Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 31 October 2023
CYW v CYX
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC(I) 17 · Case no. Originating Application No 3 of 2022 · 18 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] These proceedings arose out of an arbitration between CYW as claimant and CYX as respondent in which CYW claimed it was not liable on a certain bills of exchange accepted by it and that a security deed between it and CYX (the “Security Deed”) was invalid. It also claimed consequential damages arising from CYX’s alleged failure to practise prudential banking or conduct due diligence as required by Indonesian law.
- [2]
[2] CYX by counterclaim sought to enforce the Security Deed and counterclaimed for the amount unpaid on the accepted Bills.
- [3]
[3] The facts giving rise to the arbitration are summarised in CYW v CYX [2023] SGHC (1) 10 at [4]–[16] (the “Setting Aside Judgment”) and it is unnecessary to repeat them.
- [4]
[4] CYW was unsuccessful in the arbitration and brought SIC/OA 3/2022 (“OA 3”) seeking orders setting aside the award on the ground that it was denied natural justice. It relied in support of the application on s 24(b) of the International Arbitration Act 1994 (2020 Rev Ed) and Art 34(2)(a)(ii) of the UNCITAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration as enacted under the First Schedule to the IAA. The grounds of CYW’s application are set out in more detail in the Setting Aside Judgment at [17]–[60] but they essentially arose out of the refusal of the arbitral tribunal (the “Tribunal”) to grant extensions of time to file expert evidence and provide translations of Indonesian documents relevant to the proceedings. It should be noted that although the arbitration proceedings undoubtedly were complex, the proceedings to set aside the award involved relatively narrow issues.
The costs claimed
(a) Costs of S$23,443.70 for work done prior to the transfer of the proceedings to the Singapore International Commercial Court (the “SICC”), comprising costs of S$21,910 plus GST at 7% of S$1533.70.
(b) Costs of S$173,377.80 for work done subsequent to the transfer of the proceedings to the SICC, comprising the following:
(c) Costs of S$16,383.60 for work done in preparing submissions on costs comprising costs of S$15,170 plus GST at 8% of S$1,213.60.
(d) Disbursements totalling S$5,539.01 comprising: (i) S$5,359.01 for the period up to the Setting Aside Judgment; and (ii) S$180 in respect of the submissions on costs. The disbursements have been itemised and it was not contended by CYW that any of them were unreasonably incurred.
The relevant rules
- [15]
[15] The court summarised the relevant principles in the following manner (at [100]):
The parties’ submissions
CYX’s submissions
- [17]
[17] CYX points out that the Court of Appeal in Senda stated at [51]–[52] that in the SICC, parties are better resourced and more willing to incur greater expense in litigation due to the amounts at stake and the pursuit of commercial objectives and accordingly, the policy of enhancing access to justice is less relevant and the principal underlying consideration is a commercial one of ensuring that a successful litigant is not unfairly put out of pocket.
CYW’s submissions
- [23]
[23] In relation to O 22 r 3(2)(a) of the SICC Rules, CYW accepts that the setting aside of an arbitral award for breach of natural justice is a relatively complex area of law.
- [24]
[24] In relation to O 22 r 3(2)(b) of the SICC Rules, CYW notes that the case involved one set of affidavits, one set of written submissions and a hearing. CYW submits that although the affidavits amounted to about 1,000 pages each for both parties, they involved documents that had already been perused before which formed part of the documents in the arbitration, and the hours spent by CYX’s counsel in this regard should thus be reduced.
Consideration
Pre-transfer costs
- [29]
[29] The work was said to occupy 4.3 hours of the time of lead counsel at a charge out rate of S$800 per hour, 12.4 hours of a partner’s time at a charge out rate of S$500 per hour, 14.9 hours of a senior associate’s time at a charge out rate of S$400 per hour and 18 hours of an associate’s time at a charge out rate of S$300 per hour.
- [34]
[34] In the present case, the pre-transfer work carried out on behalf of CYX involved considering CYW’s application to set aside the arbitral award made in the arbitration between the parties and an affidavit which although lengthy, contained documents which had only limited relevance to the proceedings. Although it also involved preparation for two case conferences and I accept some legal research and analysis, the case was still at a preliminary stage at those points in time.
Post-transfer costs
- [39]
[39] For the period between 7 October 2022 and 31 December 2022, the work carried out by the legal representatives of CYX involved preparation of the affidavit of Mr B (filed on behalf of CYX), preparation of CYX’s case management bundle, reviewing the case management bundle supplied by CYW and preparation of a draft joint case management bundle. The total amount claimed was S$40,500 plus GST at 7% of S$2,835 (totalling S$43,335).
- [40]
[40] The work done in this period involved 21.7 hours of work by lead counsel at S$800 per hour, 10.6 hours of work done by a partner at S$500 per hour, 31.8 hours of work done by a senior associate at S$400 per hour and 20.1 hours of work done by two associates at S$300 per hour.
- [42]
[42] The affidavit of Mr B was lengthy, although it must be remembered that of the 1,093 pages, the affidavit itself comprised about 37 pages, the balance being annexures. The annexures, which mainly comprised documents brought into existence in connection with the arbitration, were certainly relevant to the issues for determination in the proceedings, namely, whether in the circumstances which confronted the Tribunal, its orders in relation to the production of expert evidence and translation of Indonesian documents denied CYW natural justice.
- [43]
[43] In comparing the work done by the representatives of CYX and CYW over the period, it must be remembered that the supporting affidavit filed by CYW was prepared in the pre-transfer period whilst that filed on behalf of CYX was prepared in the post-transfer period.
- [44]
[44] In all the circumstances and having regard to the issues involved in the proceedings, the significance of the proceedings to the parties and clause 14.2 of the Security Deed, I am of the view that CYX should be awarded the amount claimed in the period between 7 October 2022 and 31 December 2022, being S$43,335.
- [46]
[46] The next claim is for the period from 27 January 2023 up to 16 March 2023, including the hearing on 15 March 2023. The total amount claimed was S$117,450 exclusive of GST. The work said to be done in the period included the preparation of written submissions and bundles of authorities, reviewing CYW’s written submissions and bundles of authorities, attending the hearing, and conducting case analysis, documentation review and legal research.
- [47]
[47] The time spent totalled 228.1 hours. Assuming that seven hours was spent per day on average, that is a little over 32 days. Of these 228.1 hours, 69.8 hours was spent by lead counsel at S$800 per hour, 29.4 hours by a partner at S$500 per hour, 82.4 hours by a senior associate at S$400 per hour and 46.5 hours at S$300 per hour by an associate.
- [52]
[52] As I indicated at [6(d)] above, it was not contended by CYW that any of CYX’s disbursements were unreasonably incurred, and I therefore regard the disbursements claimed by CYX as having been properly incurred.
Conclusion