Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 19 Sep 2023
Contents

Singapore International Commercial Court

Ivanishvili, Bidzina and others v Credit Suisse Trust L td

Feedback & support

[2023] SGHC(I) 14Case no. Suit No 4 of 2021

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] These reasons relate to the finalisation of orders to be made consequent upon judgment in SIC/S 4/2021 (the “Suit”) which was delivered on 26 May 2023: Ivanishvili, Bidzina and others v Credit Suisse Trust [2023] SGHC(I) 9 (the “Judgment”). Unless otherwise specified, the same abbreviations as used in the Judgment are adopted.

  3. Quantification

  4. [3] The Judgment included a request for the experts to further assist the Court by updating the Model 1B calculations to commence from the date of the breach, 30 March 2008, to the date of Judgment, taking into account the Settlement amount to ensure there is no double recovery: the Judgment at [729]–[731].

  5. [4] The parties’ respective forensic accounting experts, Mr Davies and Mr Nicholson, conferred after the delivery of the Judgment to assist the parties to reach agreement on the amount payable under Model 1B from the date of breach. As the parties were not able to agree, the experts provided their respective reports dated 25 August 2023 to assist the Court in the determination of the amount.

  6. [5] For the Model 1B calculations, Mr Davies adjusted: (a) the start date from 31 December 2007 to 30 March 2008 for all accounts other than Meadowsweet’s account 75, which remained at 31 December 2008; and (b) the end date from 30 September 2021 to 26 May 2023.

  7. [6] The original value of US$926.04m in the Model 1B calculations has reduced to US$781.51m by reason of the change in commencement date, some three months later than the original calculations, and the significantly reduced performance of the Benchmark Portfolio between 1 October 2021 and 26 May 2023.

  8. [7] The Settlement amount of US$79,430,773 referred to in the Judgment at [730] was in fact made up of three components, only one of which related to Meadowsweet in the amount of US$30,011,498 (the “Meadowsweet Settlement Amount”). The other two amounts related to the plaintiff’s company Wellminstone SA and personal accounts held by the plaintiff.

  9. [8] Mr Davies calculated the amount for deduction on two bases. The first was by deducting the whole of the amount of the Settlement and reaching a total of US$702.8m. The second was by deducting only the Meadowsweet Settlement Amount and reaching a total of US$742.73m.

  10. [9] Both experts have indicated that the parties agree that the correct treatment of the Settlement payments is to adopt the second basis of calculation, albeit that there is disagreement on the approach to be adopted. As 30 March 2008 fell on a Sunday, Mr Davies calculations commenced from 31 March 2008. Mr Nicholson’s calculations commenced from 28 March 2008. Having considered both experts’ analysis of the approach to be adopted, Mr Davies’ approach is preferred as the fairest and most reasonable in the circumstances.

  11. [10] The amount of compensation that the defendant must pay is US$742.73m.

  12. Costs

  13. Approach to determination of costs

  14. Parties’ positions on costs

  15. Agreed costs

  16. Contested costs

  17. [24] The defendant opposes the plaintiffs’ claims and proposes that the Court should award the plaintiffs a total of S$5,251,000 made up of:

  18. (a) S$3.5m for Post-Transfer Costs;

  19. (b) S$1.75m for Quantum Experts’ Fees; and

  20. (c) S$1,500 as costs for SUM 49.

  21. It proposes that all parties pay their own costs of SUM 11.

  22. Post Judgment costs proposals

  23. [32] It is not in issue that although the hours of work were set out in each of the stages and time periods, there was no narration of the actual or type of work that was carried out by the legal practitioners for the plaintiffs.

  24. There was also a section detailing the amounts of disbursements.

  25. [38] The 7 July Schedule included a similar observation of failing to understand why the defendant wanted a narration of the work done in relation to the Quantum Experts’ Fees. However, the plaintiffs’ solicitors provided further information as follows:

  26. Written Submissions

  27. [42] On 1 August 2023 the plaintiffs provided additional information in a Form 24 format. As this was provided as an attachment to the plaintiffs’ reply submissions, the defendant had not had an opportunity to comment upon it. The defendant was given the opportunity to file supplementary written submissions on the content of the Form 24 by 22 August 2023 and the plaintiffs were given the opportunity to file reply submissions by 29 August 2023.

  28. Post-Transfer Costs

  29. The defendant’s failure to provide information about its legal costs

  30. [51] The defendant submitted that this “asymmetry” arose by reason of a number of factors: the AEICs were staggered and the defendant had to consider that plaintiffs’ evidence before responding; unlike the plaintiffs, it was not in a position to leverage off the work of witnesses in the Bermuda Proceedings; it likely spent “significantly more time on discovery” given the allegations that were made against it; and it had to respond to the new allegations arising from the amendment of the Statement of Claim just three months before trial which required further work in relation to discovery and document production.

  31. [52] It was submitted therefore that there was “no equivalence between the preparatory work leading up to trial for there to be a like for like comparison”.

  32. [56] These observations also apply to the work that the defendant claimed it had to perform because of the amendments to the Statement of Claim. This work was no impediment to the comparison being made.

  33. Form 24

  34. [59] As discussed above, the initial information that the plaintiffs provided did not include any explanation of the type of work that was carried out during the hours for which claims are made. This was the subject of complaint by the defendant to which the plaintiffs responded by providing the information in the Form 24 format on 1 August 2023. The plaintiffs have provided detailed descriptions of the nature of the work done in each of the seven areas identified in the Form.

  35. (1) Pleadings

  36. [63] The first item is the plaintiffs’ claim for S$72,508.83 for 104.67 hours of work relating to Further and Better Particulars (“F&BPs”) of Statement of Claim (Amendment No. 1) (“SOC A1”) dated 8 June 2021. The defendant claimed that a substantial portion of the F&BPs concerned the Swiss proceedings against Mr Lescaudron and were obtained from the findings of the Swiss Court. It also submitted that these details were in the plaintiffs’ knowledge prior to the filing of the SOC A1 and that the remaining portions of the F&BPs contained “broad statements supporting the Plaintiffs’ allegation on breach of trust”.

  37. [64] In response, the plaintiffs submitted that the fact that particulars had to be drawn from other materials does not mean that less or no work is required. Obviously, work had to be done to review and consider the relevant materials and then draft the particulars.

  38. [66] The second item is the plaintiffs’ claim of S$38,373.73 for 54.17 hours of work in relation to F&BPs of SOC A1 dated 31 July 2021. The defendant submitted that these “mainly contained details on the alleged unsuitable, imprudent or undiversified investments”. It contended that the work of identifying these details would have been undertaken by the plaintiffs’ experts.

  39. [67] The plaintiffs submitted that the defendant’s claim is “illogical”. They contend that it cannot be disputed that the F&BPs provided in this regard were substantial and, irrespective of whether the experts had input in relation to the identification of the details relating to the breach of trust, work still had to be done to prepare the particulars and provide them to the defendant.

  40. [69] The third item is the plaintiffs’ claim for S$32,443.72 for 57.17 hours of work in relation to the Reply (Amendment No.1) dated 12 October 2021 (the “Reply”). It was submitted that the key substantive amendments were contained “in about five pages” concerning the defences raised by the defendant under s 60 of the Trustees Act, contributory negligence and consent/acquiescence, and that apart from bare denials, the facts pleaded in response repeated matters set out in the Statement of Claim.

  41. [70] The plaintiffs submitted that the amendments were substantive, a matter recognised by the defendant, resulting from work that included considering the new defences, considering the law so as to form a position and drafting the Reply. Notwithstanding that the amendments were only contained in five pages, the plaintiffs submitted that the achievement of succinctness in pleadings does not mean that little work was done.

  42. (2) CMCs

  43. [79] The plaintiffs also submitted that the defendant’s description of the balance of the hearing being in relation to “administrative matters” is very misleading. They point to the fact that submissions were made in respect of: (a) timelines for the exchange of specific discovery requests; (b) timelines for the filing of AEICs, with discussion in respect of the prospect of the defendant commencing a counterclaim or third-party action and/or the filing of a bifurcation application; and (c) the prospect of mediation. It was submitted that these are case management issues and even if procedural, require the plaintiffs’ counsel’s consideration and discussion with the plaintiffs. It was submitted that the defendant is deliberately downplaying the work done by the plaintiffs by describing it as “administrative work”. Whereas these are matters requiring careful consideration and advice to the plaintiffs.

  44. [80] The plaintiffs also disagreed with the defendant’s description that it was “inconceivable” that the hours of work claimed should have been incurred. They pointed out that the Case Management Bundle at that time included the Agreed Case Memorandum (21 pages), Agreed List of Issues (17 pages), Plaintiffs’ Proposed Case Management Plan (13 pages), Agreed List of Case Management Issues (15 pages) and Defendant’s Proposed Case Management Plan.

  45. [81] It was submitted that, apart from the last of these documents, the plaintiffs’ counsel prepared first drafts of each document and corresponded with both the plaintiffs and the solicitors for the defendant. It was also noted that the Agreed Case Memorandum required consolidation of the parties’ respective substantive positions in the Suit with a narrative of the procedural history of the Suit, which of course is not free from complexity. The plaintiffs submitted that multiple drafts were exchanged with the defendant’s solicitors before agreement was reached on the documents and the hours claimed were “entirely reasonable”.

  46. [86] The defendant submitted that in those circumstances it is not clear what work was required to be done in respect of the vacated 17 June 2021 CMC.

  47. [89] The next item is the plaintiff’s claim for S$85,482.50 for the work done in relation to the CMC on 10 August 2021. The defendant submitted that the issues covered at that CMC were timelines for pre-trial procedures, such as specific discovery and AEICs and trial, and were largely administrative in nature. It was submitted there is no explanation why 111.83 hours of work was required to prepare for and attend this CMC. Similar submissions were made in respect of the CMCs on 28 September 2021 with a claim for S$38,250.44 and a CMC on 15 March 2022 with a claim for S$39,718.29.

  48. [92] The plaintiffs reiterated the necessity to recognise that these matters were “case management issues”, rather than mere “administrative” matters. It was submitted that they were clearly important procedural matters which had a bearing on the Suit and their importance should not be downplayed using the defendant’s description.

  49. (3) Disclosure

  50. [99] The defendant also submitted that the parties issued their respective requests for specific discovery on 11 May 2021 and exchanged their substantive responses for specific discovery requests on 1 September 2021. In the interim, correspondence was exchanged on timelines and the defendant submitted that, given the nature of the work during this period, it did not appear reasonable for the plaintiffs to have done extensive work. It was submitted that the amount claimed is “unreasonably high”.

  51. [100] The plaintiffs submitted that the defendant has not adduced any evidence to support its claim that the amounts between 9 March 2021 and 30 June 2021 are unreasonably high. It was submitted that what the defendant has done is simply to speculate and make a “vague assertion” that it was not reasonable for the plaintiffs to have done extensive work.

  52. [102] Finally on the topic of disclosure, the defendant submitted that the claims made for the plaintiffs’ work on its 2nd, 3rd and 4th Supplementary Lists of Documents did not require the plaintiffs’ legal representatives to engage in extensive or time-consuming searches or reviews.

  53. [103] The defendant submitted that in the main the 2nd Supplementary List of Documents comprised correspondence between lawyers, documents in the Bermuda Proceedings, documents relating to the Swiss criminal proceedings and various bank statements and reports from 2016 onwards. It contended that the 3rd and 4th Supplementary Lists of Documents mainly comprised statements of account and investment reports as well as cause papers, documents, witness statements and transcripts for the Bermuda Proceedings.

  54. [105] The plaintiffs submitted that the defendant appeared to suggest that simply because documents emanated from the Bermuda Proceedings, the plaintiffs could and should just disclose them without reviewing them further. The plaintiffs submitted that regardless of whether these documents had emanated from related proceedings in Bermuda, the plaintiffs’ legal representatives in the Singapore proceedings would still have to review them for relevance and necessity to the issues in the Suit. The lawyers could not and would not rely solely on the review of the plaintiffs’ foreign lawyers to decide whether or not documents should be disclosed in the Singapore Suit. The plaintiffs also relied upon the evidence that had been previously filed relating to the differences between the Bermuda Proceedings and the Singapore proceedings.

  55. (4) Expert Evidence

  56. [109] The defendant made a comparison between the work done in that period, referring to it as dealing with administrative matters, and the work done between 1 January 2022 and 28 March 2022, referring to it as “substantive”, which was approximately half the amount claimed in the earlier period (S$90,617.30 for 119.83 hours). It submitted that, in this latter period, the plaintiffs’ lawyers were reviewing matters of substance and discussing matters with the experts in relation to their reports. It submitted that it cannot be reasonable that the “administrative” matters dealt with in the period in March 2021 could be twice the amount claimed in respect of this latter period.

  57. [110] The plaintiffs submitted that simply because the list of issues was five pages long, it should not be understood that this was a straightforward or simple matter, or indeed an administrative matter. Rather, it involved extensive discussions from 1 November 2021 to 3 March 2022 with multiple drafts being created and shared, the final version being discussed with the Court at the CMC on 7 February 2022. The final version resulted in the 24 expert issues.

  58. [112] The plaintiffs submitted that even if there was overlap between the Singapore proceedings and the Bermuda Proceedings it was necessary to be instructed on the differences between those two sets of proceedings.

  59. [113] The plaintiffs also submitted that the description given by the defendant in respect of the matters that were dealt with by the plaintiffs between 9 March 2021 and 28 March 2022 as “mainly administrative matters” is erroneous.

  60. [114] The defendant questioned whether there was some overlap in the plaintiffs’ claims in respect of the work that was done between 29 March 2022 to 8 June 2022. The defendant was concerned that there may have been a double claim. The plaintiffs indicated there was no double claim and identified the differences between the two claims.

  61. (5) Affidavits and Preparation for hearings

  62. [120] The defendant complains that the amount claimed by the plaintiffs for the preparation of AEICs and the preparation for hearings of $248,755.22 is “excessive”. It was submitted that the plaintiffs filed only three factual AEICs, two for each witness, the plaintiff and Mr Bachiashvili, and one in reply for the plaintiff. The defendant submitted that both of those individuals provided written testimony in the Bermuda Proceedings and, accordingly, there was significant overlap.

  63. [121] The plaintiffs have already addressed these submissions in respect of overlap and submitted that the defendant had not answered their submissions but repeats its previous submissions without a proper basis.

  64. [123] The plaintiffs submitted that the defendant omitted to mention that it had requested additional documents from the plaintiffs and had asked the plaintiffs to lift certain redactions or explain the basis for the application for redactions. The plaintiffs submitted that they further identified duplicates for the defendant and provided cross-references to other documents.

  65. [125] The plaintiffs also submitted that the defendant “deliberately” ignored the fact that the 131.83 hours included work done by the plaintiffs in relation to the restated financial statements, which were a significant matter in the proceedings and in the closing submissions.

  66. [134] The parties are at issue in respect of the nature of the work done in respect of the non-admission to the authenticity of certain documents. It is apparent that that issue relates to some communications between the parties in respect of the defendant’s communications with the Monetary Authority of Singapore.

  67. [137] The written submissions of the plaintiffs and the defendant when combined were more than 1,000 pages. One might wonder with such detailed submissions what might be left for oral submissions. However, the length of the submissions and the fact the parties took up the two days for oral submissions is demonstrative of the complexity of the case and the intensity of the positions adopted. The defendant raised new and rather innovative submissions for the first time in final oral submissions which had to be analysed, understood, and met by the plaintiffs.

  68. (6) Application of discount

  69. [139] The defendant submitted that the plaintiffs’ 10% discount on their claim in recognition of the date of the breach having been found to be in 2008 instead of 2007 does not reflect the significance of that issue on which the plaintiffs were not successful.

  70. [140] The defendant submitted that the further issue on which the plaintiffs failed to prevail at trial was the propounding of Model 1A, whereas Model 1B was found to be the appropriate model for quantification of losses. The defendant submitted that the significance of the plaintiffs’ failure in this regard can be assessed having regard to the difference between Mr Davies’ quantification of Model 1A as US$1.268bn and Model 1B as US$920.40m. It was submitted that the effect of the application of Model 1B was a reduction of approximately 25%.

  71. [143] The date of the breach was intrinsically linked to the model to be adopted for the quantification of loss, compensation or damages. Once the date of breach was identified and various other findings relevant to the management of the Trust assets were made the choice of model could be made. The parties approached this aspect of the matter in a cooperative and sensible fashion.

  72. [144] The fact that the plaintiffs did not succeed in securing a finding of breach of duty by the defendant as at 2007 but rather March 2008 with the consequential choice of model is properly reflected by a 10% discount as adopted by the plaintiffs.

  73. Quantum Experts’ Fees

  74. [147] The defendant’s complaint in relation to a lack of particularisation in respect of the Quantum Experts’ Fees was responded to by the plaintiffs supplying its experts’ supporting invoices as an attachment to their earlier submissions.

  75. [148] The plaintiffs complained that the defendant had not adduced any evidence to justify its counter-proposal of S$1,750,000. That submission was met by the defendant supplying the amount of the fees charged by their experts in their earlier submissions. This information is in tabular form for specific periods without any detail of the nature of the work carried out in those periods. Those tables are as follows:

  76. SN

  77. Approximate time period

  78. Plaintiffs

  79. CST

  80. GBP

  81. SGD

  82. USD

  83. SGD

  84. 1.

  85. Mar 2022

  86. 251,947.25

  87. 433,349.25

  88. 1,125,493.00

  89. 1,596,905.69

  90. Apr 2022

  91. 34,387.50

  92. 59,146.50

  93. May 2022

  94. 23,300.25

  95. 40,076.43

  96. Subtotal

  97. 309,635.00

  98. 532,572.20

  99. 2.

  100. Jun 2022

  101. 221,177.50

  102. 380,425.30

  103. 327,923.00

  104. 436,137.59

  105. Jul 2022

  106. 103,596.50

  107. 178,185.98

  108. Aug 2022

  109. 132,426.75

  110. 227,774.01

  111. Sep 2022

  112. 187,290.75

  113. 322,140.09

  114. Subtotal

  115. 644,491.50

  116. 1,108,525.38

  117. 3.

  118. late-Sep 2022 –

  119. mid-Feb 2023

  120. 77,007.55

  121. 132,452.99

  122. 20,104.00

  123. 26,738.32

  124. Subtotal

  125. 77,007.55

  126. 132,452.99

  127. TOTAL

  128. 1,773,550.57

  129. 1,959,781.60

  130. SN

  131. Approximate time period

  132. Plaintiffs

  133. CST

  134. GBP

  135. SGD

  136. USD

  137. SGD

  138. 1.

  139. Mar 2022

  140. 97,364.00

  141. 167,466.08

  142. 700,293.00

  143. 1,204,503.96

  144. Apr 2022

  145. 1,947.50

  146. 3,349.70

  147. May 2022

  148. 0.00

  149. 0.00

  150. Subtotal

  151. 99,311.50

  152. 170,815.78

  153. 2.

  154. Jun 2022

  155. 73,377.50

  156. 126,209.30

  157. 247,195.00

  158. 425,175.40

  159. Jul 2022

  160. 58,242.50

  161. 100,177.10

  162. Aug 2022

  163. 43,437.50

  164. 74,712.50

  165. Sep 2022

  166. 79,900.00

  167. 137,428.00

  168. Subtotal

  169. 254,957.50

  170. 438,526.90

  171. 3.

  172. late-Sep 2022 –

  173. mid-Feb 2023

  174. 0.00

  175. 0.00

  176. 11,078.00

  177. 19,054.16

  178. Subtotal

  179. 0.00

  180. 0.00

  181. TOTAL

  182. 609,342.68

  183. 1,648,733.52

  184. [149] The defendant’s Quantum Experts’ Fees total S$3,608,515.12, which is S$1,225,620.87 greater than the plaintiffs’ Quantum Experts’ Fees. Notwithstanding this fact, the defendant robustly submitted that the plaintiff’s Quantum Experts’ Fees were “excessive”, “staggering”, “plainly unreasonable”, and “exorbitant”. It will be necessary to determine whether these epithets are appropriate in the circumstances.

  185. [151] The defendant submitted that the plaintiffs’ experts were familiar with the factual background and relevant details of the matter because they were involved in the Bermuda Proceedings and that there was some direct overlap in the work performed by the experts. It was submitted that the plaintiffs’ experts had an ability to “leverage off” the work done in Bermuda.

  186. [152] The defendants compared the amount of fees incurred for preparing the plaintiffs’ experts’ reports of S$703,387.98 and the amount incurred following the preparation of the reports of S$1,547,052.28.

  187. [153] The defendant contrasted these figures with the fees of its own experts who were “freshly instructed” and had to spend “considerable time getting up on the matter”. The defendant submitted that it incurred higher experts’ fees than the plaintiffs’ experts over the course of the entire engagement “largely due to the fees incurred in the preparation of the expert reports”.

  188. [155] The comparison between the amounts that the experts collectively incurred for preparing the experts’ reports compared to the amounts incurred thereafter by the plaintiffs’ experts was the basis for the defendant’s description that the plaintiffs’ fees were “staggering”. Once again, this is a comparison of amounts without considering the detail of the structure of the proceedings and what had to be done by the experts during the proceedings.

  189. [156] One matter of significance to be considered in assessing whether the use of the defendant’s epithets is appropriate is the evidence that was filed and served by the defendant in respect of the defendant’s restated financial statements of the Trust and Meadowsweet for the period 2006 to 2014. These were disclosed on 3 December 2021.

  190. [157] The defendant had originally indicated that it would call Mr Patrick Guldimann to give evidence and had served his affidavit of 18 April 2022. As discussed in the Judgment at [39]–[46], details from Mr Guldimann’s affidavit and his report/analysis were included in both the oral and documentary evidence of the experts. The plaintiffs’ experts had to review Mr Guldimann’s material and the fees in respect of that work are included within the relevant period. The plaintiffs’ experts’ work on the restated financial statements resulted in a supplemental expert report of Mr Davies on 11 August 2022.

  191. [158] It is not appropriate to simply compare the breakup of the fees in particular periods, without more, and to then deploy the epithets that the defendant has in respect of the plaintiffs’ experts’ fees. It is also significant that the defendant’s experts’ fees are greater than the plaintiffs’ experts’ fees. If one were to apply the defendant’s approach to matters, then it may perhaps be appropriate to apply the defendant’s epithets to its own experts’ fees. That would not be fair.

  192. [159] In any event, in all the circumstances of the complexities of this case and the obvious professional and diligent approach adopted by the plaintiffs’ experts to the task to assist the Court, these fees were, as the plaintiffs describe them, “eminently reasonable”.

  193. [160] It is appropriate to award the plaintiffs the amount claimed by them in respect of the Quantum Experts’ Fees.

  194. [161] There will be an award in respect of the plaintiffs’ Quantum Experts’ Fees in the amount of S$2,382,893.25.

  195. SUM 11

  196. [162] The application was heard on 20 May 2022 and judgment was delivered on 27 May 2022. Many of the proposed amendments were by consent. The amendments that were disallowed were paragraphs 27D, 27E(a), the first sentence of paragraph 27H, and paragraphs 52A(g)(v) and 52A(i)(iv).

  197. [163] The application was hard-fought, and the plaintiffs were substantially successful in those claims.

  198. SUM 49

  199. Interest

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.