Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 28 June 2024
Pertamina International Marketing & Distribution Pte Ltd v P-H-O-E-N-I-X Petroleum Philippines, Inc (also known as Phoenix Petroleum Philippines, Inc)
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC(I) 20 · Case no. Originating Application No 1 of 2024 (Summons No 8 of 2024) · 4 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] This judgment (“Judgment”) follows on from the hearing on 19 April 2024 in these proceedings when I heard the parties’ submissions in relation to P-H-O-E-N-I-X Petroleum Philippines, Inc.’s (“Phoenix”) application in SIC/SUM 8/2024 (“SUM 8”).
- [2]
[2] In the event, I dismissed that application for reasons which I set out in my grounds of decision dated 26 April 2024.
(a) $208,275.28 in legal costs incurred by PIMD's Singapore counsel ("Singapore counsel costs");
(b) $26,813.66 in legal costs incurred by PIMD's arbitration counsel ("arbitration counsel costs");
(c) $6,416.16 in fees to engage ACCRALAW on matters of Philippines law; and
(d) $1,964.25 in disbursements (such as filing fees, translation fees, courier charges, and overtime transport expenses).
Phoenix do not dispute the sums claimed in respect of (c) and (d). However, for the reasons set out below. Phoenix submits that a discount of 50 per cent ought to be applied to the costs claimed by PIMD in relation to the Singapore counsel costs and the arbitration counsel costs ie, $104,137.64 for the former and $13,406.83 for the latter.
Singapore counsel costs: $208,275.28
- [8]
[8] In short, Phoenix submits that the amount claimed by PIMD under this head is disproportionately high and unreasonable for the following reasons, viz:
(a) First, Phoenix submits that the large bulk of such costs amounting to $137,796.93 relates to what is described as Stage A5, ie, work done in relation to “preparing written submissions and accompanying bundles, reviewing Defendant’s written submissions and accompanying bundles, and preparing for hearing (including research)”. The total number of hours spent on Stage A5 (including both director and associate time) is 113.63 hours. Assuming that seven hours were spent per day on average, that is a little over 16 days. By comparison, the time spent and costs incurred by Phoenix’s solicitors for the same scope of work was 60.4 hours and $38,980 respectively.
(b) Second, Phoenix submits that a comparison with other recent cost awards made by the Singapore International Commercial Court (“SICC”) demonstrates that this head of costs is disproportionately high and unreasonable.
(c) Third, Phoenix submits that the total time spent (19.5 hours) corresponding to a claim of $17,689.37 for taking instructions in relation to and preparing the 3rd witness statement of Mohammad Fitrawan Nur dated 5 March 2024 (“3MFN”) is disproportionate and unreasonable.
(d) Fourth, Phoenix submits that the costs claimed by PIMD for “getting-up and attending hearing” for four of its Singapore lawyers, two directors and two associates amounting to a total cost of $17,560.59 is excessive. In comparison, Phoenix only had two Singapore lawyers who attended the hearing and incurred costs of only $4,030.
(e) Fifth, Phoenix submits that the sum of $15,772.95 claimed by PIMD for work done for preparing the cost submissions is excessive and unreasonable.
(f) Sixth, Phoenix submits that the total of 174.03 hours spent by PIMD’s Singapore counsel was not reasonably incurred when compared with the time spent by its own Singapore counsel (142.1 hours) having regard, in particular, to the fact that whereas Phoenix filed three witness statements, PIMD only filed one witness statement.
(g) Finally, Phoenix submits that even if the costs (in terms of time and labour expended or hourly rates charged) were reasonably incurred by PIMD, the extent of the disparity in quantum between the professional fees of the parties’ Singapore counsel supports the conclusion that the quantum of the costs claimed by PIMD is unreasonable.
- [9]
[9] As for these submissions, my observations and conclusions are as follows:
(a) Pursuant to the final award signed and dated 28 November 2023 (“Award”), the amount at stake in the present case was considerable, viz, approximately US$142 million including interest up to the date of the Award as well as further interest at a rate of 5.33 per cent per annum (equivalent to approximately US$120,000 per week or US$18,000 per day) up to the date of payment. Even now, the Award is unsatisfied.
(b) In one sense, the issues raised were, or at least should have been, relatively straightforward. However, a number of the points raised by Phoenix raised potentially difficult factual and legal issues. As submitted by PIMD, this expanded the scope of the issues that PIMD had to deal with including on matters of Philippines law, research on the effect of findings made in an arbitral award, and coordination with Philippines counsel on the status of the proceedings commenced by Phoenix in the Republic of the Philippines under Civil Case No. R-DVO-23-6338-SC (“Philippines Action”) and to procure the necessary legal opinion. To this end, the main papers filed in the Philippines Action (excluding exhibits) exceeded 210 pages. I readily accept that it was important that PIMD’s Singapore counsel put themselves in a position to explain properly the nature and course of the proceedings initiated by Phoenix in the Philippines and to correct any misimpressions.
(c) As I stated in my judgment, the steps taken by Phoenix in the Philippines were in breach of the orders of this Court amounting to contempt of court. Even though it was well aware of SIC/ORC 5/2024 (“ORC 5”), Phoenix failed to bring ORC 5 to the attention of the Philippines Court and continued to forcefully press on with its pursuit of the Philippines Action. Phoenix has made no apology or excuse for its contempt. Even now, I am far from certain that Phoenix has properly explained to the Courts in the Philippines the jurisdictional framework which exists under the Model Law and the New York Convention (to which, as I understand, the Philippines is a party) which lie at the heart of modern international commercial arbitration.
(e) All of the above factors are relevant in considering the approach to the assessment of PIMD’s costs in the present case and point strongly in favour of PIMD.
(f) Comparison with the costs allowed in other SICC cases may, in certain circumstances, provide a useful “check” but ultimately each case turns on its own facts and particular circumstances. In the present case and given all that I have said above, I do not find it necessarily surprising that PIMD’s Singapore counsel’s costs are somewhat higher than those apparently incurred by Phoenix’s counsel. Nor do I find PIMD’s Singapore counsel’s costs outside what one might ordinarily expect.
Arbitration counsel costs: $26,813.66
Conclusion