Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 11 Jul 2025

Singapore International Commercial Court

Re Terraform Labs Pte Ltd (Dulberger, Adam and others, non-parties)

Feedback & support

[2025] SGHC(I) 18Case no. Originating Application No 5 of 2024 (Summonses No 26 of 2025)16 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] These grounds of decision address the court’s resolution of SIC/SUM 26/2025 (“SUM 26”), an application by Terraform Labs Pte Ltd (“TFL”) to strike out a related application, SIC/SUM 19/2025 (“SUM 19”), brought by the non-parties who belatedly attempted to join pending litigation against TFL docketed as SIC/OA 3/2024 (“OA 3” or the “Beltran Action”).

  2. Background in relation to SUM 26

  3. TFL’s financial difficulties and restructuring in the US

  4. TFL’s application for recognition and reliefs in Singapore

  5. [7] Notably for purposes of SUM 26, ORC 13 provided at paragraph 4 as follows (the TFL Plan Recognition Decision at [84]):

  6. [8] SUM 57 included some references to the treatment afforded to the Beltran Parties under the Plan. That treatment allows them to freely litigate their claims within OA 3, thereby distinguishing them from other creditors with somewhat similar underlying claims against TFL based on alleged crypto currency losses. The Beltran Parties have separate rights predicated on their ability to obtain a potential recovery from an escrow account created and funded by TFL as a condition to releasing an injunction that the Beltran Parties had succeeded in securing against TFL.

  7. [9] These rights of recourse to the escrowed funds were in place before commencement of TFL’s bankruptcy case and have been preserved in the Plan exclusively for the benefit of the Beltran Parties. Any judgment or settlement resulting from prosecution of OA 3 is secured by these funds that have been deposited with the Singapore International Commercial Court in the amount of USD $56,948,675.49. Under the Plan, the escrowed funds are assets of TFL with the potential to be returned to TFL and redistributed to other claimants to the extent any of the funds are not needed to satisfy claims made by the Beltran Parties in OA 3. TFL, therefore, has an interest in whatever may be left in the account and a natural motivation to maximise that potential reversionary return.

  8. [10] The contingent right of the Beltran Parties to recover from the escrow was the reason their claims against TFL were separately classified and given more favourable treatment under the classification scheme of the Plan. By virtue of this vested right under Singapore law to share in the escrow, the claims of the Beltran Parties have been characterised as secured claims within class 3, but this entitlement only extends to those individuals who were members of that class when the Plan was confirmed.

  9. [11] Other holders of so-called crypto loss claims who were not parties to OA 3 were not entitled to share in the escrow. These other claimants, including the non-parties, were classified under the Plan as members of class 5, an unsecured class with claims lacking a dedicated source of payment and with presently undetermined recovery percentages.

  10. [12] The distinction in rights granted under the Plan may superficially seem somewhat discriminatory from the point of view of class 5 claimants such as the non-parties who are not members of class 3. But the classification scheme makes perfect sense given the distinct rights that were created under Singapore law due to the pendency of the representative action (ie, OA 3) that was brought solely on behalf of the individual Beltran Parties and did not encompass other similarly situated investors like the non-parties.

  11. [13] The overall structure of the Plan is outlined in [65]–[68] of the TFL Plan Recognition Decision, and in [69], the court highlighted the preferred status afforded to the Beltran Parties as follows:

  12. [14] The TFL Plan Recognition Decision is foundational and sets the stage for the rulings of the court with respect to SUM 26.

  13. Background in relation to SUM 19 and SUM 26

  14. Summary of the parties’ positions

  15. Applicable principles in awarding costs

  16. The decision

  17. [33] The court was guided by factors (a)–(e) and (g) of O 23 r 3(2) of the SICC Rules 2021 (above at [27]). These largely corresponded to TFL’s arguments (above at [21]–[23]). The court found that the award sought by TFL (particularly legal expenses in pursuing SUM 26), was reasonable for three reasons.

  18. [35] Second, TFL’s solicitors were not only required to expend significant effort in opposing SUM 19 and preparing for SUM 26 but were also compelled to respond to this challenge to the settled structure of the Plan in a compressed time period, against the backdrop of a fast-approaching trial for OA 3.

  19. [39] The non-parties really should have understood that this tactic had almost no chance of success from the start. The Plan is fixed in its structure and not capable of being modified by having the non-parties leapfrog into class 3 simply by being admitted as claimants in OA 3. Class 3 of the Plan is composed of the representative parties that had rights to the escrow as of the date when the Plan was structured. That class cannot be reimagined, redefined and expanded without also amending the Plan. It is too late for such an amendment without obtaining the consent of the proponents of the Plan and approval of the Bankruptcy Court just as it has proven to be too late for the non-parties to become claimants in OA 3.

  20. [40] SUM 19, when considered independently, appeared to be without merit. It was filed close to the eve of trial and had elicited strong opposition from TFL, the other defendants and the Beltran Parties. The non-parties faced very heavy head winds even without regard to the formidable procedural hurdles raised in SUM 26.

  21. [43] Further, their ability to maintain SUM 19 against the second and third defendants in OA 3 was, as TFL has argued, beside the point since their sole commercial goal in trying to join OA 3 was to gain potential access to TFL’s escrow, an objective that could not be achieved by proceeding against the other defendants. The non-parties’ efforts to justify themselves fell flat and failed to explain their wilful or reckless actions in violating ORC 13.

  22. Conclusion

  23. [49] Orders that recognise foreign restructurings such as ORC 13 must be respected and strictly observed. That is such an abundantly clear proposition that it should not need to be stated or repeated here. Yet the fact that SUM 19 was filed without seeking leave of court or a carve out from the restrictions of ORC 13 indicates that the non-parties and/or their counsel have missed this obvious point.

  24. [50] Accordingly, the court made the following orders: