Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 16 April 2024
Reliance Infrastructure Ltd v Shanghai Electric Group Co Ltd
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC(I) 8 · Case no. Originating Application No 1 of 2023 · 3 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Factual background
- [3]
[3] On 12 March 2023, Reliance Infrastructure applied in OA 1 to set aside an arbitral award rendered by a tribunal on 8 December 2022, following a Singapore-seated arbitration between Parties (“the Award”). The Award held that Reliance Infrastructure was liable to Shanghai Electric under the guarantee obligations found within a purported guarantee letter said to have been executed between the Parties on 26 June 2008 (“the Guarantee Letter”) (see the Award at [6]–[7], [9(a)] and [9(d)]) (see also Reliance Infrastructure (Merits) at [23] and [32]).
- [5]
[5] In their OA 1, Reliance Infrastructure alleged that the signature of its former officer on the Guarantee Letter had been a forgery, and in the alternative, that its former officer had no authority to execute the arbitration agreement that was contained within the Guarantee Letter (see Reliance Infrastructure (Merits) at [38]–[39], [59] and [62]).
- [6]
[6] We dismissed OA 1 on 31 January 2024, following a 2-day hearing from 11–12 January 2024 (see Reliance Infrastructure (Merits) at [34]). We heard the evidence of three factual witnesses (two from Reliance Infrastructure and one from Shanghai Electric) and two handwriting experts (one from each party) (see Reliance Infrastructure (Merits) at [34(a)]–[34(e)]).
Costs are awarded to Shanghai Electric in the amount of US$734,660.02
Summary of Parties’ positions on costs
Breakdown of Parties’ respective costs estimates
The costs claimed by Shanghai Electric in respect of foreign counsel’s fees and all of their disbursements are granted in full
The costs claimed by Shanghai Electric in respect of Singapore counsel’s fees are granted in part
(a) the quantum of the amount at stake, viz, an arbitral award which had awarded more than US$146 million to Shanghai Electric (not including post-award interest thereon and any reimbursements for the final costs of the arbitration) (see at [4] above);
(b) the importance to Shanghai Electric of fully responding to and rebutting the very serious allegation of forgery (see at [5] above), and thus obtaining the vindication that it did;
(c) the voluminous factual record which had to be examined (ie, a Case Management Bundle spanning 14 volumes and over 7,000 pages);
(d) the relative legal complexity of the issues raised (here, Reliance Infrastructure tendered a bundle of 72 legal authorities in total while Shanghai Electric tendered 55 in total in its main and supplementary bundles);
(e) the extent of the time and effort expended by Shanghai Electric’s Singapore practitioners here (1,431.49 hours expended by six practitioners, with 83.83 hours on the low end and 532.33 hours on the high end), the quantity of which is not unreasonable given the complexity and volume of the legal authorities, facts, and evidence engaged here (see at [(c)]–[(d)] above); and
(f) the proceedings here lasted for nearly a year from March 2023 to January 2024 (see at [3] and [6] above), albeit that there were only two Case Management Conferences and a 2-day hearing on the merits (see at [6] above), and featured five interlocutory applications in the interregnum, notwithstanding that three of them were granted by consent.
Conclusion
(a) US$550,000 in respect of professional fees for Singapore counsel, a reduction from the US$726,584.85 claimed for this component; and
(b) US$184,660.02 in respect of foreign counsel, expert’s fees, and other disbursements, in the amounts claimed by Shanghai Electric therefor.