Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 19 December 2022
BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd and another v PT Bayan Resources TBK and another
Feedback & support[2022] SGHC(I) 17 · Case no. Suit No 1 of 2015 · 26 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background
- [2]
[2] The facts of this case have been comprehensively set out in our earlier judgments: see BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd and another v PT Bayan Resources TBK and another [2016] 4 SLR 1 (“First Judgment”); BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd and another v PT Bayan Resources TBK and another [2017] 5 SLR 77 (“Second Judgment”) and BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd and another v PT Bayan Resources TBK and another [2022] SGHC(I) 2 (“Third Judgment”). We will not rehearse them except to highlight salient points. Unless otherwise specified, the abbreviations defined in our earlier judgments have also been used here.
The parties
- [3]
[3] The second plaintiff, Binderless Coal Briquetting Company Pty Ltd (BCBC), is an Australian company that holds the exclusive worldwide licence of a technology for upgrading sub-bituminous coal into briquettes, known as the Binderless Coal Briquetting Process (the BCB Process). The first plaintiff, BCBC Singapore Pte Ltd (BCBCS), is a Singapore company. BCBC and BCBCS are indirect wholly-owned subsidiaries of White Energy Company Ltd (WEC), a public-listed company in Australia.
- [4]
[4] The first defendant, PT Bayan Resources TBK (BR), is a public-listed company in Indonesia that owns subsidiaries operating sub-bituminous coal mines in Tabang, Indonesia. The second defendant, Bayan International Pte Ltd (BI), is a Singapore company associated with BR.
The parties’ cases in SIC 1
- [5]
[5] In June 2006, BCBC and BI executed a joint venture deed (referred to in the First Judgment (at [16]) as “the JV Deed”). Pursuant to the JV Deed, the parties agreed to construct and commission a coal briquette processing plant in Tabang (referred to in the First Judgment (at [17]) as “the Tabang Plant”) to exploit the BCB Process and upgrade sub-bituminous coal into briquettes for commercial sale. The joint venture company, PT Kaltim Supacoal (KSC), was incorporated in Indonesia in January 2007, with BCBCS and BI holding 51% and 49% of its shares respectively. In October 2008, BI sold its shares in KSC to BR, as part of BR’s corporate restructuring. Then, in 2009, by way of a Deed of Novation, BCBCS and BR were substituted for BCBC and BI as the parties to the JV Deed. The identities of the parties to the JV Deed were thereafter aligned with the identities of the shareholders of KSC.
- [6]
[6] By November 2011, disagreements had arisen between BCBCS and BR in relation to the joint venture. In December 2011, the plaintiffs commenced an action in the High Court against the defendants for breach of their contractual obligations under the joint venture. On 4 March 2015, the action was transferred to the SICC and renumbered SIC/S 1/2015 (“SIC 1”).
- [7]
[7] The gist of the plaintiffs’ pleaded case was that BR was under an obligation to: (a) provide funding to KSC; and (b) procure the supply of coal by its Indonesian subsidiaries to KSC until the Tabang Plant was in a position to exploit the BCB Process on a commercial basis. The Tabang Plant would be in that position when it could produce approximately 1 million metric tonnes per annum (“MTPA”) of upgraded coal briquettes. The parties referred to this benchmark production capacity as “nameplate capacity”. BR acted in breach of those obligations and thereby wrongfully repudiated the JV Deed. The plaintiffs’ case was that but for BR’s breaches, the Tabang Plant would have achieved nameplate capacity by end-January 2012 or June 2012 at the latest. The plaintiffs sought to recover from the defendants the wasted expenditure that they had incurred as a result of the joint venture as well as damages for the loss of a chance to expand the production capacity of the Tabang Plant to 3 MTPA.
- [8]
[8] The defendants denied that BR was under any obligation to provide funding or procure the supply of coal to KSC and, in any event, the performance of the coal supply obligation had been rendered illegal by legislation passed by the Indonesian government which put in place benchmark prices for the sale of minerals and coals in Indonesia (referred to in the Third Judgment (at [8(d)]) as “the HBA Regulations”), relieving BR of any performance obligations. The defendants further denied that the Tabang Plant could have achieved nameplate capacity by end-January 2012 or June 2012, or at all, and so the joint venture would not have made any profits enabling the plaintiffs to recoup its alleged wasted expenditure. The defendants pleaded that the plaintiffs’ claim for damages for loss of a chance was flawed because there had never been an agreement between BR and BCBCS to expand the Tabang Plant’s capacity to 3 MTPA.
- [9]
[9] The defendants also contended that KSC would have been starved of the funding needed for the Tabang Plant to achieve nameplate capacity or expand production capacity to 3 MTPA. The defendants pleaded that, by November 2011, BR had informed BCBCS that it wished to liquidate KSC. BR would thus not have consented to further funding being provided to KSC by BCBCS and/or WEC. The defendants also denied that BCBCS or WEC were financially able to provide gift funding to KSC and, even if they could, such funding would have amounted to breach of duties owed by BCBCS’s and WEC’s directors under the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed) and/or the Australian Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The defendants additionally argued that the plaintiffs’ claims were barred by the rule against reflective loss as its alleged loss simply mirrored any loss or damage suffered by the joint venture company, KSC. Finally, the defendants counterclaimed that BCBCS had acted in breach of its implied obligations to use reasonable care and skill in providing technical assistance to KSC and procure that the Tabang Plant reach nameplate capacity within a reasonable period of time.
The proceedings
- [10]
[10] We will refer in this judgment to the three tranches of the litigation in SIC 1 as “Tranche 1”, “Tranche 2” and “Tranche 3”.
- [11]
[11] By agreement, the parties asked the court to decide in Tranche 1 issues concerning the parties’ contractual obligations without going into whether or not those obligations had been breached, leaving those and further issues to be decided in later tranches. In Tranche 1 (as set out in the First Judgment ([2] above)) we held, inter alia, that: (a) BR did not owe the funding obligations alleged by the plaintiffs; and (b) BCBCS was not under any of the implied obligations pleaded by the defendants. We therefore dismissed the defendants’ counterclaim. We found that there was insufficient evidence before the court to determine if BR owed the alleged coal supply obligation, but held that BR had not established that any such coal supply obligation had been made illegal by the HBA Regulations. There was no appeal against our decision in Tranche 1.
- [12]
[12] The extent of BR’s coal supply obligation, whether BR had breached that obligation and the other alleged breaches of the parties’ contractual obligations under the joint venture, were determined in Tranche 2. As set out in the Second Judgment ([2] above), we held that BR had breached its coal supply obligations and further, that this was a repudiation of the JV Deed. However, as it is not disputed that BCBCS did not purport to accept the breaches, BR’s repudiatory conduct in this regard had no legal effect. We also held that BR had wrongfully repudiated the JV Deed by issuing a notice to terminate the joint venture (referred to in the Second Judgment (at [64]) as “BR’s Termination Notice”) in February 2012. We found that BCBCS had, by way of a letter dated 2 March 2012, validly accepted the latter aspect of BR’s repudiatory conduct and so that brought the joint venture to an end on that date.
- [14]
[14] In Tranche 3, we dealt with damages and quantum. As set out in the Third Judgment ([2] above), we dismissed various preliminary legal objections raised by the defendants to the plaintiffs’ claimed losses. We also found, on the basis of extensive expert evidence, that the Tabang Plant would have achieved nameplate capacity by June 2012 at the latest. However, we found that BCBCS would not have recouped its wasted expenditure for two reasons. First, BR would have applied to wind up KSC before 2028. That would be long before 2037 which, on the evidence, was the earliest time when any positive return on the joint venture could be expected. It followed that the joint venture would never have had sufficient cash flow to enable BCBCS to recoup its wasted expenditure. Secondly, even if BR did not apply to wind up KSC, based on the evidence of the parties’ quantum experts, BCBCS’s likely cash flow from the joint venture would not have covered its alleged wasted expenditure. We dismissed the plaintiffs’ claim for damages for the loss of a chance because BR was not contractually obliged to expand the production capacity of the Tabang Plant to 3 MTPA. We also held that, in any event, BCBCS’s claim for damages for the loss of a chance would fail because the loss of a chance doctrine was inapplicable on the facts, since the contingency (the expansion of the Tabang Plant to 3 MTPA) would be based, not on the actions of an independent third party, but of BR itself (as the defendant against which the claim is made). The plaintiffs have appealed against our decision in Tranche 3.
The parties’ submissions on costs
How should costs be awarded in this case
The appropriate quantum of costs
The issues before the court
- [25]
[25] The following issues arise for determination:
(a) What approach should we adopt in the award of costs in this case?
(b) Applying that approach, what is the quantum of costs (if any) that the defendants should recover?
(c) What is the quantum of disbursements that the defendants should recover?
Issue 1: How should we award costs in this case
Costs under O 110 r 46(1)
Identifying the “successful party”
- [30]
[30] In determining the identity of the successful party, the court must look at the outcome of the litigation overall, in a realistic and commercially sensible way, asking which party in substance and reality won the litigation (see Comfort Management Pte Ltd v OGSP Engineering Pte Ltd and another [2022] SGHC 77 (“Comfort Management”) at [28], citing HLB Kidsons (A Firm) v Lloyds Underwriters subscribing to Lloyds Policy No 621/PKID00101 & Others [2007] EWHC 2699 (Comm) at [10]). As the English Court of Appeal has held in the context of the UK CPR, the key is to identify who is to pay money to whom (see A L Barnes Ltd v Time Talk (UK) Ltd [2003] EWCA Civ 402 at [28]).
- [31]
[31] Applying these principles, it cannot seriously be disputed that the defendants are the overall “successful party” in SIC 1, even though they failed on significant aspects of their defence and also in their counterclaim against the plaintiffs. The identification of the “successful party” in SIC 1 does not turn on the outcome of the individual tranches or the individual issues therein. Instead, the ultimate result of SIC 1 is that the plaintiffs failed in their claims for damages against the defendants and obtained nothing by their litigation.
The court’s discretion under O 110 r 46(1)
(1) Whether an issue-based approach can be adopted where an overall winner in the litigation can be identified
- [36]
[36] The plaintiffs submit that the present case additionally warrants the adoption of an issue-based approach because the defendants acted unreasonably and protracted the hearing of SIC 1 unnecessarily. The plaintiffs rely on, among other authorities, the High Court’s decision in Khng Thian Huat ([33] above), which considered O 59 r 6A of the ROC 2014, which in turn provides:
(2) Whether costs should be reduced
- [41]
[41] As noted above, the “international” and “commercial” nature of disputes before the SICC (see O 110 rr 1(2)(a) and 1(2)(b) of the ROC 2014) means that the parties who come before the SICC are generally commercially sophisticated and are better-resourced and better-advised than the run-of-the-mill litigant (see Lao Holdings NV ([27] above) at [56]). Further, “commercial” disputes before the SICC will generally involve larger amounts at stake, and as a result, parties would be willing to spend more on legal representation in pursuit of their commercial objectives (see Lao Holdings NV at [65]-[66]). This means that, generally, parties in the SICC are likely to adopt a more liberal approach to raising different claims or issues in the litigation, as compared to the average litigant coming before the High Court.
Whether and if so to what extent should the defendants’ costs be reduced?
- [47]
[47] In Tranche 1 and Tranche 2, the plaintiffs succeeded in establishing that BR was under an enforceable obligation to supply coal to KSC at the material time, and that BR was in breach of this obligation. The plaintiffs also succeeded in resisting the defendants’ defence that BR’s coal supply obligation was tainted by illegality under Indonesian law as a result of the HBA Regulations and hence unenforceable. These issues established the defendants’ liability for breach of their contractual obligations under the joint venture and were crucial and critical parts of the plaintiffs’ case in SIC 1. The plaintiffs also successfully defended themselves against the defendants’ counterclaim for BCBCS’s breach of its implied obligation under the joint venture.
- [48]
[48] In Tranche 3, the plaintiffs succeeded in resisting all preliminary legal objections that the defendants raised to the plaintiffs’ claim for damages and, importantly, succeeded in proving that the Tabang Plant would have achieved a production capacity of 1 MTPA (or nameplate capacity) by June 2012. The latter is a crucial fact on which the plaintiffs’ claim for wasted expenditure and damages for loss of a chance rested (see [7] above). The plaintiffs ultimately failed in their wasted expenditure claim because the defendants succeeded in proving that the wasted expenditure could not have been recovered in any event because BR would have applied to liquidate KSC and put the joint venture to an end before any profits would have been generated and because KSC’s likely cash flow from the joint venture would not have covered its wasted expenditure. The plaintiffs also failed on their loss of a chance claim because the defendants succeeded in establishing that the plaintiffs had no basis to claim for the loss of a chance in this case.
Issue 2: What is the quantum of the defendants’ recoverable costs
Pre-Transfer Costs
The parties’ calculations
Our decision
(1) The tariff to be applied
- [55]
[55] In this case, the parties agreed that electronic discovery was to take place in two stages. The first stage concerned the discovery of documents from KSC’s premises, and the second stage concerned the discovery of documents in the parties’ possession. At the time when SIC 1 was transferred, implementation of the first stage of the discovery plan was underway, while the parties were still finalising the discovery plan for the second stage. A significant portion of discovery work therefore remained to be done at the time SIC 1 was transferred to the SICC. However, it would appear that the discovery work that had been done up to that point was complicated. The first stage of the discovery plan involved more than 660 boxes of documents and hard drives containing approximately 30 terabytes of data. Its implementation took place in five phases. Even by November 2014 (that was about a year since the first stage of the discovery plan had commenced), the parties were only in phase three of five of implementing the first stage of the discovery plan. Thus, in our view, the complexity of the discovery-related work performed in the pre-transfer period justifies the use of the highest tariff of S$35,000.
(2) The uplift to be applied
- [56]
[56] We now turn to the issue of the appropriate uplift to be applied to the tariffs that we have identified, namely, S$18,000 for pleadings-related work and S$35,000 for discovery-related work.
- [58]
[58] In our view, for pleadings-related work, a slight uplift of S$2,000 is justified. We consider an overall figure of S$20,000 (S$18,000 + S$2,000) as sufficiently reflective of the complexity of the pleadings-related work undertaken during the pre-transfer period, bearing in mind that during the pre-transfer period, two sets of amendments had been made to the Statement of Claim, Defence & Counterclaim and the Reply to Defence & Counterclaim.
- [59]
[59] We have alluded to the complexity of the discovery-related work in the pre-transfer period (see [54] above), and we are of the view that it far exceeds the complexity of the discovery-related work likely to be undertaken in the ordinary construction, intellectual property, admiralty or medical negligence suits in the High Court. Even the highest tariff might not appropriately reflect such complexity and we therefore agree with the defendants that a significant uplift should be applied. However, we are of the view that a two times uplift should be applied instead of a three times uplift, especially since we have already adopted a higher tariff of S$35,000 instead of the S$28,000 proposed by the defendants.
Post-Transfer Costs
Conclusion on the quantum of costs that the defendants should recover
Issue 3: What is the quantum of the defendants’ recoverable disbursements
- [72]
[72] We therefore use the defendants’ figure of S$3,221,410.33 (which the plaintiffs have not challenged as unreasonable) as a starting point, to which a 40% discount is to be applied. The amount of disbursements that the defendants are entitled to recover is therefore S$1,932,846.20 (0.6 x S$3,221,410.33).
Conclusion
- [74]
[74] For ease of reference, we summarise the sums that the defendants are entitled to recover from the plaintiffs in the following table:
- [75]
[75] The plaintiffs are to pay simple interest on the aforementioned sums at a rate of 5.33% per annum, calculated from the date of this judgment until the date of payment.