Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 25 April 2022
Larpin, Christian Alfred and another v Kaikhushru Shiavax Nargolwala and another
Feedback & support[2022] SGHC(I) 7 · Case no. Suit No 3 of 2020 · 7 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] The judgment on the substantive issues in these proceedings, Larpin, Christian Alfred and another v Kaikhushru Shiavax Nargolwala and another [2022] SGHC(I) 4 (the “Main Judgment”), was given on 21 February 2022. This judgment assumes familiarity with the Main Judgment.
- [2]
[2] The proceedings were dismissed, and the Main Judgment concluded (at [218]):
(a) the plaintiffs having accepted that the price paid for the Villa was a proper price, the real reason for the proceedings must have been to obtain indemnity for the irrecoverable costs incurred in the Lew proceedings (Main Judgment at [9]); but in the light of the decision of the Court of Appeal in Maryani Sadeli v Arjun Permanand Samtani and another and other appeals [2015] 1 SLR 496 (“Maryani”), that endeavour was doomed to fail, and the plaintiffs “cannot seek to deny that they appreciated or otherwise ought to have appreciated the likelihood that the Suit constituted an abuse of process”;
(b) the plaintiffs had unreasonably declined to admit the facts in a Notice to Admit Facts dated 14 June 2021, whereby the defendants were needlessly required to deal with the facts in evidence; and
(c) the refusal to admit the facts was “indicative of the [generally] unreasonable manner in which the Plaintiffs’ case was conducted”. However, the defendants did not provide any further instances or explanation of the asserted general unreasonableness.
(a) the Calderbank letters were not genuine offers to compromise the plaintiffs’ claim but asked the plaintiffs to capitulate, and (with reference to Man B&W Diesel S E Asia Pte Ltd and another v PT Bumi International Tankers and another appeal [2004] 3 SLR(R) 267 (“Man B&W”)) such an offer will not bring indemnity costs;
(b) the refusal to admit facts was of no significance, because the facts in question were not relevant and the defendants were in any event put on notice that they did not have to deal with them;
Indemnity costs in the SICC?
- [8]
[8] The essential prescription is that in O 110 r 46(1) concerning proceedings in the SICC, with a mirror provision in r 46(2) concerning an appeal from the SICC to the Court of Appeal. It provides:
- [10]
[10] In O 59 r 1(1), it is provided that “standard basis” and “indemnity basis” have the same meaning assigned to them by rr 27(2) and 27(3), respectively.
- [22]
[22] Secondly, the defendants referred to the Singapore Court Practice (LexisNexis Singapore, 2021), para 110/46/2, for the commentary by Professor Jeffrey Pinsler SC:
Ordering indemnity costs?
- [32]
[32] The reasonableness of the plaintiffs’ failure to accept the offer in the letter takes one to the justification for and strength of their claims.
- [34]
[34] Although the case for undoing the purchase of the Villa by Quo Vadis failed at the hurdle of misrepresentation (Main Judgment at [189]), and faced also a difficulty in inducement (Main Judgment at [195]), that was after a careful and detailed consideration of the evidence and factual findings made. Had I come to a different view on, for example, when Mr Nargolwala read Mr Zeman’s email of 14 November 2017 (Main Judgment at [137]) or falsity of the belief representation (Main Judgment at [188]), and on inducement, there may have been a different outcome. It is true that the facts had been extensively canvassed in the Lew proceedings, and the plaintiffs were thereby informed, but the direction and scope of those proceedings was different. I do not regard the proceedings as unreasonably brought, or brought when the plaintiffs should have foreseen that they were likely to fail, and certainly not as brought as an abuse of process.
The result