Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 11 March 2025
W Power Group EOOD v Ming yang Wind Power (International) Co Ltd
Feedback & support[2025] SGHC(I) 7 · Case no. Originating Application No 2 of 2023 · 8 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Pre-transfer costs
The parties’ submissions
Mingyang’s case
W Power’s case
Consideration
- [15]
[15] In Senda International Capital Ltd v Kiri Industries Ltd [2023] 1 SLR 96 (“Kiri Industries (CA)”), the Court of Appeal pointed out at [47]:
The Court of Appeal stated that access to justice considerations required that the level of costs be tailored to the attributes of the case itself and what is generally accepted to be recoverable (at [48]). The Court of Appeal stated at [49] the effect of Appendix G means that even catering for the specificities of individual cases, the level of recoverable costs will generally remain within the range set out therein.
Post-transfer costs
The parties’ submissions
Mingyang’s case
W Power’s case
Consideration
(a) the starting point for the assessment is what costs were in fact incurred by the successful party to the extent that such costs are reasonable;
(b) it is for the trial court to assess costs and it is within the court’s discretion to determine the manner in which costs are to be assessed;
(c) the legal burden is on the successful party to establish its claimed costs are indeed reasonable costs and it must provide information to show how the claimed costs have been incurred and thereby allowing the unsuccessful party or the court to assess whether they are reasonable; and
(d) upon the successful party providing a sufficient breakdown of its claimed costs, the evidential burden shifts to the unsuccessful party to adduce evidence in rebuttal.
- [34]
[34] That claim must be considered in conjunction with the further amount of $17,395 which is claimed in respect of the preparation and issue of two requests for further and better particulars, and the preparation and service of a Statement of Further and Better Particulars of its defence.
- [35]
[35] In my opinion, the amounts of $30,665 and $17,395 taken together are in excess of what is reasonable and proportionate having regard to the matters involved. Without seeking to apportion the amount between the two claims I would allow $37,000 in respect of work done post-transfer to the SICC separate to the work done in respect of SUM 15.
Foreign Counsel’s Fees
- [36]
[36] I do not propose to set out the parties’ submissions on this issue. I have taken them into account.
- [37]
[37] In the pre-transfer period an amount of RMB99,154.50 is claimed in respect of Hong Kong counsel’s fees involving consideration of Mingyang’s litigation strategy preparing for and attending a without prejudice meeting between the parties and coordinating with Singapore counsel. The work undertaken was said to have occupied 43.10 hours.
- [38]
[38] Whilst I accept that Mingyang was not a Singapore-based company and was brought to this court, I am unable to conclude that amount was reasonably incurred for the purpose of the proceedings. I would allow RMB50,000.
- [39]
[39] However, I would allow the amount of RMB5,452 claimed for Hong Kong counsel in respect of the post-transfer period. This work which occupied 2.90 hours and involved reviewing W Power’s witness statements and submissions seems to me to have been reasonably incurred.
- [40]
[40] I would allow the Bulgarian counsel’s fees. To understand W Power’s claim it was necessary to investigate the relevant Bulgarian regulatory regime and the changes to it which rendered Project 2 unprofitable. It was also appropriate to seek their input on the Bulgarian regulations in responding to W Power’s request for further and better particulars.
Other costs claimed
Conclusion