalas were unaware what documents had been passed over and did not authorise the documents from their villa to be removed. This was an occasion where Mr Meury unilaterally acted as he thought to be in the best interests of the parties but which possibly contributed to a further measure of misunderstanding between them.
- [81]
[81] On the evening of 11 October 2017, Mr Zeman came on the scene. News obviously travels fast at the Andara Resort because he sent an e-mail to Mr Nargolwala saying:
- [82]
[82] Mr Nargolwala responded from New York after his telephone conversation with his wife in which he had persuaded her that if all other matters were sorted out to their satisfaction, the price was acceptable to them. He said:
- [83]
[83] Mr Zeman then sent a further e-mail early in the morning, Hong Kong time, on 12 October 2017 which reads:
- [84]
[84] Mr Nargolwala was cross-examined on these e-mails. He emphasised that he had agreed to consider selling at that price and that he would not push for a higher price if all the caveats such as what “net”, and “in your account” meant were cleared up.
- [85]
[85] Mr Nargolwala did telephone Mr Meury on his return to Singapore. This was around 14 October 2017. In para 42 of his first AEIC he lists the matters which were discussed namely:
(a) The price was in principle acceptable subject to the other terms being acceptable to both sides.
(b) His Singapore lawyers were to act on his behalf and would do so when there was more clarity on the terms Mr Lew had in mind.
(c) Mr Lew’s lawyers should get in touch with him so that he could put them in touch with his lawyers.
(d) When he might expect to hear from Mr Lew’s lawyers.
- [86]
[86] Mr Meury did not dispute this and Mr Nargolwala’s cross-examination on the issues raised in this paragraph was consistent with his written evidence.
- [87]
[87] So far as the Nargolwalas are concerned, by 14 October 2017 they considered that the ball was firmly in Mr Lew’s court. He was to instruct Singapore lawyers to act on his behalf, they were to contact the Nargolwalas’ lawyers to clarify the terms of his offer and they were to be kept informed of progress.
- [88]
[88] Thereafter not a great deal happened so far as the Nargolwalas are concerned. On 17 October 2017, Mr Meury sent an e-mail to Mr Nargolwala saying that he had not heard back from Mr Lew but that he had been assured by Mr Lew that he would do so as soon as Mr Lew returned to Melbourne. Mr Meury asked Mr Nargolwala to let him have his bank account details and contact details of his lawyers because Mr Nargolwala was about to leave for Delhi. Mr Nargolwala responded:
- [89]
[89] Mr Meury replied on the following day saying that he understood and would keep Mr Nargolwala informed once he heard back from Mr Lew. Mrs Nargolwala’s mother sadly passed away on 20 October 2017 in Delhi.
- [90]
[90] The next communications between Mr Nargolwala and Mr Meury are said to have taken place by text messages on or about 23 or 24 October 2017 when Mr Nargolwala was still in Delhi. An undated exchange of texts between the two was disclosed on discovery. Mr Nargolwala wrote:
- [91]
[91] Mr Meury replied saying:
- [92]
[92] Mr Nargolwala responded by saying that it would be good to get his lawyers’ name so that “we can start the process in Singapore”.
- [93]
[93] The authenticity of this text chain was disputed by the Plaintiff. It was said that it had not been produced voluntarily and did not look like a regular WhatsApp chain. Mr Nargolwala gave evidence that he no longer had a copy of the messages since it was his practice to delete text messages at regular intervals. He recalls that he contacted Mr Meury to make sure that Mr Lew had not passed something on to Mr Meury which Mr Meury had inadvertently forgotten to pass on.
- [94]
[94] I accept this evidence and it ties in with text messages sent by Mr Meury to Mr Lew. The first, on 23 October 2017, asked whether Mr Lew or his lawyer needed any further information with regard to Villa 29. Mr Lew responded indicating that he was then with his lawyer. The following day Mr Meury texted again saying that the owner was “asking on any news … as he has not heard from us for 10 days”.
- [95]
[95] Taking all these matters into account I conclude that the WhatsApp exchange at 1AB2 is authentic.
- [96]
[96] The next communication between Mr Meury and Mr Nargolwala was on 27 October 2017 when Mr Meury e-mailed to say:
- [97]
[97] In fact the reference to funds being deposited in Hong Kong was incorrect but there is no need to dwell on the reasons for this. This was followed later the following day by a further e-mail from Mr Meury’s personal assistant giving contact details of Mr Lew’s lawyers but the name given was of a Thai lawyer with DLA Piper (Thailand) and not a lawyer in Singapore as had been requested.
- [98]
[98] Mr Nargolwala is unsure whether he read these e-mails whilst still in Delhi or on his return to Singapore the next day. On reading them, he concluded that Mr Lew was not a serious buyer and this is confirmed by Mrs Nargolwala. Mr Nargolwala was cross-examined at some length on this evidence. He explained why, even on receipt of the details of the Thai lawyer, he concluded that Mr Lew was not a serious buyer and that any potential deal with him was dead because none of the requests which he understood had been made to Mr Lew by Mr Meury had been followed through and that he, Mr Nargolwala, had been very patient waiting for 14 days and nothing had been done. He presumed (correctly as it turned out, see [120]–[122]) that Mr Lew’s late action in appointing a Thai lawyer had been caused by his knowledge that a new potential purchaser had come on the scene. The upshot was that he gave cogent reasons for reaching the conclusion that Mr Lew was not a serious buyer and someone that he no longer wished to transact with. I am satisfied that this was the Nargolwalas’ states of mind after receipt of the e-mails of Friday, 27 October 2017 (see also [140] below).
- [99]
[99] On 5 November 2017, Mr Meury once again contacted Mrs Nargolwala when she informed him that since Mr Lew had failed to proceed within his own timeline they were no longer interested in dealing with him and Mrs Nargolwala recollects that she spoke to Mr Zeman along the same lines. Mr Meury’s evidence is that he told Mr Lew this and then reverted to Mrs Nargolwala to ask whether she would still be interested in dealing with Mr Lew and she said that she would not.
- [100]
[100] In any event, that information was also relayed to Mr Anurag, who had been in communication with DLA Piper (Thailand), who sent an e-mail on 7 November 2017 to them saying that his client had instructed him to put the matter on hold. There was some dispute as to whether the client in question was the Nargolwalas or the Resort or both. I do not consider that anything turns on this, but it is clear that DLA Piper (Thailand) thought that Mr Anurag was acting on behalf of the vendors as an e-mail was sent to Mr Stephen Kenmar (Mr Lew’s senior in-house lawyer) on 7 November 2017 informing him that “the vendor” had instructed Mr Anurag to put the matter on hold. Mr Kenmar responded on 8 November 2017 saying that he was seeking instruction but that “[i]n the interim, it would probably be prudent to place everything on hold”.
- [101]
[101] It was this information that caused Mr Lew to write the e-mail to Mr Zeman referred to at [20] above. It is a thoroughly intemperate and offensive e-mail which was plainly written in anger. It is however helpful in identifying Mr Lew’s state of mind with regard to the alleged oral agreement as at 7 November 2017 and I shall therefore return to consider it further below.
- [102]
[102] It is apparent that Mr Zeman then became involved because he sent an e-mail to the Nargolwalas on 9 November 2017 saying that he had been receiving calls to see if they had made any further decisions and Mr Nargolwala replied:
- [103]
[103] The previous day, on 8 November 2017, the Nargolwalas and Mr Larpin entered a Reservation Agreement which gave Mr Larpin exclusivity until 30 November 2017.
- [104]
[104] Before considering the history of the dealings between the Nargolwalas and Mr Larpin, I shall step back in time to consider the events post 11 October 2017 from Mr Lew’s point of view.
Events subsequent to 11 October 2017 – Mr Lew
- [105]
[105] On 12 October 2017 before Mr Lew left Phuket, Mr Meury gave him the documents referred to above.
- [106]
[106] It is Mr Meury’s evidence that he informed Mr Lew at this meeting that he should pass the documents to his lawyer in Singapore but he also gave him Mr Anurag’s contact details.
- [107]
[107] This is consistent with contemporaneous documents being his e-mail to Mr Nargolwala referred to in [75] above as well as a text message sent to Mr Lew on 16 October 2017 in which Mr Meury enquires when he might hear from Mr Lew “or [his] lawyer in Singapore about the next step” [emphasis added]. Mr Lew however disputes that he was told this and undoubtedly formed the view that the reference to Mr Anurag was an indication that the Nargolwalas intended to instruct him in relation to the transaction and thus that Mr Lew should also appoint a Thai lawyer. The reference to a Singapore lawyer in the text message of 16 October 2017 did not serve to alert Mr Lew to the misunderstanding.
- [108]
[108] They also had a discussion about the commission that the Andara Resort might be receiving on the sale. This is a continuation of the “Chocolates to Switzerland” incident referred to in [25] above. Both Mr Lew and Mr Meury recall this discussion but their accounts of it in their AEICs differ. Mr Lew recalls that Mr Meury had indicated that matters relating to commission were in the hands of Mr Zeman and that any sum which he, Mr Meury, might receive was up to Mr Zeman. Mr Meury recalls that he said that any agency fees that might be payable to the Resort would be paid directly to the Resort but that there would be no commission because the Resort was not acting as an agent.
- [109]
[109] Both parties are however agreed that Mr Lew indicted that he would pay Mr Meury the sum of US$100,000 as a thank-you for his efforts on Mr Lew’s behalf. Accordingly, when Mr Meury handed the documents to Mr Lew, he also gave him details of a Swiss bank account into which any sums which Mr Lew was minded to pay to Mr Meury could be transferred (hence the reference to “Chocolates to Switzerland”).
- [110]
[110] In cross-examination, Mr Lew said that the offer was not part of commission due to Mr Meury but was offered as a gift. In the witness box, whilst giving evidence-in-chief, Mr Meury clarified that there was no sales agency agreement with the Resort for the sale of Villa 29 and repeated this in cross-examination. Indeed, as General Manager Mr Meury would be expected to know whether or not an agency agreement was in place and I therefore accept his evidence that he told Mr Lew that there was no commission agreement in place between the Nargolwalas and the Andara Resort. However, I also accept that Mr Lew certainly thought that Mr Meury and Mr Zeman were acting on behalf of the Nargolwalas in some way.
- [111]
[111] I also accept Mr Lew’s evidence that the subject of the sum of any payment to Mr Meury was not raised until after the alleged oral agreement was “made” on 11 October 2017 and that Mr Lew’s offer was the offer of a gift to express his gratitude and was not in the form of commission for acting on Mr Lew’s behalf.
- [112]
[112] Mr Lew then left Phuket to travel to Malaysia and Singapore before returning to Melbourne. He did not send the documents on in advance. He returned to Melbourne on Monday, 16 October 2017. On that day he received the text message referred to above from Mr Meury asking that he be informed either by Mr Lew or his lawyers in Singapore about the next step in the sale of Villa 29. Mr Lew replied that he had just arrived home and was onto it.
- [113]
[113] Mr Lew’s AEIC indicated that he immediately instructed his in-house lawyers on receiving the documents. This was not the case. He only did so on his return to Melbourne. His evidence was that he probably did this in the middle of the week after his return. He was intending that Mr Kenmar should be responsible for overseeing the transaction but Mr Kenmar was away from the office having had an operation. It appears that the documents were handed to another lawyer, Ms Hannah Hopper, with instructions to hand them on to Mr Kenmar on his return.
- [114]
[114] In any event, by 19 October 2017, his lawyers had turned their attention to the matter because Mr Lew sent a text to Mr Meury with an enquiry from his lawyers as to where the share certificates were located and Mr Meury responded that they were in Singapore with the owners. On Monday, 23 October 2017, Mr Meury texted Mr Lew to ask whether he or his lawyer needed any further information to receive the response that he was currently with his lawyers. Mr Meury followed this up with a further text indicating that the owner was “asking on any news … as he has not heard from us for 10 days” to which, apparently there was no response.
- [115]
[115] On 26 October 2017 Mr Meury again sought information from Mr Lew saying that “as it is already 2 weeks tomorrow … the present owners expect to hear from us tomorrow” to which Mr Lew replied that he would “check with [his] in house counsel in the morning. I was led to believe we are all set for settlement!”
- [116]
[116] In fact that was not the case. It was not until 24 October 2017 that Mr Kenmar approached a law firm in Thailand, Siam Law, that had worked with him before, by e-mail with a view to instructing them. In that e-mail Mr Kenmar stated:
- [117]
[117] Having received no response, on 25 and 27 October 2017 Mr Kenmar sent follow up e-mails. He received a response on Friday 27 October 2017 saying that Siam Law would do a conflicts check and get back on the following Monday. Late on the Monday they responded confirming that they were free to act but Mr Kenmar informed them that he had been forced to retain another law firm because:
- [118]
[118] The other law firm was DLA Piper (Thailand). That firm was first approached by Mr Kenmar on Friday, 27 October 2017, by an e-mail which contained much the same details as in the e-mail to Siam Law referred to above but which contained the sentence:
- [119]
[119] On the Friday and over the weekend the necessary conflicts check were carried out which involved a long e-mail from Mr Kenmar. The following extracts should be noted:
- [120]
[120] There is no record that Mr Meury (or indeed the Nargolwalas) advised Mr Lew on Friday 27 October 2017 that if the lawyer’s name was not supplied, the sale would not proceed. What did happen was that late in the evening of 26 October 2017 Mr Meury sent a text to Mr Lew:
- [121]
[121] It was on the 26th that Mr Larpin was first shown Villa 29 by Mr Martin Phillips. Mr Lew’s answers in cross-examination on this aspect were not wholly convincing when compared with the contemporaneous documents. He sought to suggest that the information with regard to a new offer was probably “deal talk”, that he did not feel there was any special urgency because he had a deal and that he had told the legal department at the outset that he wanted the job done quickly. The fact is that he did not speak to his legal department until the middle of the week beginning on 16 October 2017, his legal department first became involved on the 19th, no attempt was made to instruct a Thai law firm until the 24th and no law firm actually confirmed its ability to act until after receipt of Mr Kenmar’s e-mail sent over the weekend of the 28/29th. It was this e-mail which included the words in bold “there is considerable urgency in completing this purchase".
- [122]
[122] Mr Kenmar did not give evidence but the documents lead to the conclusion that Mr Lew was stirred into action by the suggestion that there was another offer and sought to instil a measure of urgency into the lawyers which had not previously been the case. In any event on the 27th Mr Lew did pass his Thai lawyers’ name to Mr Meury who passed it on to the Nargolwalas.
- [123]
[123] There was then, apparently, some communications between DLA Piper (Thailand) and Mr Anurag on 31 October 2017 but there are no details in the papers and neither Mr Anurag nor any lawyer from DLA Piper (Thailand) gave evidence. In a text message on the 31st Mr Lew told Mr Meury that his lawyers had told him that Mr Anurag was “waiting for instructions from the owner”. There is no record that Mr Anurag ever did contact the Nargolwalas for instructions.
- [124]
[124] On 3 November 2017 Mr Lew told Mr Meury that Mr Zeman had expressed disappointment that the contract had not been received from the vendor but save for this nothing of substance appears to have happened so far as Mr Lew is concerned until the Lews entertained Mr Meury to lunch on Sunday, 5 November 2017. During lunch, Mr Meury told Mr Lew that he had instructed the wrong lawyers since the Nargolwalas wanted to use Singapore lawyers and Mr Lew was prepared to do this.
- [125]
[125] It appears however that Mr Meury did not convey to Mr Lew on 5 November 2017 the substance of his telephone calls with Mrs Nargolwala on that day where she informed him that they were no longer interested in dealing with Mr Lew (see [99] above) as Mr Lew sent text messages and e-mails to Mr Zeman and Mr Meury on 7 November 2017 saying that he had appointed lawyers in Singapore and that his Thai lawyers had been unsuccessfully trying to obtain the contract from the Nargolwalas’ lawyers. This chain of messages ended with one to Mr Meury confirming that:
- [126]
[126] It is noteworthy that whilst Mr Lew refers to the expenses which have been incurred, he does not say that the Nargolwalas should not be dealing with another buyer because of a concluded contract with Mr Lew. It is no doubt this text which caused Mr Zeman to contact the Nargolwalas on 9 November 2017 (see [102] above).
- [127]
[127] On the same day Mr Lew sent the e-mail to Mr Zeman referred to in [101] above. This reads:
- [128]
[128] I have set this out in full since, again, it reflects Mr Lew’s thinking at the time. He was plainly very angry with Mrs Nargolwala but the one thing he does not say is that the Nargolwalas should not be entertaining a further offer since there was a concluded contract with him. Instead he refers to her duty to prepare “the contract of sale as agreed” and “she has never furnished us with a contract so that we could settle 14 days from receipt of contract”.
- [129]
[129] On 11 November 2017 Mr Meury spoke to Mr Lew on the telephone which was followed by a long text message from Mr Lew which reads:
- [130]
[130] This was followed by e-mails from Mr Lew to Mr Zeman on 13 November 2017 reiterating the points already made. Finally, on 14 November 2017, for the first time, Mr Lew contacted Mr Nargolwala directly by e-mail. The text of this e-mail is important as it was received on the very day that the SPA between the Nargolwalas and Mr Larpin (through Quo Vadis) was signed.
- [131]
[131] I shall have to consider the text of this e-mail in more detail when considering the events of 14 November 2017 involving the Nargolwalas, Mr Larpin and Mrs Te Lagger but first shall consider the history of the dealings between the Nargolwalas and Mr Larpin which led to the signing of the SPA on 14 November 2017.
Dealings between Mr Larpin and the Nargolwalas
- [132]
[132] In the early evening of 24 October 2017, Mr Larpin, who was then in Koh Samui, phoned Mr Martin Phillips (“Martin”), having previously phoned the offices of Phillips Property to obtain Martin’s contact details. Mr Larpin was interested in purchasing property in Phuket as an investment and had found details of some potentially suitable villas on the Phillips Property website.
- [133]
[133] They discussed some possible villas including Villa 11 at the Andara Resort. Mr Larpin then made arrangements to travel to Phuket the following day. In the meantime Martin contacted his brother, Mr Lyndon Phillips (“Lyndon”), then still the General Sales Manager at the Andara Resort (his last day in this position was 26 October 2017), to ask which villas were still available and was told that Villas 11 and 29 were available and that Lyndon could obtain access to both the following day.
- [134]
[134] On 25 October 2017 Martin and Mr Larpin considered a number of villas and viewed Villa 11 and Villa 29 with Lyndon. During the viewing of the latter Lyndon mentioned that he had heard that another party was interested in buying Villa 29 but that he had not been involved in any discussions and he may have said that they were being conducted directly through Mr Meury and, possibly, Mr Zeman. Mr Larpin did not enquire further.
- [135]
[135] On 26 October 2017 Mr Larpin e-mailed Martin to seek further details of both villas and Martin responded with some of the information and indicated that he hoped to have all the documents requested by the following Sunday. The e-mail contained the following passage:
In cross-examination Mr Larpin confirmed that he did not follow up with Martin about that paragraph.
- [136]
[136] The discussions between Martin and Mr Nargolwala are evidenced by a number of e-mails passing between them on the 26th. Two comments from Martin should be noted:
- [137]
[137] On Saturday 28 October 2017 Martin spoke again to Mr Larpin when Mr Larpin said that he remained keen to make offers in respect of both villas. They discussed the way forward which Martin said would first involve the signing of a Reservation Agreement and a copy of a draft of such an agreement was e-mailed to Mr Larpin who, in response, indicated that he might make an offer on both villas and that the matter would be handled by Mrs Te Lagger.
- [138]
[138] Martin then met with the Nargolwalas on Sunday 29 October 2017 in Singapore. Mr Nargolwala’s account of the meeting was not disputed by Martin as being accurate. The gist of Mr Nargolwala’s account was that he wanted a “clean and swift deal” which would leave him with at least US$7m after deduction of any commission. He mentioned that another potential buyer “not too long ago made an offer to purchase the Villa but failed to follow up properly because … that potential buyer failed [to] act with diligence … as a result of this, we concluded that he was not a serious buyer ...”.
- [139]
[139] Mr Nargolwala was cross-examined on this in a passage which ends with Mr Nargolwala saying “It was an offer that was never accepted, never followed up by any documentation. As far as I was concerned, it was dead.”
- [140]
[140] It is however to be remembered that on 27 October 2017, Mr Nargolwala had been informed by Mr Meury that Mr Lew had appointed lawyers in Thailand. But, as indicated in [98] above, I have accepted that even on receipt of the details of the Thai lawyer, the Nargolwalas had concluded that Mr Lew was not a serious buyer and the evidence relating to the meeting with Martin on 29 October 2017 is consistent with this.
- [141]
[141] Matters then proceeded in a conventional manner. The Nargolwalas entered a Fee Arrangement Agreement with Martin which provided for the payment of a commission of 7% of the sale price if this was equal to or above US$7.5m and thereafter the deal proceeded on the basis of an offer by Mr Larpin in the sum of US$7.9m.
- [142]
[142] Following the ironing out of some details, which was facilitated by direct communications between Mrs Te Lagger and Mr Nargolwala, a Reservation Agreement dated 8 November 2017 was entered into by the Nargolwalas and Quo Vadis and a 10% deposit was paid to the Nargolwalas’ solicitors, Lee & Lee, as a stakeholder. The Reservation Agreement gave Quo Vadis exclusivity until 30 November 2017 and the deposit was paid on the basis that the shares in Querencia were to be acquired “on a debt free basis, and free from any encumbrance” (see Clause 1.1).
- [143]
[143] The necessary due diligence was then carried out and the transaction documents prepared and agreed. The SPA was signed by Mr Nargolwala in Singapore and was taken by Mrs Nargolwala to Phuket where it was signed by Mrs Nargolwala and by Mrs Te Lagger on behalf of Quo Vadis late in the afternoon of 14 November 2017. The following provisions of the SPA should be noted:
- [144]
[144] On that same afternoon, Mr Zeman sent Mr Nargolwala an e-mail the text of which reads:
- [145]
[145] Mr Nargolwala then spoke to Mr Zeman, he thinks at around 6.00 or 7.00pm. Mr Nargolwala recalls that Mr Zeman tried to assure him that he would speak to Mr Lew and “try to manage him” and that he told Mr Zeman that Mr Lew’s claims were baseless and that he should really be blaming himself for failing to act with due diligence. Consistent with this, in cross-examination, he said that Mr Zeman had said:
- [146]
[146] Later that evening Mr Nargolwala received the e-mail from Mr Lew the text of which I have set out in [130] above.
- [147]
[147] Mr Nargolwala, in his AEIC, states that it was clear to him that Mr Lew was trying to bully his way through to get him to abandon the deal with Mr Larpin and sell Villa 29 to him instead. On receipt he telephoned his wife to ask her to contact Mr Meury to find out exactly what happened between him and Mr Lew because he was surprised that Mr Lew should consider that Mr Meury was the Nargolwalas’ agent.
- [148]
[148] Mrs Nargolwala then spoke to Mr Meury who told her that he had communicated with Mr Lew mainly by text messages and that he would share the relevant text messages with her. He did this on 15 November 2017. These messages appear at 1AB/1 and 1AB/2 and constitute only a very few of the messages that passed between them but do indicate that Mr Meury was pressing Mr Lew to appoint a lawyer between 23 and 27 October 2017 and that this information had been passed on to Mr Nargolwala. In cross-examination, Mr Nargolwala was asked why he did not pass on the documents to Mr Larpin and said that he did not consider it appropriate to do so since they merely showed that Mr Meury was getting concerned as the 14 days’ deadline was approaching and that Mr Lew’s assurances were not resulting in any action.
- [149]
[149] On the morning of 15 November 2017, Mrs Nargolwala had breakfast with Mr Larpin, Mrs Te Lagger and Martin at which Mrs Nargolwala indicated that an issue might have arisen with Villa 29 and it was agreed that Mr Larpin and Mrs Te Lagger would speak to Mr Nargolwala about this later in the day. A telephone call then took place between Mr Nargolwala in Singapore and Mrs Nargolwala, Mr Larpin and Mrs Te Lagger in Phuket. A good deal of evidence was adduced in relation to this phone conversation and the parties’ reactions to it.
- [150]
[150] Whilst Mr Nargolwala cannot now recall whether or not he forwarded the e-mail from Mr Lew on 14 November 2017 to his wife, the other parties have no recollection that he did. Both Mr Larpin and Mrs Te Lagger said that they did not see the e-mail at this time and I accept their evidence. In cross-examination the substance of what Mr Nargolwala recalls he said is contained in the following extracts.
- [151]
[151] Mrs Nargolwala confirmed this. Mr Larpin in his AEIC stated at para 46(2):
- [152]
[152] In a long passage of cross-examination, Mr Larpin repeated the fact that he had been told that Mr Nargolwala had received a threatening and vexatious e-mail, that he had concluded that Mr Nargolwala was a “fit and proper gentleman” and that he chose to believe Mr Nargolwala. From what he had heard from Mr Nargolwala he regarded the e-mail as being an attempt at blackmail. Mrs Te Lagger’s evidence supported this. He went on to say that Mr Nargolwala offered to “abort the deal” but that he decided to, and indeed felt obliged to, complete the deal.
- [153]
[153] Accordingly, completion did take place on 16 November 2017 in Singapore as required by the SPA, being two days after the SPA was signed, when the share transfer, the share certificates and the letters of resignation were all handed over. Thereafter Mrs Te Lagger in her capacity as director of Quo Vadis authorised the necessary alterations in respect of the shareholders and directors of Querencia to be made in the BVI.
- [154]
[154] This litigation then ensued as did litigation in the BVI in which a stop notice in respect of the shareholding in Querencia together with an interlocutory injunction to restrain any dealings in those shares was obtained.
The issues
- [155]
[155] On the basis of that factual background, I can now turn to consider the issues that arise in this case.
Issue 1: Proper law
- [157]
[157] Somewhat surprisingly, having regard to the fact that at all times in their dealings both with Mr Lew and Mr Larpin the Nargolwalas had insisted on using Singapore lawyers and that the agreements that were reached with Quo Vadis were all expressly governed by the law of Singapore, counsel for the Nargolwalas contended that the proper law was Thai law. This became less surprising after evidence of Thai law was adduced which gives rise to an argument that a binding oral contract is potentially less easy to enforce under Thai law than it would be under Singapore law.
- [158]
[158] It is settled law that the principles to be applied in seeking to determine what is the proper law is the lex fori, in this case Singapore law. Those principles are well developed in relation to the case where there is no dispute that a binding contract exists but where there is no choice of law clause contained in the contract.
- [159]
[159] In JIO Minerals FZC and others v Mineral Enterprises Ltd [2011] SLR 391 (“JIO Minerals”) at [79] the Court of Appeal set out the following principles:
- [160]
[160] The position is less clear however where the question to be answered is whether a binding contract was actually entered into by the parties in the first place. Applying the three-stage approach introduces an element of circularity in that it involves first trying to ascertain what the governing law would have been if a contract had been made and then applying that law to determine whether it has in fact been made. This has led to some commentators to suggest that no attempt should be made to apply the three-stage approach and that the more appropriate course is simply to apply the lex fori to answer the question.
- [162]
[162] Having considered the authorities and some learned articles relied upon by the parties (Yeo Tiong Min, Private International Law: Law Reform in Miscellaneous Matters (unpublished); Tan Yock Lin, “Good Faith Choice of a Law to Govern a Contract” [2014] SJLS 307), I agree that there is a division of both judicial and academic opinion on the correct approach in circumstances such as the present case where the fundamental dispute between the parties is whether a contact was ever made. I do not however accept the submission made by counsel for the Plaintiff that the learned judge was deciding that the lex fori should apply in all cases where the existence of a contract was in dispute. As the judge makes clear she favoured the lex fori approach in such a case but also concluded that the same result would have been reached by adopting the putative proper law test. She was not seeking to lay down a hard and fast rule that the lex fori should apply in all cases where the existence of a contract was in issue. This would, to my mind, be to introduce an approach which constitutes too much of a blunt instrument to serve the interests of justice. There will be cases where it is the appropriate course to take, as in the Pegaso case, but there will be others where the facts are sufficiently clear that justice can better be done by approaching the matter by reference to the three-stage test in JIO Minerals, with necessary adjustments to take into account that there is the fundamental dispute as to the existence of the contract in the first place.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.