Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 8 Oct 2020

Singapore International Commercial Court

[2020] SGHC(I) 21

Feedback & support

[2020] SGHC(I) 21Case no. Originating Summons No 1 of 20202 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Discussion

  3. Preliminary matters

  4. [3] At the outset, two issues need to be determined.

  5. [4] First, there is the question of the 20% discount on account of the alleged breach of ORC 559. These proceedings are not the appropriate forum for dealing with any alleged infraction of ORC 559. In particular, ORC 559 permitted the parties to publish details about the relevant arbitrations where “such disclosure ... falls within an exception to the obligation of confidentiality in arbitration under Singapore law”. According to the Defendants, any disclosure that they made fell squarely within an exception to the obligation of confidentiality under Singapore’s arbitration law. This court has not investigated the circumstances of the relevant incident. If the Plaintiffs are of the view that there has been a breach of ORC 559 which needs to be sanctioned in some way, they should take out an appropriate summons for that purpose.

  6. The Defendants’ reasonable costs

  7. (a) a Senior Counsel for 125 hours at S$1,100.00 per hour;

  8. (b) a Junior Counsel for 30 hours at S$820.00 per hour;

  9. (c) a second Junior Counsel for 34.77 hours at S$500.00 per hour until 31 December 2019 and 21.47 hours at S$540.00 per hour from 1 January 2020;

  10. (d) a third Junior Counsel for 64.53 hours at S$400.00 per hour until 31 December 2019 and 271.32 hours at S$440.00 hours per hour from 1 January 2020;

  11. (e) a fourth Junior Counsel for 137.42 hours at S$400.00 per hour;

  12. (f) a fifth Junior Counsel for 4.33 hours at S$350.00 per hour; and

  13. (g) a sixth Junior Counsel for 4 hours at S$360.00 per hour.

  14. In addition, the Defendants incurred disbursements of US$8,715.15 plus S$11,633.23, comprising:

  15. (a) Thai law expert fees of US$8,715.15;

  16. (b) attestation fees of S$30.00;

  17. (c) E-litigation fees of S$10,517.00;

  18. (d) over-time meals and transportation costs of S$480.31;

  19. (e) costs of overseas calls amounting to S$12.87;

  20. (f) photocopying costs of S$560.55;

  21. (g) transportation costs for court attendance amounting to S$28.00; and

  22. (h) costs of telephone calls amounting to S$4.50.

  23. I state at once that, as far as the disbursements are concerned, they seem to me reasonable and proportionate.

  24. (a) In contrast to the Plaintiffs’ legal representatives, the Defendants’ lawyers had not previously been involved in the underlying arbitrations. The Defendants’ lawyers therefore had to review the record and documents of two ICC arbitrations which were conducted in multiple phases over three years and resulted in seven awards, of which the Plaintiffs were seeking to set aside two in part and one in its entirety.

  25. (b) The Defendants’ lawyers had to keep abreast of proceedings in the ongoing ALRO arbitration. This was necessary to ensure that the Defendants’ conduct of these proceedings was in line with their position in the ALRO arbitration.

  26. (c) The Defendants had to contend with issues of Thai law, on which both parties tendered expert evidence. These Thai law issues included the treatment of compound interest under Thai law and whether the Thai court would recognise and enforce an award of compound interest in Thailand.

  27. (d) The Plaintiffs filed six affidavits in support of their setting aside application, one of which (inclusive of exhibits) ran to 3,135 pages. The Defendants filed two affidavits in response. One was by their Thai law expert (48 pages) and the other ran to 1,616 pages.

  28. The Plaintiffs replied on 14 February 2020 saying that the Defendants’ figure of S$60,000 was “unsubstantiated”. Nonetheless, “purely in the interests of saving time and costs,” the Plaintiffs offered S$25,000 by way of security. On 12 March 2020 the Defendants rejected the Plaintiffs’ proposed amount as “insufficient security”. The Plaintiffs said that, “in the interests of saving time and costs,” they would accept S$45,000 instead. On 17 March 2020, the Plaintiffs countered with S$40,000. By a letter dated 24 March 2020, the Defendants accepted the offer of S$40,000.

  29. In BYL v BYN (Costs) itself, I commented (at [13]) that I was hampered in assessing the defendant’s reasonable costs by the lack of detail in its cost submissions. I did not rule out the possibility that the defendant might be entitled to more by way of recovering its reasonable costs, if it had provided more information. In contrast, the Defendants here have provided fuller and more comprehensive details of their costs. The only additional information that might have been helpful would have been a schedule providing a breakdown of the hours spent by Senior and Junior Counsel by reference to the specific pre- and post-transfer activities in which they were engaged.

  30. Conclusion