Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 31 Aug 2020

Singapore International Commercial Court

Sheila Kazzaz and another v Standard Chartered Bank and others

Feedback & support

[2020] SGHC(I) 19Case no. Suit No 4 of 20189 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Discussion

  3. The application of Clause 14.1

  4. [5] Clause 14.1 stipulates:

  5. [6] The Plaintiffs submit that Clause 14.1 does not cover the situation where (as was the case here) the Defendants are sued by a client in respect of circumstances leading to the taking up of banking services. I am unable to agree.

  6. [7] By Clause 14.1 the Plaintiffs agreed to compensate the Defendants on “a full indemnity basis” for “all Losses which [the Defendants] may suffer as a result of or in connection with the operation or provision of the Account(s), Facilities, Transactions and Services whether incurred directly or indirectly”. The present action essentially concerned the Plaintiffs’ complaints about the way in which the Defendants operated the Plaintiffs’ Accounts, Facilities, and Transactions and the way in which the Defendants provided services in respect of those matters. The Plaintiffs alleged that, when providing services, the Defendants negligently misled the Plaintiffs about the scope, nature and suitability of the same for the Plaintiffs’ needs. On its terms, Clause 14.1 does not distinguish between services and advice rendered by the Defendants before or after the Plaintiffs took up a banking product or entered into a particular transaction. Clause 14.1 thus applies where (as here) the Defendants have incurred loss (in the form of legal expenses and disbursements) as a result of defending themselves against the Plaintiffs’ wrongful allegations about the way in which the Defendants’ went about providing their advice and services. The Defendants are consequently entitled to be indemnified in full for their legal fees and disbursements under Clause 14.1.

  7. The application of Appendix G

  8. [11] The Defendants have put forward the following as special factors: (1) Clause 14.1; (2) the need to deal with questions of DIFC law; (3) the fact that the Plaintiffs’ allegations spanned events and issues involving Singapore, Dubai, the UK, Guernsey, the Cayman Islands, Jersey, France and Iraq; and (4) the fact that one of the four Defendants was no longer employed by the 1st Defendant. I do not find factor (4) to be a compelling basis for departing from Appendix G. However, in my view, the fact that Clause 14.1 entitles the Defendants to a “full indemnity” (that is, factor (1)) and the complexities arising from factors (2) and (3) sufficiently justify a departure from the S$512,400 posited by Appendix G to the extent of the S$1.1m claimed by the Defendants.

  9. [12] There is an additional factor which I believe ought to be taken into account. I should also have regard to the fact that, right through the trial and until just before their initial round of closing submissions, the Plaintiffs maintained that the Defendants were liable for fraudulent misrepresentation and exerting undue influence. This is despite (as I noted in [11] of my previous judgment) there being “no evidence whatsoever that the Defendants, whether individually or collectively, had acted in a fraudulent manner or had exerted undue influence on either of the Plaintiffs”. In short, the allegations of fraud should never have been made in the first place. The Defendants’ reputations being at stake as a result of the Plaintiffs’ unwarranted allegations, it was reasonable and hardly surprising that the Defendants would vigorously defend themselves and thereby incur much more in legal fees than the levels envisaged by Appendix G.

  10. [13] That leaves disbursements. The Defendants claim the following as disbursements:

  11. (a) Disbursements in relation to the airfare and hotel accommodation of the Defendants’ expert, Mr Bassem Snaije (“Mr Snaije”): S$5,814.14.

  12. (b) Disbursements & expenses in relation to AEIC notarisation and the trial (including travel and hotel expenses): AED88,844.73.

  13. (c) Disbursements & expenses incurred by the Defendants’ DIFC law counsel, Mr Michael Black QC: £398.02.

  14. (d) Professional fees of Mr Snaije: £178,134.21. This comprises:

  15. (i) Review of documents and preparation of expert report: £88,540.

  16. (ii) Review of documents, including the expert report of the Plaintiffs’ expert Dr Thomas Walford (“Dr Walford”), and preparation of a supplementary expert report: £70,394.21

  17. (iii) Preparation for and attendance at trial and travel to and from Singapore: £19,200.

  18. (e) Disbursements and expenses in relation to the notarisation of the AEIC of Mr Clive Harrison and his giving of evidence by video: US$4,336.83 + £140.

  19. (f) Miscellaneous expenses: photocopying and printing fees S$32,178.60; other filing and transmission fees S$973.00; transportation fees S$8,082.87; telephone and fax fees S$3,399.31; interpretation and translation fees S$618; attestation fees S$840; postage, mail delivery and courier fees S$275.06; transcription fees S$17,970.70; court hearing fees S$15,800; SICC video conferencing fees S$250; incidentals and others S$7,964.94.

  20. [14] The foregoing items add up to S$113,177.12, £178,672.23, AED88,844.73 and US$4,336.83. The Plaintiffs say that I should only allow disbursements in the amounts of S$86,672.57, £90,538.02, AED88,844.73 and US$4,336.83. The dispute is accordingly in respect of the S$ and £ amounts.

  21. [16] I am not persuaded by the Plaintiffs’ contentions. For example, as the Defendants submit, the assumption that the Defendants would only make a single copy of the documents in the case is unrealistic. Multiple sets of documents were printed, given the number of defendants and lawyers (including DIFC counsel) involved. Further, there was also material requiring translation by the Defendants from Arabic into English. In relation to Mr Snaije, he did not only consider his own report, but also reviewed and commented on Dr Walford’s report. It seems to me that, taken in the round, the disbursements claimed by the Defendants are reasonable.

  22. The lack of success on certain issues

  23. The costs of certain interlocutory applications

  24. Miscellaneous

  25. Conclusion

  26. [21] The Plaintiffs are to bear the Defendants’ legal fees of S$1,100,000 and disbursements of S$113,177.12, £178,672.23, AED88,844.73, and US$4,336.83. Simple interest at 5.33% per annum is to run on all such amounts from the date of this Judgment until payment by the Plaintiffs.