Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 6 Aug 2025

Singapore International Commercial Court

DOI v DOJ and others and another matter

Feedback & support

[2025] SGHC(I) 20Case no. Originating Application No 20 of 2024 and Summons No 12 of 20254 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. The costs of the interlocutory application

  3. Professional costs

  4. [8] The Claimant provided details of the Wong Partnership (“WP”) lawyers, their hourly rates, and the hours spent, arriving at the S$62,413. The work involved was described as the review of SUM 12 and the witness statement; drafting and reviewing the WP letter to the court dated 11 February 2025; drafting and reviewing the Claimant’s responsive witness statement; research into relevant legal authorities; preparing for the hearing of SUM 12, including the bundles of authorities; attending the hearing of SUM 12 on 26 February 2025; and correspondence between WP and the Indian instructing solicitors.

  5. Disbursements

  6. [13] The Claimant provided details of the Indian lawyers, their hourly rates and the hours spent: a partner and an associate (six hours each) and a “counsel” (twelve hours). Their work was described as review of SUM 12 and the witness statement, review of the WP letter of 11 February 2025, review of the Claimant’s responsive witness statement, reviewing research on legal principles “and providing input for hearing of SUM 12”; attendance at the hearing of SUM 12; correspondence with WP regarding SUM 12 including responding to WP’s queries; and updating and corresponding with the Claimant regarding SUM 12.

  7. The costs of the substantive proceedings

  8. Professional costs

  9. [23] I see no reason not to allow the S$182,192, noting that the work in the period appears to have included the labour intensive (but relatively unskilled) compilation of the Claimant’s comparative schedule. But three partners, two associates, and a foreign associate for a total of more than 450 hours from 1 January 2025 up to and including the hearing on 25 February 2025, over 56 eight hour person-days with the discounted amount of S$259,803.60, cannot be regarded as reasonable for the period from 1 January 2025 up to and including the one-day hearing. The claimed amounts for the subsequent periods also appear excessive: for example, the S$27,523.20 for the same team of lawyers for a total of 45.1 hours to produce a six-page submission on why the decision of the Court of Appeal supported setting the Award aside. Bearing in mind also that the Claimant relied on the four grounds and then was not fully successful on all, and even accepting that there were the additional matters of preclusion and waiver and the decision of the Court of Appeal, I am unable to see more than S$225,000 as a reasonable and proportionate amount for the work from 1 January 2025 onwards.

  10. Disbursements

  11. [26] The amount for disbursements will therefore be S$76,440.40.

  12. Conclusion