Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 3 May 2024
DFI v DFJ
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC(I) 11 · Case no. Originating Application No 5 of 2023 · 11 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] On 1 February 2024, I issued a judgment in this case dismissing the claimant’s application to set aside the arbitral award (the “Award”) issued by an arbitral tribunal (the “Tribunal”) in an arbitration (the “Arbitration”) between the parties administered by the International Chamber of Commerce.
Submissions
- [7]
[7] It submits that the subject matter of the Award was factually complex and technical in nature, with expert evidence being led by both parties in the Arbitration. Further, it says that the documents reviewed by its counsel were voluminous and it refers to a table summarising the papers filed in this application.
- [8]
[8] As the defendant’s counsel dealing with the application were not involved in the Arbitration, it says that they had to review the entirety of the claimant’s 2924-page long supporting affidavit which exhibited, in particular, the documents filed in the Arbitration and the transcripts of the seven-day hearing to understand the case and frame the arguments necessary to resist the application.
- [9]
[9] On that basis, the defendant submits that it was entirely reasonable to engage a team of consisting of a senior legal practitioner and two assisting counsel to assimilate the voluminous material and assist the court at the hearing, including drafting legal submissions to address the issues raised by the claimant. It says that the defendant’s lead counsel in the Arbitration provided valuable insight and assistance to the defendant’s Singapore counsel. If he had not been involved as instructing counsel, the defendant says that its Singapore counsel would have incurred even more time in reviewing the matter and structuring their arguments to resist the application.
- [12]
[12] Based on these factors, the claimants submits that the application was straightforward and was neither factually nor legally complex, being premised on the single issue of whether the Tribunal, in breach of the rules of natural justice, had failed to take into account the evidence and legal submissions of the claimant. It says that all the relevant documents were annexed to its supporting affidavit, which contained 22 pages of text and 3,053 pages of exhibits. The defendant then filed a single response affidavit, which spanned 29 pages and contained no documentary exhibits.
- [13]
[13] The claimant says that the written submissions filed by the parties were brief, with the claimant’s being 21 pages and the defendant’s 38 pages, with nine legal authorities cited by the claimant and five by the defendant. The parties attended one case management conference on 12 October 2023, which lasted approximately 30 minutes, and the substantive hearing on 4 December 2023 took a total of 1.5 hours.
- [16]
[16] The defendant also says that the claimant mischaracterises the application as a straightforward case which was neither factually nor legally complex. It submits that it could hardly be said that the matter was straightforward or not complex when the parties had to engage experts at the hearing of the Arbitration. In addition, the claimant acknowledges the voluminous documents that the defendant’s counsel had to review. In relation to the written submissions being brief and the substantive hearing being short, the defendant submits that this does not detract from the voluminous material that the defendant’s counsel had to assimilate to prepare concise written submissions and properly assist the Court at the substantive hearing.
Decision
- [20]
[20] Instead the claimant makes, essentially, two points. First, that this was a straightforward case, which was not complex and which involved the sole issue of whether the Tribunal, in breach of the rules of natural justice, had failed to take into account the evidence and legal submissions of the claimant. I do not consider that portrayal of the case is correct. Whilst this case was not at the most complex end of the spectrum, the affidavit exhibited over 3000 pages of exhibits containing documents on the record in the Arbitration. The claimant focused on the evidence and submissions which had been deployed in the Arbitration in relation to the two main issues which the Tribunal had to decide.
- [21]
[21] It was therefore necessary to consider what had been submitted and what evidence had been given in the Arbitration relating to several allegations that the Tribunal had failed to take account of the evidence and submissions in respect of each of the issues. The defendant’s counsel and the defendant’s original counsel in the Arbitration both, therefore, had to be involved in gathering together those parts of the lengthy Arbitration record to identify documents which would support its defence. This was by no means straightforward.
- [24]
[24] As was pointed out in CNA at [40], there is no logical reason why a discount applied in other cases should be applied and, in the CNA case itself, the court would not have applied a reduction of 30%, and “would have approached the matter afresh”, had there not been a concession by the defendants: see CNA at [44].
- [28]
[28] In relation to the sum claimed for disbursements of $12,585.86, there is no challenge to the reasonableness of this sum, the majority of which are eLitigation fees. I therefore allow the sum claimed.