Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 11 Oct 2024

High Court

SBS Holdings, Inc v Anant Kumar Choudary and others (A2S Logistics Pte Ltd and another, non-parties)

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHCR 11Case no. Originating Application No 435 of 2023 (Summons No 2238 of 2024)

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Background

  3. [7] The parties subsequently attended a Registrar’s Case Conference (“RCC”) on 30 May 2024 and took directions from the court regarding the Trial, including directions for the filing of pleadings and lists of witnesses. SBS filed its Statement of Claim on 14 June 2024, and the Trial Defendants (including Ms Choudary) filed their respective Defences on 28 June 2024. Ms Choudary’s solicitors made a request for SFC to SBS’s solicitors on 10 July 2024, which the latter refused in a response on 15 July 2024. At an RCC on 17 June 2024, the court gave further directions for the production of documents and requests for further and better particulars. At this hearing, Ms Choudary sought, and obtained, permission to file an SFC application against SBS, which it did by taking out SUM 2238.

  4. The parties’ submissions

  5. The applicable principles

  6. (a) whether the claimant has a bona fide claim;

  7. (b) the claimant’s financial standing;

  8. (c) the ease of enforcing any judgment for costs against the claimant;

  9. (d) the relative strength of the parties’ cases;

  10. (e) whether the application for SFC has been taken out oppressively to stifle the claimant’s action, or for tactical reasons, having regard to the timing at which the application is brought and whether there has been delay.

  11. [15] In SW Trustees ([3] above) (at [19]–[22]), the High Court explained that each of the factors above can be rationalised under the three key purposes underlying the provision of SFC:

  12. (a) to protect the defendant, who cannot avoid being sued, by enabling him to recover costs from the plaintiff out of a fund within the jurisdiction in the event he prevails in the litigation – I refer to this as the “protective rationale”;

  13. (b) to ensure, within the limits of protecting the defendant, that the plaintiff’s ability to pursue his claim is not stifled – I refer to this as the “access to justice” rationale since this ultimately relates to the need to ensure that the defendant should not be seeking SFC with the aim of “quell[ing] the plaintiff’s quest for justice” (see SW Trustees at [21]); and

  14. (c) to maintain a sense of fair play between the parties amidst the cut-and-thrust of civil litigation – I refer to this the “procedural fairness” rationale as it ultimately relates to the need to ensure that SFC is not deployed in a manner that occasions procedural unfairness to the other party in the litigation or in a manner which results in the applicant for SFC enjoying an unfair procedural advantage over the other (see SW Trustees at [22]).

  15. The issues for decision

  16. [18] I considered the circumstances raised in the parties’ submissions and their bearing on the question of whether SFC is to be granted in terms of the following five broad issues:

  17. (i) Whether SBS’s financial standing, which showed its ability to pay Ms Choudary’s costs for the Trial, is a factor in favour of the court not ordering SFC?

  18. (b) Whether Ms Choudary enjoyed ease of enforcement within the jurisdiction of adverse costs orders that she might come to obtain against SBS in the Trial, having regard to the assets identified by SBS.

  19. (c) The relative strength of the parties’ cases, and specifically, the merits of SBS’s claim in the Trial.

  20. (d) Whether Ms Choudary had been guilty of delay in taking out SUM 2238, and if so, whether SUM 2238 was taken out for tactical reasons.

  21. (e) Whether Ms Choudary had taken out SUM 2238 for collateral purposes, given what she knew or ought to have known about SBS’s financial position and its ability to pay costs.

  22. The relevance of SBS’s financial standing

  23. Whether SBS’s financial standing weighs in favour of the court not ordering SFC

  24. Whether SBS’s ability to furnish SFC weighs in favour of the court ordering SFC

  25. [26] Based on the decided case law, where the claimant is of poor financial standing, that tends to weigh in favour of the court not ordering SFC because the claimant’s impecuniosity, coupled with its prospects of success against the defendant or the bona fides of its claim, renders the grant of SFC oppressive to the claimant and quells its access to justice (see Creative Elegance (M) Sdn Bhd v Puay Kim Seng and another [1999] 1 SLR(R) 112 (“Creative Elegance”) at [22]–[23]). Therefore, a claimant’s financial standing has been viewed as relevant in connection with the access to justice rationale, and it allows the court to assess if extending the protection of SFC to the defendant would be oppressive to the claimant.

  26. Ease of enforcement of costs orders

  27. (a) whether there exists a mechanism for the reciprocal enforcement of judgments in the jurisdiction in which the claimant is ordinarily resident (see, for example, Creative Elegance at [22]); and

  28. [33] With the above in mind, I turn to consider the assets identified by SBS, which come under two categories: (a) first, SBS’s shares in SBS Logistics; and (b) secondly, the Judgment Debt and the ARB 114 Award.

  29. SBS’s shares in SBS Logistics

  30. The Judgment Debt and the ARB 114 Award

  31. The assets in other jurisdictions

  32. Relative strength of the parties’ cases

  33. [49] In her supporting affidavit for SUM 3460 (that is, the application for the release of the Shares), Ms Choudary put forward her account as to why she came to be the owner of the Shares. She explained that A2S Singapore is part of a group of companies under the name “A2S Logistics” which had been founded by her. A2S Singapore had been incorporated with Mr Choudary and her as equal shareholders, with the intention of expanding A2S Logistics’ business to Singapore, but prior to the time due for actual payment to contribute to the paid-up capital of A2S Singapore, a decision was made to change A2S Singapore’s business model, and Mr Choudary therefore did not pay for his portion of the shareholding in A2S Singapore, and it was intended that Mr Choudary would soon transfer his 50% shareholding to Ms Choudary. It was then agreed on 2 March 2022 that Mr Choudary would transfer his 50% shareholding to Ms Choudary for nominal payment, but the transfer was only executed on 27 December 2022, in time for the end of the FY ending 31 December 2022, because Mr Choudary’s father (ie, her father-in-law) had been in ill-health since March 2022 and so she saw no urgency for the transfer to be completed immediately following the agreement between her and Mr Choudary. Eventually, the court hearing SUM 3460 held that Ms Choudary’s case raised serious disputes of fact which cannot be resolved on affidavit evidence alone, and therefore directed that the issue concerning the beneficial ownership of the shares in A2S Singapore to be tried.

  34. Delay

  35. [52] I reiterate the procedural history to put the time at which SUM 2238 is taken out in context – on 3 May 2024, the court directed, as part of its decision for SUM 3460, that the issue of the beneficial ownership of the Shares be tried; on 30 May 2024, the parties took directions at an RCC regarding the Trial, and timelines were given for the filing of pleadings and lists of witnesses; Ms Choudary (as well as the other defendants in the Trial) filed her Defence on 28 June 2024; on 10 July 2024, Ms Choudary’s solicitors wrote to SBS’s solicitors to request for SFC, to which SBS’s solicitors responded with their objections; and on 17 July 2024, Ms Choudary’s solicitors sought permission from the court for Ms Choudary to file an SFC application, and pursuant to the court’s grant of permission, SUM 2238 was filed on 30 July 2024.

  36. [53] As I mentioned earlier, SBS’s counsel submitted that the latest point of time in which Ms Choudary ought to have filed SUM 2238 is the time of the RCC on 30 May 2024 where the court gave directions pertaining to pleadings and lists of witnesses, and having failed to do so, Ms Choudary is guilty of delay.

  37. Whether the application had been taken out for collateral purposes

  38. Ms Choudary is not an ‘involuntary’ defendant

  39. Conclusion

  40. [63] For the reasons above, I dismissed SUM 2238.

  41. [65] Given that the central issue at the Trial is whether Mr Choudary is the beneficial owner of the Shares, the relevant tariffs for “equity and trusts” claims in Appendix G is an appropriate starting point for assessing the appropriate quantum of SFC. Despite there being only a single issue on which the outcome of the Trial turns, the parties’ pleadings raise a few distinct factual disputes, the main ones being whether it was Ms Choudary or Mr Choudary who had founded, owned or managed A2S Logistics, and the reasons for which Mr Choudary had transferred his 50% shareholding in A2S Singapore to Ms Choudary. In the alternative, SBS pleads that Mr Choudary is at least a beneficial owner of the 50% shares in A2S Singapore which he had transferred to Ms Choudary and/or that the transfer should be set aside pursuant to s 438(2) of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.