Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 27 Aug 2021

Singapore International Commercial Court

CJM and others v CJT

Feedback & support

[2021] SGHC(I) 9Case no. Originating Summons No 5 of 20215 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Pre-transfer costs

  3. [3] Appendix G gives a guideline of S$12,000 per day for contentious originating summonses not involving cross-examination. But Appendix G allows the court a discretion to depart from that guideline when appropriate in the circumstances of the case.

  4. [6] I am unable to agree with the plaintiffs.

  5. [7] First, while the plaintiffs’ supporting factual affidavit only ran for 57 pages, the reality of the exhibits to the affidavit running to thousands of pages cannot be ignored. The plaintiffs must be assumed to have included such volume of material for a reason. Accordingly, conscientious Singapore counsel who had not been involved in the arbitration would have little option but to go through the exhibits, even if only to conclude, after consideration of the same, that much of the material was not actually relevant. It is unrealistic to expect defendant’s lawyers to have concluded, without taking the time to review the plaintiffs’ several thousands of pages of exhibits in depth, that the application was commonplace and unexceptional.

  6. Post-transfer costs

  7. [13] I am not persuaded that the S$45,000 claimed by the defendant is exorbitant.

  8. [15] I do not believe that the plaintiffs advanced arguments or allegations which were unwarranted in the sense of going beyond the normal cut and thrust of litigation. Nor do I think that the plaintiffs’ amendment application or its reliance on four setting aside grounds further complicated the proceedings. But my views on those matters do not detract from the hard reality that to discern what is relevant and what is not in a mass of several thousand pages requires considerable attention and thought on counsel’s part. In that context, S$45,000 for the work done by a Senior Counsel and his two assisting lawyers must be regarded as wholly reasonable.

  9. Conclusion