Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 4 October 2024
Navayo International AG and another v Ministry of Defence, Government of Indonesia
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC(I) 28 · Case no. Originating Summons No 2 of 2023 (Summonses Nos 11, 589, 606 and 607 of 2023) · 7 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [2]
[2] The MOD applied:
(b) in HC/SUM 606/2023 (“SUM 606”), for leave to file further affidavits in support of SUM 589;
(c) in HC/SUM 607/2023 (“SUM 607”), for sealing and redaction orders; and
(d) after the proceedings were transferred to the Singapore International Commercial Court (“the SICC”), in SIC/SUM 11/2023 (“SUM 11”), for a retrospective extension of time to file SUM 589.
Procedural matters
The exchange of submissions
- [10]
[10] However, the MOD had not engaged new Singapore solicitors, and its submissions were under the hand of First Air Marshall Muhammad Idris, Head of Legal Bureau in the MOD. In the MOD’s submissions it was said that the MOD could not engage new Singapore solicitors “due to time constraints and associated expenses”, with the explanation that the procurement process for legal consultant services under prevailing Indonesian laws required four months “which is beyond the given timeframe”. The MOD asked that it be allowed to file and serve the submissions without representation by Singapore solicitors.
The questions
(a) First, that the filing and service of the costs submissions was on the condition imposed by the Court that the MOD engaged new Singapore solicitors, but this had not been done.
(b) Second, that if the MOD intended to be self-represented, under O 64 r 3 of the ROC 2014 it was necessary that it file a notice of intention to act in person, which it had not done, and it was not sufficient for the MOD to merely state its intention to be self-represented in an email to the Registry.
We observe, at this juncture, that implicit in the second limb to this submission is an assumption that the MOD could be self-represented in the first place: the Plaintiffs did not argue that the MOD could make its costs submissions only through Singapore solicitors.
- [13]
[13] It was said also that the MOD’s explanation that engaging new solicitors would take four months should not be accepted, since the former solicitors appeared to have been engaged and able to file SUM 589, SUM 606 and SUM 607 in less than three months, and the MOD had been aware from at least 31 May 2024 that it needed to appoint new Singapore solicitors.
The course we have taken
The parties’ cases
The Plaintiffs’ arguments
Pre-transfer costs
Post-transfer costs
Disbursements
The MOD’s arguments
- [26]
[26] The MOD’s submissions contain a primary submission and a fallback submission.
Costs should be limited to disbursements
Costs of $40,000
Our decision
The MOD’s submission that costs be limited to disbursements
- [30]
[30] The MOD’s reference to “the proven Part A Fraud” is based on [209] of the Judgment where, in the course of considering the MOD’s prospects of success in SUM 589, we stated that:
- [33]
[33] We went on to enquire into the MOD’s allegations of fraud in the conduct of the arbitration, more specifically, why a case of fraud in the procurement, execution and performance of the Navayo Agreement was not mounted successfully (or at all) by the MOD (see Judgment at [214]). We concluded that the MOD had very little chance of success in SUM 589 because we considered that there was inadequate evidence to attribute the inadequacy of the MOD’s defence in the arbitration to a fraudulent conspiracy in its conduct (see Judgment at [218]), and that enforcing an award obtained in such circumstances would not shock the conscience and be regarded as contrary to Singapore’s public policy (see Judgment at [227]).
Pre-transfer costs
Post-transfer costs
Disbursements
- [42]
[42] There is no occasion to decline the amount claimed by the Plaintiffs for disbursements, which in any event the MOD appears to accept. We thus grant disbursements of $8,022.52.
Conclusion