Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 29 Apr 2024

Singapore International Commercial Court

Transpac Investments Ltd v TIH Ltd

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHC(I) 12Case no. Originating Application No 8 of 2023 (Summons No 14 of 2024)13 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [2] In short, TIH submits that TIL is a BVI company whose financial position has been shrouded in secrecy and whose ultimate beneficial owner, Cliff Leong, the son of Chris and Mary Leong, has not suggested that he will have any difficulty providing security as sought.

  3. Applicable Principles

  4. [3] The applicable principles are well established. In summary:

  5. (a) Given that this is a “transfer” case, TIH’s application for security for costs is made pursuant to Rules of Court 2021 (“ROC 2021”) and not the Singapore International Commercial Court Rules 2021.

  6. (e) When taking into account the aforementioned list of non-exhaustive factors set out above in Cova Group Holding, the General Division of the High Court in SW Trustees at [19] noted that the court must keep in mind the three key purposes of security for costs, namely – “(a) to protect the defendant, who cannot avoid being sued, by enabling him to recover costs from the plaintiff out of a fund within the jurisdiction in the event that the claim against him by the plaintiff proves to be unsuccessful; (b) to ensure, within the limits of protecting the defendant, that the plaintiff’s ability to pursue his claim is not stifled; and (c) to maintain a sense of fair play between the parties even amidst the cut-and-thrust of civil litigation”.

  7. Summary of issues

  8. (a) TIL is a company that is ordinarily resident out of jurisdiction;

  9. (b) TIL’s claims in this action have a low prospect of success;

  10. (c) There is real reason to believe that TIL will be unable to pay TIH’s costs;

  11. (d) TIH is likely to be put to significant inconvenience and expenses in enforcing costs against TIL; and

  12. (e) providing security for costs will not stifle TIL’s claims in this suit.

  13. [6] Although TIL accepts that it is a BVI company and therefore a company registered out of the jurisdiction, it otherwise disputes all of the above. In addition, in inviting the court to reject the application, TIL relies upon (a) the imminence of the trial which is due to start on 27 May 2024 for nine days and (b) TIL’s delay in making the present application.

  14. [8] I deal with the other points relied upon by the parties below.

  15. TIL is a company that is ordinarily resident out of jurisdiction

  16. TIL’s shares in TIH

  17. [12] It is common ground that TIH is a company listed on the Singapore Exchange Limited. According to the evidence submitted by TIL, it (ie, TIL) has 24,576,126 shares (being 10.17% of the entire issued share capital of TIH) in TIH with an approximate market price of $4,177,041.42; and that the 10.17% stake in TIH, based on the net asset value of TIH (as stated in TIH’s Annual Report 2023), would be worth $12,326,040. It appears that the foregoing is not disputed by TIH.

  18. [13] In Tjong Very Sumito (HC) at [38]–[39], the High Court held that where shares in Singapore-incorporated companies are being put up as evidence of the claimant’s assets within jurisdiction, evidence of their value and existence should be provided. In this regard, TIL submits that it has satisfied this evidential burden.

  19. [14] However, in my view, the foregoing does not assist TIL for the following reasons:

  20. (a) First, the evidence is that these shares are “thinly traded”. As such, whatever their current notional market value may be, it is a matter of some uncertainty as to how or when such shares might be sold and what price might be achieved in any sale at some future date.

  21. (b) Second, although the evidence is that TIL must give notice of the sale of any shares, it appears that it could sell its shares at any time.

  22. (c) Third, as submitted by TIH, the financial position of TIL is shrouded in mystery. As stated above, TIL is a company incorporated in the BVI. It does not file publicly available financial statements and there is no publicly available information on its cash holdings, assets or what its liabilities are. It has refused to disclose TIL's financial position despite TIH’s request to do so. I note that some information has been obtained by way of company searches conducted by TIH on TIL in the BVI which show the existence of certain charges in favour of certain banks over assets that TIL may have in Singapore, Hong Kong, and Liechtenstein although it remains unclear to me whether these charges would cover TIL’s shares in TIH. Be that as it may, the important point is that there is no satisfactory up to date information as to TIL’s current financial position; nor as to its likely financial position going forward.

  23. Bond Account

  24. TIL’s other assets

  25. [17] Third, TIL submits that it has substantial assets in the form of investments maintained with various financial institutions referred to as LGT, CSSG and CSHK totalling US$15,771,264.26, which, according to TIL, are largely low-risk. Although TIL accepts that there are charges over these funds pursuant to secured credit facilities extended to TIL, TIL has confirmed that it has not taken out any loans under these facilities and that no liabilities were created vis-à-vis these moneys. TIL further submits that TIH has provided no evidence that TIL would be unable to pay off any loans taken up under the secured facilities to trigger liabilities vis-à-vis TIL’s moneys, or that any default of a loan would trigger liabilities large enough to wipe out the entire amount of US$15,771,264.26.

  26. Whether there is reason to believe that TIL will be unable to pay TIH’s costs and/or TIH is likely to be put to significant inconvenience and expenses in enforcing costs against TIL?

  27. [21] It is convenient to take these two points relied upon by TIH together.

  28. Will an order for security for costs stifle TIL’s claims?

  29. [28] Further, TIH submits and I accept that when a company is impecunious, it is those who stand to benefit from the litigation who should provide security. These individuals cannot hide behind the separate personality of the company. As noted in Frantonios Marine Services Pte Ltd and another v Kay Swee Tuan [2008] 4 SLR(R) 224 at [53]:

  30. Delay?

  31. [31] TIL submits that the application should be dismissed because of TIH’s delay in bringing this application for security. In particular, TIH submits:

  32. (a) The 1st Undertaking was provided up to the discovery stage of OA 8, including specific discovery. The court made its ruling on parties’ production requests by way of Redfern Schedules on 25 October 2023, and production of documents to each other was completed by 28 November 2023 at the latest. Thus, there would have been a delay of at least two months before TIH first made its request for further security to TIL on 2 February 2024, and a further month to file the present application by way of SUM 14 on 22 March 2024.

  33. (b) At the time the 1st Undertaking was provided on 29 August 2023, any amendments to the Statement of Claim had not been contemplated by TIL. It was on this basis that TIL had agreed to provide $100,000 as security for TIH’s costs of OA 8 – for which discovery would have been completed by 28 November 2023. Thus, it is inaccurate for TIH to allege that there is no delay in bringing SUM 14 due to TIL’s amendment to its Statement of Claim.

  34. (c) TIH has not shown any good explanations for the delay in making its request for security and the filing of SUM 14.

  35. (d) The delay would cause considerable prejudice to TIL, given that parties are at the doorstep of trial commencing on 27 May 2024 and any such application would only serve to put an obstacle before TIL in proceeding to trial.

  36. [32] At first blush, I was rather impressed by this submission. However:

  37. (b) Thus, the original request for further security on 2 February 2024 was, in fact, made before completion of the discovery process.

  38. (c) Thereafter, the evidence before me indicates that, following that request, the parties were engaged in negotiations on the matter until 1 March 2024. When it became clear that TIL would not voluntarily provide security, TIH promptly made its application for security for costs on 22 March 2024 which was still before the discovery process was eventually completed on 7 April 2024.

  39. Conclusion

  40. [36] As for these submissions, my brief observations and conclusions are as follows.